Title: My Forbidden Heart
Rating: PG-13
Content: Love & Angst (so far)
Distribution: Please Ask First
Characters: (Main Characters) Michelle, Randy Orton, John Cena, Bret Hart (Minor Characters) Bret's wife and children, JR, Vince McMahon, Chris Benoit, Chris Jericho
Disclaimer: To Each Their Own
WARNINGS: Mild language, sexual reference and some sex scenes
Summary by Chapter: Randy & Michelle go on their date and Michelle is left in shock when Randy turns her down. Michelle lies to her Dad. Randy & Michelle go on another date and Michelle is once again left in awe when Randy turns her down again.
My Forbidden Heart – Chapter 4
THE DATE
Randy turned up at the door and a frantic Michelle opened the door and invited him in while running around like a crazy person trying to get ready. Randy walked in and sat down to rest his leg. He picked up a picture off Michelle's coffee table of her and her family. He smiled and put it down as Michelle walked back in a little calmer putting her earrings in. She noticed that Randy was looking at the picture and smiled.
"I miss them" she said honestly
"Why don't you invite them down here?" Randy asked
"Because they don't know I'm here"
Randy gave a look of confusion and Michelle continued to explain.
"They think I'm in New York. My Dad doesn't want me to become a wrestler and he definitely doesn't want me to be in the WWE, so I did this behind their backs"
"Oh" said Randy. Michelle looked into Randy's eyes and whether real or not she saw disgust.
"I don't want to hurt my Dad you know"
"Yeah I know"
"I love him more than anything in the world but I want to do this"
"Fair enough"
Michelle quickly changed the subject
"So how do I look?" she said posing for Randy
Randy smiled and stood up "You look beautiful"
Michelle smiled at Randy and rested her hands on her hips "You look pretty good yourself" she complimented as Randy stood all handsome in a pinstripe suit and crisp white shirt.
"Thanks I try"
"So where are you taking me? Why did I have to get all dressed up?"
"I'm taking you for dinner"
"Somewhere classy I hope" she said pointing at her dress
"Well come on and you'll find out" said Randy opening her apartment door and holding his arm out.
Michelle walked over and linked arms with Randy and closed the door behind her and they made their way to the restaurant.
LATER AT THE RESTAURANT
"I went to the top rope and went for a cross body and I don't know I landed wrong next thing I know I'm writhing in pain and being carried to the back where they told me it was broken"
"Ouch, why am I getting into this business?"
"Because you're good at it and it's in your blood"
Michelle knew she'd never be able to escape her family name and she didn't want to she loved being a Hart and was proud of her family but sometimes she would just like to be Michelle Hart and not Bret's daughter. Randy noticed the expression on her face and knew he needed to change the subject quickly.
"You really do look beautiful tonight"
Michelle looked up and smiled at Randy "Thanks"
For the rest of the night they talked about everything from families, to friends, to wrestling. By the end of the night there were no more words they'd asked each other everything. The couple holding hands walked back to Michelle's apartment.
"Are you sure you're ok?" Michelle asked as she watched Randy hobbling uncomfortably without support from his crutches
"I'm fine" Randy swung Michelle round into his arms and sat down on the wall beside them Michelle upon Randy's lap. "I'm better now though"
"Aww bless you. You should have your crutches"
"I didn't want to embarrass you"
"You wouldn't embarrass me"
"Well I'll remember that tomorrow"
"Tomorrow?" Michelle asked with hope
"Yeah when I take you out on our second date that's if you want to"
Michelle smiled at Randy and shook her head "No"
"No?" asked a stunned Randy
"No tomorrow night I'm taking you out"
"You're going to take me out the guy?"
"Yeah you got a problem with that?"
"Not at all. So where are you taking me?"
"Oh I don't know…running?" Michelle smiled
"Don't be mean"
"I don't know I'll have to think about this but you definitely won't need to dress up like this"
"Ok"
Randy pulled Michelle into him and kissed her fiercely the couple became the main attraction as passers by walked with their eyes locked on the couple. As they broke they realised they were being watched and smiled.
"We must be good" said Randy standing up causing Michelle to stand. They continued to Michelle's apartment.
AT THE APARTMENT
Michelle unlocked the door and walked in she looked back at the door where Randy was leaning to take pressure of his ankle.
"You coming in?"
"No I'm guna get going but I don't want to leave without a goodnight kiss"
Michelle walked over to Randy and wrapped her arms around him and gave him the goodnight kiss he desired.
"If you come in I'll give you a good night"
Randy rested his head against Michelle's and inhaled taking in her sweet scent. He kissed her on the nose.
