"Jen… she was here and a guy went… and poof gone," Madison rambled in a state of shock.
"Repeat that in English please," Dean stated not comprehending a word that came out of Madison's mouth.
"She said," Haley began. "That Jen was here and she killed that guy, then disappeared with Jake and Luke."
"You understood that?" Sam asked staring at her.
"Yeah, didn't you?" Haley replied looking at Sam.
"That's not the point," Dean continued. "Are you saying Jen was here?"
"Yes," Madison finally stated. "And she was"
"Yes?" Dean prodded.
"A vampire," Haley finished. "And now she had Jake and Luke. We have to do something!"
"Calm down," Sam stated. "You two stay here we'll go look for Jake and Luke."
"No way!" Madison exclaimed. "I am not staying here to take the blame! Everyone blames me!" Then she walked off.
"What was that about?" Dean questioned.
"Nothing. She just needs some time al…" Haley began.
"I'm going to go talk to her," Dean interrupted.
"No," Haley yelled but it was too late. Dean was already halfway across the yard. Dean found Madison sitting alone inside.
"Are you okay?" He asked sitting down next to her, but she got up and moved. "What did I say?"
Moments later Dean came back to the backyard where Haley and Sam still stood.
"How did it go?" Haley asked as she saw Dean.
"She just got up and walked away," Dean answered and Sam started walking towards the house.
"You're not going to try to stop him?" Dean questioned Haley.
"No," Haley simply answered. She knew exactly what was up with her friend, and she knew Madison wouldn't tell either one of them what was up. She would be more likely to tell Sam more than she would Dean.
Sam found Madison sitting on the front porch steps with her head leaning against the banister.
"What was that all about?" He questioned as he sat down beside her.
Madison turned to look at Sam as he sat down and she was crying. She turned her head away from him, as if searching for the right words to say.
After a moments silence she answered, "I've just been blamed for a lot of things that I didn't do all my life."
She still wouldn't look at Sam as he replied, "we all get blamed for stuff we never do."
His reply made her look at him then. He saw something really painful in her blue eyes as she softly answered, "not for the stuff I've been blamed for."
"What kind of stuff were you blamed for?" Sam had to ask. He didn't get an answer from her, she just shook her head and looked away. Her guard was going up again. It had been a long shot asking that question, but he thought he would try.
"Okay, we'll just make up some story to tell the police. We can't tell them 'a vampire killed them.' Dean and I have to do this all the time," Sam reassured her. "Then we'll get to the bottom of all of this."
Madison nodded her head, then her and Sam made their way back to the backyard