Thanks for the reviews!
Okay, everyone said they want a sequel, so I'll make one when this story is finished but that's not for a while yet. This story is going to have about 30 chapters or so
Chapter 22
Do you love me?
"Happy Birthday to you, happy birthday to you, happy birthday to Phoebe, happy birthday to you,"
Phoebe opened her eyes to see all her sisters surrounding her bed holding presents
"Happy birthday Pheebs," the said cheerfully
"Thanks guys, now give me my presents," Phoebe said grinning
They all laughed
Phoebe unwrapped a "Kill It Before It Dies" DVD from Paige
A CD of her favourite band from Piper and a new denim skirt from Prue
"Grams wanted to give you hers herself so you'll get it when she comes back from work," Piper explained
There was another present lying at the bottom of her bed
"Who is that from?" Phoebe asked
"Cole, he gave it to Leo who gave it to me to give to you," Piper answered
"Why couldn't he give it to me himself?" Phoebe asked
"He went away last night with his dad for a few days, he would have told you but Leo said it was a spur of the moment type thing," Piper said
"Oh," Phoebe said disappointed
She picked up the present and unwrapped it to reveal a thin gold chain with a heart at the bottom
She carefully opened the heart and inside was a photo of her mum
"He remembered," Phoebe whispered
"What?" Paige asked
"A while ago I told Cole I used to have a locket that I kept my mum's photo in but one day I broke it and it got thrown in the bin," Phoebe said not taking her eyes off the locket
"It's beautiful, it must have cost him a lot," Paige said
"He must really like you," Prue said
"We're just friends," Phoebe said half convincingly
"Pheebs friends buy each other chocolates or something like that, boyfriends buy something like this," Prue said taking the necklace from Phoebe to look at
"Phoebe Cole likes you and you like him," Paige said matter-of-factly
"Speaking of more than just friends, you and Glen," Piper said nudging Paige
Paige's cheeks suddenly turned slightly red
"Since when?" Phoebe asked
Paige opened her mouth to talk but it was Piper, who answered "Since yesterday,"
Paige looked at her "How do you know, we haven't told anyone yet?"
"Me and Leo were at the mall yesterday and we saw you kiss," Piper said grinning
"Oh," Paige said blushing again
"So are you two together?" Phoebe asked
"Yeah," Paige admitted
Piper and Phoebe squealed and hugged her
"Oh yeah me and Leo got back together yesterday too," Piper said happily
Paige and Phoebe squealed
"I'm so happy for you two, yesterday was a big day for the Halliwell girls," Phoebe said laughing
They all suddenly looked at Prue and felt really bad, yesterday she had seen Andy with Lindsay
"Oh Prue that was so stupid of us to say all that…"
"No guys it's fine, I'm happy for you all," Prue said giving them a weak smile
The doorbell rang
"Who is that?" Phoebe asked
Piper got off the bed and went over to the window
Her face fell slightly "Prue, it's Andy, if you want I can go and get rid of him,"
"No, it's fine, actually I called him," Prue said
"You did?" they all asked surprised
"Yes," Prue said
"But last night, you wouldn't answer any of his calls and there were a lot of them," Paige said remembering the night before and Prue's phone and the house phoebe rang constantly all night practically
"I know but I've been thinking since then, I mean I am carrying his child," Prue said
"I guess, what are you going to say?" Piper asked
"Ask him why," Prue sighed leaving the room to answer the door
She took a deep breath and opened the door
"Hi," he said softly
"Hi," she replied then she looked up at him and suddenly the image of him and Lindsay filled her head
She tried to shake it off
"Thanks for seeing me, I know I don't deserve it," Andy said
"Come in," Prue said and he followed her upstairs
Prue walked into her room and went over to the window
Andy slowly shut the door behind him trying to prepare himself for what was to come
"Look Prue I'm so sorry, I didn't…" he began
"Andy I don't want an apology, I want to know why," Prue said sharply, "Why did you do it, especially with Lindsay Taylor, you know how I feel about her,"
"Prue I was drunk I didn't know what I was doing," Andy said desperately
"It didn't look that way to me, I saw you two, you had your arm around her and when you woke up you looked over and smiled at her and I think you were pretty sober by this point," Prue said her voice rising with every word she said "And that's not all everytime I say a wrong word about her, you're always quick to get in there and defend her. Like when I told you it was her that told everyone I was pregnant, you wouldn't believe me and at the dance you two almost kissed, yeah that's right I saw you but I didn't say anything, I told myself stop it Prue you're overreacting, Andy wouldn't do that, but here we are, you know maybe I should have walked out the bathroom a minute later and you would have kissed then we probably wouldn't be here having this conversation," By the end Prue was completely yelling
Andy gulped "Prue…"
"Andy do you love me?" Prue asked suddenly
"Of course I do, surely you don't need to ask that," Andy said
"Do you like Lindsay?" Prue asked quieter this time
"That doesn't matter, I love you," Andy said looking her in the eye, she quickly looked away
"Do you like Lindsay?" she demanded louder this time
Andy looked down at the floor "Yes," he admitted quietly
Prue felt her heart sink, she bit her lip to stop herself from crying and then took a deep breath "Then I won't stand in your way,"
Andy suddenly looked up at hearing what Prue had said "No Prue, I'm not leaving you,"
He reached out for her hand but she pulled away
"You don't have a choice, I'm leaving you," she couldn't believe what she was saying
"But Prue…"
"Andy, I love you but I'm not going to sit around and wait for something like this to happen again, you and Lindsay like each other and you owe it to yourselves to give it a shot and I'm not saying it'll work out but you have to at least give it a go," Prue said trying to keep her voice even
"I don't want to lose you," Andy said tears threatening to fall from his eyes
"We're still going to be friends and we're having a baby so I think you're stuck with me," Prue joked trying to lighten the mood "But just because we're having a bay together doesn't mean we have to be together," a few tears rolled down her cheeks as she realised what she was saying
"Prue I love you," Andy said as tears really fell from his eyes, he gently stroked her cheek
"I love you too," Prue choked and let a few more tears fall, Andy held her tightly for a few moments then she quickly regained her composure and wiped her tears away, "I do love you, don't ever think that I don't but this is for the best, I don't want you to be with me just because you feel like you have to,"
"I don't feel like that…"
"Andy, please," Prue whispered
He hugged her tightly again and kissed her forehead before leaving her room silently
Prue couldn't hold back any longer and her tears flowed down her face like a river
She looked up and saw her sisters walk in the room and hug her hard
And it was at that moment she realised whatever happened they would always be there for her and that meant a lot
Andy walked into his bedroom and was completely surprised to see Lindsay sitting on his bed
"Lindsay, what are you doing here?" he asked
"Your mum let me in, I just to know if you talked to Prue?" Lindsay asked
"She broke up with me," Andy said turning away so she couldn't see the tears well up in his eyes
"No way, I'm so sorry this is all my fault," Lindsay rambled
"It's mine aswell," Andy said
"I…Andy…I'm so sorry," Lindsay stuttered, "That night it should never have happened,"
"I'm glad it did," Andy said looking back round at her "I mean I hate that it hurt Prue but Lindsay I really like you,"
"You do?" Lindsay asked surprised
"Yeah but I just broke up with Prue so…"
"I understand, well I better go," Lindsay stood up quickly
"Yeah that would probably be for the best," Andy said
"I'll see you then," Lindsay
"Yeah, bye," Andy said
She gave him a quick peck on the cheek and before he knew it she was kissing him on the lips but he didn't break it, he just let it happen
Okay so I know all the Prue/Andy fans probably all hate me but please keep reading because I can promise a happy ending
Please review!