Wow, it's been longer than I realized since I updated! I don't really have an excuse. Unfortunately I have had to socialize with people from school. Not that they are all bad. But school starts on Monday, so I can go back just seeing them then and to just writing in class instead of 'learning' their pointless crap.

The song at the beginning of the episode where Andy dies (sniff), is called Animal Instinct and it's by The Cranberries. But I also like the song at the beginning of Love Hurts.

Excuses

Prue and Andy jumped away from each other faster than lightening but both knew it was too late. Piper stood in the doorway. Prue felt relief wash over her that it was only Piper and not Roger.

"I…I was…just…" Piper shook her head in disgust and turned to Andy expectantly.

"It was me," he said quickly. I kissed her." Prue stared at him.

"Well I didn't't see her pushing you away!" Piper shrieked.

"She hadn't had a chance to." Piper didn't't look like she believed it.

"Prue, you can't do this! Roger's only in the other room! What if he'd caught you instead of me?" Piper looked shocked and horrified. Prue bit her lip. If Roger had caught her, then she would probably already be dead by now.

"It's not her fault," Andy said. "I'm sorry Prue. Piper. I shouldn't have done it." Prue still didn't't say anything.

"I think I can finish clearing up with Prue," Piper said with a glare. Andy nodded and left the room. Piper turned to Prue.

"Prue!"

"Piper, breath! It's not your problem, okay? This is between me and Andy."

"And Roger."

"No. You're not going to tell him, are you?" Prue gave Piper a pleading look, trying to make Piper's answer the one she wanted by adding a positive question on the end.

"No," Piper said with a sigh, "But please stop Prue. Don't do it. I won't keep quiet if you keep on doing it." Prue nodded.

"Thank you. I won't. It was one kiss, that's all. I swear. We aren't doing anything" Piper shrugged.

"It had better have been. You can go into the lounge. With Roger, your fiancé, remember?" Prue nodded and walked into the lounge, feeling terrible about Piper having seen, and her view on Roger as the perfect fiancé. She avoided Andy's eyes and Roger took hold of her hand, pulling her down onto the arm of his chair. Prue stared at the ground, as Cole, Phoebe and Roger talked and laughed. Piper came back in, but she was watching Prue carefully.

"I think we should be going honey," Roger said, getting up and pulling her up with him. "Work tomorrow." Prue didn't answer.

"Thanks for a great evening, Piper," Roger said, when they reached the door.

"Bye Piper, bye Pheebs," Prue said quietly, hugging both her sisters. She shook Cole's hand and stopped hesitantly in front of Andy. He stood up, and kissed her cheek, hugging her too.

"It'll be okay," he whispered. "Stay strong." Piper was watching them carefully, and Roger pulled Prue abruptly away from Andy. Prue followed him out miserably. They got into the car in silence, and drove in silence. Roger waited until they were in the house to start.

"You never told me about that cop being your ex!"

"That was in high school! It was years ago and irrelevant!"

"Irrelevant? I saw the looks you two were sharing!" Prue couldn't help feeling panic, wondering if she had been sharing any 'looks' with Andy.

"You're being ridiculous, Roger." From the look on Roger's face, she knew she'd said too much.

"Do you think Prue's happy?" Phoebe looked up from her magazine at Piper.

"What?"

"I mean, do you think she and Roger are happy?"

"Are you kidding? Of course!" Phoebe laughed. "Why?" she said with a sudden frown.

"No reason, I just wondered."

"No, Piper. Why are you asking?" Piper considered telling Phoebe. It wouldn't really be betraying Prue. She never promised she wouldn't tell anyone. But then telling Phoebe wouldn't help Prue.

"I said. I just wondered, that's all." Phoebe looked at her suspiciously for a few seconds and then shrugged.

"So, do you like Cole?" She asked excitedly.

"Yes, he's actually very nice. Not your usual type though."

"My usual type? What's that?"

"Oh, you know. Not lawyers, that's for sure."

"Well, Cole is…great. I wouldn't have thought he was a lawyer. But he's really fun and…" Piper had stopped listening to Phoebe's happy babble. She wanted to ask someone else if Prue was happy, but she couldn't think of anyone else. She also couldn't think of a reason why Prue wouldn't be happy. Maybe Prue had been telling her the truth when she had said that she and Andy weren't doing anything.

AN: Can whitelighters heal other whitelighters? Like when they get shot by darklighters? Out of interest, if anyone happens to know. Oh wait, Sam heals Paige and Leo in that episode where he's Paige's charge. So they can then.