Before Piper or Phoebe could walk away to another room in the manor to wait for their return an elder orbed in. "Where is Paige?" the elder asked. "With a charge." Piper said with her irritated, oh it's him voice. "Why?" Phoebe asked with a slightly less voice of irritation. "I just wanted to let her know she has been assigned another charge." The elder revealed. "Brook Lynn?" Sam asked standing a few feet away. "Well, yes. How did you know?" the elder asked. "We found her. She's Billie's sister." Sam told the elder. "We'll make sure Paige gets the message." Piper said raising an eyebrow. The elder nodded and orbed away.
"Brook Lynn?" Billie asked walking with Paige in the underworld. The place was familiar and Billie knew were she was. She heard someone talking. Billie and Paige walked over to where they herd the voice. Brook Lynn sat in the corner indian style talking to someone. Billie looked at the spot in the room Brook Lynn was talking to, but no one was there.
"Brook Lynn, who are you talking to?" Billie asked. Paige stood there behind Billie watching her and Brook Lynn. Brook Lynn looked up at Billie with a smile. "Christy, don't you recognize her?" Brook Lynn asked. "I don't see anyone, Brook Lynn." Billie said scared and in shock. Why would she be talking to someone who is not there? Is she going crazy or something? Billie asked herself. "I don't think they can see me." 'Christy' said looking and Billie and Paige. Brook Lynn looked at Christy and then Billie. "Um…yeah we do sweetie. Billie is just joking." Paige said with a smile. "Oh, yeah. Ha ha the jokes on you." Billie said with a fake smile. "We should get the two of you home." Paige said. Billie pulled Paige aside. "I can't let Brook Lynn think she is talking and seeing Christy when she's not." Billie whispered. "I know and you can tell her, but the last thing we need is for her to shimmer off again. Let's get her home and then you can tell her that Christy is…you know…dead." Paige said. Billie nodded and went back over to Brook Lynn ready to go to the manor. Paige followed and orbed them back.
Paige orbs Billie and Brook Lynn home. "Brook Lynn we need to talk." Billie said. "About what?" Brook Lynn asked. "Just come on." Billie said. She looked at the sisters as she passed by and watched Brook Lynn enter the kitchen after her. "What's up?" Brook Lynn asked. "There is something I think you should know. It's about Christy." Billie said. She looked around. "Is she here?" Billie asked. "No, she's in the living room. You know that." Brook Lynn said. "She's not there, Brook Lynn. She died…in my arms." Billie said tears falling down her cheeks. "No! She's not! I see her! She's really there. She's not dead!" Brook Lynn yelled in tears. She ran into the living room and up the stairs.
Billie walked into the living room to where the sisters and Sam were. "I see that didn't go well." Piper said knowing what happened because Paige explained what happened while they were in the kitchen. "No, she still believes she sees Christy." Billie said. "I'm sorry, honey." Phoebe said hugging Billie. Billie nodded and walked away. She went upstairs to the guest room where Brook Lynn is. "Brook Lynn." Billie said. Brook Lynn turned around crying. "I'm sorry, but I wouldn't make something like that up. I loved Christy. I wanted her to be alive just as much as you do, but she's not." Billie said this obviously hard to say. Brook Lynn didn't respond. This was devastating news to Brook Lynn. She turned around and was silent.
Billie went downstairs. "She's not talking again." Billie said as her walked into the conservatory were the sisters and Sam had went into to relax as much as they could. Billie was upset and it showed. "She just needs some time to process all of this." Sam said. "I just want to know what is going through her head." Billie said with a feeling of hopelessness.