Hey guys here is another MLP Creepypasta cross over. This one is 'Muffins' (which is a continuation of the Cupcakes story) made by the Youtuber- Reitanna Seishin. It is best if you watch the 33 episodes she made since this takes place sometime after the (at this point) final episode.

'Muffins' is one of my favorite Youtube series.


McGonagall was sitting at her desk going over the letters of acceptance or the denial of going to Hogwarts that were sent in that morning when the room light up and a new letter appeared on her desk. As she looked over the letter she noticed that it looked like it was written in blood by a five-year-old.

Hi

No sorry not this Harry Potter pony

Minkie Pie

After reading this McGonagall left her office and headed out to find Dumbledore for he had some explaining to do.


A few days later

Muffins universe

Obsidian 'Minkie' Pie was lying on the floor next to Apple Bloom who was teaching Minkie with a book that Babs Seed left them after their last baking playdate.

Marblestone 'Inkie' Pie and Limestone 'Blinkie' Pie were talking about what they would do if somepony was dumb enough to come to the abandoned castle that they were using as their hideout since the ponies were still trying to take them down for the ponies they killed.

Derpy Hooves and Pinkamena 'Pinkie' Diane Pie were playing with Gummy.

They all froze when they heard the door open only to relax when they saw it was Babs.

"They guy," Babs said as she closed the door "any word about that weird letter Minkie got a few days ago?"

"No nothing" Inkie answered in a bored tone "can we bake today?"

Pinkie perked up at this until Minkie quietly said "shouldn't we wait one more day to be safe?"

"Minkie's right," Babs said "we should wait for tomorrow so if in case somepony does come we can react faster. But let's see who's next so we can form a plan."

"Oh! I'll see who's next," Derpy said as she flew to get the book off the shelf "the next pony is…."

A knock at the door interrupted Derpy causing everypony to hide with Inkie and Blinkie on both sides of the door with a bat ready to knock the intruders out. Babs walked up to the door giving them a nod before she opened both doors to keep them from being seen until it was to later for the intruder.

"What" Babs yelled at the two creatures on the other side of the door.


A few minutes before with Dumbledore

After a few days of looking Dumbledore found a spell that would open a portal near his missing weapon. Getting Snape to join him with little difficulty thanks to his hate of James. Looking around after exiting the portal seeing an old abandon castle in thick creepy woods was not what he expected to see.

"Let me do the talking," Dumbledore said. Snape nodded as he was keeping an eye on the woods.

Dumbledore reached the door with Snape next to him and knocked on the big heavy looking doors. After a few seconds, the doors opened to a small brown pony that yelled "what" and before they could react two gray blurs slammed into them knocking them out.


Back with the Girls

"What the hay are these things," Blinkie asked poking the greasy-looking one with her bat.

"I don't know," Babs said.

"Can we make them into Muffins?" Derpy asked.

"I don't see why not" Pinkie answered.

"Let's make sure they don't have anypony coming after them while we are harvesting" Apple Bloom stated.

"Good idea. Now, who gets to do these two" Inkie asked.


A few minutes later

Snape awoke to the screams of Dumbledore as Derpy was playing with her 'oh I'm so stupid' game by missing Dumbledore's beard on purpose and hitting him with her knife.

"Oh you're awake" a quiet voice spoke causing Snape to jump and to notice that he was tied down to a table. At seeing the dark gray pony with a lock mark on her flank, a dark blue long mane, and dark sunken very familiar green eyes standing over him, he froze.

"Hello I'm Minkie, now why were you two trying to find me," she asked in her quiet voice that made Snape shiver.

"Dumbledore said that you were the missing Harry Potter and that we needed to bring you to Hogwarts so you can learn magic then send you to your relatives so they would beat you during the summer while you were not needed" Snape answered giving the truth in his fear.

"Good job Snape, you're smarter than the other one," she said as a creepy smile spread on her face "my old body was named Harry Potter daughter of Lily and James Potter and it is very dead, my 'loving relatives' killed me on the first day with them. Thanks to that soul shard Voldie left in me, I was reborn with our memories locked away until I read your letter. Thanks to you I now know why I have this darkness inside of me that my 'parents' locked me away for 20 years in the cellar. But now its time to bake" Minkie said with a laugh as she began Snape's long torture.


