Replies-

The-Cheese-Fairy: Glad you liked it! Phobia is going to become a main character and I might give her a subplot in the sequel! I have plans for a Grace subplot planned for the sequel, but I can't seem to think of one for Karis! So I'm glad you love her, but she may not be a main focus in any of the chapters of this or the first few of the sequel! I haven't decided what to do with Gideon, he may not even appear!

Princess Pinky: Glad you liked it! I'm really glad you like Phobia because she's going to be a main character! There are quite a few Grace and Karis moments to come before the end of the fic! I am a massive Piper/Leo shipper, but you'll just have to wait and see!

Peanut2lb: Glad you liked it! You might just get a chance to see Phobia sway towards the dark side in the sequel! Glad you liked Prue's line!

The title for this chapter is a play on 'Romeo, Romeo, were art thou Romeo'.

Leo, Leo, where art thou Dan:

Piper wearily climbed the stairs and shuffled towards her bedroom, she opened the door and found a man sitting on her bed. He had blonde hair and sparkling blue eyes, wore a black tuxedo and shiny black shoes,

"my dearest Piper, you look exquisite," the stranger said. Piper looked down at the torn jeans and blue sweater she was wearing, in her opinion she looked more scruffy than exquisite,

"who are you?" she questioned,

"Romeo, your true love," he replied.

"Uh oh, is this to do with the spell I cast last night?" Piper asked,

"yep," Romeo replied, "I'm the ultimate mixture of Leo and Dan, I have the build and attitude of Leo, with the normalness of Dan,"

"wow, you really are perfect," she said, letting him pull her into a passionate kiss.

On an island somewhere in the Pacific ocean, Cole ran through a dark rainforest, he was chasing an aquatic demon,

"come out, come out, wherever you are," he called, after coming to a halt and walking round in a circle. Suddenly, a blue and white demon pounced out of a tree and threw a ball of water at Cole, who destroyed it with an energy ball. Then the aquatic demon hit Cole with a burst of water so strong it forced him through the air and slammed him into a tree,

"you'll get your little witch friends to cast a spell to hide me from the aquatic angels, Poseidon will be sending them after me soon," the demon said.

"I don't think so," Cole told him, holding a giant energy ball with his two hands, the watery creature became a figure of water, which began to turn into bubbles and pop. Cole jumped forward and into the water, just as it all became bubbles and disappeared, taking him with it.

Meanwhile, Piper tied her bathrobe and kissed Romeo's lips, careful not to wake him,

"have you been in bed?" Paige asked, seeing Piper leave her room,

"let's just say Romeo's perfect in every way," Piper replied, a smile plastered across her face.

"What? who's Romeo? how can you not feel guilty after cheating on Dan?" Paige questioned,

"well, I kinda didn't, last night I cast a spell to help me choose between him and Leo, and I ended up creating a mixture of the two," Piper said, opening her bedroom door to show the sleeping blond.

"Wow!" Paige exclaimed, as Piper closed the door and went into her bathroom,

"what's wow?" Prue asked, walking up behind her youngest sister,

"Piper's Leo/Dan mixture," Paige replied.

In the Dimension of Olympia, swirling bubbles formed the aquatic demon and Cole,

"why did you come here?" Cole asked, "this is where the aquatic angels will be, plus hundreds of other things"

"well this is where the great evil is rising, and then they shall bring forth an even greater one," the aquatic demon replied.

"Shame you won't be there to see it," Cole said, vanquishing him with an energy ball, "I think I'll take a look around this place," he said to himself, shimmering out.

He shimmered into a small, one-story, building,

"can I help you?" a man asked,

"I don't know, what do you do?" Cole replied,

"I make dream lovers, are you interested?" the man said, Cole began to think about Phoebe and said;

"maybe."

Piper and Romeo were walking down the stairs, hand in hand, when the doorbell went,

"you have to hide, that'll be Dan," Piper told him, Romeo began to walk back up the stairs when orbs materialised in the foyer,

"and that's Leo," Piper said, Romeo kept walking up the stairs when the orbs completely became Leo and the front door opened.

"The door was open," Dan said, "Leo? What are you doing here?"

"probably the same thing you are, coming to see the woman I love," Leo replied,

"who are you?" they questioned in unison, turning to face Romeo.

