"Hay girls what's the matter", asked Leo as he walked into the kitchen where the four sisters were
"Andy found out about us and pretty much told Prue that he wasn't sure if he wanted to be with her anymore", answered Paige as Prue cried on Pipers shoulder
"Would you like me to help him forget", asked Leo
"No it can't work like that, you see in the end he died trying to save me even though he didn't understand what was going on. This time he needs to chose to stay or leave with the information of what I am", cried Prue
"And you know Andy, he'll come back in his own time", comforted Phoebe
P4
"We've gotten through the Egyptian curse and the Wendigo and Andy still wont talk to me and tomorrow's Friday the thirteenth, what am I going to do", asked Prue as she, Phoebe and Paige sat in one of the nooks
"The same thing as last time deal with Barbas just try to set aside all fears", answered Phoebe
"Sure the last time he showed us our fears you beat me to a bloody pulp because you feared being evil and I feared not being good enough", said Paige as Piper and Leo walked up to them
"Get married now", replied Phoebe
"Just keep a low profile and everything will be okay", stated Leo
"It doesn't work like that, he will find us", answered Prue
"Speaking about finding, we've got to do something about the shop keep", said Piper as the other girls got out of the booth
"Hi can I help you", asked the lady behind the counter
"We're just looking", smiled Prue as the four slowly walked around the store
"That's fine but I need you gone by twelve I'm closing early", stated the lady as she looked at the clock saying 11:47
"Of course, I'll take this", replied Paige as she held up a small amulet
"I think that's it", added Phoebe as Paige charged the amulet
"Thanks", said Piper as the four walked out
"Okay where the hell is he it's 12:35 and her death was placed at 12:01", asked Prue as they sat outside of the shop
"I don't know she's safe and Barbas is no where to be see so lets just go home", answered Piper as she stood up
Manor Morning
"Who could it be this early", asked Paige as she walked to the door
"Paige I need to talk to you", stated Andy as Paige opened the door to Andy and Darrel
"What about", replied Paige as the inspectors walked in
"Last night you were at an Occult store and the owner died under strange circumstances", answered Darrel
"Yah she was in her twenties and she had a heart attack and all her hair was white and three others have died the same way", added Andy
"She was fine when we left and she seemed fine", said Paige as her sisters walked in
"You all were there", asked Andy as he looked directly at Prue
"Yah Paige wanted a new necklace", answered Prue as Paige held up the amulet she was wearing
"Okay I guess that's it we should track down some other leads", stated Darrel as he turned to exit
"Listen Andy if you want to know what really's going on come back without Darrel and I'll explain", whispered Prue as Andy looked at her intently
"Good girl give him what he wants to know and may be he'll come back", replied Piper once the door closed
"So why did Barbas come after we left", asked Prue changing the subject
"May be something we didn't think of, he wasn't always as bold to take out more then one witch at a time and may be five made him afraid", said Phoebe as Barbas appeared
"Four's no problem since I've gotten stronger", stated Barbas as he held up his hand
"You wont win we're stronger then you", replied Prue
"Prue afraid of rejection by love, Piper the elders taking away her love, Phoebe not being able to save hers, Paige not being able to find love. Amazing such a loving set of sisters with so many fears about love but still fears that give me what I need", read Barbas as he made their fears come true
"No one loves me I just push them away", whispered Paige as she crawled in a corner
"I'm evil baby don't you love me any more", asked a fake Cole as he appeared in front of Phoebe who shrank back crying sorry
"Leo, Leo where are you what did I do wrong", screamed Piper as she looked around frantically
"You disgust me Prue, what was I thinking loving you, you're just a sick monster", laughed a fake Andy just as the real Andy and Darrel came in hearing the screams and cries
"I'm sorry", replied Prue through tears as she fell to the flour
"You worthless bitch you should burn in hell for what you are", said the fake Andy as the real went to Prues side
"Prue I don't know what's going on but you need to snap out of this you can't die, I still love you even for what you are", stated Andy as he noticed that the four sisters were having trouble breathing and their hair was turning white
"Andy", whispered Prue as she focused on the real Andy
"Yes", answered Andy
"You can't have us Barbas we're not afraid, Piper Leo will never be taken away from you they need you together, Phoebe you know the potion will work on Cole, Paige we can make sure you find your true love just look at the rest of us", said Prue as she looked at her sisters
"That's right without the white lighter witch being born magic will die", whispered Piper as Barbas started turning to embers
"The potion will take away the demon and he won't be able to become the Source so why am I scare", asked Phoebe as Barbas started crumbing
"I guess it's a Hallowell tradition to deal with pain and suffering first and who am I to break tradition", smiled Paige as Barbas was completely disappeared
"We defiantly have some weak ass fears", laughed Phoebe
"We beat all others because of him so all that's left are the little ones", replied Prue
"What the hells going on", asked Darrel as he looked at the four sisters with white hair
"Are you hurt", asked Leo as he appeared
"A little we had an encounter with Barbas, you think you can fix our hearts and hair", answered Piper
"Sure just as long as you're fine", stated Leo as he placed a hand on Piper and Phoebes shoulder healing them, them moved to Paige and Prue
"Darrel why don't you come to the kitchen and we can explain", smiled Phoebe as she Piper and Paige guided him
"Andy, you probably want that explanation now", said Prue
"Yah and I need to talk to you alone", replied Andy as he helped her stand
"Come with me", answered Prue as she took him to her room
"So what just happened", asked Andy as Prue sat on her bed
"You know how I'm a witch, we'll that was a demon by the name of Barbas he's released every 1,300 years and if he can feed on the fears of 13 witches in twenty four hours he's set free. He can't be vanquished but he can be pushed back if a witch conquers their fears", stated Prue as Andy sat next to her
"And your fear was that I thought you were disgusting because you're a witch", realized Andy out loud
"It's been a month that you didn't call me back, that was the only thing I could think and I wouldn't blame you", said Prue as she lowered her head
"Are you ashamed of being a witch", asked Andy
"No I'm worried I wont be able to protect you again, me and my sisters have saved so many people and can save so many people, one time we saved a man from being turned into a ghost, another we stopped this girl from turning to evil, and another we stopped a Wendigo from eating the hearts out of people", retorted Prue
"What do you mean protect me again when have you fail", asked Andy
"You died so my sisters and me didn't have to and we couldn't save you, you told me it was alright that it wasn't my fault but I still felt like it was", cried Prue
"What do you mean I told you if I was dead how could I", replied Andy
"A while later I was killed by the Source and I met back up with you in heaven. I can know this because my sisters and I were pulled to the future by a future demon and we got our memories of our future selves to try and make things better. So you wouldn't die, I wouldn't die, so there was a chance for Melinda to be born and so I'd have a chance to know Paige as well", stated Prue
"It doesn't matter I still love you and I want to be part of your life no matter what, we can work through everything together", smiled Andy as he kissed Prue
"Thank you for saving me, for saving my sisters and for saving us", whispered Prue