Jack and Will didn't say for the rest of the voyage to the cave. Mr. Gibbs went up to Will and asked "How are you doin' mate?" "Why didn't you all let me save her? I could have. She would still be right here." Mr. Gibbs looked at Will confused. "Why do ye care so much bout what happens to Katherine? I thought it was Miss Swan ye were after." "I love Elizabeth. I do but Katherine was like a sister to me. I would tell her about all of my problems and when I told her she would find a way to make be feel better. I've known…. knew her all my life," will said. Mr. Gibbs put his arm around Will and said "I had a brother once., but he is no longer with us. Head bitten off by a rabid goat it was!" Mr. Gibbs began to sod uncontrollably. "I told him not the feed the goat! The sign specified it all!" Will looked very uncomfortable. Mr. Gibbs threw his arms around Will and let out a loud comical help. Will pretended that someone was calling his name and said "I'll be right there!" Will walked to the starboard side of the ship. He didn't see that Jack was there as well "If it's any consolation mate, I am sorry." Jack said. Will gave Jack an evil look. "Why didn't you let me save her?" Will asked "Because," Jack began "If you would have jumped in it would have put the both of you at risk and I didn't want to taker that chance." Will's eyes shot up to meet Jacks "so you are telling me that the reason why you didn't let me save her is because you are about my well being," will asked Jack had a 'oh crap' look on his face "No" Jack said quickly. Will could tell that Jack was lying and that he did in fact care but Will was confused to as why. "Would my welfare have anything to do with Barbosa and/or the Black Pearl?' Jacks face turned pale. "well my boy…that is….. Define welfare….umm…" All of a sudden Mr. Gibbs yelled "Captain we are at the cave," Jack smiles and said come lad let us get your bonny lass Elizabeth." The moment Jack mentioned Elizabeth he completely forgot about Katherine and the secrets that Jack was keeping from him all he care about now was Elizabeth. "What should we do if the worst should come?" Mr. Gibbs asked Jack slowly "Jacks face turned very seriously 'Keep to the code," Will thought to himself about all the possible definitions there could be for the code.
While Jack and Will were rowing into Will had to ask Jack, "What did you mean when you said 'Keep to the code'?" Jack turned an d looked at Will and said ""Any man that falls behind stays behind." Will then remembered someone "So that is why you left Katherine? That is why you killed her!" Will asked sharply Jack turned and looked at Will very confused "I don't know what pretty little think you saw tossing and turning in the water, but I didn't kill her the water in her lungs did the trick." Jack said calmly. "I am not sure whether or not you are aware of it mate but I fell bad about her fallin I do mate. But do you really think that you could have saved her if you if you jumped in?" Jack asked. Will quickly snapped back "I could have tried!" Jack then said slowly and calmly, "What if Katherine had fallin in and your Miss Swam tried to jump in and save her?" "I would have jumped in first!" Will said "And why is that mate?" Jack asked Will got very quiet and didn't look Jack in the eye "Because she would have died as well." Will said Jack said again even louder "Because… she would have died AS WELL! So mate do you see where I am coming from?" Will hated to admit it but in some way Jack was making sense. He knew that there was no way that he would have found her in that storm, and even if he did there could have been no way for them to get back on the ship.
"Why do you care so much about my well being?" Will asked " Aye are be back to this again?" Jack asked exasperated look everyone one had to have something that they can depend on so whey wont get the sharp end of the blade so I need security." "You need leverage!" Will said as the both god out of the boat Will picked up the oar and hit Jack on the back of the head and said "Sorry Jack but I wont be your leverage!" As Will snuck up on Barbossa and his cursed crew he saw Elizabeth and was waiting for the right moment to rescue her and he found it. Sadly it was when Barossa smacked the heck out her but never-the-less it was moment. Will covered Elizabeth's mouth to let her know not to make a sound and they were out of there!
On Elizabeth and Will way back to the ship Will told her about everything that they had to go through and then sadly he told her about how Katherine fell overboard and how he tried to save her "Will there was nothing that you could have done. If you would have tried to ave her you both would have died." Will looked at Katherine surprised "what?" Elizabeth asked "That is exactly what Sparrow said to me." Will said "Well that is I think the only thing he will ever be right about in his entire life.
When Will and Elizabeth returned to the ship Elizabeth was surprised to see Mr. Gibb "Mr. Gibbs!" she said "Welcome aboard!" Mr. Gibbs said happily, but that happiness faded when he asked, "Where is Jack?" "He fell behind." will said coldly