A.N: Wow you guys really seem to like my story. I was informed that someelse has a story with the same name and it follows the challenge. Mine one the other had was just inspired by the challege and i will do things that aren't allowed by the rules of the challenage. Just wanted to let you know
I want to say thanks to:
Lifeisconfusing: hope you like this on too
sparxx27: thank you so much for putting me on your alert list that makes me so happy.
iyasunflower: I'm glad you think it's great
Gilmore-BuffyFan13: Thanks for letting me know about the other story and i will continue until you guys stop reviewing, or until i'm done with the story then i will start a new one.
Rexsgirl29: of course it's Rogan i love Rogan.
4uALWAYZ: so glad you love
jojo26pink glad you think it's cute (my story is like me and my personality :) jk
Hope2High: i couldn't think of enough question so i sorta changed it but there is still the game
coffeeaddict1515,cancan227, astragail, thanks i'm glad you guys like it
sicklittlesuicide: glad i made you form an opinion and i'm glad it's a good one
When they got there, Colin went and ordered the first round of drinks, while the others got a booth. Finn and Logan headed for their usual booth in the back corner of the room. They sat down with Logan and Rory in the middle Stephanie on Rory's right and Finn on Logan's right. Colin came back with the shots and had the idea to play "I never"
"It's the best way to get to know everyone," Colin argued, every one agreed
"Alright the rules are that if you did what is in question then you take a shot, if the others request a story you tell.' Stephanie explained, everyone nods in understanding.
"Ok, I'll go first" Fin said while passing out shot glasses. "Alright, I never kissed a member of the same sex."
They all take a shot. The guys look to Rory and yelled "STORY!"
"My god you make sound like full on made out with a girl it was just a kiss to get into a club when I was 16. That was it." The guys grumble something under their breaths.
"Ok, I'm starting easy, I never cheated on a test." Steph asked, everyone but Rory took a shot. Steph looked at her with a comical look.
"What, I was usually the one people cheated off of." Rory said matter-of-factly
"Oh My God, It's Rory- Mary turned Magdalene- Gilmore" a new voice enter the conversation, Rory turned around to see who it was to find out that it was Madeline and Louise.
"Oh my gosh Maddie, Louise, what are you doing here?" Rory jumped up and hugged the two girls.
"Well the reason we are in Hartford was to see Maddie's aunt and uncle about a transfer. The reason we are at Yale was to see the Dean, Paris, You and Maddie's cousin. The reason we are at the pub is You and Maddie's cousin." Louise explained.
"You guys are transferring here. And who is Maddie's cousin?" Rory asked
"Colin McRae, Do you know him?" Maddie asked, always clueless.
"No, Mads, she's just sitting with me and talking to me but she has no clue who I am." Colin said in a voice that you would use with a 5 year old.
"Sorry Colin I didn't see ya. Hey Finn, Logan and Stephanie" Maddie went around and gave everyone a hug.
"
So Rory, I thought you guys like these?" Louise asked
"I didn't hate the guys just one guy" Rory said emphasizing guy in a way that said she didn't want to talk about that again.
"So, can me and Maddie join in on the game you started?" Louise asked taking the hint Rory didn't want to talk about that guy.
"Yea that would be great you can help us find out something about Rory," Finn answered with a suggestive undertone.
"So how bout I never… went to second base at school?" Louise asked only Rory took a shot. Maddie and Louise look at Rory confused and Logan, Colin and Finn look at her in awe.
"Rory you never had a boyfriend that went to Chilton how could you do that." Louise finally asked
"Oh, you meant in a sexual way not baseball." Rory said with an innocent face and a smirk. Everyone started to laugh.
"That was awesome Gilmore, I almost believed you." Stephanie said with a laugh
They game went on for a few more rounds. They learned Logan and Finn went skinny-dipping in the middle of December. Colin once broke into the school to turn in a paper that he convinced the teacher that it was there on his desk. Stephanie had sex parent's bed. They also learned that Maddie and Louise were once in a threesome, and that Rory also skipped school to meet a guy in New York.
"Alright, this game is getting boring I saw we play "I show you mine, You show me yours." Logan said, kind of slurred from the game.
"Dirty!" drunk Rory and Louise said, went into a fit of giggles
"No, I meant you tell us about you're first time having sex and we tell you ours." Logan explained. Everyone nodded in agreement.
"I'll go first". Steph started "Mine first was your typical. My parents went out of town for a vacation they were gone two weeks, my boyfriend of a month came over we started to watch movie, he leaned in a kissed me one thing lead to another we ended up in my parents room and we had sex. Then a week afterwards he breaks up with me because he just had a bet with a friend that I would put- out." Steph said with a regretful look on her face. Rory put her arms around Steph to comfort her.
"How old were you?" Louise asked in a concerned voice
"16." Steph answered in an even more regretful voice.
"Well if you think that one was bad wait for mine," Rory said in a with a humorless laugh. When every one stayed quiet she took it as her cue to continue.
"Alright mine has a background story to it, so here it goes. My mom decided that I would have a better chance to get into a good college if I went to Chilton instead of Stars Hallow High, so I got transferred. On my first day I was sitting in my first class when, this guy walked in late, and my gosh he was cute.-" Rory started but got interrupted by Louise.
"OH MY GOSH YOU REALLY DID SLEPT WITH TRISTAN!" she exclaimed
"Yes, who did you think it was?" Rory said while turning redder that a beet.
"Dean" Maddie interjected
"Oh, lord no" Rory said.
Oh, just get on with the story." Finn said impatiently
"Alright, so he takes his seat and I hear him ask his friend who I am and the friend replies new girl. The bell rings and they walk behind me and say "Look like we got ourselves a Mary." I get up and walk out of the class and Tristan is leaning against the wall, and when he sees me he comes up and asks if I want to borrow his notes, I say yea that would be great. Then he takes a step towards me and I take one back and I end up against a locker. He then bends his head down and say how great, then I tell him to never mind I will get someone else's then push him away from me and go to my next class which he was in and he kept pestering me and calling me Mary. I thought after awhile that he would quit but he didn't after about a month of it he kinda started to quit and we kinda became friends. Well Maddie had a party one weekend her parents were out of town and Tristan asked if I wanted to go with him I told him I would. We get there and we start to dance, well more like grind but same thing. He whispers in my ear if I wanted to go somewhere quieter and nod and he leads me up stairs. We find a room, we start making out, and we end up having sex. Then on Monday everyone found out we had sex and the called me Magdalene. He told me that he didn't tell anyone that someone probably just saw us go in our out of the room and spread it around. We then decided that we wouldn't start to date. We would keep it casual that lasted for two months then we break it off because his dad decides to send him to boarding school." Rory said
"Wow, and think no one knew for a fact" Louise said in awe.
"Is that why Louise greeted you as 'Mary turned Magdalene." Colin asked. Rory nodded.
"Wow it's late we should head back to the dorms." Logan said while looking at his watch. "We can start back up tomorrow night if that's ok say around 8?" Every one nodded.
"I'll walk you back Rory" Logan offered, ever the gentlemen.
"Maddie, Louise where are you staying?" Colin asked.
"With Rory and Paris" the both answered.
With that Logan walk the three girls home and Finn went to his and Colin walked Steph to hers.
Rory's thoughts on the walk home were about Logan and how she thought he would act and how wrong she was. Maybe the stories were exagerated.