Phoebe drove home in a trance, the images from her premonition haunting her mind. When she got home she stumbled into the kitchen, dropped the bags on the counter, and went into the living room where she collapsed on the sofa.
'Maybe I say myself being born, maybe we were born at the same time and that triggered the premonition.' Phoebe thought, but than another thought replaced that. 'No, Sam was there, if it was me, or Piper, or Prue, our father would have been there.'
Phoebe tried to push back the thought that nagged at her mind the most, 'maybe she's our sister.' Phoebe tried to reason that that was impossible, she tried to talk herself into thinking that her premonition was wrong, but she knew it wasn't.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Piper walked into the living room followed by Prue. They were discussing the girl (Paige), but stopped mid-sentence when they saw Phoebe, lying on the sofa, staring of into space, completely unaware of her surroundings.
"Phoebe?" Prue asked, and when it produced no result she said it again louder, "Phoebe!"
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Phoebe gave a start, it took her a few moments to realize where she was. She looked up to see Prue and Piper looking at her with concern.
"You ok?" Prue asked.
"No. Yes. Maybe" Was Phoebe's muddled response.
"What happened?" Piper talking this time.
Phoebe told them as best she could about the events of the afternoon, her head becoming clearer as she talked. When she finished, Prue said with as much conviction as she could muster, "Are you sure it wasn't a heat stroke or something, maybe you dozed off of a minute." And Piper added, "I mean, another sister, another sister who mugged you and Prue, mom would have said something."
"I know how this sounds guys, I've been trying to convince myself it's not true, but I can't. I know what my premonitions feel like, and I can't deny what I saw. We were drawn to her, why do you think that out of all the people in this town, she met Prue and me? That girl, Paige is our sister, half-sister anyway, and I think its time we talked to mom about this." Phoebe said.
The three of them trouped up to the attic and called their mom's spirit, wanting to know, but dreading the answer.