A/N: thanks for the reviews, I loved them! A lot of you said Jeff is so nice, well duh liv wouldn't marry a jerk for crying out loud, plus it makes it different from other stories since it makes it harder to see who the obvious guy is. Every EO I read always has El as the good guy (the way it should be) so I thought its more interesting for once that there were two good guys! Hope you like my whole so called interesting idea! Shocker in this chapter as I promised, enjoy!
That night Jeff spent the night at Lucas's house. He hated sleeping alone, even though he couldn't sleep at all. The next day he went to their apartment to pick up some of his stuff. Olivia was at work so he knew that moving his stuff out with her in the apartment would be too hard. Lucas and Andy came to help him; Jeff already explained what happened and why he was getting a divorce.
"What are you packing up?" Andy asked as Jeff unlocked the door and went inside their apartment. It killed both Andy and Lucas to see this happen since they loved Olivia like their own sister.
"Some clothes and some sports stuff" Jeff answered walking in with his two brothers following him. Lucas came in and saw a movie sitting on the table; he went over and picked it up.
"You taken this movie, cause I want to watch it" Lucas asked with a smirk. Jeff just looked at him.
"No, that's her favorite movie, it's staying here" Jeff said staring at his brother. Lucas knew better then to argue with him when it concerned Olivia, he just shrugged and put the movie down.
Jeff went into their bedroom and opened his closet. He looked at all the t-shirts she made him buy over the years. He wasn't big on any of those shirts but he wore them cause she liked them. He grabbed a blue shirt that she bought for him when he got a promotion at his job, when he became lead agent for the FBI. He smiled as he read what it said 'Female Body Inspector' he never wanted to wear it, but she insisted it was funny cause he was FBI.
Flashback"liv, I'm not going to wear this," Jeff protested looking at the shirt and sitting on the couch.
"c'mon, its cute and its funny" Olivia said smiling and wrapping her arm around his neck from the back.
"of all people you buy me this shirt," Jeff said smiling and leaning back to look up at her.
"you're lucky you have such a cool wife, plus you can wear it when you're out with the boys not around me" she said smiling and kissing him lightly on the lips.
"like I married you cause your cool, I married you cause your hot" he said sarcastically placing his hand on the beck of her neck.
"what a coincidence , same here, speaking of hot take off that shirt and later put on the new one" Olivia said smiling placing her hands on his chest.
"but what will we do in the middle?" He asked sarcastically, he pulled her over the couch, she laid upside down, laughing. Her legs were on the headrest and she was looking up at him, her head hanging over the edge.
"well this is interesting" she said laughing.
"that shirt looks horrible on you, I think the bare look works for you" he said smiling and kissing her on the forehead.
"really? Speaking of things that look bad…those jeans need to go…pants off now, move it," she said giggling
"aren't we bossy, so pushy about everything, I'll trade you, you take off that ridiculous shirt, I'll take off my ridiculous pants,"
"hhmm, let me think, I want the shirt, might motivate me to give you my shirt"
"I like the way you think, plus your hot and lets face it that's why we got married, were just two hot people in love" Jeff said laughing while pulling off his shirt and throwing it at her.
"so conceded, lets see I want the jeans now, cause I'm just too good looking for one silly shirt." Olivia said smiling and holding his shirt.
"that is so true, let's see if my negotiating skills might help here" he said smiling as he sat on top of her and started kissing her, she wrapped her arms around his neck and pulled him closer.
End Flashback
"JEFF!" Andy yelled watching Jeff stare at a shirt.
"What?" Jeff said getting startled.
"I've been calling you for 5 minutes, where do you want this?" Andy asked holding up a baseball bat.
"Leave it here" Jeff answered, knowing Olivia liked to have it in the house.
"Ok," Andy shrugged and put the baseball down.
Jeff grabbed a couple of shirts and threw them in a box, afraid to look at any of them, afraid of good memories.
"Guys?" He heard a familiar voice call out, he knew it wasn't Olivia. He stepped out by his doorway to see who came in the apartment.
