Chapter #15 The Arguement -
Blackrose watched as her kit told the clan about everything he knew about Smokeshade. About his overhearing, the fur in Wrentail's claws, and Ashfur's break down. Everyone listened with their ears and eyes and they examined the bodies and sure enough, found the fur of the deadly warrior. Blackrose wondered why Dewkit had not told her and Rainwhisker and Mousefur explained why. She nodded and held, Flowerkit, Luxkit, and Fodkit close to her dark body. Ravenwing held Stormkit close and watched his eldest son explain. When he was done, the new deputy, Brambleclaw nodded.
"Thank you, Dewkit. Smokeshade is for now and forever, Banished from ThunderClan."
Firestar looked around. "Any cat that sees him, report to me, or kill him. He is no longer an Clan mate and he is a threat."
Blackrose held back as the other cats chanted to the killing. Blackrose yowled above everyone else, "Thunderclan is no murderer!"
"That's why we must get rid of the problem." Brambleclaw said as-a-matter-of-factly. Blackrose spat.
"Like your father was a problem, but did you get rid of him."
"He was banished before I was born! I cannot help that."
"But, he was still alive, and you still could of killed him."
"I was only a apprentice! Anyways the leader of BloodClan killed him, and Firestar killed that cat, why does that apply?"
"Because you didn't do anything. We should give Smokeshade the heads up, to leave forever!"
"So he can kill us, your talking like a kittypet!" Firestar nor Cloudtail flinched, they were forgetful of their past.
"Well we can just see him pissing on a tree and kill him!" Blackrose spat.
"Oh yes we can, and damn it, we will!" Dustpelt said from the crowd of cats.
