Chapter 5: Three Girls, Three Stories

A/N: I don't own any of the characters of One Tree Hill. Thank you to those who reviewed! Keep reviewing, please! Enjoy!

"What are you doing here Nikki?"

"I think it's my daughter's first birthday this week?"

"Actually, it's MY daughter's first birthday this week," Peyton said stepping in.

"Listen Curly, she's my daughter. I carried her for 9 months, and I was there when she was made. Didn't you listen during Sexual Reproduction?"

"Sorry Skank, I didn't know that. But did you pay attention during listening? Because I remember a certain judge telling you that I am legally her mother."

"Listen Jake, Perthon…"

"It's Peyton."

"Yeah. Okay. Well, even though Peyton is Jenny's mother, I am still her birth mother. And I've changed. I know it's only been a few months, but, I would like it if I could be in Jenny's life. Not as her mother, but maybe as her aunt, or just Nikki. I just….I want to see her grow up."

"I don't know about this Jake."

Peyton and Jake listened to Nikki's little speech and told her they'd call her with their decision.

"I don't either Peyt. But I just think if Nikki got someone to adopt Jenny. I would die. I would want to see her grow up."

"It's your decision, Jake."

"Actually, it's both of ours. You are Jenny's mother, Peyton."

"Yeah. But then again, so is Nikki."

Brooke sat home alone in her room replaying over and over again what happened with her and Lucas, pretending it didn't bother her.

"I think I'm falling in love with you Brooke…."

"Take it or leave it, Lucas."

"I can't believe I did that. Lucas obviously has feelings for me. Why can't I just trust him?"

She thought about calling him. She picked up the phone three times. She never got passed the first 3 digits. She then realized that it was done, until she grew up and matured and realized she wanted just what Lucas did. She burst into tears, and cried herself to sleep.

Brooke's Dream

Brooke ran down the street to Lucas's house, finally growing the courage to tell him she truly did love him too.

"LUCAS! LUCAS OPEN THE DOOR!"

"Brooke? What are you doing here?"

Brooke jumped and kissed him. Lucas then pushed her off.

"Listen Brooke.."

"No Lucas. I want it all too. I want it all. I trust you. I want to be in a relationship with you. I love you, too."

"Brooke-"

"No, Lucas, I mean it. I love you."

"Brooke, I've moved on."

"What?"

"It's been 2 years. I told you I wasn't going to wait forever."

End Dream

"I have to tell him how I feel."

Brooke jumped out of her bed and ran down the street looking for Lucas. She ran straight to the river court. He had once told her that whenever he needed time to think, he'd go and play some basketball.

"LUCAS?"

"LUCAS ARE YOU OUT THERE?"

"LUC-"

And what she saw at that moment is the exact reason on why she never wanted to commit. There was Lucas laughing and hugging some girl that she didn't even recognize. They looked pretty comfortable with each other, they obviously weren't just friends. The tears came down again, and she turned around, and ran home.

Nathan was trying to get a drunk, no, a very drunk Haley home.

"Nathan! You're here!"

"Haley, I've been here for a while now."

"Really?"

"Yeah."

"Well then why didn't you say you were here?"

"Haley, I took you home."

"When?"

"Forget it Haley, let's just get you ready for bed."

"But I'm not tired!"

"Haley, you have to sleep this off."

"But if I fall asleep then I'm going to wake up with a really bad hangover."

"Well, what are you going to do then?"

"Just stay up forever and ever!"

"Ahh.. I don't think so. Come on."

"Nathan you are like my bestest friend in this whole entire universe."

"Thanks, Haley."

"Nathan! Why aren't we friends in school!"

"I don't know Haley," Nathan said tucking Haley in.

"But you are like, SO SO sweet! Oh my goodness! I have like SUCH a great idea!"

"And what is that?"

"We should totally be friends!"

"Haley, I can't wait to tell you this on Monday when you aren't a crazy drunk."

"Yeah. And I can't wait to tell you when you're not on some crazy drugs!"

"Haley, I'm not on drugs."

"Then how come you're being nice to me?"

"I'm actually just being myself."

"But you're an ass!"

Nathan laughed at Haley's behavior. He'd never seen her like this before. Maybe it's because we never gave each other a chance, Nathan thought.

"You are super hot Nathan!"

"Thanks Haley."

"Do you think I'm super hot?"

"Yes, I do."

"Really! Then we should get married!"

"That is such a good idea. Tell you what. You get some sleep, and on Monday when you're better, we'll start planning."

"OKAY!"

"There are some Advil and a glass of water right next to you."

"Thanks Hubby."

"Night Haley."

"NIGHT!"

Nathan laughed to himself as he let himself out of Haley's house. He never realized the person Haley truly was on the inside. All he knows is that the two of them basically live to fight. "I don't hate Haley at all…in fact, I remember when we used to be friends."

Flashback-7th grade

Nathan and Haley were walking around the Scott Mansion, which was at this point, completely empty.

"Nate…Where are your parents?"

"With my Uncle Keith and Aunt Deb in Charlotte."

"Where's Luke?"

"I don't know."

"Oh."

After joking around for a while. Nathan looked at Haley as she laughed and realized how pretty she really was.

"So, Haley, have you ever kissed a boy?"

"Yeah."

"What?"

"Yep. 6th grade. Thomas Anderson. You?"

"No, I've never kissed a boy."

"Good to know. But what I meant was, have you ever kissed a girl?"

"Well-yeah-you know-of course I hav-"

"You haven't kissed a girl!"

"No. But don't tell anyone."

"I won't but I mean, you Nathan Scott. Oh my goodness!" Haley said laughing.

"What's that supposed to mean?" Nathan said getting mad.

"I mean I've even gotten my first kiss."

"Well that's because you're a dumb slut!"

Haley looked at Nathan shocked. She got up and stormed out of Nathan's room, and life.

"Haley, I'm SORRY!"

End Flashback

And that's why they hated each other. She laughed at him, and he called her a dumb slut. But neither would admit it, that the two were actually pretty fond of one another. They secretly watched each other, and got mad whenever they realized the other was doing wrong. But instead of helping each other during their times of needs, they poked and picked on those times of needs. Neither did know that within the matter of the next few months, Haley and Nathan wouldn't be normal anymore. They'd be miles from it….

Up next on Accidentally In Love:

"So, who's your Maid of Honor, Haley?"

"What?"

"I told you that you wouldn't remember."

"Brooke! Listen, I tried calling you last night."

"Really?"

"Yeah. I wanted to talk to you about what happened."

"With us?"

"Yeah. Of course."

"Really, I thought it would be about that girl who you had your arms around Friday night."

"Nikki's back. And I don't know if I should trust her, or my instincts…"

Special Thanks:

Hilaryhilary: You are one of my favorite authors on this website. For you to review my story, and to actually enjoy it means so much to me. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this!

Angel6: Thank you for your support of this story. The song is All or Nothing, on O'Town's CD. I'm so glad you are enjoying this story. Next chapter will have some more Naley…good or bad?

1THLUVR4EVA: I'm so happy you are enjoying this story! I'm going to try and update at least a chapter everyday…I'm so glad that I made you want to read this story more and more…Hope you liked this chapter!

Medine: Thank you so much!

Kylie2060: Thank you for reviewing. Don't worry, Haley's feelings will change…eventually. Lol. Hope you enjoy!