"Hey Casey" Jeff said and went back to pack more stuff. He was used to her being around since Lucas was dating her for almost 3 months. He heard them talking and laughing, he couldn't help but think that's how he was with Olivia when they were together.
He came out of the room, carrying two boxes full of stuff.
"Hey Jeff" Casey said when she saw him, she already knew what happened since Lucas told her.
"Hi" Jeff said quietly and walked past them. He was happy for his brother but hated to be around them when they were so happy and he used to be just as happy.
"How you doing?" Casey asked noticing that he wasn't the same guy that she spent time with before.
"Fine, Luke can you take this to the car?"
"Sure, I'll be right back" Lucas said smiling at Casey as he took the boxes and left the apartment.
"How come you're here?" Jeff asked as he opened his fridge.
"Oh Luke and I are going to see a movie, I didn't mean to intrude" Casey said, feeling guilty she was so happy when one of her friends was hurting so bad, she knew she shouldn't have come but Luke insisted.
"You're not intruding, it's fine, it's not like it's my apartment anymore, you want something to drink?" Jeff asked as he just stared at the open fridge.
"No I'm fine, thanks, um…look I don't know if this counts for anything but she does still love you"
"Well its all shot to hell now so it doesn't really matter, but thanks anyway" Jeff said closing the fridge door and walking back into their room where there were so many memories.
Olivia sat quietly at her desk doing paper work, well Fin and Munch went to arrest their perp. Elliot sat quietly and did paper work, he grabbed a piece of paper and wrote 'rooftop. Need to talk' and passed it to Olivia and got up and left the bullpen. Olivia read it and got up and followed him.
"Hey" Olivia said as she saw him standing and staring at the city.
"hey"
"what's going on?"
"I told Kathy last night, she wants a divorce," Elliot said looking over at Olivia.
"Jeff wants a divorce also, he spent last night at Lucas's house and Casey told me she was meeting Lucas at our apartment since Jeff was moving out some stuff." Olivia said putting her arm around Elliot's waist. Elliot put his arm around her and hugged her. She wrapped her arms around him and rested her head on his chest.
"Maybe its all for the best in the end for everyone" Elliot said kissing Olivia on the forehead. She looked up at him and smiled.
"It is, they will get over it and move on and might be happier"
"hey guys we…oh sorry" Fin said appearing on the roof and just looked at them hugging. Elliot and Olivia quickly let go of each other. Fin just smiled and left the rooftop. He knew they were together since it was so obvious with all the ignoring during work but hugging on the roof.
"Well, that's going to cause a lot of betting with him and Munch" Elliot said smiling.
"I'll place some money on you kissing me now" Olivia said smiling.
"and you would win" Elliot said moving closer to her.
"Its true!" They heard John yell.
"You moron, I told you not to go…sorry guys" Fin said and pulled John inside the building. Elliot and Olivia started laughing, they could hear both of the guys laughing hysterically by the door.
"So much for romantic moment" Olivia said laughing.
"Well, a kiss can still count for romantic right?" Elliot said smiling and kissing her. She smiled and wrapped her arms around his neck.
"Very romantic" Olivia whispered as they released their kiss. Elliot smiled and kissed her again. Neither one could believe how happy they were when they were with each other. After everything they still had each other to be happy and that's all it mattered.
Elliot was going to spend the night with Olivia since Kathy took the kids to her mothers and told him she wasn't going to be back until they started with the divorce since she was too mad at him. They were so happy spending the night with each other and knowing that it wasn't a secret they carried around with them.
"I can't believe John actually opened the door" Olivia said laughing as she unlocked the door to her apartment.
"Lets just be glad he didn't take a picture, since its something he would do" Elliot said laughing as he walked in. Both of them stopped laughing as they saw Jeff, Andy and Jessica, Jeff's sister.
"I came to get some stuff, I was just leaving" Jeff said looking at them. Hating that Elliot made her laugh like he did.
"Oh its fine, its not a problem" Olivia said closing the door, she could tell that Andy and Jessica were glaring at her and they hated her guts at that moment. She didn't blame them at all for hating her.
