Title: Burn In My Light (Randy Orton's Theme Song: "Burn In My Light" by Mercy Drive)

Disclaimer: I don't own anyone/anything except for my PS2 some games and my brother's WWE Smackdown! VS. Raw and if you want it you gotta beat me in a hell in a cell match for it. I DON'T OWN OLIVE GARDEN! Lastly I don't own "The Ring" except for my copy of the DVD. Don't sue me, I'm just an innocent city gal!

Author's Note: Hey. Thanks for your encouraging reviews. So your votes were all took into consideration, except for anyone that voted for Molly. I'm sorry. Ok… After votes, we have a winner for the Cena Diva Search. Ladies and Gentlemen, (I'm guessin' it's mostly Ladies, LOL) you're Cena Diva is… LITA!

Voting Results

Lita6 Votes

Stacy5 Votes

Torrie5 Votes

Maria1 Vote

Miss Jackie1 Vote

XXXXXXXXXXX

It was an extremely close vote. Lita beat both Torrie and Stacy by one vote. Thanks to all of you that voted. I'm sorry if anyone is mad about the outcome, but I remember I didn't pick, I let you vote. Please don't stop reading because you didn't like the fact Lita won. PLEASE! I'll find a way to make it up to you! OK, now on with Chapter 5.

MUST READ: OMG! Tess made the sequel to NLT! Check it out! I can't thank you enough, Tess! It's called "The Past ReVisited". My newest friend Stratusfiedorton has a story that rocks as well. It's called "My Hero". CHECK IT OUT! Also check out Trishrocks' fic: "Be With You" is great. Check that out, too. LOL! I don't think they had any idea that I would plug 'em… umm… surprise…LOL! Okay now I'll leave ya alone and Let you read! Hey Stratusfiedorton, I want a review from you next time! LOL!

Chapter 5: Triple Date Dare Scare

(THE NEXT DAY…)

Trish woke up in Randy's arms. Randy and John were both fast asleep. Trish got up and noticed how happy Randy looked. She turned to look at John. She felt bad for him. He seemed to be alone and unhappy.

Trish washed up and got ready to start her day. It was 9 AM. She made breakfast for her favorite little "twins". Randy and John were so alike. Not only were they both strikingly handsome, but they were each other's best friend. Heck! They were closer than brothers. Randy and John had known each other for a long time. They fought over stupid things, looked out for each other, got drunk together, played together, they practically did everything together. As she watched John sleeping alone, a light bulb lit up in her head. She had an idea…

(SOMETIME LATER IN THE SAME DAY, PERHAPS AN HOUR)

"Randy… Please!"

"No, Trish!"

"But, he seems alone!

"I'm not going to convince him to date someone if he doesn't want to, especially someone you picked for him."

Trish stood there facing Randy. She started faking tears hoping he'd fall for them. Randy looked down at Trish and said "not this time". She looked into his deep blue sea like eyes. She started crying so much, Randy fell for the trap. "Fine…" Randy said.

"Thanks, sweetie! I love you!" Trish said joyfully as she hugged Randy and kissed him. "Wait, I forgot. You have to invite someone else also." Trish said quietly.

"WHAT!" Randy bellowed. "I NEVER AGREED TO THAT!" he added. "WHAT DO YOU MEAN SOMEONE ELSE, IS IT SUPPOSED TO BE A DOUBLE DATE!" Randy asked.

"Triple date." Trish said softly.

"GOD DAMN, WOMAN! ARE YOU OUTTA YOUR FREAKIN' MIND!" Randy shouted at the top of his lungs.

"Umm… I love you!" Trish said smiling.

"YOU'RE NOT GONNA WEASEL YOURSELF OUTTA THIS ONE, MISS STRATUS!" Randy said still shouting.

"Randy, keep your voice down, doctor's orders!" Trish said knowing she won this argument, too. Randy knew she was right and he couldn't argue back, the doctor told him to keep his voice down and not to yell or his throat injury can come back. Before Randy could say another word Trish jumped into his arms and planted a "hard to resist" kiss on his lips. "You win!" Randy said in a soft satisfied tone.

"Okay, here's the deal, I'll get two of my friends and you get John and someone else." Trish told Randy.

"Okay, but we seal the deal with a kiss." Randy smirked. Trish looked into his orbs of raging oceans. The raging oceans turned into blue flames of passion. Trish hesitated at first, but Randy went for it. He had kissed her like never before. First their lips collided, but soon after their tongues furiously fought. They had sealed the deal.

