A/N: Hello everyone and Happy New Years! We are finally done with 2020 and I hope that 2021 is better for everyone. I am very sorry for anyone that lost a loved one from COVID-19. I hope this year is filled with blessings and financial favor. On to the story, this is one kind of long its around 5000 + words. I hope you all like the chapter update. I am very sorry for making everyone wait so long. Thank you all for being patient. Here is what we have all been waiting for. Please Read and Review. Until Next Time Please Enjoy!
Chapter # 16
~ The Next Day ~
~ Rachel's P.O.V ~
I hope that Kurt and Finn are home as I approached Finn's house. I walked up and knocked on the door and Carol answered.
"Hey so are Finn and Kurt home?" I asked.
"Yeah, they're home why do you ask?" Carol said.
"I asked because I would like to invite them for lunch, so we can end this tension between us on a friendly note. We're graduating next month and I'm leaving for New York right after and I don't want to harbor bad feeling towards them. I want to part ways not necessarily with us been friends but also not as enemies." I said sweetly, not meaning one word I just said, I want to and will be leaving with them dead!
"That's big of you, um, one second, please." Carol said.
"No problem."
"Hey, Finn and Kurt, come down here, please." Carol called them down. Finn and Kurt came downstairs with a confused look on their faces.
"Why are you here?" Finn asks. I resist the urge to roll my eyes.
"Listen, what you guys did wasn't okay, you got Santana and her dad arrested on charges that weren't true, which is why they were released. You outed Quinn to her father because didn't want to be with you anymore. You and Kurt, outed Santana to the entire state and I'm clueless as to why? She's another gay person, Kurt. How could do that to another person, knowing what you went through at the same school? That just wasn't cool, but I want to put that behind us. When I leave for New York, I don't want to part on bad terms. I would like to buy you guys lunch and we say goodbye formally." I said.
"I don't trust you." Kurt said and you're right not too.
"Okay, well I thought we could have lunch but never mind, have a great life." I turned around and walked back to my car when I heard Finn say something. Always the dumb ass, oh how I love it. I swipe the smirk off my face, then turn around to face them again.
"Wait, I want to go with you." Finn said.
"You cannot trust her, Finn." Kurt said. Listen to him, Finn, he's telling the truth.
"It's just lunch, bro, chill." Finn said.
"Okay then." Kurt said giving in. Kurt, this is why you're going to die right along with Finn. You don't have a backbone, bro.
Finn and Kurt got into my car and I drove us to Subway and while I was doing that, Dave wrote a convincing suicide note explaining why Finn killed Kurt then himself, stating all the shit he did from outing Quinn to losing Rachel to getting Santana arrested.
From: Davy
"It all ready."
To: Davy
"Taking the targets out to lunch now."
From: Quinn
"Weapons checked, ready and packed."
To: Quinn
"Good Job."
From: Babe
"Safe house is ready."
Great, we don't need to be killing them out in the open.
"Subway okay with you guys?" I asked and Kurt looked up from his phone.
"Yeah, that's cool." Kurt said, looking back down at his phone.
"Finn?" I asked.
"Yeah, it's cool with me."
"Great." I said driving to Subway.
~ Kurt's P.O.V ~
This bitch is setting us up, I know it. After everything we did to her, she just wants to forgive and forget. No, I'm not buying it. What we need to do is kidnap Rachel and Santana and kill them. They are causing way too many problems. Rachel was right about one thing; we are graduation next month and the only way we can move on is with them dead!
To: Finn
"Bro we have to take them out. Santana and Rachel have got to go."
From: Finn
"What do you mean take out? You want us to kill them?"
To: Finn
"Yes, that's exactly what I'm saying."
From: Finn
"Okay I understand and I'm with you. I was thinking the same thing."
To: Finn
"Why did we agree to this lunch? This could be a setup, you know?"
From: Finn
"We are going to make nice with them, that's it."
To: Finn
"I see then we hit them, they least expect it."