"Hi, Elliot" Andy said angrily starring at Elliot. Jeff just ran his hand threw his hair knowing that Andy or Jessica might do something he would have done if one of them were in the same situation.
"He wasn't good enough for you?" Jessica yelled at Olivia, Jeff knew she was going to be the first to lose it. He let out a deep breath and pulled his sister toward the door.
"Time to go, Jess, lets go" Jeff said opening the door.
"No, that bitch shoul…"
"Shut up!" Jeff yelled. Everyone looked at him since he never yelled at his younger sister, no matter what she did.
"What?" Jessica asked shocked looking up at him.
"You heard me, don't call her a bitch, just go" Jeff said as calmly as he could.
"Fine, I'll go, but not cause you asked me, cause I can't look at her," Jessica said giving an evil glance at Olivia. Olivia said nothing and just looked at the ground. "and I said she was like my own sister" Jessica muttered and left the apartment.
"I'm sorry about that, were going to…" Jeff said but Andy interrupted him by pushing him out of the way and punching Elliot in the face. Elliot fell down since he didn't expect it.
"He trusted you, you stupid son of…" Andy yelled getting on top of Elliot and trying to hit him again. Elliot hit him, Andy hit him back, Jeff jumped on Andy and pulled him off. Olivia just watched not knowing what to do.
"Out. Andy move it" Jeff yelled pulling his older brother out of the apartment.
"Jeff, he…" Andy yelled.
"Shut up, or I swear to god I will hit you" Jeff yelled pushing him out and slamming the door closed.
"I'm sorry about them" Jeff apologized.
"It's fine" Elliot said getting up and wiping the blood off of his lip, amazed that Jeff didn't hit him also.
"Um…I'm going to get going, if any of them give you trouble just give me a call" Jeff said grabbing a box full of his stuff.
"sure, thanks" Olivia said, she was amazed how he was acting. He didn't hit Elliot, which she knew he wanted to. He was still protective over her and he yelled at his baby sister for her.
"Goodnight" Jeff said as he opened the door and left the apartment. It killed him that they were spending the night, but he was glad that he heard Olivia laughing and not crying for once in these past couple of days, he knew it was the best for her to have Elliot with her.
"Wow. Andy sure throws a good punch" Elliot said holding his jaw.
"Yea, never get in fights with them cause they spent most of their childhood in their fathers gym boxing" Olivia said smiling as she handed him an ice pack from the fridge.
"I don't need ice, I need you" Elliot said smiling and moving closer to her.
"Who knew detective Stabler was such a smooth talker," Olivia teased smiling as she closed the gap in between their bodies.
"Well I try, did it work?"
"You tell me," Olivia said smiling as she started kissing him. He pulled her closer and kissed her.
Olivia woke up at 6. She looked over by her and Elliot was still sleeping. She smiled watching him, amazed at how comfortable they were with each other. She thought because they were friends before it would be weird but love always makes you comfortable. She smiled and got up out of bed. He woke up when she opened her closet.
"Hey you" He said smiling watching her.
"Hi, how did you sleep?" She asked turning around and smiling.
"Amazing, you?"
"Same, you want me to go make coffee?" She asked smiling since she hardly ever made coffee in the mornings since Jeff always had it ready for her.
"No, I'll make you coffee" Elliot said smiling as he got out of bed and gave her a kiss on the cheek and left the bedroom.
Olivia just smiled and grabbed some jeans and a sweater. She looked at the sweater and realized that it was the one Jeff loved to see her in. She smiled and threw it back in the closet and grabbed another one.
"You want breakfast?" Elliot asked looking at the fridge.
"Only if you make it" Olivia said smiling watching him look inside the fridge.
"I wouldn't have it any other way," Elliot said grabbing some eggs out of the fridge.
"That's what I like to hear…" Olivia started to say but started gagging and ran to the bathroom and started vomiting. Elliot followed her quickly.
"You ok?" He asked placing a hand on her back.
"I don't know, same thing happened yesterday, but I don't feel sick at all," Olivia said as she just stood bent over by the toilet.
"Maybe you should go see a doctor just in case" Elliot suggested handing her a towel. Olivia grabbed the towel and turned on the water putting her face under and then wiped her face.