(LATER THAT DAY, AROUND 12 NOON)

"Amy, come on. I'm begging you… Amy. You're my best friend and ever since you broke up with Matt Hardy you've turned into a moping loser!" Trish screamed out of anger, frustration, and the fact that Trish knew her comment had hit a nerve.

"Fine, Trish, I'll go!" Amy accepted just to shut Trish up. Trish just smiled.

(AT THE SAME TIME…)

"John, wanna go out and grab some food later on, like say… dinnertime." Randy asked not wanting to tell John the full truth.

"Sure, man." John replied.

"Oh by the way, dress decently." Randy told him.

"My jersey isn't decent?" John asked giving Randy the "evil eye".

"Your jersey is fine but, it's that maybe you should try a shirt or something." Randy suggested. John made a disgusted face and growled "fine".

(BACK TO TRISH)

"Hey Tess!" How've you been? Listen you need to meet me for dinner. It's gonna be at Olive Garden. (I don't own Olive Garden. Oh God! Please don't sue me! I love your food, it's so fucking good!) Meet you there at 7:30 sharp. Ta-Ta!" Trish blurted as she ran away from a confused Tess satisfied she got her two friends and date partners. The rest was up to Randy.

(BACK TO RANDY)

"Batista, man, what's up?" asked a jolly Randy.

"Nothin' man, just bored of beating losers in the ring, I got no girl, I feel sick, and I'm miserable." Batista growled.

"Batista, come on man, how about if you had dinner with me, John, Trish, and two of her friends?" Randy asked hoping for a "yes".

" I don't wanna ruin your evening." Batista replied.

"Batista, if you come, I'll buy you lunch another time, all on me!" Randy said hoping he would reconsider.

"NO!" Batista roared.

"Batista, you don't understand, Trish is gonna kill me, murder me, bury me alive if you don't come." Randy pouted with begging eyes.

"Randy, I'm not a chick, so don't try the eyes, but since I feel sorry for you and I'm your friend, I'll go." Batista grinned knowing Randy was embarrassed.

(AT OLIVE GARDEN, 7:30 PM SHARP)

Trish, Amy, and Tess came together and Randy, John, and Batista came together. They met each other at the restaurant. As soon as Randy saw Trish, his mouth dropped straight to the floor. Trish was drop dead gorgeous. She was wearing a metallic silver colored, strapless, evening gown. Amy wore an evening gown that was red at the top and as it goes down it turned into black. Tess wore the same evening gown as Trish, but only her one was metallic green except silver. Randy looked hot as usual only this time he wore a black shirt with the first 2 buttons unbuttoned so his chest could be seen. He smelled like "Obsession" and there was no doubt he was obsession. Batista wore a green shirt with black slacks. He had his sunglasses on and he looked awesome.

"Well if it isn't Mr. You Can't See Me!" Amy said in disgust.

"That's Doctor of Thugonomics to you!" John shot back.

"Whatever! You're right about one thing though, I can't see you, and not only can't I see you, I can't stand you either! As a matter of fact I hate you!" Amy screamed as she stormed off with John chasing behind her. Trish and Randy were confused and shocked at what just happened.

"See Trish, I told you your ridiculous plans wouldn't work." Randy said in an "I told you so" tone.

"Shut up Randy. Best keep your mouth shut if you wanna see me in a lingerie later." Trish said back.

"Mouth is closed!" Randy said pointing at his closed mouth.

(OUTSIDE THE RESTAURANT)

John ran after Amy, remembering what had happened between them two years ago. He had been a bitch to Amy, and they haven't talked since. They had been together before and John thought Amy was sleeping with someone else, but he actually heard Gail Kim fucking around with Maven, not Amy. He didn't know at the time that he had made a mistake and he called her a slut and walked away. They haven't talked ever since, not even after John found out that he had made the mistake, because they both moved on. John's past with Amy came back to bite him in the ass. He finally realized the sayings were true. Assuming makes an ASS out of U and ME. Back then John was a jerk. He was mean and immature, but he truly changed and he wanted to prove it to Amy now more than ever.

John finally caught up with Amy. "Amy, I'm sorry." John said. Amy realized the voice that just spoke to her wasn't the same one she heard two years ago. It wasn't a voice of treason, it was a voice of sincerity. She turned around to see a handsome John. He was wearing a metallic blue shirt, which he obviously borrowed from Randy. For one, it smelled like Randy. Two, Amy saw Randy wear it before. And three, John hated shirts. Amy and John locked eyes. Amy took a step closer to John.

"Amy, I am so sorry! I was a bitch for no reason, please forgive me." John said softly. Amy took another step closer and kissed John. They stood there in the shitty rainy weather and locked lips while Randy and Trish were inside wondering.

