Disclaimer- I don't own this.
Chapter 2-Nightmare Prue giggled as Cole kissed her neck. They were lying in Cole's bed. Phoebe and Piper had just only left for the grocery store 5 minutes ago and they were already all over each other. Cole pushed deeper inside her. "Cole," She moaned, it came out in a hoarse whisper which turned him on more. He kissed her hard. Suddenly, they heard the door open. They both looked up slowly to see Phoebe standing there with her jaw set and her mouth a straight line. Cole got up, covering his waist with the bed sheet and Prue wrapped the blanket around her like a shield."Phoebe, we…" Cole started.
"How long?" Phoebe asked in a shaky voice.
"Phoebe, sweetie…" Prue tried as she stood next to Cole.
"How long?" Phoebe asked again in a higher voice.
"Almost two months." Cole muttered as he looked to the ground.
"We're so sorry Phoebe." Prue said, her own voice getting shaky.
"Yea, sorry that you got caught. I can't believe it. My sister and my boyfriend!" Phoebe screamed and turned to Cole. "I should've vanquished you when I had the chance!" She said through gritted teeth. She pulled out a vanquishing potion and threw it at his feet.
Cole screamed and pushed Prue out of the way. The vile broke and Cole soon felt himself on fire. He looked at Phoebe through the flames then finally exploded.
Cole screamed and sat up. He looked around, trying to get his eyes to adjust to the darkness. He was in his room that was for sure, and in once piece too. But who was next to him? He flipped on his lamp and turned to see that Phoebe was next to him. 'It was just a dream.' Cole thought, relieved.
Phoebe started to stir. She opened her eyes but quickly closed them again because of the light.
"Cole?" She asked groggily, squinting at him. "What's wrong?"
"Ah, n-nothing, just a bad dream." Cole assured her.
"You wanna talk about it?"
"No, it's fine." Cole answered.
"Good, cuz I gotta be at work early." Phoebe yawned.
"Okay, sorry I woke you up." He apologized, turning off the light and lying back down.
"Don't worry about it." Phoebe muttered and put her head on Cole's chest. "Love you,"
"Love you too," Cole replied, 'I think,'
Cole stayed in bed long after Phoebe left for work in the morning. He wasn't asleep; he just needed to work some things out in his head. And if he saw Prue, he knew he wouldn't be able to. When he thought it was safe and everyone had left. He got up, showered, and headed downstairs. Already a few hours late for work he walked in the kitchen but stopped when he saw Prue sitting at the table, coffee in hand, reading the paper. He turned to leave but she spotted him.
"Cole?"
He turned around slowly and flashed her a small smile.
"Are you alright?" She asked.
"Yea, of course. Why wouldn't I be?" He asked uncomfortably.
"Well, I heard you screaming last night." Prue said.
"Oh, that. I just had a nightmare." Cole answered as he poured himself a cup of coffee and sat down next to her.
"Oh, just wanted to make sure." She smiled warmly at him.
'God she's amazing.' He thought. "So why aren't you at work yet?"
"I don't have an auction until noon." She answered.
Cole raised an eyebrow. There were lots of things they could do before then. 'No, stop it!' He tried to fight with himself. But he couldn't win, because the truth was, Cole was happier with Prue.
She was smart, funny, and hot. She did things in bed Phoebe never even consideredBut he pledged his love to Phoebe. Phoebe was the one who he had at one time loved, but not anymore. Cole couldn't even imagine being with her. Even when they were in bed together he had to imagine it was Prue or he couldn't go through with it.
But he could never tell Phoebe the truth. She would die, or kill him. It was all so complicated. Damn Prue and her great blo…body. 'Okay, that settles it. I love Prue. No Phoebe! No-Pr-Ph, PRUE!'
"Oh what the hell." Cole muttered as he stood up and pulled Prue up too. He planted a long kiss on her lips and Pyroported them both upstairs, totally forgetting his nightmare.
TBC…
Riigghhtt!
Nicole/Shannen