"Not tonight"
Randy pulled away and walked towards the elevator. Michelle stood in her doorway in complete awe. Randy looked back over his shoulder and smiled at Michelle.
"I'll see you tomorrow"
Randy stepped into the elevator and as the doors closed Michelle threw her hands up in disbelief and confusion she couldn't understand why Randy hadn't spent the night. She was madly attracted to him and she knew he felt the same way and she was pretty sure it was what he wanted from the signs she'd been picking up all night and the smokin' session they'd had in the kitchen. She walked back into the apartment and closed the door.
'Why did he leave? Doesn't he like me?'
Questions circled her head for the rest of the night whatever the reason was for Randy not spending the night Michelle was never going to work it out so she turned out the light and forced herself to sleep.
THE NEXT MORNING
Knock Knock!
Michelle looked at the door and turned off the TV she wasn't expecting company and made her way to the door to stop her curiosity. She opened the door to a bunch of flowers which lowered to reveal Randy. Michelle smiled and took the flowers from Randy.
"Good morning" said Randy kissing Michelle on the cheek
"You bought me flowers?"
"Thought you might like them"
"I do thank you"
Randy sat down on the couch as Michelle put the flowers in water. She walked back in and placed the flowers on a table. She walked over to Randy still confused about the night before she mounted him and kissed him furiously she felt Randy's hand slide up her shirt with the signs Michelle was sure Randy wanted her and put her hands up Randy's shirt and ran them across his abdomen and chest. Michelle decided to speed up the process and pulled her shirt off revealing her well packed bra Randy looked on with glee at the sight before him and continued to run his hands up and down her back. Michelle then moved her hand down to Randy's drawstring pants and pulled the string lose she then inserted her hand into his pants and glided it along his soft member still stealing kisses from Randy. Randy tried to fight his urge to take her right there on the couch but with every stroke an arousing sensation exploded inside his body Randy soon gave in and pushed Michelle down on her back he leant on top of her and Randy pulled off his shirt. Michelle smiled happy that she'd got this reaction feeling a little more confident in herself than she did last night when he rejected her invitation. Suddenly Michelle's cell phone began to ring Randy's head popped up as he stopped his exploration of her sexually intense body.
"Ignore it" Michelle demanded but Randy saw this as a perfect opportunity to put an end to this sexual endeavour. Randy picked up the phone and answered it.
"Hello Michelle's phone…sure she's right here"
Randy handed Michelle her phone and sat up. Michelle looked at Randy in complete disbelief and total frustration.
"Hello"
"Why do you have people answering your phone for you?" asked a familiar voice
"I guess he can't stand a ringing phone" she said indicating her frustration with Randy as he pulled on his shirt.
"Well who is it?"
"A work colleague" well he was it's not as if she was lying
"Oh was he not given a name"
Michelle answered trying to change the subject "Dad did you call for a reason because I really need to get back to something"
"Oh I'm keeping you? What am I keeping you from?"
"A debate"
"A debate that sounds really interesting. Well I was just wondering if you wanted to meet up because I'm in New York"
"You are?"
"Yep just got here I'm on my way to the hotel and I just thought why should I go to a hotel when my daughter has an apartment"
"Oh Dad I don't even have my bed so you can't stay with me" she said hurrying for an excuse to try and put him off to make sure she doesn't get caught out.
"Ok that's cool but you will be meeting me though right?"
"I don't know I'm really busy today I'll have to get back to you"
"Well if I haven't heard from you at three I'll call you back"
Michelle knew she couldn't get out of it but if she agreed she had till three to think of an excuse to throw her Dad off.
"Ok I'll talk to you later then" Michelle hung up and walked over to Randy who kissed her and walked to the door.
"Where are you going?"
"I only came to give you the flowers I have to go to the gym but I'll see you here later ok?"
Before Michelle could utter another word Randy left with the door slamming firmly shut behind him. Now Michelle was more confused than ever. First he turned her down, then he had her pinned to the couch but as soon as the phone rang he jumped off her and back into his clothes and now he couldn't get out of the apartment fast enough. What was going on? Michelle thought things over as she cleaned frantically this was something she did when she was anxious and angry.
LATER
Knock Knock!
Michelle opened the door and walked away from it and Randy without kissing him hello. Randy a little misplaced walked in and closed the door behind him. Michelle walked out of the bedroom pulling on a shirt, she stopped and turned to the mirror where she bundled up her hair and tied it up. She applied a fresh coat of lip gloss and put the petite container into the back pocket of her hip hugging jeans. She pulled her purse down off the coat hook and opened the door. Randy pushed the door shut and looked at Michelle who was either angry at him or upset but Randy felt that it was a little of both.
