It was early morning and Antoinette Giry was preparing herself for morning lessons. She answered the sharp knock that was a code, hurriedly. They entered even more quickly. "What has happened?" She looked from him to Christine.

Christine looked down and started to speak but Erik broke in--"I brought her here for you to protect," he said quickly, "no one must disturb her. There will be changes in tonight's program, Christine will play countess. We have been practicing…she knows the part." It was true, he trained her in every active role of Carlotta's. It had only been recently that he thought her ready for it. Antoinette seemed to accept this and took immediate control after making sure Christine was not harmed.

"My dear why don't you go lie down, we will speak shortly and I will send for Meg she said gently." Christine seemed relieved and left to the adjoining bedroom. She gave him one last look and he understood-- he would not reveal their secret. "Sit down Erik," she said not as gently, after she had left. He did. She spoke firmly. " I have allowed this relationship to continue for many years as it has done you both a great deal of good. I cannot allow this to continue until I know of your intentions."

He fully understood her concern. "I love her Antoinette. She has seen my face. I have left it to her to decide if she willaccept me as a man. I would marry her, Mme if she would have me. It has been my desire for some time now. With things the way they are, I fear I will have to leave here and start a new life. I have decided on America. I cannot leave without her."

"Please be patient and allow me to deal with Andre and Firmin, patience is not your virtue," she smiled wryly. "Threats will not help this situation, nor will continuous manipulation on your part." She sighed with acceptance. "You have as many problems as you have talents Monsieur…I don't know if you are ready for the outside world.

His brow creased, "Madame, I will have no choice regardless of whether I am ready or not. I hope I do not have to leave here but if I must…give them the letters Mme, he said. " I have promised her the role of Countess-- it must happen." He then rose quickly and turned to leave," please take care of her Madame," he said with tears in his eyes, and disappeared.