"Dude is this you?" asks Dean "Dean! Yeah! Where the hell are you man?" "Um…I don't know..?" replies a stressed sounding Dean. "Ok, Jess said we are meeting up with you today, so we can talk then ok?" "Yeah ok…just hurry up! I'm freaking out! …Wait Jess is alive?" "Yeah! Isn't that great?" shouts Sam so loud that Dean jerks his head away from the phone "Yeah I'm happy for ya Sammy, now get here!" Shouts Dean, even louder. Dean hangs up the phone and soon notices a figure standing in the hallway. "Was that Sammy?" questions the girl "Oh…um…yeah…sweetie?" jokes Dean "Its Hope to you! …Honey" Dean just smiles and then looks out the window, waiting for Sam's car to pull up in his? Driveway. The he sees a sight that warms his heart
"The car!" squeals Dean as he runs out into the driveway and starts hugging the beautiful piece of metal. Hope follows him and just stands in the front door of the house laughing at him "Boys and their toys" she giggles "You remember how we used this as our just married car?" asks Hope. Dean let's go of the car and just stares blankly at her, like he just saw a ghost "….just…married..?" He then looks at his hand and sees a ring on it. He feels like he is going to faint and thinks to himself "How much did I drink?"
All the sudden Sam's car comes turning into the driveway. Jess is driving because Sam has no idea where he is either. Sam hops out of the car and Dean turns around and walks towards him and shouts "What the hell is going on?" "According to Jess I am here to celebrate you kids birthday" jokes Sam. "Dude not cool!" yells Dean as he slaps Sam in the back of the head. "So as soon as your mum and dad get here, we can start the barbeque" says Hope as Jess and she move inside. "Man at least my baby is still here" says Dean, patting the car and trying to calm himself down. "Wait did your…wife, just say mum and dad?" asks Sam softly. "Ok this isn't real…wait! That creature! Doesn't it put its victims in an alternative reality? Maybe that's what its doing to us?" expresses Dean. "So…Jess isn't alive?" "Sorry man, but I think this is all fake" "It can't be! Everything seems so real, he touch and smell. Maybe where we were before wasn't real!" shouts Sam "Oh yeah! Sure! The last 27 years of my life has been a dream! That we both had...I wish!" There is a silence for a moment and then Sam begins "I…just wish she was alive" "I know Sammy and I wish mum were alive too, but they aren't…and we just have each other. So let's find a way to get out of here." Says Dean.
"But I mean, is it so bad living here. We aren't hurting anyone; no one would be looking for us." Says Sam "Dude! Don't say that! This isn't natural and plus it is going to drain us until we just …die" Before Sam can respond another car pulls up into the driveway. They can't make out their faces until they both get out of the car; it's their dad…and mum. "Hey! There's the dad" says Mary as she moves her way to hug her boys. "…mum?" Dean says, stunned. "Hey Dean and Sam, how are you guys" Sam just looks at his dad, very confused to see his dad so at ease. "Um…hey dad, I'm great thanks" replies a confused yet happy Sam.
Dean is looking at his mum like a little kid; well I guess he doesn't know how to look at her because he has only seen her as a little kid. "M...u...m?" "Yeah what is it honey" "I missed you… you to dad" Sam just stands there enjoying the family being together again, until he realizes that it isn't real. He shakes his head and grabs Dean "just head on inside you guys, Dean and I need to talk for a sec" "Ok, but Dean probably wants to show of his bravery award too" says Mary. Dean just smiles at his mum not wanting to leave, but Sam is slowly dragging him away. "That…was…mum" "No it wasn't Dean…" replies Sam "But…the family, we are all together" pleads Dean. "Common Dean, remember this isn't real". Dean's face goes pail and begins "Your right…sorry dude, I got a little carried away for a second" They head inside and begin the barbeque.
"Hey….Hope? Can Sammy and Jess stay over?" asks Dean "Sure why not, since when were you one to ask permission?" jokes Hope. Dean once more smiles at her joke and Sam sees the smile. "Well me and Sammy are going to throw the football around outside for a while you girls do what you do" jokes Dean "Like what? Cleaning and cooking?" teases Hope "Sure!" "Dean I would shut up before you get a bitch slap" replies Sam "How many times have I beat you in foosball? I'm sorry I forgot" Hope says sarcastically.
Dean now sick and tired I being told in front of his brother heads into the backyard, dragging Sam behind him. "Ok so when we were reading about the biubdigfl… did it say anything about a way for the victim to get out of the fake universe?" questions Dean "No, that's the thing. Its victims maybe don't necessarily want to get out. I mean think about it, all the victims had lost someone important to them. In this world they are all alive again….just like mum and Jess" replies Sam "So what, you think there is no way of getting out of here? That's real positive Sammy" "it's Sam and it's not that there isn't a way out…its juts we have no idea how, that's all" says Sam "Oh…that's all!" replies Dean sarcastically "Common, lets hit the library" "better tell you wife" jokes Sam "Shut up! Or I will set her on you!" replies Dean.
"Did I hear correctly? Dean wants to go to the library?" teases Hope, Sam just stands there laughing quietly "Yeah, I'm going to help Sam with a Uni Assignment" "Oh ok, just remember you have to go to work this afternoon" "Work?" Sam and Dean both ask simultaneously "um yeah..? The fire station called and wants you in this afternoon…Dean? What's gotten into you?" questions Hope "Oh um nothing… we wont be long, cya" says Dean as he rushes out the door with Sam.