"Yea maybe, can you come with me?"
"Of course, I'll call Fin and Munch to tell them we might be late" Elliot said stroking her hair.
"Thanks" Olivia said with a smirk. Elliot smiled and went to the bedroom to get his cell phone.
"Hey Fin its me…Yea…just to let you know me and Liv might be a little late…no, not cause of something like that...she's sick…no I'm not lying…Fin she's sick I swear…Fine bye" Elliot talked in the phone and kept rolling his eyes. Olivia just smiled knowing exactly what Fin was trying to hint at.
"John is going to make so many theories about that call," Olivia said laughing as Elliot closed his phone. Elliot laughed and grabbed his jeans and pulled them on.
"Let's go," He said grabbing his car keys. Olivia just followed him.
Olivia sat on the table at the doctor's room. Elliot sat on the chair across from her.
"Ok. Ms. Benson, its not a flu, its something that lasts a little longer" The doctor said smiling as he came in the room carrying a paper pad. Olivia and Elliot looked at each not knowing what he was talking about and both thinking why the hell is he smiling.
"Ok, um…what's that something?" Olivia asked sort of confused and aggravated that he didn't just tell her.
"You have been pregnant for almost three weeks" Olivia's eyes just got wider, resembling Elliot's expression. Both of them shocked just staring at the doctor.
"Um…how didn't I know? I mean is that normal?" Olivia asked very fast, wanting the answers right away.
"Well yea, if you got pregnant right after your monthly cycle then you wouldn't know about it until a month," the doctor answered.
"Oh god…Liv…um…we drank, remember" Elliot said quietly not wanting to bring it up but when he realized he just blurted it out.
"Oh god…oh my god." Olivia said placing her hands over her mouth.
"Well morning sickness is a sign of a healthy pregnancy even this early on, since its only 3 weeks, and your already having morning sickness FAS might not occur" The doctor said looking at both of them.
"Oh ok, are you sure?" Olivia asked still in shock, and the doctors cheery attitude was pissing her off.
"There were experiments done with 400,000 women, all of whom had consumed alcohol during pregnancy. Not a single case of FAS occurred and no adverse effects on children were found when consumption was under 8.5 drinks per week." The doctor said satisfyingly. Elliot and Olivia felt like hitting him, he was too cheery and too happy.
"Ok, thank you doctor" Elliot said getting up, realizing Olivia was getting annoyed at him and she was still in shock
"No problem, congratulations, you will make great parents, have a good day" The doctor said smiling and left the room.
Olivia and Elliot just looked at each other. Knowing that it was Jeff's baby. Would this change everything? Would it change them being together?
"Hey, it will fine" Elliot said knowing he had to comfort her as much as possible at that moment.
"Yea, but how can I tell him?" Olivia said taking his hand as tears started forming in her eyes.
"You'll find a way, I'm here don't worry, if you want I'll be with you when you tell him if it makes it easier." Elliot said quietly wrapping his arm around her shoulder.
"Yea and get you knocked out," Olivia said smiling "I need to tell him alone" She said as she rested her head on Elliot's chest.
"Ok, but if you need me, you know you can count on me" Elliot said kissing her on her head.
"I know, thanks, lets go so John and Fin don't start betting how long we might be gone" Olivia said smiling as she got off the table. Elliot smiled even though it was killing him that the women he loved was going to have another mans baby. He finally had the women of his dreams when he slept, but now a baby, her soon to be ex-husband's baby.
Olivia went outside the doctor's room and had a million thoughts in her head. Questions she wanted answers to but she was the only one that might know the answers. How in the world was she going to tell her husband she was about to divorce that she was having his child? Will things change with her and Elliot? She couldn't keep all these questions in her head since it was driving her insane. She knew Jeff would be happy and be there for her and their child but it would kill him to know that she wasn't going to change anything with Elliot even if she was pregnant. If it was before that they got a divorce then they might get together for the child, but not now, she wasn't going to let this ruin what she finally got and for so long wanted with Elliot. In her head she just kept thinking, love does make you do crazy things.