Hogwarts

McGonagall was pacing in Dumbledore's office as it has been a full day since Dumbledore and Snape left to get the young Harry Potter back and they still haven't returned. Just as McGonagall was thinking of trying to use the spell to follow them a blinding light filled Dumbledore's desk. When the light faded revealing a plate with two Muffins, one blueberry the other chocolate chip, and a letter. McGonagall, thinking that the House Elves left the Muffins, picked up the blueberry and took a bight as she lifts the letter.

Dear McGonagall,

I told you that I wasn't Harry she's been dead for 29 years. Dumbledore and Snape have been returned to you. Dumbledore is the blueberry and Snape is the chocolate chip enjoy. The rest of them have been sent to your heads of government and Vodemorts men. If you don't want to be turned into delicious Muffins or other baking goods as well, free the incident Sirius and never try to come for me again.

Life is a Party,

Minkie Pie

McGonagall then through up.


In a forested area

Nagini was just about to lend her body to Voldemort when their surroundings light up with a blinding light. Once it dimed and both regain their eyesight they found a stitched up body, two Muffins, and a letter.

"Nagini can you open the letter?" Voldemort hissed.

"Ssssure" Nagini hissed as she used her tail to get it opened.

Dear Voldie,

Long-time no see. Well longer for me since I got reborn in a different universe with a different speed in time making it 29 years on my end when it was 10 years for you. I bet you're confused so am I with three different sets of memories in my head. To fill in the blanks, the night you tried to kill Harry Potter and failed you made another Horcruse inside of little Harry. Dumbledore wanting to make the poor girl into a weapon brought her to her magic hating relatives to make her easy to control. Harry's relatives gave her one look and feed her to the dog. Harry with the Soul Shard was reborn in a new body with their memories sealed. The seal is now gone and I now am whole again. Now in front of you is a taxidermied body made of the skin of Snape and Dumbledore that you can use until you get a better body. The Muffins are an example of what my sisters and I do in this world. The blueberry is made with a part of Dumbledore's heart and the chocolate chip is made with a part of Snape's heart as well. I found their hearts as my favorite part so I thought you would enjoy it as well. Now on the back of this letter is the spell Dumbledore used to enter my world since I am giving you that world to do whatever you wish with it, could you send some more human to us. The ponies here are becoming less fun to bake with and we don't want to use them all up to fast so any human you want to remove send them over. Also, could you send Sirius here I would like to have someone here that I can talk with about being locked up in the cellar for 20 years and he is the closes being that I know who's gone through something like that?

Life is a Party,

Minkie Pie

Voldemort stared in shock at the letter rereading it many times looking over to the body he could see that it had Snape's hair though it was no longer greasy. The eyes he could tell were Dumbledores but everything else he couldn't tell. The age the body gave off was somewhere in its thirties was wearing a black wizard's robe that was most likely Snape's knowing Dumbledore's taste in clothes.

If he were to use the body he will need to use a glimmer for many of the stitches since there were way too many to just say he got it in a liveable accident.

Deciding to wait until the next day to chose to use it or not he had Nagini turn the letter over to look at the spell while wishing that he could eat the Muffins in his mist form since they looked and smelled really good….. "That's it! I'm using the body" he yelled then jumped into the body then attacked the Muffins "so good" he moaned into them.

Nagini shook her head at how Voldemort was acting and asked "sssso are we teaming up with thisss Minkie and ssshe makesss you thessse Muffinsss? Thisss ssspell looksss sssimple to do."

"Yesss, mmm so good, we are teaming up I might even bring her and her family here that way they won't have to worry about running out of meat for their baking and the ponies will repopulate while they are here it's a win-win," Voldemort said summoning paper and a quill writing a quick letter opening the portal. He spelled the letter to go to Minkie and sent it through.


I gonna stop here since I can see that it wants to be a story by itself self and I got way too many as it is if you want to pick it up from there you may.

P.S. Reitanna Seishin if you see this you've done an amazing job on your story and can't wait to see how it goes from here.