One Night's Mistake

By: RoxyRoo

Disclaimer: I own nothing.

Summary: A story of how one night's mistake, can ruin the lives of two people.

AN: Thank you for all the reviews!

Chapter Thirteen

"I can not believe that every single one of those presents were for you yesterday," Tristan said the next afternoon, shaking his head.

"What can I say? I'm the town princess," Rory said proudly as she ate her poptart, sitting at the breakfast nook. The presents the day before had included an espresso machine, books, Hello Kitty stuff, ect. Not a single thing for Tristan. Just for Rory.

Tristan rolled his eyes. He looked up as the front door rattled, as someone was unlocking it.

"Hello!" Abigail said bouncing in, throwing a bag on the floor.

"Hey Abigail," Rory said, getting up to give her a hug. "What are you doing here?"

"I figured I would see what my favorite brother and sister-in-law were up to for the day," Abigail said, stealing Tristan's poptart right as he was about to bite into it.

"Hey!" Tristan protested, Abigail just smirked at him, as she took a bite. "Favorite brother my ass," he muttered under his breathe.

"What was that Trissy?" Abigail asked cheerfully.

Rory just grinned at the interaction between the two.

"So? What's going on today?" Abigail pried.

"Nothing really," Rory said. "I was going to try to get Tristan to do a movie day with me."

"Oh! Sounds fun!" Abigail said excitedly.

"Who said you were invited?" Tristan said narrowing his eyes at her, trying to snatch his poptart back.

"Tristan!" Rory scolded slapping his hand away. She put her arm around Abigail. "Is that anyway to talk to your sister?"

Tristan rolled his eyes, making Rory smack him upside the head.

"Ow!" Tristan yelped, rubbing the back of his head. "What was that for?"

"For rolling your eyes at me!"

"You're starting to sound like my mom," Tristan said glaring at her as he rubbed his head.

"Who you don't listen to neither," Abigail said with a roll of her eyes. "So anyways, what movie are we going to see?"

"I don't know, let's go to the movie store," Rory said, grabbing her jacket and purse. "We'll have to get a lot of junk food too, and order pizza!"

-

"I think we should get 'When Fools Rush In'," Abigail suggested with a sly smile once they were at the movie store. She handed the box to Tristan before walking off.

"No chick flicks," Tristan groaned, handing the box to Rory, without looking at it.

Rory looked at the box, reading what it said the movie was about. Her jaw dropped. "Abigail!"

"What?" Tristan asked, looking over at Rory.

"Nothing!" Rory said quickly, as her cheeks heated up. She stuck the movie back quickly, before moving on. "I think we need to get 'Charlie and the Chocolate Factory'. You can't go wrong with that." Rory grabbed it off the shelf.

"How about we get the newer one?" Tristan suggested.

Rory just starred at him, as if he was crazy.

"Or maybe not..." Tristan trailed off. "Fine, if you get that, I want Goonies!"

"Noooo," Abigail wailed. "You have seen that enough! When we were younger, he use to watch it twice a day!"

Rory laughed.

An evil smile suddenly came to Abigail's face. "Since you have both picked a movie, I get to pick the last one!"

"I do not like that look that she had on her face," Tristan trailed off, as he watched his sister's dark head dart between people to her destination.

"So what did you pick out?" Rory asked Abigail, as she started grabbing candy and putting it on the counter with the movies.

"Well," Abigail said with a huge smirk. "Since Tristan seems to love pirates so much, picking out Goonies, and we all know he loves Orlando..."

"You didn't?" Rory laughed, turning to look at Tristan.

"Three, two, one, you're dead!" Rory laughed as Tristan chased his sister out of the store, leaving her to pay for the movies and all the junk food.

-

"Let's watch 'Pirates of the Caribbean' first!" Abigail said, as she purposely plopped down in the only chair, which only left the couch to sit on.

Tristan rolled his eyes from the kitchen, where he was getting the drinks. "Does anyone want to buy a sister? I'll give her away for free."

"Tristan," Rory said in a warning voice, spreading all the junk food and pizza around on the coffee table. She then grabbed a slice of pizza, and relaxed on the couch, stretching the whole length of it with her feet up.

"So what are you two doing for Valentines day?" Abigail pried. She noticed that Tristan suddenly started concentrating on the drinks more so as he poured them into glasses.

"Nothing, at least for me," Rory sighed as she thought of Logan.

"Oh, I know, since neither of you are with someone, maybe you two should be each other's Valentines!" Abigail said excitedly. "You two are married after all."

Rory smiled, looking over at Tristan, who looked up from the drinks to meet her eyes.

"You want to?" Rory asked softly.

Tristan shrugged his shoulder. "Sure, why not?" He then brought the drinks over, setting them down on the table. He looked over the seating arrangements.

"Hey! Where am I suppose to sit?" he protested.

Rory looked from him to the ground. "The floor looks mighty comfy."

Tristan narrowed his eyes at her. "Well, then why don't you sit on it?" He then proceeded to swat her feet off the couch, settling himself into that spot. Rory immediately put her feet back up, on his lap, causing Tristan to glare at her. "Your feet stink."

"They do not!" Rory protested. "For that, we're watching Pirates first!"

Abigail hid her grin from them at their interaction. This was too easy.

-

"I love that movie," Rory sighed, leaning against Tristan's shoulder. Both of them had settled for sitting on the floor for the last movie, "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory".

Tristan looked over to Abigail who was curled up in the chair. "She's out."

"Oh! Should we wake her?" Rory asked. "It's a school night, doesn't she need to get home?"

"No, she keeps an extra Chilton uniform here, for when she stays over on school nights," Tristan explained, moving his arm out from under her to put alongside the couch.

"Oh," Rory said. "Chilton, huh?"

"Yup, bring back memories?" Tristan teased. He then sobered up. "So, um, about Valentines day... We don't have to do anything."

"Are you sure?" Rory asked, looking up at him. "It could just be a movie night, so we don't have to think of what the night really is. Just as friends."

"Okay," Tristan smiled down at her, then a thought dawned on him. "As long as nothing has Orlando Bloom!"

Rory laughed at that, getting up. She grabbed a blanket that was on the couch, using it to cover Abigail up. She looked over at Tristan who also had got up.

"Night Tristan," Rory said softly, before heading to her room.

"Night Rory," Tristan said softly as he watched her shut her door, before heading towards his own.

Abigail peaked out from under her blanket, grinning big time about how the day went. She couldn't wait until she left in the morning so she could call Lorelai with an update.

-

-

AN: I had trouble getting this chapter up, but finally let me! If you haven't seen 'When Fools Rush In' before, I recommend you google it to read what it's about. Rory's expression to the movie will make more sense then ;). The next chapter is what I have been building up the charecters and storyline for. Not sure when it will be up, as I'm trying to get my whole plot straighten out before putting it up. Hope you guys enjoy this chapter, and make sure to REVIEW! -Roxy