(AT THE SAME TIME… BACK TO RANDY AND TRISH)

Randy and Trish were talking about John and Amy and whether or not they should still have dinner.

"Speaking of dates, where are your sister and Batista?" Randy asked.

"I don't know…" Trish replied as she searched around the restaurant with her eyes. Trish and Randy both saw the same thing and they were shocked. They had just seen a WWE submission match between Tess' tongue and Batista's tongue.

"Okaaaay! That's enough yum-yum for one day!" Trish said loud enough for them to hear as she pulled Tess off of Batista.

"HEY! We were ki-----." Tess started.

"Tongue wrestling!" Randy finished following with an eerie silence.

"Let's just order dinner." Batista broke the silence 2 minutes later. Before anyone can respond…

"That would be great!" Amy and John said in unison as they walked back into the restaurant holding hands.

(AFTER DINNER AT RANDY'S HOUSE IN ST. LOUIS, MISSOURI)

Randy, Trish, and the rest got changed and met up at Randy's house.

"I'm bored!" Randy yawned.

"Me, too!" John added.

"Me, three!" The rest yelled in unison.

"Let's play truth or dare." Trish said with a devious smile.

"Better than doing nothing!" Batista grunted.

The pen was spinning and it when it stopped it pointed at John, indicating john would go first.

"Okay John, truth or dare?" Tess asked.

"Truth!" John said confidently.

"Is it true, you fucked Trish?" Tess asked.

"Umm…Tess are you high? Trish and me only went out once and that was like a year ago."

"Just answer the question." Tess asked.

"No, we didn't have sex." John said. Right after John finished his statement, Trish started throwing pillows at her younger sister for asking such a question.

"I'M SORRY!" Tess screamed as Trish finally stopped.

"Anyway, let's go on with the game. Amy, truth or dare?" John asked hoping she'd say truth.

"Dare!" Amy said making herself loud and clear.

"Okay, I dare you to kiss a girl here." John stated out of frustration that she didn't pick truth. Amy moved over to Trish and kissed her. Trish wasn't really shocked because it was just a dare. Randy on the other hand thought he saw heaven, but this was nothing compared to what was coming for him. Randy started making "OOOOOOOOOOO" noises.

"Randy, truth or dare?" Amy asked.

"Dare." Randy said trying to impress Trish, but it didn't work to well.

"Randy, I dare you to kiss one of the guys." Amy told him. Randy started freaking out.

"Hell no!" Randy shot back.

"What's the matter, is Randall too scared." John made fun of Randy.

"Shut up! I hate being called Randall, if you say that again, you won't know what hit you!

"Say what, RANDALL!" John pushed Randy's buttons.

"That's it, you asked for it!" Randy somewhat yelled with his fists clenched. He went to give John a good punch right in the kisser, but he stopped as soon as he heard Trish's beautiful voice.

"Okay, that's not nice, How 'bout if you do this Amy, Tess, and I will walk around in our bras." Trish came to the aid of Randy. Before Trish had to ask twice, Randy jumped on John and kissed him.

"Now, show me what ya got bebes." Randy said with his infamous famous smirk. Trish was defeated. Trish pulled of her t-shirt, as did the other divas. Randy was now in heaven as he drooled at the image of Trish in her bra. Randy didn't even look at Amy and Tess. He just stared at Trish. John was staring at Amy and Batista didn't have a clue of what just happened, but he couldn't help but look at Tess with amazement. He loved Tess already and Tess loved him. They had clicked together within the second they met.

"Okay, I had enough of truth or dare, and I'm cold! Amy said as she put back on her t-shirt. Trish followed Amy's lead, as did Tess.

"No fair! I kissed that crackhead for nothing!" Randy whined.

"Who the fuck are you calling crackhead!" John shouted.

"You, you crackhead!" Randy shouted back. John started chasing Randy around the house as the rest of them laughed and giggled at both Randy and John's childish behavior.

"STOP!" Trish screamed after ten minutes. She was starting to get dizzy of watching John trying to catch Randy and missing.

"Let's watch a movie or something." Randy suggested still running from John.

"That sounds great!" Tess and Batista said in unison.

"Okay, what do you want to see?" Randy asked as he stopped to catch his breath. Randy's sudden stop surprised John. John couldn't stop and collided full speed with Randy. They both started moaning in pain. Trish just snickered at them as she helped Randy up. Amy helped John up.

