A/N: This chapter took three days to write... at least it's pretty long for me...
Also before anyone complains, I'm aware that Halloween is a very recent thing in Japan. I know because when I to Japan in 2008, I stayed in Shibuya which now hosts a giant Halloween party... and on Halloween I only saw two people dressed up in costume, and one of them was a white guy... But a counterpoint: MHA takes place in the future so I can point out it would be a thing in their childhood so... yeah... Enjoy the chapter!
Chapter 23: The Horrors of Nightmare Night
Something they learned during their time was during their year and half stuck in Equestria that they would be able to participate in two holidays… not once but twice.
Thankfully the holidays weren't too foreign to them. The holidays were actually similar to something from their world.
In this case it was similar to Halloween.
A very popular holiday among children and most of them had participated at least once.
And of course the adults had a party so it was going to be a fun night.
Thankfully Momo made almost everyone costumes… well those who didn't already have costumes.
"You're wearing that again?" asked Starlight who was dressed like a hippie.
"Of course it's my favorite costume." Said Sunburst dressed like Starswirl the Bearded.
"You know I'm going to burn it before next Nightmare Night right?" asked Starlight.
"Why?" asked Sunburst.
"You need to wear something else next year…" said Starlight, "It literally going to be our last nightmare night."
That was when both Ochaco and Momo came down downstairs wearing their costumes, Momo dressed like a hula dancer while Ochaco decided to go as a breezy, a type of fairy like pony that lived in a hidden location.
"But…" said Sunburst.
"Say… do you know what the other costume will be?" asked Sunburst changing the subject.
"Don't change the subject." Said Starlight.
"Well Shoto didn't ask me to make his costume." Said Momo.
"What about the others?" asked Sunburst.
"For two of them there will be explanations." Said Momo.
"What does that mean?" asked Starlight.
"You'll see." Said Momo.
That was when both Spike and Tenya both left the men's… uh… area (it's hard to describe that area okay).
Spike was dressed like a newsie.
While Tenya was dressed like a robot.
"Cool costumes." Said Ochaco.
"A newsie?" asked Starlight.
"I wanted to mix things up this year." Said Spike with a shrug.
He usually dressed like something awesome or heroic…
But living with a bunch of heroes in training from another world just made him feeling award wearing something like that this year.
"So are the others ready?" asked Starlight.
"I think Izuku's planning to make some sort of big entrance." Said Spike with a shrug.
Momo giggled when he said that.
That was when Shoto joined them.
Everyone stared at his costume.
"Are you sure you want to wear that?" asked Starlight unsure how to react.
"I can make you something else." Said Momo.
It was a piece of paper taped onto him that said "Costume."
"It's fine." Said Shoto.
"You haven't done Halloween have you?" asked Ochaco.
"No…" said Shoto.
None of the others were surprised by this after discovering the type of person his father was.
That was when Katsuki showed up… and turned out his costume was his hero costume.
"You're seriously wearing that?" asked Ochaco.
"Why would you care." Muttered Katsuki.
"It's not functional is it?" asked Tenya.
"Don't worry it's just a replica." Said Momo.
"Why is that important?" asked Spike.
"The gauntlets store up his sweat." Said Momo.
"Okay where's Deku?" asked Bakugo.
That was when Izuku made his entrance, to no one's surprise he was dressed like All Might.
"Have no fear for I am here!" yelled Izuku, even imitating All Might's face.
Ochaco broke down laughing because of the face.
"Of course you're a fucking nerd." Muttered Bakugo.
"I take it your All Might?" asked Sunburst.
"I am." Said Izuku returning his face to normal, "Is Twilight coming too?"
"No I'm holding down the fort." Said Twilight magically lifting what appeared to be small bombs and some sort of non-lethal guns.
"What are those weapons for?" asked Tenya.
"Tenya… this is a library…" said Twilight.
That was when there was the sound of pelting hitting the library.
"Excuse me for a second!" said Twilight pulling out one of the guns and a sack of potatoes.
She then teleported away with those things.
They all turned to the nearby window and watched as a bunch of teenaged ponies were pelted by the potatoes.
"Twilight uses Nightmare Night as a well to expel all her repressed anger." Said Starlight.
