A/N: This is all 4 now, you'll get dialogue later. My computer's pissed me off…

Disclaimer: Don't Want Them…

(Rory)

Luke

Pro

He takes care of me and mom

He feeds us

He gives us coffee

He fixes our house

He brought ice to my birthday party

He came to my birthday party

He made me a birthday coffee cake

He blew up birthday balloons for me

He reserved me a birthday table

He made me mashed potatoes for a week when I had the chicken pox

He's reliable

He's always been around, and he's like a father to me

He can keep up with us

He tries to convert our eating habits so we won't die at a young age

He helped mom find my chick

I love him

Mom loves him

He loves us

Con

If him and mom don't work out we'll either die from coffee deprivation or starvation

Max

Pro

He loves us

He's smart

He can keep up with us

He's dependable

He's engaged to mom

Con

He doesn't seen like the father type

He can't make coffee

He can't fix things around the house

He didn't make me mashed potatoes for a week

He can't tell that mom doesn't love him

(Lorelai)

Luke

Pro

He made Rory mashed potatoes for a week when she had the chicken pox

He takes care of us

He feeds us

He gives us coffee

He's reliable

He can keep up with us

He helped me find Rory's chick

He brought ice to Rory's birthday party

He came to Rory's birthday party

He made Rory a birthday coffee cake

He blew up birthday balloons for Rory

He reserved Rory a birthday table

He fixes the Crap Shack

He's always been around

He's like a dad to Rory

He tries to convert our eating habits so we won't die early

I love him

Rory loves him

He loves us

Con

What if he doesn't love me?

What if we break up?

Max

Pro

We're engaged

He loves me

He loves Rory

He's reliable

He can keep up with us

Con

He can't make coffee

He can't fix the Shack when it's falling apart

I don't love him

Lorelai could feel the tears spring up in her eyes after reading the list and after looking up met the hopeful eyes of her daughter. "So, you think I'm doing the right thing?" She asked shakily. Rory only nodded her head and smiled, tears forming in her own eyes.

"As soon as possible."

"I'll do it tonight." Lorelai smiled as the door to her office opened.

"I hope it's after our date…" Came the voice of the intruder. Rory's eyes automatically bulged as she quickly stuffed Lorelai's list in her pocket, the rustling of paper as obvious as a daisy in field of roses.