This was originally meant to be a one-shot, but due to the all the positive reviews and requests for more, I thought I'd have another go at it! I'm not sure if this one is up to par with the first, but it was short and fun to write so I decided to throw it up on here.
"Elizabeth, I have a proposition for you."

"I SAID NO!"

"Actually, I was going to recommend we play little game. Pass the time and whatnot."

"Oh. What kind of game?"

"It's profoundly simple. You'll love it."

"If I play, will you promise to leave me be afterwards?"

"Darling, you have my word as Captain of the Black Pearl."

"But you're not Capta-"

"Right then, the rules are these. I name two things and you must immediately choose which one you prefer without pausing to think about it. Savvy?"

"I think so."

"Marvelous, I'll begin. Sunrise or sunset?"

"Sunset"

"Rum or tea?"

"Tea!"

"Silver or gold?"

"Gold."

"Land or sea?"

"Sea"

"Diamonds or pearls?"

"Pearls"

"Will or Jack?"

"Ja- wait! Will!"

"Ah."

"No wait! WILL! I meant Will! I didn't understand the rules! I-I was confused! I want another chance!"

"Don't worry, Love."

"About what?"

"I swear I won't tell."

"AUGH! "

Reviews appreciated! I'm toying with a spin-off featuring Jack and Norrington, so stay tuned for that.