The Truth

Discalimer: I don't own POTC. Don't own the song Why by Avril Lavigne.

Sarah stared at Jack for quite some time, he seemed to be looking at her with most intensity. His stare never wavering as she walked up the final steps to the helm, she glared at him.

"Why are ye filty 'ands on me wheel?" she asked.

Jack stepped back away from it. "I uh- well- uh- I'm use to me own I guess."

She didn't say anything for a few minutes. "Sparrow, I really don't want to see you ever again. As hard as that may seem, since I use ter love ye and all but it's the bloody truth."

He reached up and scratched his head. "I understand but I want you to know one thing."

"And that is?"

"I never was with that MaKayla lass" Jack confessed. He nodded to Sarah as she stood there looking at him. "Well, I'll leave you to yer lonesome."

He walked down the stairs and was already half across the deck when Sarah came rushing towards him.

Hey, listen to what we're not saying

Let's play, a different game than what we're playing

Try, to look at me and really see my heart

"Jack!" she cried out stopping him in his tracks. He whipped around to see her running towards him.

"Aye love?" He looked at her watching her breathing hard.

Tears welled in her eyes, damn, pirates don't cry. It's not supposed to hurt this way.

Do you expect me to believe I'm gonna let us fall apart?
I can feel, I can feel you near me, even when you're far away I can feel, I can feel you baby, why

"Why?"

"Why what?" He asked her. She sighed.

"Why did ye betray me then? That's all I want to know then go."

"Well" he began. "I still 'ad hard feelings about the mutiny thing I be guessin'."

Sarah glared hard at him, she stepped toward him menacingly. "Excuse me!" She cried.

"The whole Barbossa Mutiny" Jack confirmed what she had thought he was talking about.

She wanted to hit him, thoroughly enjoy killing him slowly.

"You think I 'ad sometin ter do with that do ya?"

Jack put a finger to his chin as if thinking about it for a moment. "Of course ye did love."

Sarah took in a deep breath. "I didn't mutiny ye Jack. 'Ow could I if I was in the brig at the time?"

He stared down into her dark blue eyes. "I-uh-well…ye were not in the brig!"

"Aye, I was Jack. In fact it was ye that put me there!"

Flashback

"I swear Sarah it's the last time ye ever lay yer filthy 'ands on me stuff" Jack glared at Sarah. It was ten years earlier and Sarah had been on Jack's ship as a crew member and a lover.

"Come on Jack!" Sarah groaned.

"Captain! And that's the last time ye don't respect me title!"

Sarah glared at him. "Excuse Me?"

"Aye, Sarah, ye be always callin' me Jack" he said making the Jack more girly.

"Are ye on yer monthly or something?" Sarah asked her mouth hanging open.

"Wha'?" Jack looked at her confused as to what she was talking about.

Sarah and Jack had known each other since they were kids. They became lovers at the age of sixteen, and that's when they both left with each other to become pirates on his dad's ship. The Black Pearl. And now that he was Captain, he wanted everyone to call him that, he wanted the title to be there everywhere. And he had forced Sarah to call him Captain everywhere, even when he made love to her. Now he was being really foolish.

"Yer name is Jack! I've called ye Jack forever!" Sarah cried. Jack came towards her. She started to back up, she still clutched Jack's rum bottle in her hand. She had taken it upon herself to help herself to his stash.

"Don't ye dare touch me Sparrow" She spat at him. He raised an eyebrow at her.

"No?"

"Nay!" she protested as he pinned her to the wall. "I'll drop it!"

His eyes grew wide as he stared at the half full bottle of rum. Hey, look at everything half full and not empty.

"Jack.."

"Captain!"

She glared, "I'm not gonna call ya Captain when its just me and you savvy?"

"I'm going to put ye in the brig!"

She raised an eyebrow. Well if he was going to punish her then hell, why not bring him with her. She threw down the bottle hard making it smash and a shrill anguished sound came from Jack.

