Roger ended up joining them go save Francine on the lifeboat, and the group are stranded several days til finally they reach an island, but Pinkie noticed Trevor's company logo all over it and begins having a bad feeling. But Stan says they don't have many alternatives and heads to a big house, taking Roger with him. Inside Trevor, Ron, Wade and a bunch of others are having party, some of them sniffing cocaine. Trevor answers the door, wearing a yellow cream suit to show himself as the boss.
Stan asks for food but Trevor only answers that he's an intruder and he's gonna hunt him and the others for game. Minus Roger who immediately has a change of costume to head bandana and a white t-shirt and black jeans with a chain on it. "I'm with them now." he said from suddenly inside the house, all while loading one of the guns.
Stan goes back and nonchalantly says they are gonna hunt them down. "What!?" Francine cried.
"Yeah, saying it out loud, it does sound weird." Stan admitted.
Francine goes over next. Again finding Trevor. "Excuse me, my husband has a crazy idea you're gonna hunt us down." Francine chuckled.
"We are." Trevor said, showing his gun.
"... I see." Francine said and calmly walks off, only to immediately start running back over once the door closes. "IT'S REAL! IT'S REAL!" She screams in panic.
The group begin fleeing for their lives once Trevor's team run out after them, and eventually they hide in a cave; Becky, however, pulls a leaf near the entrance of the cave, intending to collect rainwater for them to drink. This causes a cave-in, crushing her to death and trapping the Smiths inside.
Realizing they have not eaten in over a week, Francine opts for cannibalism, arguing that it's the only way to survive; the family eventually joins her (with Stan only doing so after he reads her driver's license and discovers she was an organ donor anyway).
After eating her, Francine comments (to the incredibly traumatized group) that at least they had a nice meal together as a family, as she wanted.
Making things Roger blows open the cave in and shouts "Found them!". At that Trevor and the others all surround the Smiths.
"Trevor?" Pinkie said in surprise.
"Open fire!" Trevor cried, not seeming to hear her and his men open fire on her and the Smiths, seemingly killing them, but after a few seconds they notice it doesn't hurt.
"Is that paint?" Stan asked. At this Trevor and his men all cheer, except Roger who's noticeably confused, Ron heard saying "Gotcha!"
"Wait what?" Steve asked nervously.
"It was fake guys! Welcome TP Inc's Family Retreat Island!" Trevor cried happily.
"Uhh, yeah, I totally was in on it, yeah." Roger said awkwardly, obviously lying.
"Trevor, y-your with the cruise?" Pinkie asked, still shaken.
"Yeah, feels good to be doing good for once. Now come on, they've been looking for you guys, you must be starving" Trevor said, leading his team back out. At this Hayley breaks down into tears, realizing it was for nothing, hugging Steve who's noticeable speechless. Pinkie just covers her mouth as the realization hits her.
"Well.. Nothing brings a family together, like a dark, terrible secret." Francine said to Stan, rather nervously.