Disclaimer: I don't own One Tree Hill or its characters. I'm doing this for fun, so please don't sue me.

Chapter 4

The girls were laughing and enjoying themselves when the waiter arrived at the table with a bottle of Martini and Rossi champagne.

Peyton was the first to speak up, "Excuse me, but we did not order this."

The waiter answered back and said, "This is from the two gentlemen in the corner. They asked me to bring it with this note." With that the waiter walked away leaving the girls with the note on the table.

The note said:

Dear Peyton and Haley,

I'm sorry that I acted like a first class jerk. I hope that this will make up for it.

-Nathan Scott

Instead of being touched by the small gesture, Haley and Peyton were incensed.

Peyton started with, "What nerve that guy has?"

Haley answered, "I know. I mean who does he think he is. God's gift to women or something."

Peyton continued, "Does he expect us to swoon? I'll swoon alright. My fist will swoon right into his face."

Brooke took a pause as her opportunity to jump in. "Wait a minute Tutorgirl and P. Jagalski. Don't you think you might be blowing this out of proportion?"

With this both girls looked back at her and said, "No."

Brooke just stared at them for a second planning her next move. Dang, why do they always have to make everything so difficult? Look at those two over there. They are fine. I need to act fast or they are going to blow this for both Tutorgirl and me.

Peyton started back in. "You know what? I don't care, because I have to leave anyway. Lets get the check."

Brooke began to sulk. "Come on P Jagalski, we were having fun. Can't we just stay a little while longer?"

Peyton and Haley just laughed at Brooke as she pouted and begged like a little girl.

Peyton answered, "Sorry ladies, Jake and Jenny are expecting me."

At this point Brooke stuck her lip out and turned to Haley. "Puh-lease roommate. Pretty please. We both look beautiful and are having so much fun. Pretty please.

Haley hated it when Brooke begged. She knew that if she decided to leave, she would not hear the end of it for at least a week. She finally gave in and said, "Fine, we'll stay."

Brooke jumped up and said "Yea! I love you Tutorgirl!"

Peyton took this chance to say good-bye to her friends and go home.

Haley said, "Well if you are going to keep me out tonight Brookie, I need to head to the ladies room. I'll be right back."

Brooke smiled and said, "Okay Tutorgirl, take your time." A wonderful plan had just hatched in Brooke's head and her friend had just unknowingly given her the chance to carry it out.