"How about we watch "The Ring". I got the movie a couple days ago from my little bro for a present, but I haven't seen it yet. I really want to see it because I heard it was really good, but I don't know what it's about." Randy stated. Trish had already seen the movie, but she kept her mouth shut about it so the rest can enjoy it.

"Okay!" everyone agreed.

"They were watching the movie. John and Amy were hugging each other from fear. Tess was snug in Batista's arms. They were freaked out by the movie, but they concentrated more on each other. They were in LOVE! Towards the end of the movie, perhaps the last 15 minutes, Trish got up.

"I gotta go to the bathroom." Trish said as she ran off to the bathroom. Nobody answered her back as they all hugged each other and were shaking like crazy from fear of Samara. Samara was a scary individual especially when she comes to get you. (I won't spill the ending for those of you who haven't watched it! I can't wait 'til the second one comes out in 9 days!)

After the movie ended. Everyone stretched. And got up to clean up the popcorn on the floor. Just then… "Briing…Briiing…Briiiing!" The phone started to ring.

"AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH!" They all screamed except Randy.

"It's Samara! She's come to get us! Don't pick up the phone!" John screamed as he trembled.

"Geez, you've got to stop watching horror movies, calm down, it's probably my family or something!" Randy said to John as he went to pick up the phone.

"Hello." Randy spoke into the speaker.

"…" There was no answer.

"Hello!" Randy repeated.

"…" Again there was no answer.

"Okay, I'll just hang up then." Randy said, as he was about to hang up the phone.

"Seven Days…" said a calm, creepy voice. Everyone heard it and started to scream. Randy put the phone back to his ear to talk but then the phone hung up. Everyone started to murmur and freak out, especially John. Randy was freaked out himself.

"HAHAHAHA! I got all of you good!" Trish came back into the room holding her cell phone in her hand. Everyone was shocked.

One Second Later…

"I'M SORRY!" Trish screamed as she ran from an angry Randy, John, Amy, Tess, and Batista.

End of Chapter

Yay! I finished another chapter. I'm sorry I haven't updated in so long, but the month of March is a real annoying month for me. I have 5 huge ass projects. I got sliced in the throat so I'm recovering from that and I'm gonna find the bitch and her boyfriend that tried killing me and I'm gonna fuck them up. Anyway, Lita/Amy is your winner. I'll try updating soon but I'm not sure if I can.

I don't get how it goes with the chapter so I'd try to ignore it. I didn't want to delete that part because it would be wrong! LOL. I think I gave you guys a huge chapter. I hope you liked it!

rkofreak-04-Hi friend! LOL, Randy and John really do love each other. Anyway I hope you loved this chapter and we'll talk more online, that is if you ever go back online!

Mushroom-Normally I wouldn't mind if you criticized me, but fuck you! You don't have to shove it in my face that it sucks! I got four words for you bitch: Suck Rikishi's fat ASS!

OrtonCenaYJericho-I am so sorry Torrie didn't win, but I'll find a way to make it up to you, I promise! I hope you liked this chapter.

Ms. Cena RKO-Well here you go! Lita/Amy won and I hope you loved this chapter!

Trishrocks- Sorry, I have AOL. Update "Be with you" ASAP! Hope you liked this chapter!

StratusfyingOrton/Tess-Hey, my nagging you worked! You finally made the sequel to Not Like This! As a self-proclaimed #1 StratusfyingOrton fan I expect nothing but the best quality sequel from you. I hope you liked this chapter! Hey, who knows maybe we can do a joint fanfic or something in the future.

WWEchica-Hey Shannon! Thanks for the review! Hey I do have newfound respect for Randy. LOL. Anyway, I hope you like this chapter.

Livin in the Moment-Here's an update! I hope you like it!

TrishOrton-I hope you like this chapter! I'm sorry Stacy didn't win, but please don't stop reading because of that! Please! I hope you liked this chapter!

H-Kvss-Thanks for your critique, I appreciate it and I'm sorry you feel that way.

Perfect Imperfections-I'm sorry that Torrie didn't win. I hope you like this chapter!

Aph-Roh-You didn't offend me. I totally understand and people are entitled to their own opinions. Thanks for the review and I'm glad you thought it was good. You better update your stories fast or else you'll hear threatening mail from me! LOL. Kidding!

Shanesgurl-Thanks for your review, too. I won't send you scary death threats, but you'd better update soon, cuz I'm getting impatient and I'll send you death threat if you don't. LOL. I love your story too. It kicks ASS big time!

Here's the deal you review, I'll update. If the story is getting boring just let me know in the review and feel free to give me suggestions on where to take this story and they'll all be considered.