"When you were born Barbossa had no idea about you, so hid you for 2 years. Then when your sister was born, Barbossa found out about you. We were scared of what Barbossa was going to do. So when Barbossa made your father come back. Barbossa forced him to take one of you. We knew that if he brought you with him, they would kill you. So they had to make the hardest decision ever. Bill had to give you up, and Sara had to give up Clarésse. We knew that Barbossa would be less likely to her Clarésse."

"But what about the thing no one should have gone through?" Will asked.

Then Jack got the regretful look again.