Disclaimer: Everything belongs to J.K Rowling and the idea came from an episode of Unfabulous.

A/N- sorry about the wait- I feel really guilty. I hope it's alright!

James was dragged away from Lily only a couple of minutes after they had begun to dance. Those drunk Hufflepuffs had come and stolen him from her. Lily was sure she had heard something about a drinking contest and she was probably right.

Bloody Hufflepuffs and their obsession with drinking.

She stormed over to Stacey who was currently in the middle of a passionate snogging session with Ravenclaw hottie, Jack Davis. Lily had never seen Jack when he was annoyed so it was a surprise to see the normally sweet natured boy looking murderous when she pulled Stacey away from him.

'Lily, what the hell are you doing?' cried Stacey, when Lily had dragged her over to the gummy worn corner.

'I've got to talk to you!'

'Can't it wait?' she moaned.

'No! This is entirely your fault so you are going to help me!'

Okay, first of all, it is so not my fault since you did not have to use the plan. And secondly, never ever again shall you drag me away from a cute boy.'

Lily put her head in her hands and groaned in exasperation.

Why am I friends with such a superficial moron?

'Stacey you are going completely off topic. We are down to 2 wolves, okay? Sirius and James-'

'Hang on a second. Sirius? Sirius is the other werewolf? Your ex- crush and your boyfriends best friend? Lily, are you secretly filming a soap opera that I am not aware of?'

'No! This is totally real! What am I going to do? They are both the same height and they both wear the same aftershave-'

'Wait a minute. They both wear the same aftershave? Can they not buy their own? Are they completely useless?'

'Wake up Stacey. This is Sirius Black and James Potter, two of the most useless people on the planet. Now, what am I going to do?'

'Easy. Just forget about the kiss and pull James in for another one. Simple.'

But it was not that simple for Lily. She couldn't just forget that kiss. Her first kiss.

'How do I know that this new plan of yours isn't just as dodgy as all your other plans?'

'Don't you trust me Lily?'

Lily just stared at Stacey disbelievingly with her hands on her hips.

'OK, fine, so the other plans didn't go accordingly but all you have to do in this one is snog your boyfriend. Simple Pimple'.

'I guess…'

'You guessed right,' and with that, Stacey shoved Lily back into the crowd of people who wee too drunk to take notice of the dilemma Lily was going through at the moment.

She was sure this wouldn't work. Since when had Stacey's plans ever worked? When they were 1st years and Lily was still innocently oblivious to Stacey's 'amazing' plans, she had gone along with one of her best friend's plans to get to class quickly. Not only did they turn up to class half an hour late, Lily broke her wrist when she fell onto a trick staircase.

Amazing plans my arse.

Never the less, Lily decided to go along with Stacey's newest plan.

She headed over to the drinks table where James had been dragged off to by the Hufflepuffs. Sure enough, he was leaning on the table talking to Remus Lupin, another Marauder.

She grabbed his arm and before he had a chance to question her, she dragged him away and towards the 'Red Area' where the game was still in full swing.

Just as the next couple were about to walk into the closet, Lily shoved them out of the way, pulled James in and slammed the door shut. Ignoring Amanda's angry protests, she lifted up the wolf mask once more. She stood on her tiptoes and was about to kiss him when a pair of strong hands gently pushed her away.

'Lily, what's going on?'

Oh God. Oh God no.

'Lily?'

'Sirius?' she whispered disbelievingly. She lit up her wand and shined it in his face, just to check it really was him.

'Yeah. Why, who did you think it was?' he said, squinting as the light blinded him.

'James', she said hoarsely before clearing her throat, 'I thought he was at the drinks table with the Hufflepuffs?'

'Yeah, he was but they went outside to throw up'.

'Nice', said Lily, with a disgusted look on her face.

Sirius chuckled. 'Yeah. So what's been up with you tonight? You seem a bit off.'

And just like that, Lily told him everything. The plan, the kiss, the boogying. She told him how worried she was and how messed up her life had become.

'That explains a lot', said Sirius sincerely, 'you've been acting strangely all night'.

Lily gave him a weak smile and Sirius put a comforting arm around her shoulder.

'Well, if it's any consolation, you didn't kiss me'.

'What?'

'It wasn't me you were in the closet with earlier'.

This statement took a while to process through Lily's head.

She hadn't kissed Sirius. She had kissed James.

So why don't I feel happier?

James was her boyfriend and that kiss with him had been magical.

And she would be able to kiss him until the day they died.

Sirius watched Lily walk out of the closet and he slumped down onto the ground, his head in his hands.

Did I do the right thing?

He took his head away from his hands and berated himself for having such thoughts. Of course he had done the right thing! He had salvaged his best friend's relationship even though it meant letting the love of his life walk away.

At least he would always have that kiss to remember her by.

THE END

A/N- I don't think it's my best work but you might not care about what I think. I, however, care a lot about what you think, so please REVIEW!

Thanks for reading the story- my first ever! And all of you who have used the little blue/ grey box below- cookies to you!