Yes this is based off the book, I do like the movie but I thought it would be more fun to see Annie's reaction to the REAL Erik.

DISCALIMER: Remember only 3 of the characters are mine…and that doesn't include Erik, Raoul, Christine, or any of the other characters in POTO.

Chapter 6: It's not all bad

Annie roamed the hallways of the Opera House right before the gala; she was hoping to see Raoul again, his beautiful brown hair, and his great manners, what girl wouldn't want to see him again.

"Raoul?" Annie asked as she walked around.

"Annie!" Raoul said as he walked over to her.

"Raoul how are you?" Annie asked trying to be polite.

Raoul laughed and said.

"Annie I am the same I was a few minutes ago."

"I just wanted to make sure you didn't come down with anything in the past 5 minutes" Annie said making things up as she went along.

"Why would I, it's not like I can go anywhere." Raoul said with a heavy sigh.

"What do you mean?" Annie asked

"My brother can be so over protective of me, I can barely ever go anyplace without him there or him hounding me about where I have been, it bothers me so much" Raoul said quietly so his brother wouldn't overhear him.

"Is your brother older than you?" Annie asked

Raoul looked at her as if she was crazy.

"I guess you are new to Paris am I correct?" Raoul asked.

"Yes I came from New York City, New York" Annie said calmly.

"Where's New York?" Raoul asked

"New York is in America, but it's a lot different in the year 2005" Annie said with a dreamily sigh as she remembered her home.

"What do you mean 2005? We are still in the 1800's," Raoul stated.

"Somehow, strangely my twin sister, my cousin and I were transported here from our home in the future." Annie explained.

"You have a twin?" Raoul asked, his eyes sparkling as he said that.

"Yes, but we are nothing alike" Annie said.

"Does she look like you?" Raoul asked

"Not really I have red hair she has brownish hair, but our eye colors are the same and if you didn't know any better people think I'm her." Annie said quickly.

"Who is older?" Raoul asked

"She is, but only by 3 minutes and she's just like your brother but worse…she's a girl" Annie groaned.

"I know what you mean, I have two older sisters and an older brother and they just think they can baby me all the time because they are older" Raoul said.

"Yeah and it makes it worse that you don't have any parents to stop them" Annie said

"I know, and they just know that you hate it so that's why they do it." Raoul added.

"Oh. My. God. Raoul you just described the relationship between me and my sister!" Annie said ecstatically.

"You just described the same thing with my family" Raoul said.

"I guess things aren't all bad, if you have somebody to share the problems with you." Annie said quietly.

Ok truthfully how was that? I really want reviews so please tell me what you think!