That evening, Lydia heard cries of, "Land ahoy!" from Gibbs. She went above deck to investigate. What she saw amazed her. Four islands, forming a perfect square, lay out before her. Each island was the same shape, and it looked like each one had the same landscape.

"Impossible," she muttered.

"No, it's not," Jack's voice startled her. "If it was impossible, then it wouldn't be here," continued, condescendingly. "We're sailing to the center of the islands. Then, with the medallion's help of course, we'll be able to see which island holds the treasure."

"Right," Lydia nodded in agreement, but her mind was elsewhere. She was thinking of how to get the necklace, and the treasure. She would have to steal it now, and keep it until dawn. When she knew where the treasure was, she could throw the necklace overboard. She would be the only one who knew where it was. She glanced around. Jack had gone off to help maneuver the ship in between the islands. No one was watching her, not even Will. She crept towards the Captain's cabin, undetected. She quickly opened the door, and slipped inside. She searched through his drawers, until she found it. She tucked it into her belt, and silently slid out of the room. She walked as nonchalantly as possible towards the sails, and helped Gibbs. By the time they had gotten directly in the center of the square, night had fallen.

"They should be arriving at any minute," Will told her. "You should go hide." Lydia sighed.

"Alright," she said and walked to her room. She sat thinking, I have to wait until dawn. Will they be too busy fighting to notice me? Jack will surely look for the necklace, but will he suspect me? Of course he will, she answered herself. But by then, it'll be too late. She fell into a light sleep, but was awoken by yells and screams. She opened the door an inch. There was fighting and yelling. It looked like Jack was fighting Eyeless Eddie, while the rest of her crew was defending the ship. She looked to the sky; it looked to be very early morning. She slithered out of her room and tiptoed towards the crow's nest. Nobody was watching her. She stealthily climbed up the pole, and hid in the basket. She could see the skirmish below. Jack was so engrossed in his battle with Eyeless Eddie; he didn't notice one of Eddie's henchmen sneak up behind him.

"Jack, behind you!" Lydia yelled. He looked behind him just in time to see the man pull a knife. Jack quickly slit his throat, and returned to fighting Eddie. But Lydia was in trouble. Her cry to Jack had brought attention to herself. Eyeless Eddie signaled to his men. They sprinted towards the crow's nest, and began climbing the post. Lydia searched herself for a knife, a weapon, anything, but came up empty-handed. "Damn it," she swore. She leaned over the railing. They were approaching all too quickly. She sat back against the pole, and waited for the first face to pop over the barrier. When it did, she was ready. She grabbed the knife out of his mouth, pulling out a few teeth in the process, and kicked him back over. There were five more men coming, who all had knives and pistols. Today is my lucky day, she thought. The second man to arrive was killed easily; he was unaware that she had a knife. She slit his throat, and he fell. The only problem with this was that it served as a warning to his fellow crew. The third man came up behind her and grabbed her. Lydia elbowed him in the stomach, and threw him out of the basket. The fourth and fifth man came from different sides, and ganged up on her. She twisted her body to miss a would-be-fatal stab from one of them. He got her arm instead. She ducked behind the other one, to use him as a shield. As the first one lunged, she pushed her shield into his knife, killing him instantly. All that was left was that one man. He had a sword, and a pistol. He pulled his sword, and Lydia knew she was in deep trouble. She hauled the dead man's sword out of its sheath and lunged. He blocked it, and then made his attack. It went on like this for some time, until Lydia realized that cheating was the only way to ensure victory. She lured him away from the corpse, and using the same maneuver she used on Jack the first night she met him, she tripped him. She slit his throat, not bothering to listen to his pleads.

She sank back against the railing and breathed heavily. She titled her head to the sky, and saw to her horror the sun peaking up on the horizon. She fumbled for the necklace, and stood up. Just as the sun's first ray was lighting up the sky, she held up the necklace. The result was a blinding light, and then sudden dark. She looked up and saw the light being harnessed by the hole in the medallion. It filtered through, and then pointed at the island to her left. The beam was directed at the exact center. And just as quickly as it came, the light vanished. The sun came up, and lit the ship below. There were bodies and blood everywhere. She tried to find Jack and Will among all the carnage. Suddenly she was grabbed around the waist from behind, and heaved over the side. Her captor was a big man from the crew of Eyeless Eddie. He carried her down the pole and dragged her in front of his captain. She looked up at Eddie; he had one patch over his eye. He was wearing an evil grin. In a moment of inspiration, she threw the medallion overboard. She heard the splash and was satisfied, now no one could ever find the treasure. Eddie slapped her, hard.

"Stupid girl!" he yelled. Then he smiled, that smile hurt more than his slap. "You will have to pay for that, with more than your life."