From: Finn
"Correct!"
To: Finn
"How we gone do it?"
From: Finn
"We just gone catch them off guard, when they alone and just shoot them."
To: Finn
"Seems kind of messy."
From: Finn
"So, what! That's how we gone do it! Friday night.
To: Finn
"No, it's not how we gone do it, that's how we end up in prison."
From: Finn
"Listen, my guy, you talking to me the way you do, and I promise you'll won't live to see tomorrow."
To: Finn
"Whatever."
~ Rachel's P.O.V ~
Okay, so we finally arrived at Subway. We all got out the car and went to the restaurant. They must think it was a setup or something, by the way they keep looking around. Boys, you have no idea what's in store for you.
"Let's go get some food, I'm super hungry." I walked into Subway and ordered my sandwich, waited for them to order their food, paid for it, then we sat down at a table and talked.
"So, how's the sandwiches? I love Subway, they know just how to make my sandwich." I said, taking a bite of my sandwich. Kurt and Finn dropped their sandwiches on the table.
"I knew this was a setup! Did you poison these sandwiches?" Kurt said, jumping up from the table, and now everyone is looking at us.
"How could I? You made you're own sandwich, this is Subway you know. Now would you have a fucking seat, you're being hella weird bro chill. I'm trying to be nice here and treat you out to lunch when, in reality, I should still kick your fucking ass for what you and Finn did. But I'm trying to move on. I start my new life in New York with friends and girlfriend next month and it doesn't include you, Finn, or this horrible fucking town." I said getting pissed, Finn has a smirk on his face, as if saying he knows something I don't. He better not be planning anything, then again it doesn't matter they are since they are about to die anyway.
"Kurt, sit down and relax bro." Finn said in a calm yet creepy tone, but Kurt did as he was told. We finished our lunch and once it was over, we threw the trash away and I dropped them back off at home. The sedative will take about an hour to work and it last for a few hours, so that's good.
~ Santana's P.O.V ~
~ Later That Same Evening ~
It's 7:30 pm and I'm doing the meeting this time as I begin to talk, everyone gives me their attention.
"Okay, it's very simple Rachel gave them a sedative that will put them to sleep. She had our friend at Subway do it. So, they should be sleep when we get there. If they aren't, then we knock them out. We will take them to the safe house on Mount Portland. It's a 2-hour drive from here. Quinn and Brittany aren't here at the meeting, because they are there already making sure everything thing happens according to plan."
"How do we do it?" Puck asked.
"When we arrive, we go to the back and pick the back-door locks. Dave and Puck will take Finn and Rachel and I will take Kurt. Mike will be in the van ready to go." I said, and Puck nodded his head in agreement.
"Okay, now you said we knock them out if they are up, but how?" Puck asked.
"With these tranquilizers 22 handguns. I picked these up today, whoever is up, we shoot them, watch them fall asleep, remove the dart, and continue. I wish we would have gotten these for our previous mission, that would have saved so many lives. That rescue mission went horribly, but this time we are doing it right."
"So, shoot them with the darts, they fall into a deep sleep if the sedative wore off. Then we remove the darts and proceed with taking Finn and Kurt. What about their phones?" Puck asked.
"We leave them." Rachel said.
"I think we should take them." Dave said.
"Why?" I asked.
"This is a murder/suicide, right? Plus, Finn isn't smart, remember? He would take his phone with him. Now that I'm thinking about it, we could leave Kurt's phone. Kind of like he lured Kurt to the woods and killed him." Dave said, and I must admit that sounds better than what I was thinking of just breaking the phones.
"That makes sense and make sure the tracker is on, so when the police look for them, they can track them to the woods. But remember to turn off Finn's phone first until we kill them." I said.
"Also, on the way to Subway earlier, they were texting each about something. So, we have to check and erase any messages about us, or them fearing it could be a setup." Rachel said.
"Agreed." I said.
"How gruesome is this going to be?" Dave asked.