"Hi"
Michelle shot daggers at Randy and opened the door and walked out. Randy followed her slowly with his bad ankle.
"Are you going to ignore me all night?" he asked
Michelle didn't reply and Randy stepped in front of her.
"If you're going to be like this with me all night why are we bothering going out?"
The elevator arrived and Michelle still not uttering a word to Randy walked into the elevator. The doors closed and Randy hit the emergency stop button. The elevator jerked almost causing Michelle to stumble on her 6 inch heels.
"What are you doing?" she snapped
"Oh so you can talk, that's great" Randy hit the button and the elevator jerked again and Michelle lost her balance and stumbled in the corner as it began it's decent to the ground floor.
They reached the ground floor without making a sound as the doors opened Michelle pushed passed Randy to leave but was pulled back into the elevator where Randy crowded her and got in her face.
"What is wrong with you?"
"Nothing!"
"Don't give me that bull there's obviously something wrong with you so spill"
"I've been ignoring my Dads calls all afternoon because I can't think of a way to put him off"
"What?"
"He's in New York and he wants to meet up with me because that's where he thinks I am. I feel so guilty for doing it and I don't mean to be like this but my Dad is so God damn stubborn that he can't even open his heart and make the sacrifice of watching me become a wrestler in the WWE"
"That's what the cold looks and silent treatments about?"
Michelle looked at Randy and even though she knew some of this anger was directed at Randy, lying to her Dad was definitely playing its part. She realised that Randy was definitely interested in her and smiled that maybe tonight would be the night. As she calmed down and realised that her little sulk might be pushing him further away she pulled Randy in and kissed him. As she pulled away she replied.
"Yeah that's what it's about" Michelle walked out of the elevator and Randy followed her.
"So where are you taking me?" asked Randy as he followed her towards the door.
"No where special"
"Oh that's nice" Randy laughed
LATER
Michelle directed a happy Randy into Screen 7.
"I can't believe I took you to that classy restaurant last night and you're more psyched about this place"
"Well you should remember this moment then. Why make the effort?"
"Because you're worth it" Randy said following Michelle up the stairs. Michelle stopped and turned to Randy she smiled and ran down to him and kissed him hard on the lips. Randy laughed through the kiss and tried to speak without stopping the embrace.
"You're going to knock the popcorn out my hand"
Michelle pulled away and smiled then took the popcorn out of his hands and made her way to the middle of the rows. She sat down and waited for Randy to catch up he finally got in and made himself comfortable then stole the popcorn off Michelle. The movie started and Randy and Michelle watched it contently Randy's arm draped around Michelle's shoulder occasionally pulling her in and kissing her. The movie turned out to be a flop and people were getting up and leaving as the mass of people thinned out and the movie got worse Randy and Michelle found themselves concentrating on each other rather than on the movie. Randy pulled Michelle's legs up onto his lap and continued kissing her he ran his hand up her thigh and as his hand reached her rear he cupped her ass and pulled her fully onto his lap.
"Hey there's people here you know?" Michelle whispered with a smile now almost positive tonight was the night.
"They'd think worse of me for not kissing you" said Randy hungrily fighting for a kiss. Michelle pulled away and leaned in to whisper in his ear.
"I bet they'd applaud us if we took it a little further. We'd definitely be better than the movie"
"We can't do that here" said Randy with a smile. Michelle stood up and took Randy's hand and pulled him up after her. Michelle walked with Randy as he hobbled out of the theatre. They walked outside lips locked as they hailed a taxi to take them back to Michelle's apartment.
A Little While Later
The taxi pulled up outside Michelle's apartment block and Randy and Michelle managed to pull themselves apart long enough to get out the taxi.
"Keep the meter running I'm coming right back"
Michelle stood in awe why was Randy asking him to keep the meter running? Why wasn't he coming up with her? Randy walked over to Michelle who was stood on the bottom step of her stoop.
"I had a great time ton—"
"I thought you were coming up?"
"No why did you think that?"
"We were all over each other and we left half way through the movie and we –"
"We left because of the movie. I'm sorry but I have to get up early for physio I'm sorry"
Randy kissed Michelle on the cheek and got back in the taxi.
"I'll see you tomorrow baby"
The taxi drove away and Michelle stood in lockjaw for a second before collecting herself and walking into the building. She proceeded upstairs and unlocked her apartment door and stood in the doorway wondering why Randy wouldn't come upstairs with her. What was his problem? She slammed the door in fury and threw her coat across the room and jumped onto the couch and covered herself with the blanket.
