Say it Isn't So

By xox sweet n sexy xox

.:This story is being written by the two of us, and we're each writing our own chapters so there will be some difference in writing styles. We will each sign off at the bottom so you know who is writing what chapters:.

Disclaimer: Sadly, we don't own Gilmore Girls. Too bad because if we did…Tristan would be back and sweeping Rory off her feet ;)

Rated PG (this might change)

Summary: Rory is with Logan and happy as ever until someone unexpectedly shows up and turns her world upside down. Can u guess who that person is? Yeah…of course this is a Trory hehe. And by the way, this is a really twisty story (at least that's what we plan on it being).

A/N:

Thanks to everybody who reviewed it means sooooo much.

Sooty7Sweep: We really have no clue why Logan calls Rory Ace.... I guess the writers where trying to make him more like Tristan. I think it is a stupid name and Mary makes more sense.

I'm so sorry this is out so late. I am in the school musical (beauty and the beast, that's why I made so many references to it.) And it takes up a lot of time. Well you guys can understand and I bet you all hate excuses as much as I do, so on with the story.

Tristan lead Rory around the house into the living room while carrying their coffees. He sat down on the piano bench leaning himself against the keys while Rory chose a seat across from the piano. They sat for a few moments in utter silence, neither saying a word. Rory was the first to speak up, "So, Bible Boy, tell me about your life since you left Chilton."

"First let me ask you a question." Without missing a beat he added, "Where did you get this Bible Boy name from?"

She put on a mock angered face and answered the question. "Well, you were the first person I had ever heard of to use the Bible characters as an insult, so hence the name."

"Well the nickname was true, wasn't it?"

She blushed a little at the remark and looked downwards at the red carpet.

"I thought so. And I assume that the nickname is still true."

Her blush was gone as she became brave to face up the accusation. She stared at him straight the eyes and said, "Well you know what they say when you assume."

Tristan's eyes got a playful look and he smirked as if challenging her. "No, Mar, actually, I don't know. What do they say about assuming."

"Well, I'm not going to tell you," she said in a three year old voice. "You still have to answer my question, I would like to know what you have been up to."

"Oh, Mary, I didn't know you cared." His facial expression changed once again into a more serious tone. "Okay, so I left you at Chilton playing Juliet. That next week I was shipped off to North Carolina to wake up at five in the morning and start working out. About five months after I had left my mom called me saying that my dad was in the hospital because of stress. He told me I had put all the stress on him by making the family name look bad. Two months after that he had a heart attack and passed away--"

Rory interrupted, "I am so sorry, Tristan, I didn't know." She looked sorrowful like she wanted to comfort him, but couldn't. Maybe because they weren't the best of friends, or because of her current position with Logan. Whatever it was she looked a little uncomfortable.

"That's ok. I can't believe I'm telling you all of this," he looked into her face and said, "I'm sorry I'm probably boring you. Why don't you tell me what happened with you."

"Oh, no, I will tell you later. Go on."

"Okay, so then Mitcham and my mom started dating and they got married about two years ago. Then I graduated with honors, got into Princeton and now I am there studying Pre-Med. I want to be a pediatrician."

"Tristan Dugrey as a pediatrician. How did you think of that one?" Rory questioned.

Tristan replied with a smile, "Well, I have always liked kids and helping people so I thought this would be great for me. It's tough, but so far I like it."

"Aw, you have a soft spot for kids, that's so sweet." Rory mocked in a baby voice.

"Ya, ya, but I have an even softer spot for sexy women." He paused and gave Rory a wink. "Tell me what you have been up to?"

"Fine," she said. "You left, Dean and I broke up, I cheated on him with this guy Jess, Jess and I dated, I loved him, he left. I graduated as Valedictorian, sharing the spot with Paris. And I chose to go to Yale instead of Harvard to be closer to my family. When I got to Yale I found out Paris was my roommate, school, journalism, summer passed by. Then this year I found out again that I was rooming with Paris, I am still writing for the paper under Features, that's where I met Logan, long story, and then Logan and I started dating. Now I am here." She took a deep breathe and exhaled while adding, "My story isn't half as interesting as yours. You have a Shakespearean story, romance, tragedy, violence, you should write a screen play."

"I'm glad you think that," He smiled, a real smile at her. Then the room got a silence for a few moments, them just taking in each others presence.

She then out of nowhere popped her head up and said, "Let's play truth or dare with no dares."

He laughed at her, "So you wanna play Truth?"

"I guess you could say that, but it is still called Truth or Dare, because that has a better ring to it. You first."

"Ok, um, best friend."

"My mom and Lane. Worst date."

"Paris, she was too nervous and I was a jerk. It was a good date at friends, but not as a couple. It was way too awkward. Favorite color."

"Blue. Favorite band."

"Metallica."

"THANK GOD!"

"Favorite movie."

"Willy Wonka. The Oompa Loompa's are so hot."

"Did you just say they are hot."

"Yes, they orange faces and green hair really turn me on, and the fact that they are 3 feet shorter than me."

"You are odd."

Rory smiled at the memory. "Thank you."

They leaned in. It was like they were magnets, always attracted to each other and they couldn't pull away. Oh my God I am going to kiss Tristan and I can't wait.

I am going to kiss Rory Gilmore and it's going to be the best kiss ever... SHIT!

Their lips were centimeters apart when Tristan saw something out of the corner of his eye. Just then he whispered against her lips, "I would reenact the next scene, but your boyfriend is watching."

A/N: I hope you like it. Jackie hates that I write the chapter with the cliffhangers cuz she never knows what to write. Hehe. I love writing them though. So sorry again for the delay, and I really do hope this chapter made up for it. Oh and if you haven't, check out Jackie's new story called "Beginning of a Beginning" under the pen name Babydrag0nfly.

Peace out,
Sexy