In this story I'm moving up Piper and Leo's relationship to now like I did in my other story. In my opinion Dan was a very pointless character to put in because we all knew Piper was going to chose Leo.

Chapter 3: Forbidden Love

Prue sat on her bed and fiddled with the ring on her finger. She looked at her mirror and saw through the reflection a note lying on her dresser. She got up and got the note. It read meet me at the beach and was written in Andy's hand writing. She grabbed her keys and was about to head out the door when Piper and Leo stopped her.

"Where are you going?" Piper asked.

Prue was going to tell her but stopped when she remembered what Leo had said to Andy.

"Just out" Prue said.

Piper looked at Prue for a second.

"Okay" Piper said.

Prue caught Leo looking her in the eye and quickly looked away.

"I'll be back" Prue said.

She hurried out the door and drove to the beach. When she got there she saw him standing out on the beach. She walked over to him.

"You know, you're the most handsome thing on this beach" Prue said smiling.

Andy turned and smiled at her.

"Now where have I heard that before?" Andy asked.

Prue then noticed he was transparent. Her smile disappeared.

"I'm not supposed to be here" Andy said. "I'm not supposed to see you"

"Why?" Prue asked.

"There are some relationships that are forbidden. Witches and whitelighters are one of them, or were. Mortals and angels are the other" Andy said.

Prue sighed and looked at the ground.

"Then why are we here?" Prue asked.

"Because I can't be without you" Andy said.

Prue smiled but then remembered.

"What happens if they catch us?" Prue asked.

"There's one way to never find out" Andy said.

"And what way would that be?" Prue asked.

"We don't get caught" Andy said.

"Can't they see us right now?" Prue asked.

"No" Andy said. "Nobody can see me when I'm earth, well you can and your sisters, but no one else"

"So I'm talking to myself currently" Prue joked.

Andy laughed.

"To other people, yes you are talking to yourself" Andy said. "Luckily no one's here right now"

Andy wrapped his arms around her without actually touching her.

"Close your eyes" Andy said. "Remember what this feels like"

Prue closed her eyes. They stood there for a while like that. She opened her eyes and saw that the sun had almost set.

"I should get home" Prue said. "When can I see you?"

"I can be whole again in your dreams" Andy said. "I'll try to come see you tonight"

Prue laughed.

"What?" Andy asked.

"It's like when we were teenagers" Prue said. "You would sneak into my room after Grams was asleep"

Andy smiled at the memory. Prue looked into his eyes.

"I love you" Prue said.

"I love you too" Andy said.

He disappeared again. Prue smiled and walked back to her car. When she came back into the manor she went to her room and shut her door. A few minutes later someone knocked on it.

"Who is it?" Prue asked.

"It's Leo"

Prue opened the door.

"I need to talk to you" Leo said.

"About what?" Prue asked playing stupid.

"I think you know" Leo said. "You can't do it"

"I don't know what you're talking about" Prue lied.

"It's against the rules" Leo said.

"So was you and Piper being together" Prue argued.

"Exactly" Leo said. "You saw how much that hurt Piper; you saw how much that hurt me"

"But you're together now" Prue said. "You know, I thought you of all people would understand this"

Prue shut her door on Leo's face.

"I will not lose you again" Prue said quietly.

000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

THREE MONTHS LATER.

Prue quietly left the manor and drove to the beach. What she didn't notice was Phoebe and Piper following her. Prue ran over to Andy when she saw him.

"Hi" Prue said happily. "I missed you last night"

"I didn't want anyone to get suspicious so I stayed away" Andy said. "But now I'm here"

Prue then noticed part of him had become visible.

"Wait, am I dreaming?" Prue asked.

Andy looked at his hand.

"Not unless I'm dreaming too" Andy said. "But since angels can't dream…"

"Then this is real" Prue said.

"I think it's because of my emotions" Andy said. "I want to feel you so bad that I guess I'm becoming whole"

Prue smiled.

"I guess your wish is coming true" Prue said.

She kissed Andy passionately. Just then she heard Phoebe gasp. Prue stopped.

"Phoebe and Piper come out here" Prue said.

Piper and Phoebe stepped out from their hiding spot. Andy turned transparent again.

"That didn't last long" Andy said.

"It's probably a good thing, they could have seen you" Prue said.

"What are you two talking about?" Piper asked. "And how could you not tell us about this?"

"I'll explain it in a second" Prue said. "Andy, you should go, make sure they didn't catch you"

Andy nodded.

"I love you" Andy said.

"I love you too" Prue said. "And be careful"

"I will" Andy said.

He disappeared.

"Now can you tell us what's going on" Phoebe said.

"It's not safe to talk here" Prue said. "We should go back to the manor"

Prue got in her car and Piper and Phoebe followed her back to the manor. When they got back to the manor it was already two in the morning.

"Okay" Prue said. "I'm going to whisper all of this so no one hears me except you two"

Piper and Phoebe looked at her confused.

"Andy is an angel" Prue whispered. "And we've been seeing each other for the last three months. Mostly at the beach or he can come into my dreams"

"But what's the big deal in keeping it a secret?" Phoebe asked.

"Mortals and angels aren't supposed to fall in love" Piper said out loud.

"Shh" Prue said.

"Sorry" Piper whispered. "But you aren't all mortal, you're a witch too"

"They don't want anyone falling in love with an angel" Prue whispered.

"Wait, so it's like when Piper was with Leo?" Phoebe asked.

"Only this time there's no exceptions" Prue whispered.

"They aren't going to budge on this rule" Leo said coming into the room. "Trust me, I know"

"Wait, you know about this?" Piper asked.

"Jeez guys, shout it a little louder, I don't think Pluto heard you yet" Prue said sarcastically.

"I knew and I tried to talk her out of it" Leo whispered. "I didn't want her and Andy to get hurt"

"What do you mean get hurt?" Phoebe asked.

"It's happened before" Leo whispered. "An angel and a witch fell in love"

"What happened?" Phoebe asked.

"The Elders found out" Leo whispered. "The witch disappeared and the angel's spirit was recycled"

"Disappeared?" Phoebe asked. "Do you mean died or what?"

"Nobody knows" Leo whispered. "She just disappeared"

"That's not going to happen" Prue said. "We won't get caught"

"But how can you be sure?" Phoebe asked.

"She can't" Piper said. "That's why we have to help her"

"Wait, you're with her on this?" Phoebe asked.

"I've been in her place" Piper said. "And it's not easy to love someone and then be told you can't"

Everyone was quiet for a second.

"I'm in" Phoebe said.

"I'm in" Piper said.

Everyone looked at Leo.

"I guess I'm in" Leo said.

"Thank you, guys" Prue said. "But we should go to bed and all of you, never mention this out loud"

Prue went upstairs.