At Derek's hideout
Derek smiled and returned to where he had bound the Charmed one. "What did you do?" Piper demanded. "Nothing. Just turning your sister Paige evil." "Leave her alone! Haven't you done enough to her already?" Piper yelled. He just smiled. "As soon as she says the spell to vanquish me, it will go horribly wrong and she'll turn into a demon/ dark lighter. She'll be confused and shimmer to here accidentally and I'll take it from there." Leo!" Piper yelled. "He can't hear you." Derek taunted. "At least, not until the spell is over." "No!" Piper struggled against her bonds and Derek shimmered away. She let out a cry of frustration, knowing that there was nothing she could do to stop them.
Back at the manor
Paige put the last ingredient in and there was a little poof. "Are you sure you're up for it Paige?" Phoebe said. Paige took a deep breath. "As ready as I'll ever be." She looked at the spell she had written and then at Leo and Phoebe. She couldn't take it to see any of them get hurt. She just hoped Piper was okay. She started reciting the spell and then as soon as she said the last word, she knew something was wrong. "Ah!" She cried, dropping the paper. Leo and Phoebe tried to rush over but they were thrown back by some invisible shield. Paige felt herself grow angrier at the two of them. Leo hadn't been able to heal her all the way because he didn't want to. Phoebe never really like her. She felt a hot anger flow through her and then she shook those thoughts aside. She looked down at her clothes and watched as they turned into a black pair of pants and a black tank top. She felt her hair and saw stands of black. She looked around. What was she doing in this attic? If the Charmed ones found out, she'd be dead.
She looked around, panicked and then felt an enormous power rush. She smiled at the power she had gained and tested out what she had. She was shocked to see herself holding a fireball in her hand a few minutes later. That hot anger rushed back in and before she could stop herself, she hurled a fireball and Phoebe and Leo. "Paige, what have you become!" Phoebe said horrified. She watched in stunned silence as her sister's eyes grew black and she leered at Phoebe. "You have no idea what kind of power I have! I don't have any need for you two anymore." She shook her head and looked at them scared. "W-what's happened to me?" She whispered more to herself then them.
"Oh Paige." Phoebe whispered. Piper was suddenly shimmered in and then Derek was about to shimmer out. "See you soon." He waved to Paige. Her eyes flashed with anger and she launched a fireball at him. He looked at her with a surprised look on his face as he caught fire. "NOO! I protected myself against witches but not demons!" He screamed and exploded into ashes. Leo ran over to Piper and they all approached Paige cautiously. "Paige?" Piper said, fearful that her sister was gone. Paige looked at them in recognition for a second and then she hurled a huge fireball at her. She shimmered a crossbow into her hand.
"I knew it!" Leo yelled. "No, that Derek guy put something in the potion to make it go wrong." Piper explained. "It wasn't Paige's fault!" Leo ducked as an arrow came whizzing by his head. "Paige, you know better than this!" Phoebe yelled. Paige was totally confused. "I-I don't understand . . ." Another demon orbed in and took a look at Paige. He grabbed her hand and they were off. "Why is this happening to Paige?" Piper moaned and she clenched her fists. "Leo, can you sense her?" Phoebe asked. Leo closed his eyes and concentrated hard. "I can sense that she's really confused right now but I can't sense where she is." Piper pulled out a map and a scrying crystal. "Um, Piper? Paige isn't exactly a witch right now in case you didn't see the fireballs she was shooting out of her hands." Phoebe said.
"I know, but she doesn't know what she is right now so there's a safe bet she's still part witch." Piper scried for about an hour before giving up. Leo had gone up to the elders and was back now. "What did the elders say?" Phoebe asked worriedly. Leo looked a bit upset. "They said either you find a way to return Paige to normal or . . ." He trailed off. "Or what?" Piper said sharply. "Or you have to kill her." Leo said softly. Piper looked at him in disbelief. "Are the elders crazy? There is NO way we are killing our own sister." She said hotly.
"Unless you can think of something to save Paige, either you kill her yourselves or the Elders get someone to kill her." Leo said. "Can they do that? I mean aren't they against killing?" Phoebe said. "Normally yes, but not when this kind of power is walking around. Paige has an enormous amount of power and she still has some of her witch powers with her also." Leo said grimly. "Let's start looking for a way to reverse what he did." Piper said and she walked over to the Book of Shadows. "Whatever you guys do, it has to be within 24 hours of Paige getting turned evil, otherwise, there's only one other option." Leo said. Phoebe's face paled. "If we run out of time . . ." She trailed off. "Paige is evil for good and we have to kill her." Piper finished grimly.