"What the bloody 'ell is up with you!" he cried.

She grinned, "Take me to the brig now Captain" She emphasized the word Captain.

"Fine, I will" he seized her hand and started pulling her roughly down the corridors then down stairs. He opened an iron gate, stepped aside.

"Ladies first" he said with a grin. She walked in and he shut the door in her face locking it.

"If yer good, I'll let ye see a crew member. Of me choice that is. But until then no one sees ye and ye can't come out till I say so!"

"Or until you get lonely" she crooned. "Or your bed gets cold."

She came closer to the bars. "Or ye can't take it anymore and you just have to 'ave me!"

He laughed and shook his head. "Ye really are full of yourself."

"We'll see who needs the other, Sparrow!"

He grinned, "We shall see!"

And with that he left her in the brig all be her onesies.

Later that day Jack was marooned but Sarah couldn't do anything about it being locked away of course.

End Flashback

It's not supposed to feel this way I need you, I need you More and more each day It's not supposed to hurt this way I need you, I need you, I need you Tell me, are you and me still together?
Tell me, you think we could last forever?
Tell me, why

"I remember!" Jack exclaimed. "You bloody did break me rum bottle! Wasted good rum too may I add!"

She rolled her eyes. "So now ye know, Sparrow."

"Okay, okay, 'ow come ye didn't come back to me with a ship?" he asked her his arms crossed. 'See if she can get herself out of this one'.

"Because I didn't know where they left you! Barbossa docked I got off, of course that's after he gave me the offer to be his bonnie lass."

Jack narrowed his eyes. "And ye said no right?"

"Uh, no I said oh yes Barbossa! I've always been wantin' ye!"

"Not funny" Jack muttered.

"No it isn't. But thanks for clearing everything up Sparrow. Now leave" she pointed off the ship.

Jack came close to her. She tried to back up but the pole was there. He pulled her close to him.

"Sarah, I'm so sorry" he told her. She had to look away from him. "I love ye a lot."

"Oh?"

"Aye, with me 'ole heart. I've never loved anyone the way I love you. And I never will."

He leaned down and brushed his lips against hers. She didn't seem to collect herself until Jack was gone. He had disappeared after the kiss. She closed her eyes. It's not supposed to be this hard to leave him.

"Sarah?" Ana Maria touched her shoulder. "Jack wanted me to give you this."

Sarah opened her eyes to look down at Ana Maria's hand. A locket with the initials, C.J.S and S.H.S. She picked it up and held it in her hand, she pocketed it.

"Sarah, what's the S stand for on yours?"

"Sarah Harris Sparrow" Sarah told her. "We got married when we were young. His dad stopped off near this island. And this tribe had this Marriage ritual, and we got married. Not legal or anything but to us it is.

"Everytime one of us separates the one who has the locket gives it to the other."

Ana Maria smiled, "That's sickly sweet."

"It is" Sarah smiled.

"He still love ye" Ana said. "Just thought you should know."

She saw Sarah's mouth open her eyes were narrowed.

"We all know it was bloody 'orrible what he did to you but that's Jack. I'm sure there is some way to get him back. But don't leave him Sarah, its not worth two hearts to be broken."

Sarah raised an eyebrow at her. "Who else's heart is going to be broken."

Ana shook her head. "If you hadn't noticed, its yours."

Ana Maria left her with her thoughts.

Sparrow'sLovelyLass: I know HE DOES deserve the cold shoulder..but come on you can't help but still love him right! He is soooooo hawt! haha Makes me sad to write her being mean to him...lol..thanks for the review! Fanfiction took of my Jack/You fics..thats makes me mad lol ...but I should have known! oh well! Must be off to do the last chappter!

Speechdisappearsintosilence: Thanks for the review! I know that chapter was way short wasnt it! lol! But this one i think is sort of longer maybe!...one more CHAPTER! OMG OMG ! Grr freaking Fanfiction took off me Jack/YOu fics lol