"I could see this happening," Prue said, as she and Paige popped their heads round the kitchen doorway,

"WILL EVERYONE JUST SHUT UP!" Piper yelled, all three of the men froze.

"Thank you," she said, "now let me explain, Dan I love you, but I love Leo too," Dan clenched his fists and glared at Leo,

"what about him?" he asked, pointing at Romeo,

"Romeo's just like both of you, that's why he's my perfect guy, he came to me after I realized I couldn't love you both, it's not fair," she replied. Tears were now glimmering in the middle charmed one's eyes,

"Leo, I do love you, I always have and always will, but we can't be together, you know it's too complicated," she said, "Romeo, right now you are the perfect thing for me, but you're also a reminder that I'm in love with two different men," finally she looked at Dan, "Dan, I love you, but there are things about me I can't tell you, things you won't understand, and if you're willing to live with that then so am I."

"Piper, I know you can't tell me everything, and I can live with that, but knowing I'm not the only man you love, well you admitting it, is gonna be hard," Dan told her,

"what are you saying?" she asked,

"I'm saying, I still want to marry you, if you never see Leo again," he said. This angered Leo so much he swung his fist forward and punched Dan right in the middle of the face, knocking him out,

"Leo!" Piper exclaimed.

"Nice punch," Romeo complimented, "Piper, I don't want to make things harder, so just reverse the spell and I'll be gone, unless you choose me, leave these two, marry me," he said, Piper felt torn,

"I've got an idea," Paige said, from where she and Prue sat by the dining table. Then she chanted;

"Show what each love shall hold,

And let the future unfold,

To help Piper decide,

From happiness no longer hide."

Piper's body went limp and she fell to the ground,

"what did you do?" Prue asked, as she and Paige ran to Piper's side,

"I think my spell has somehow astral projected her into the future so she can see what will happen with the different ones she chooses," the youngest sister replied.

A scarlet flare appeared in the attic and became Piper,

"uh oh, something's wrong, I just astral projected," she said to herself, looking around the attic and seeing it was different. She left the attic and went downstairs, only to see Leo firing electricity at the Source, while Prue and Paige lay motionless on the floor,

"if I choose Leo magic will be around forever, I'll never be able to escape and neither will my sisters," she said, before disappearing in the same flare she had appeared in.

This time she found herself in Dan's house, he was in the kitchen cooking her breakfast and she was in the bathroom. She turned around and accidentally knocked of a bottle of shampoo, Piper threw out her hands to freeze it but nothing happened, in this future she had given up her powers.

Once again she projected into another future, she was outside her bedroom door and when she went in she saw Romeo kissing another woman,

"looks like he's not so perfect," Piper said, dematerialising into a pinkish-red flash.

She awoke to find Prue and Paige one either side of her, and Leo reluctantly healing Dan,

"have you made your decision?" Romeo asked,

"Leo, our future is only going to be full of pain, and Romeo, our future is going to be full of you and other women, then again, Dan, our future will only work when you make me give up part of who I am," Piper said.

"But right now, I'm pretty sure Dan is the best choice," she told them, tears spiralling out of control, flowing down her cheeks like a waterfall, Leo just walked out the house and Romeo went into the kitchen, and disappeared, now that Piper had chosen he was no longer needed.

That night, Piper was reading a magazine when she had an epiphany,

"what have I done?" she said, "I love Leo," she jumped up from her chair and began calling his name. She got her hopes up when orbs began to materialise, but when they became a female Elder her heart sunk,

"Leo won't be answering your calls anymore, he won't even be hearing them, instead you will get a new whitelighter, that is all," the Elder said, orbing out.

"I've lost him," Piper whimpered, burying her face in her hands.

In Olympia, Cole watched as the woman-maker opened the door to show a beautiful young woman,

"Phoebe," Cole whispered,

"as you requested, though she will have only one power and it will be very different to the original Phoebe's," the woman-maker said. 'Phoebe' walked forward and moved her arms up to Cole's face in a robotic fashion, putting her hands on his cheeks and planting a kiss on his lips.

To be continued…

Next chapter- When Prue gets a new power, when she learns it is demonic she decides to look back through the family tree to see if there were any demons in the family, but she finds something much worse. Cole ponders whether to tell the sisters about Fake Phoebe after she is kidnapped. Phobia tells Paige there's a teaching job going at Magic School, will she take it?

"Daddy Dearest" should be up tomorrow.