Summary: A WWE diva's first year in her career was a bumpy and rough road but her second year is soon going to become her best year ever with a WWE superstar as her boyfriend, another career, another chance to become the Women's Champion, and much more.
Chapter 1: Prologue
Nicole Mitchell was 5'9" with long blonde hair and blue eyes and she was from St. Louis, Missouri. With such a busy, extensive, and amazing background in gymnastics, cheerleading, dance, and a little kickboxing, Nicole has competed in fitness competitions in the summer of 2002 and was crowned Miss Fitness America at the end. After that glorious moment, she became a leading international fitness model posing in such magazines like Sports Illustrated and Muscle & Fitness. After a year and a half of that, Nicole was touring wrestling schools to practice for three months because of her dream to become a wrestler since she was little.
She made her WWE debut three weeks after Wrestlemania 20. It was all because of another newcomer who made her debut that night, Delancey Scott. It all started when she cost Evolution the special 2-on-3 handicap match against the Rock N Sock Connection by nailing the Legend Killer, Randy Orton with a low blow before Mick Foley gave him the mandible claw with Mr. Socko. The thing was, Delancey wanted to get her revenge on Randy because he dated her before coming to the WWE as a joke because she was a tomboy and Delancey was one all of her life. Time after time, she kept getting her revenge by costing Randy in his matches and just when she was having her fun, well, this is how the rivalry between Nicole and Delancey started.
It was April 5th, 2004 and RAW was in Houston, Texas. The match was a Women's Battle Royal to determine who would be the number #1 contender for Victoria's Women's Title at Backlash. The women left in the ring were Trish Stratus, Lita, and Delancey Scott. Lita and Delancey were double-teaming Trish and then all of a sudden, a blonde girl wearing a black bustier, miniskirt, and stockings appeared out of nowhere and did a finishing move to Delancey that was similar to Randy Orton's RKO and threw her out of the ring. It was Nicole and everyone wanted to know who she was and what was her purpose for what she did to Delancey.
It was now known that Nicole Mitchell was a member of WWE's once-powerful clique Evolution as the "first lady" and was also going out with Randy Orton who approached her to help him get rid of Delancey Scott. She was always wearing skimpy and revealing clothing because of her on-going sex appeal and Evolution needed a female member with that personality. And then, Nicole and Delancey started having issues with each other in which was one of the most heated rivalries in the WWE. The rivalry went on for months in 2004 until it ended at Survivor Series in which got the two divas to put aside their differences and become best friends.
In August 2004, Nicole's fate with Evolution changed when she witnessed her boyfriend Randy Orton become the youngest World Heavyweight Champion ever at Summerslam and then-Evolution leader Triple H's jealousy over that moment kicked them both out of the group. After two months of Evolution's cruelty, Nicole kept her promise of making up for all the things she has done as the "first lady" of Evolution by standing up for Lita, in her feud with the Women's Champion Trish Stratus, and at Survivor Series, Nicole was engaged to Randy Orton. But her upcoming wedding was canceled thanks to him delivering the RKO to RAW diva Stacy Keibler after a slight misunderstanding of him not ending the Undertaker's 12-0 winning streak at Wrestlemania 21. It also ended Nicole's eleven-month relationship with the cocky and arrogant Legend Killer.
After that incident, Nicole was stressed out and she needed to focus on her Battle of the Missouri Divas match against Delancey Scott, who hails from Chesterfield, in order to be in Christy Hemme's corner in her Women's Championship match against Trish Stratus at Wrestlemania 21.
During that night in Birmingham, Alabama on March 21st, 2005, while she was in her hotel room laying on her bed crying thinking about what Randy did, much to her surprise, she a got a call from Smackdown superstar John Cena. It came to show that he cared about her and wanted to see if she was okay. Nicole was very grateful and throughout the two weeks before Wrestlemania 21, the more times she and John talked to each other, the more she fell in love with him but John didn't know that. Then Nicole devised a plan for her very first Wrestlemania in her WWE career. She had planned to embarrass Randy Orton in his match against the Undertaker by telling him and the whole world that she was in love with another man and that she would reveal who it was by kissing him.