"Why would she have repressed anger?" asked Tenya.
"Oh various reasons." Said Twilight teleporting in, "The fact that I got sent back in time, the fact that I lost everything and will eventually die a death that only a few will know about, the fact that I wish I could talk to certain ponies but they literally are unable to know of my existence… and all sort of other reasons."
"So it's your usual issues." Said Shoto.
"Pretty much." said Twilight, "And don't worry I give trick or treaters candy."
"That's good." Said Ochaco.
"Come on let's go." Said Spike.
They headed to the main part of the town just a group of trick or treaters arrived with poor Granny Smith with them.
They got to the main party.
They saw there were ponies from all over town having fun, playing games and sort of thing.
However what surprised them was that Twilley's group also came for nightmare night.
"Hey! We decided to come to town." Said Twilley rather nervously.
She was also dressed like Star Swirl the Bearded.
That was when she saw that Sunburst was dressed the same way.
"Starswirl Buddies!" they both said at the same time.
"This counts towards someone recognizing your costume." Said Starlight.
"Twilley doesn't count." Said Sunburst.
"Still burning the costume." Said Starlight.
"So…" said Minuette who was dressed like some sort of doctor trying to break the awkwardness.
"Why did you go with the hipster look?" asked Moon Dancer (dressed like a cat) somewhat bluntly to Shoto.
"I have my reasons." Said Shoto.
"Awkward." Said Lyra dressed like a mummy.
"Oh come on, it can't be more awkward than that." Said Bonbon dressed like a witch.
"So how things been?" asked Lemon Hearts dressed like a mouse.
"Just the same." Said Izuku.
"Hey!" called out Raspberry dressed like Fillisecond walking over along with H.P. dressed like an archer an Everlasting dressed like Sailor Mercury.
""We were wondering who are you two dressed like?" asked H.P.
"Why do you want to know?" asked Katsuki.
"Because I'm one of the biggest comic book fans in all of Ponyville and I don't recognize your costumes." Said Raspberry.
"What you want to make us the nerdiest costumes in town?" asked Katsuki.
"Please…" said Raspberry, "No one can beat him."
She pointed to a guy in a really bad blonde wig wearing some sort of sci-fi costume and glasses.
"There's no way to beat Matt the Radar Technician when comes to nerdy costumes." Said Everlasting.
The two groups of friends looked at the nerds confused.
"You didn't answer my question." Said Raspberry.
"Well it's someone from back home who's a hero." Said Izuku.
"Where do you come from anyways?" asked Raspberry.
"Why the fuck should we tell you!" yelled Katsuki.
"Calm down… fighting will get you nowhere." Said Everlasting, "Also I don't think he'll give us answer."
"Unless it's his hypothetical super hero costume he would wear." Said Raspberry with a shrug.
Katsuki glared at Raspberry.
"Wow… that's really sad." Said H.P.
Katsuki looked ready to blow her up.
"Let's go ask "Matt" if he ever managed to rewire the calcinator." Said Everlasting dragging her friends away.
"You know they have a point." Said Twinkleshine dressed like a half spider creature.
Katsuki glared at her.
Starlight began to drag him away.
"Let's go some snacks." Said Starlight dragging away the very explosive human turned pony.
"You know this is going to be Princess Luna's first official visit to Ponyville…" said Lyra changing the subject.
In the previous timeline Nightmare Night went badly due to Princess Luna visiting for a multitude of reasons.
Thanks to Twilight's changes that night wouldn't happen, including letting Ponyville know that Princess Luna was coming.
Unfortunately… that didn't mean that things wouldn't go wrong for the town…
After some fun, it was time for the story of Nightmare Night to be told.
Though it didn't help that Mayor Mare was dressed like a clown while dong the spooky voice.
"I should have told her to wear something spooky." Sighed Spike.
Everyone looked at Spike.
"This always annoyed me." Said Spike making sure it was something from the previous timeline.
However before the story of Nightmare Night could be told there was an evil laughter in the air.
A large unicorn stallion teleported on stage.
Everyone looked up at the stage.
"Oh come on!" yelled a pony.
"I was hoping for a nice nightmare night!" yelled another.
"You know… we really should have expected that." Said yet another one.
"Seriously?" asked the Unicorn Stallion.
"Welcome to Ponyville." Said a pony in the crowd.
" I see! Now my evil plan!" said the unicorn.
"Zombies" yelled Raspberry.
"Ghosts!" yelled H.P.
"You're going to turned everypony into their costumes to amass a monster army!" yelled Everlasting.
"Okay how did you know that!" yelled the unicorn.
"It's been done!" yelled a random pony.
"Yes! I win!" cheered Everlasting.
The other two grumbled and gave Everlasting bits.
"Okay! Seriously!" yelled the unicorn.
With the six humans turned ponies.
"You need to take off your costumes now." Said Starlight.
However before any of them could, there was a bright flash of light.
"Oh did I neglect to mention that it was a timed spell." Said the unicorn, "And anything evil will not only think like what they have turned into but become my slave?"
Ponies that were turned into monsters were suddenly all attacking.
And unfortunately for the six heroes in training most of them were having problems.
They did become their costumes as well. Ochaco was now a tiny breezy.
However Momo tried to use her quirk she was unable to.
As for Shoto…
Well…
Starlight stared at Shoto who was now wearing a trebly a sweater vest and a collared shirt. Oddly enough his coat was now completely red and his mane and tail were completely white.
"Why are you hipster?" asked Starlight.
"I have no idea…" said Shoto but it was clear he couldn't use his quirk either.
That was when Twinkleshine who was a half-spider creature and very much under the control of the unicorn that did all this.
However while everyone did make fun of him for it. It turned out it was a very good thing he went with for his costume.
He set off an explosion near the transformed Twinkleshine, thankfully scaring off the transformed spider creature.
"You didn't hurt her!" said Spike who was not only a newsie but also a pony.
"She's brainwashed." Muttered Katsuki.
"I didn't think you'd consider that much." Said Shoto.
"Now's not the time for this!" yelled Starlight, she moved what should have a wig originally but showed she didn't have her horn, "I'm a powerless hippie, Shoto's a powerless hipster… and…"
"Wait… what about Deku?" asked Ochaco.
That was when a zombie tried to attack them, however a gust of wind pushes away the zombie.
They turned where the wind came from, it was a large red earth pony stallion with a golden mane and tail defending a robot and an old bearded unicorn.
They quickly realized who they were.
"So that's what All Might would have looked like if he came here." Said Ochaco.
"Are you okay?" asked The massive stallion who was clearly a transformed Izuku.
"Tenya… can you fight?" asked Starlight to the transformed robot.
"No… I wasn't turned into a robot that can fight." Said the transformed Tenya.
"Okay… this is bad." Said Spike.
"We have to find out how to reverse the spell." Said Sunburst who had turned into Starswirl the Bearded.
"Hey!" called out a voice.
They turned and saw another Starswirl the Bearded, with Minuette (who didn't really change thankfully, just had some more realistic scrubs) while a cat and a mouse rode on Minuette.
"Most of us don't have our powers." Said Shoto.
"Okay… that's bad." Said the transformed Twilley.
"Twinkleshine, Lyra and Bonbon are all being controlled." Said Minuette.
" We noticed." Said Katsuki.
"We need to find out how to remove the spell." Said All Might-Izuku who began to go on a mutter storm, "But will he remove it? I mean we probably wouldn't do it unless forced to, or maybe there's a time limit on the spell…"
It was really weird due to the fact that he now had All Might's voice.
"Deku stop!" yelled Katsuki.
"I don't think I'll be able to get the image out of my head for a while." Said Ochaco to her classmates.
The other four nodded in agreement, all of them grew up watching All Might, seeing a pony version of him going into Izuku's mutter storms was just surreal.
"But still it's probably a good idea for you two to make him reverse the spell." Said Starlight, "Though I think Twilley and Sunburst should go to the library and see if there's anything about this spell there."
"Just because we were transformed into Starswirl the Bearded doesn't mean we have the ability to find the spell." Said Starswirl-Twilley.
"No… I'm telling you to do it because you two have a track record for finding spells within minutes." Said Starlight face hoofing.
"Oh… right…" said Starswirl-Twilley.
"She's right, we have to go to the library." Said Starswirl-Sunburst.
The two headed to the library while the Katsuki and All Might-Izuku looked towards the stage, the unicorn was holding now the now clown mayor hostage and had an evil smile.
"Figures we'd be the only ones useful." Muttered Katsuki, "Hopefully you won't break your bones as All Might."
"Don't worry, I feel more in control than I usual have." Said All-Might Izuku.
Mentally he was also breathing a sigh of relief that his transformed state didn't have the injury.
He had promised himself that even though he did tell them about his quirk, they would still keep All Might's injury to himself. After all there still wasn't any gauntee they would remeber this when they got home.
The two headed to the stage and found themselves surrounded by the transformed ponies (and in one case Zebra).
Meanwhile the others found a place to hide.
"Hopefully Luna will show up soon." Said Starlight.
"Oh yeah she's coming." Said Breezy-Ochaco.
"She's not coming as Nightmare Moon is she?" asked Tenya.
They all hoped it wasn't the case.
"I think we can all agree she probably won't." said Shoto.
"Can you two talk?" Spike asked the transformed Lemon Hearts and Moon Dancer.
The two ponies turned mouse and cat shook their heads no.
"Hey, you we need help right away!" yelled a mare who was appeared to be an accient queen of some kind.
"We need a doctor now." Said an astronaut.
"I'm not a real doctor!" yelled Minuette.
"We know that" said the astronaut, "Tt's just that we need so many medical supplies."
"And before you ask it's not because they got attacked by a monster… it's just that." Said the queen.
That was they were horrified as they saw a stallion in a beard screaming agony as he was being devoured by a shark.
The shark was originally just a stuffed toy…
"Does anyone else have a costume that's eating them?" asked Momo.
"No… hopefully." Said the queen.
"We should create some sort of safe zone." Said Robot-Tenya.
That was when suddenly a bag blew into Spike's face.
He removed it and it began to move on its own.
They jumped upon seeing this.
"Wait… Derpy?" asked Momo remembering the costume that the extremely clumsy Pegasus was wearing.
The Paper bag moved in a way as if it was nodding.
"Let's figure it out as we try our best to help him." Said Shoto motioning over to the hapless stallion being devoured by a shark.
Meanwhile nether Katsuki or All Might-Izuku were able to do much as they weren't sure how to the handle what they were dealing with.
After all Katsuki might have been a huge… jerk (which is putting it nicely) but he knew they weren't in control of themselves.
That was hewn they heard a call of "Bubble Spray!"
And a fog rolled in.
"Great…" said Katsuki.
However the strange thing was that while the monsters were getting worried about the fog, it seemed like the fog didn't affect the two.
"What." Muttered Katsuki.
They saw that mummy who was Lyra and a vampire who was a unicorn they weren't sure about was about to attack them.
However that was an a blur stopped the monsters.
"What!" yelled Izuku.
That was when arrows began to pin the transformed ponies in various ways.
"That's the just the thing about Nightmare Night… there's plenty of monsters." Said a voice, "But there's also plenty of heroes."
He fog cleared and they saw a lineup of various transformed ponies, but these one were firmly one the side of good.
"You two are the professionals!" said the transformed Raspberry who joined them, "We'll just clear out the crowd you can beat the main baddie."
"Whatever." Muttered Katsuki.
"Are sure that's a good idea?" asked All Might-Izuku.
That was when a demon was about to attack All Might-Izuku.
But suddenly a lion pounced on the transformed demon.
"I think we're good." Said Sailor Mercury-Everlasting tapping her earring and creating a set of goggles.
"She's right…" said H.P. shooting some arrows and turned around to face Katsuki and All Might-Izuku, "I get you're worried about us… but this spell is affecting us as much as them."
That was when the arrows she shot landed, which hit their targets perfectly.
The demon managed to get the lion off her and sent fire at them.
"Shine Aqua Illusion!" called out Sailor Mercury-Everlasting stopping the fire.
"I think you can see we got this." Said Fillisecond-Raspberry appearing as a blur.
"Please we don't need your help." Muttered Katsuki.
"You need our help." Said Sailor Mercury-Everlasting.
"Just accept their help Kacchan." Said All Might-Izuku.
"If you call me Kacchan like that again I will kill you." He muttered Katsuki.
All Might-Izuku began to sweat, though he kind of got why… he would be weirded out seeing All Might act him too.
In the library, Twilight was getting worried.
Why… because there weren't any more pranks done to the library.
"Something is going on." Said Twilight.
That was when the two Starswirl the Bearded appeared in the library, especially since it was locked and only someone with a key could unlock.
"What?" asked Twilight.
"We need to find the spell that transformed us into our costumes, not only that but the one who cast the spell is controlling those in "Evil" costumes as well. I haven't heard a spell, but I'm sure we'll be able to find soemthing!" said one of them, the one that was clearly Sunburst.
Starswirl-Twilley realized that one of the two she was unable to see or talk to was in the library and knew why her counterpart was talking that way.
Starswirl-Sunburst motioned Twilight to follow him to get out of earshot of Starswirl-Twilley.
"Okay… from the looks of it a unicorn used a spell to transform the town into their costumes." Said Twilight who seemed to sigh.
"What's wrong?" asked Starswirl- Sunburst.
"This spell didn't affect Starlight's spell." Said Twilight, "Otherwise she would have reacted to seeing me."
"Oh…" said Starswirl-Sunburst realzing that she was right.
"It would have been awkward but weird." Said Twilight.
"I know." Sighed Starswirl-Sunburst, "But we need to focus on this."
"You're right… sorry." Said Twilight.
And so she helped them with the research.
Back in what should have been the party. The group trying to help the poor guy being eaten by the shark were joined by a Princess and a firefighter.
The paper bag moved in a way towards the firefighter.
"Mommy!" said the firefighter taking the paper bag and holding.
"Wait you're a foal?" asked Robot-Tenya knowing it was better to use proper pony terms at the moment.
"I'm Dinky! Derpy's daughter!" said the firefighter holding the paper bag as gently as possible.
"Derpy has a daughter?" whispered Breezy-Ochaco surprised.
Starlight nodded.
"I'm a foal too!" said the princess, "I think the spell also made us grown-ups too!"
"It makes sense." Muttered Shoto, "If you want an army you can't have children."
"Wait does that mean there's some in that army?" asked Breezy-Ochaco.
"I was a dragon right now I would send them a message." Muttered Spike who was very angry about that.
Meanwhile in the crowd, Katsuki and All Might-Izuku were still heading towards the stage. That was when well…
"Matt the Radar Technician" stood in their way.
"What?" asked All Might-Izuku confused why he would be standing in their way.
"He's a villain." Said Katsuki figuring it out.
They knew they had to bypass him somehow. However "Matt the Radar Technician seemed ready to fight."
Thankfully somepony made sure a fight didn't break out.
"No!" yelled Fillisecond-Raspberry, "That's Matt the Radar Technician!"
Matt the Radar Technician looked at Fillisecond-Raspberry ready to do something to her.
However that was when the ninja (that was clearly on their side) showed up the fight him.
Matt The Radar Technician lifted up his hoof, and lifting the ninja into the air as the ninja was choked.
Both Katsuki and All Might-Izuku were shocked by this power.
"Who the fuck Matt the Radar technician!" yelled Katsuki staring at this.
"I'm 90 percent sure he's…" said Fillisecond-Raspberry.
"Now's not the time to make jokes!" yelled H.P.
She shot some arrows elsewhere and looked towards them.
"Just distract him because he's one of the biggest threats." H.P. to Fillisecond-Raspberry.
That was when the arrows of coruse hit the targets.
"Fine!" said Fillisecond-Raspberry, "But you owe me."
She sped towards "Matt the Radar Technician."
All Might-Izuku was about to say something.
"Don't ask." Said H.P. "When I say it's way too nerdy, I mean it's WAY too nerdy."
She then shot some arrows then looked at the two before they even hit their targets.
"You two really need to get that guy now!" said H.P.
"Why do you keep doing that." Muttered Katsuki as the arrows finally hit their targets.
"Cause it's cool and I now have the skills." Said H.P.
"She's got a point." Sid All Might-Izuku.
"Let's just go fight the guy." Muttered Katsuki.
They headed towards the stage, however that was a werewolf tackled All Might-Izuku.
All Might-Izuku looked at the werewolf pinning him to the ground, and saw it had purple eyes.
All Might-Izuku managed to push the werewolf off him.
And to say he was angry was an understatement.
"We need to get to the stage now." He practically growled out.
Katsuki looked at All Might-Izuku.
"That was Scootaloo." Muttered All Might-Izuku.
That was when it hit Katsuki, some of these transformed monsters were kids.
That when All Might-Izuku leapt to the stage like it was nothing and Katsuki's eye twitched.
He exploded to the stage too.
Back with the ever growing safe area.
Spike and Momo were bashing the somehow still living shark with some debris they found as it tried to eat the guy.
"Why did you dress up like someone being eaten by a shark?" asked Starlight.
"I didn't think I'd actually be eaten by a shark!" yelled the guy.
That was when a bride of Frankenstein saw them and was about to attack.
Thankfully a pirate and a pony dressed like a bat themed superhero showed up and defended the group.
"'sup Smitty!" said Spike as he counted to bash the shark.
The pony dressed up like the super hero nodded at Spike.
Almost everypony looked at Spike.
"What he always dresses like Batmane for Nightmare Night." Said Spike giving the shark a couple more whacks, "Don't know who the pirate is though."
"Pipsqueak." Said the pirate.
Rage could be felt some several of the ponies.
"You know…" said the queen, "You shouldn't be fighting."
"I know…" said Pipsqueak, "But I can fight and I want to help everypony."
Many of those were confused.
"This is the first time Pipsqueak is trick or treating." Said Dinky.
They felt the rage coming from the paper bag she was holding.
"So… what do you think is going to happen to him when this is all over?" asked Spike.
"We'll see…" said Shoto.
The stage the two landed.
The evil unicorn saw that the two heroes landed.
"So it took you long enough… what not used to your bodies…" said the evil unicorn holding the mayor hostage, "Wait… why do you look the same?"
Katsuki just glared at him.
The evil unicorn tossed away the mayor magically.
"I don't know that clown of a politician anymore." Said the unicorn.
"Hey!" yelled the clown mayor.
"What… you were turned into a clown I can make that remark." Said the evil unicorn.
The transformed mayor just looked at him while a honking sound was heard.
"See there's my point." Said the evil unicorn.
Mayor Mare left to find a hiding place.
"So… you two were able to either keep your powers or turn into something to fight me with… lucky." Said the evil unicorn then realizes, "Wait a second! Are you wearing a hypothetical hero costume?"
"Will you shut up!" yelled Katsuki.
"Oh… you've hearing that all night." laughed the evil unicorn.
However All Might-Izuku glared at him.
"Did you know that kids would be tranformed?" asked All Might-Izuku glaring at him.
"Kids? Oh you mean foals? I had hoped and it seemed like they were." Said the evil unicorn.
That was when a laughter filled the air as a chariot being pulled by bat ponies around and a certain more wearing a cloak appeared.
The cloaked pony appeared.
"Greetings Ponyville! Your princess has arrived to celebrate this night!" said the figured removing her cloak revealing Princess Luna.
She looked at what's going on.
"Something is wrong isn't it?" asked Princess Luna immediately realizing something bad is going on.
Meanwhile in the library.
"Found it!" called out Twilight.
She then tossed the book at the two transformed Starswirl.
"A powerful spell matrix." Said Starswirl-Sunburst.
"There's five gems scattered though out Ponyville and if we destroy all five of them within 24 hours then it will reverse the spell." Read Starswirl-Twilley.
"How do we find the gems?" asked Starswirl-Sunburst.
"We'll figure that out." Said Starswirl-Twilley, "Thank you mysterious pony I can't see or really communicate with some reason.""
"Please stop calling me that." Said Twilight.
Starswirl-Sunburst tried not to laugh before the two left.
Twilight sighed as the two left.
"Why did tonight this have to happen?" she asked.
Back on the stage, they finished their explanation.
"Go help!" said Princess Luna to her guards.
The bat like guards nodded and went to help.
"Izuku Midoriya I presume." Said Princess Luna looking at All Might-Izuku.
He nodded.
"Where are the others?" she asked.
"Can't fight… they're all lost their quirks." Said All Might.
"Icy Hot got turned to a hipster, Ponytail got turned into a hula dancer, glasses got turned into a robot and round face got turned into some weird fairy thing." Muttered Katsuki.
"Yet you two were smart and wait… did you say that he was turned into a hipster?" asked the evil unicorn, "Was he the one who wore that piece of paper that said "Costume"?"
Neither All Might-Izuku or Katsuki answered.
"I have no idea how that happened." Said the evil unicorn, "He could have turned into an actual costume."
"That's besides the point." Muttered All Might-Izuku who was still very angry.
"You're right, I have to force our dear princess into a fitting costume." Said the evil unicorn.
"What?" asked Princess Luna.
"You're seriously going to force her to wear something." Said Katsuki.
"Of course a Nightmare Moon I can control will be perfect." Said the evil unicorn.
"What?" asked Princess Luna.
Meanwhile with the two Starswirl they found the group.
"We found out about the spell… and oh Celestia is he being eaten by a shark!" yelled Starswirl-Twilley.
"Yes! And I am in tremendous pain right now!" yelled the pony who was being eaten by a shark.
"How are you not dead!" yelled Starswirl-Twilley.
"Magic… magic is what's keeping me alive I'm guessing." Yelled the pony.
"We figured out what it is." Said Starswirl-Sunburst doing his best to ignore that pony, "It's a magical matrix powered by five gems. In order to remove the spell we have to destroy the gems within 24 hours of the spell's activation or else it's permanent."
"Sounds easy enough…" said Spike.
"But how do we find them?" asked Momo.
"Hey! Evy! We need that magical computer you got!" yelled Bat-Smitty.
Everyone looked at Bat-Smitty.
"What? We both hang out at the comic store enough to know enough about each other's interest." Said Smitty.
Back on stage…
"So if I were to don a costume before you put one me I would work once?" asked Princess Luna.
"What?" asked the evil unicorn.
"You have an idea." Said Princess Luna, "Just do not tell my sister about any of this."
"What does that mean?" asked Katsuki.
She zapped a nearby piece of debris and turned into a wig… a wig that looked like her sister's mane.
She placed it on her head and immediately transformed into a copy of her sister.
"As I said do not tell her." Said Princess Celestia-Luna.
The evil unicorn began to laugh.
"I guess it's plan B then." He said.
"What's plan B?" asked All Might-Izuku.
That was when the evil Unicorn teleported in a lot of costume things.
And put them on.
Suddenly he turned into some sort of horrifying monster.
"I will rule Equestria!" yelled the now monster.
"You just had to turn into a giant monster" said All Might-Izuku.
"We can actually let loose on him." Said Katsuki with a vicious smile looking at his gauntlets.
Meanwhile with the safe group, Sailor Mercury-Everlasting was showing everypony the location where her computer was showing where the gems were.
"Thankfully the fact that magic is running through them I was able to determine their location." Said Sailor Mercury Everlasting.
"How do we destroy them?" asked Momo.
Bat-Smitty tossed them a bunch of bombs.
"Where did you get those bombs?" asked Shoto.
"Don't… don't…" said Spike stopping Smitty.
"I'd say get Raspberry but she's busy with "Matt the Radar Technician" and he's the strongest brainwashed." Said Sailor Mercury-Everlasting.
That was when Fillisecond-Raspberry crashed nearby, but she got back up.
"I really shouldn't have brought his grandpa, uncle and dad..." muttered Fillisecond-Raspberry.
And then sped away.
"And I think she might need help[ against him… unfortunately." Said Sailor Mercury-Everlasting "I'm sorry!"
"It's okay we'll figure something out." Said Starlight.
Sailor Mercury-Everlasting nodded and joined the fight against "Matt the Radar Technician".
"Why is a radar technician the strongest?" asked Breezy-Ochaco.
"I have no idea." Sighed Starlight.
"I'll go!" said Robot-Tenya.
"You're not built for fighting." Said Shoto.
"I know but I can tell this body might be able to handle the strain of the brainwashed." Said Robot-Tenya.
"I join you." Said Starswirl-Sunburst, "I have access to Starswirl's magic capabilities."
"You just want to use as much magic as possible. "said Starlight.
"Can you blame me?" asked Starswirl-Sunburst.
"No." said Starlight.
Smitty tossed them was clearly the device to set off the bombs.
The two left.
Meanwhile on Stage. All Might-Izuku pumped into the air and punched the transformed monster while shouting "Detroit Smash!"
The monster was sent to the ground, he but he got up.
But it was clear he was in pain.
"That was for Scootaloo." Muttered All Might-Izuku.
"I don't' care who's in my army he or she belongs to me now!" yelled the monster.
That was when Princess Celestia-Luna zapped him with a spell.
"HOW DARE YOU SPEAK ABOUT USING A FOAL THAT WAY!" she yelled in the Royal Canterlot Voice.
That was when Katsuki got his gauntlets ready.
"The only good thing about the spell is that it made my gauntlets the real deal." Said Katsuki with an evil smile.
"Why is that a big deal?" asked the transformed monster.
That was when he activated one of them and then pulled the pin and shot off a massive explosion at the transformed monster.
In the safe location they all saw the explosion.
"Oh no…" said Dinky.
"No… it's fine…" said Momo.
"The gauntlets are real." Sighed Shoto.
"The gauntlets are now real." Confirmed Momo.
"Oh yeah didn't you say the gauntlets store his sweat." Said Spike.
Many of those were confused but those who knew how his quirk looked were either impressed or a little terrified.
Back on the stage the monster was recovering.
"How…" muttered the monster.
"I'm not explaining my quirk to a villain like you." Said Katsuki.
The monster seemed to spout more limbs.
"You can't beat me." Said the transformed monster.
"We will find a way." Said All Might-Izuku.
He jumped into the air to punch the monster, this one much harder than before.
Meanwhile. Robot-Tenya and Starswirl-Sunburst found the last gem.
Thankfully thanks to the army on their side they didn't get hit by a lot of brainwashed monster.
"That's the last one." Said Starswirl-Sunburst.
"I hope this works." Said Robot-Tenya.
Robot-Tenya pressed the button and a bunch of bombs went off throughout Ponyville.
When they did there was a bright flash of light in throughout the town as everyone returned to normal.
"They did it!" said Ochaco as returned to normal (well pony normal).
Shoto ripped off his "costume".
"I'm alive! And the shark isn't!" yelled the pony who ripped the shark plushy off him and kicked it away.
On stage… Izuku was still in midair after that punch.
He was about to fall but Princess Luna caught him.
"I don't think that was my punch." Said Izuku.
"I don't believe it either." Said Princess Luna.
The evil unicorn looked up and saw Katsuki pointing his hoof at him.
"Don't try to think of running away." Muttered Katsuki.
The evil unicorn getting his teeth.
Though out the town… it was clear that any pony brainwashed didn't remember anything.
"What happened." Said Scootaloo.
"I don't know…" said Lyra.
"Did Berry Shine spike the punch bowl…" said a yellow mare with an orange mane dressed like a devil, "Again…"
The guards were called to arrest the evil unicorn.
"This is not normal for Nightmare Night… is it?" asked Princess Luna.
They all stared at Princess Luna.
"All right… so that is a no…" said Princess Luna.
Izuku glared harshly at the unicorn as he was led away.
"Hey it's okay to be angry…" said Ochaco.
"I know…" sighed Izuku.
"Everyone fine." Said Ochaco.
"It could have been a lot worse." Said Starlight.
"How could that be worse." Said Shoto.
"Momo could have said no to Katsuki's costume." Said Starlight.
"Fair enough." Said Spike.
"Hopefully next year won't be too bad." Said Ochaco somewhat optimistically.
"Yeah." Agreed Izuku.
Hopefully, just hopefully the next year's might be a fun night… with some scares, but not anything like that night…
Next Time: It's time for the Sisterhooves Social and Scootaloo convinces Izuku to join her as her "sister" with help of a gender changing spell. Durring it he learns about Sweetie Belle's older sister... who had disappeared... and has plans to wreck the Sisterhooves Social. What will happen? Find out next time!
A/N: I don't know why I added Matt the Radar Technician. Maybe because of Randy the Intern... either way... it was stupid... but I just loved writing him in the chapter...