"No too much, remember we want this to be believable. So, I say we will beat up Kurt, then stab him multiple times, then we shoot him in the head. We rip Finn's clothes, break his nose, and bust his lip. We put Kurt's blood all over him and we take Kurt's hand, scratch Finn's face to have Finn's DNA under the fingertips. We have to make it seem like Kurt put up a fight. They will find the bodies, do an investigation, and discover that Finn has a violent past, that he's homophobic and they will ask us questions, which we will agree to because we were victims of bullying. They will rule this a murder/suicide and close the case." I told everyone.
"How can you be so sure? What about tire tracks, footprints? The temperature of the body? Anything could go wrong." Dave said, and that's a damn good question, I didn't think of that and then look at Puck.
"Puck, you're the same size as Finn, you wear his clothes and shoes while Rachel will wear Kurt's shoes. Puck, you will drive Finn's car to the woods. Then once they are dead, we switch the shoes from they are currently wearing to the shoes Puck and Rachel put on. Puck and Rachel will put covers on their feet and walk back to our van, then we will get on the road and leave." I said.
"Okay let's go do this." Dave said.
"Here's the dart gun, please don't play with them or touch them. They are powerful, one touch and you're out like a light." I look at Puck, who was looking at his gun.
"Got it." Puck said, putting his dart gun in the back of his pants. We all leave the house and get into the unmarked van; Mike gets the address from Rachel and drives us over to Finn's house. I look in the window and see that Burt and Carol are watching tv in the living room with the window open.
Rachel, Dave, Puck, and I go around back and pick the lock and quietly open the door. We sneak in and hide as we make it to the living room, Rachel shoots Burt and I shoot Carol in the back of the head at the same time. They both fall into a deep sleep. We remove the darts, then headed upstairs. Once we get to Kurt's room, we look inside and Kurt's in his room on his phone and we look across the hall and see that Finn is still sleeping, because of his door open. Rachel and I enter Kurt's room and shoot him before he can say anything. As Puck and Dave enter Finn's room and grab him. Puck puts on Finn's clothes and shoes and puts his in the bag.
They carried Finn out of the room, down the stairs, out the back door and into the waiting van. Once Kurt was out, he drops his phone on his bed. Rachel puts his shoes on, and we put hers in a bag, then Rachel and I carry Kurt out the room, down the stairs, out the back door and into the van. I ran back upstairs and put gloves on and place the suicide/confession letter on Finn's bed. Then as I was about to leave the room, out the corner of my eye, I see a notebook and the floor near his bed. I pick it up and read it. It has details of how they were going to kill Rachel and I. Then I saw a pen and added some details about wanting to kill Kurt because he knew too much and how he was a wimp and would have eventually turned him in. Finn's handwriting matched my own, so I felt comfortable adding some things. Finn could have been something instead of a dick head about to be killed. I sat the journal back where it was and the pen next to it.
"Oh Finn, Finn, Finn, you made my job so easy." I say in my head, as I leave the room and head to Kurt's room and pick up his phone…Shit, we don't know his password. I see the home screen and left out a sigh of relief.
"Thank God he didn't put a passcode on his phone, or we would have been fucked." I see the messages from Finn and erase all the messages but the last one, of Finn saying Kurt won't live to see tomorrow and he was correct. I placed the phone back on the bed and ran back downstairs, out the back door, locking and closing it behind me, then I jumped into the van and Mike took off towards the safe house.
~ 2 Hours Later ~
~ General P.O.V ~
The crew arrived at the safe house, which is just about 3 miles from the woods. Santana threw some cold water on Finn and Kurt, and they finally woke up to realize they are strapped to chairs in an old house.
"Where am I?" Kurt asks.
"The last place you will ever see." Santana told him, coming out of the dark.
"What's going on here?" Finn asked.
"It's time to the end of all this bullshit. That's what's going on." Rachel said, coming out of the dark.
"End what?" Finn asked, noticing that his hands were free. He slipped his hands in his pocket and took out his phone, pressing the side button that automatically records memo's. Puck heard the beep and laughed, went behind Finn, and took his phone and deleted the recording. Finn gave Kurt a look and Kurt started patting himself down as Puck hands Finn's phone to me.
"You thought you could record us, and we wouldn't know? Come on dumbass, we know better than that." Puck said.
"You left your phone, if that's what you're were searching for." Santana told him as she secretly called Kurt's phone, knowing Finn was going to say some crazy shit. She called, and it went straight to voicemail. When Finn opened his mouth, the voicemail got it all.
"You think having me beat up, will save you, trust me when I get my hands on you, you will regret the day you met me. I'm going to fucking kill you. You hear me bitch!" Finn angrily shouted as Santana pressed end call and made should the call was ended.
"Thank you for leaving that very threatening message on Kurt's phone. It will further prove that you killed him. Also, message of you saying earlier that Kurt will not live to see tomorrow. Harsh buddy." Kurt swallowed hard.
"What, you shallowing hard for Kurt? You're the one that said we had to go, right? That we are causing too much of a problem, right? You and Finn wanted to kidnap Rachel and I and kill us, right? You probably were going to have Finn try to rape us too, huh, you sick, demented asshole? Well guess what, you're a little too late to the murder game." Santana looked at the Finn's phone again and went the text message screen and deleted all but the last message, turned Finn's phone off and placed it on the table.
Puck walked over to Kurt with his black gloves on and punched him in face, blood poured from his nose and lip. Puck kept punching him, gave him a two black eyes. One was almost shut. Dave ripped at Finn's shirt, punched Finn in the nose and jaw. Hit him over the head so the side of his head was bleeding. Puck stabbed Kurt multiple times in his stomach and chest. Then shot him in the head. Kurt was dead and Finn looked at his dead brother and said,
"IM GOING TO KILL YOU BITCHES! YOU KILLED MY BROTHER!" Finn shouted.
"No, you killed your brother and felt so sorry about it, that you killed yourself." Finn sat there wide eyed as Rachel pointed the gun at his head.
"You're not going to kill me, you're too weak! Give the gun Santana, you will be nothing but second best, Santana's bitch!" Rachel pulled the trigger and shout Finn in the head with a dart. Finn was out. Dave and Puck packed up Kurt's dead body and Finn's unconscious body in black bags and toss them in the van. Quinn, Brittany, Dave, and Santana drove to the drop off point in the wood and unloaded the bodies. Rachel and Puck drove Finn's car to the drop off near the streets. Rachel and Puck walked to where the bodies were.
Rachel still with her gloves on, she put the silencer on the gun with the scratched off serial number, then walked over to the unconscious Finn, opened his mouth, put the gun inside and pulled the trigger. His brains splattered all over the rocks, leaves and shit. It's safe to say Finn is now dead. Puck grabbed an already dead Kurt and stabbed him a few more times to draw out fresh blood, then grabbed Kurt's hand and scratching along Finn's face. Got to make it seem like a struggle. Rachel places the gun in Finn's hands. She rubbed his hands all over the gun and knife. Rachel made sure that Finn's prints were good on the murder weapons.
Rachel and Puck took off Finn and Kurt's shoes, put them on the dead bodies, after they slipped their shoes back on with the plastic shoe covers already attached. Rachel and Puck bagged the shoes the boys had on. Santana turned Finn's phone back on and placed it in his pocket. They left and got back in the van where Mike was waiting. Mike left the scene and Santana called her auntie to make sure the safe house was taken care of and no traces of them were left anywhere. On the way home, Mike noticed everyone looked out of it.
~ Rachel's P.O.V ~
"Let's talk guys, what's everyone feeling?" I asked, as Mike got back on the main road and drove us home.
"He was an asshole, but I grew up with him. I don't know when he turned into someone so fucking evil." Puck said, crying a little, quickly wiping his face.
"I know what you mean. We played Peewee Football, Middle School, and 3 years of High School Football together. He went from a happy, clumsy guy to this guy that was out to destroy lives." Dave said.
"Was you telling the truth about Finn wanting to kill us?" I asked Santana.
"Yeah, I saw it in a journal on the floor near his bed like almost under it. I read it and it said he would kidnap us and kill us. You were right, Kurt and Finn were texting about us, so I deleted all the messages except the last one from Kurt's phone at his house and Finn's phones at the drop off." I told her.
"Damn, you never know how crazy someone is in the head." I said, and I received text message from Santana's auntie, Santana was also added to the message.
From: Adrianna
"All done, you guys okay?"
From: Santana to Adrianna
"We are talking about it now, auntie, but I'm doing okay."
To: Adrianna
"I'm doing okay as well, thanks."
From: Adrianna
"Okay, you girls call me if you need me, love you guys."
To: Adrianna from Santana
"Love you too auntie, I'll call you later."
To: Adrianna
"Love you too, Anna."
From: Adrianna
"Okay, ttyl."
We get home and one by one we jump in the shower and try to scrub this murder off us. We go out to the shed to dismantle the weapons and placed them in their correct cases before putting them up. Santana washed all the clothes we were wearing, dried them, and put them up. Quinn and Brittany left to go home as showing and changing back into fresh clothes. Dave and Puck took the guess rooms while Santana and I watched some Netflix and then went to sleep. It was a long ass night, and I was beyond tired.
~ The Next Day ~
~ General P.O.V ~
Carl Hudson and her husband Burt woke up from the couch hours later and went to their bedroom. The next morning around 7:00 am, Carol walked into Finn's room to wake him up for school and noticed he wasn't there, so she checked Kurt's room and he wasn't there either. She doubled backed to Finn's room and picked up the letter laying on his bed.
"Dear Mom and Burt,
I'm writing you this letter because I cannot bring myself to tell you what I did. I am so ashamed, and I cannot believe I became this person. I have been drinking and fighting a lot. I slept with multiple girls and didn't care about any of them.
When Rachel and Quinn came out the closet as gay, I lost it. They were my safety net. Quinn fell for Brittany, and Rachel fell for Santana. Me and Kurt outed Quinn to her father, who kicked Quinn out, and I didn't care. Me and Kurt got Santana's dad arrested for being a drug dealer. I tried to get Santana, but she only spent a day in jail and that's it. So, I knew I had to step it up, so I had Kurt out Santana to the entire school. It was supposed to be just the school, not the entire state
But I didn't care what happened to her, she stole my woman. This is only going to end one way, I'm going to kill myself and maybe Kurt, I haven't decided yet, but I feel like Kurt knows too much. It's time to put an end to all this pain and anger once and for all. By the time you read this, I will be dead and maybe Kurt too. I am sorry for not being the son you wanted.
Love Finn." Carol dropped the paper and screamed, causing Burt to run into the room.
"What's wrong?" Burt asked, concerned.
"Finn killed himself and maybe Kurt." Carol said.
"What?" Burt said, as Carol picked up the paper from the floor and handed it to him. Burt read it, dropped the paper, ran back to his room, and ran back with his phone.
"Hey, this is Kurt's phone, leave me a message." Burt ran across to Kurt's room and seen his phone his bed. Kurt never put a passcode on his phone.
"He left his phone, wait one new message." Burt put in Kurt's birth year into the voicemail password. Finn's voice filled the room.
"You think having me beat up, will save you, trust me when I get my hands on you, you will regret the day you met me. I am going to fucking kill you! Do you hear me, bitch!" Burt dropped Kurt's phone on the floor.
"He killed my son; he killed my son!" Burt said outraged as he kicked the chair need the door.
"Listen to me, Finn didn't do this. Finn didn't even write that letter. He is being setup. That Rachel girl was here yesterday talking about making up and shit. I bet it was her." Carol told Burt.
"You think so, he sounded angry." