Authors Note: Anything in Italics is a flashback

Disclaimer : I do not own One Tree Hill or the Charachters.

"Nathan, who are you gonna pick?" Brooke asked

"I don't care." He muttered

"I'm gonna get some refills for everyone." Haley said. "Luke, could you help me out?"

"I can help you Haley." Nathan said trying to something to make Haley less mad.

"Lucas will you help me?" Haley said ignoring Nathan's offer

"Tutor girl, if you wanna make a move on Lucas it would be nice if his girlfriend and your husband weren't in the room." Brooke said with a smile

Haley laughed somewhat nervously as Lucas went with her to the kitchen.

"So..." Lucas said quietly

"So?" Haley asked trying to be just as quiet

"Haley, one of us is next. And it doesn't really matter who because either way we'll be telling the same thing."

"Luke, no way."

"Haley come one. It would be nice to finally just get this out in the open."

"God, I dont know Luke."

"Haley if you don't want to tell I won't. I just think its time we stopped lying. OK?"

"What were we thinking when we did this. God, this was terrible."

"Whoa wait do you mean, I was terrible?"

Haley hit him in the arm and thought for a moment.

"Haley?" Lucas called "Haley? Are you still here?"

"Yeah" Haley said with tears in her eyes

"Hales, I just saw Nathan leaving . Did he bother you?"

"I wouldn't let him in."

"I think you did let him in Haley and thats why you're so hurt." Lucas said sympathetically

"Didn't I tell you I wanted to be left alone?"

"Yeah, I just left Of Mice and Men here and I wanted to finish it."

"Well, I'm glad you did. Luke, you know I never let myself get close to anyone, ecspecially a guy but I just thought he was different."

Lucas hugged her.

"Hales, I know t hurts right now. Trust me."

"Yeah, Luke I'm sorry. I'm complaiing and I totally forgot about what happeneed betwwen you and Peyton."

"Its, OK Hales." He whispered as he broke the hug. But as he broke it Haley kissed him.

"Haley..." was all he could mutter before he kissed her back.They moved over to a couch in the corner and started kissing some more.

"Haley are we gonna do this?" Lucas asked

"Haley are we gonna do this?" Lucas asked. "I mean tell?"

"Tutor girl, Broody!" Brooke called.

Haley and Lucas walked back into the living room. And handed everyone their drinks.

"Thanks" Peyton said. "So which one of you two is going next?"

Haley and Lucas looked at eachother.

"I think its up to Haley." Lucas said.

"Well, I doesn't really matter which one of us goes." Haley said looking at the ground

"What does that mean?" Peyton asked

"Ok, Haley and I well we sort of, I mean once we kinda, we were both really upset and..."

"Oh my God!" Brooke screamed. "You had sex with Tutor Girl!"

"What!" Nathan screamed. "Haley?"

"Whoa, when did this happen?" Peyton asked

"OK, well Haley and I were both really upset after the whole basketball party at Nathan's and."

"And it all ahppened very fast." Haley added

"Well, not too fast." Lucas said defensively

"Wait you had sex with Haley right after almost having sex with me?" Peyton asked

"Peyton, that doesn't matter." Nathan said. "Haley, you told me you weren't ready and that you wanted to wait until you got married. And Lucas all that bull you gave me about not pressuring Haley when you had already had a one-night-stand with her. You guys have been lying to me forever."

"Nathan, after sleeping with Lucas, I realized I wasn't ready and I wanted to be in love and married the next time I had sex." Haley said

"And Haley, you told me that you were a virgin." Peyton said

"Yeah, that was a lie." Haley said "Nathan, are you OK?"

"I don't know." He said "I just need some time to get my head around this. OK?"

No one talked for a few minutes. Then Nathan chimed in again.

"Haley after the party you and Lucas were at the cafe, right?" Nathan asked

"Yeah" Haley said

"You had sex at your mom's cafe Lucas?" Brooke asked. "Please tell me you didn't do it where people ate."

"On the couch." Haley said

"EW. Ive sat on that couch." Peyton said.

"OK can we stop talking about the Lucas, Haley sex thing? I need to get that picture out of my head." Brooke said. "But, one secret can't count for two people. Lucas or Haley, one of you needs to confess something else."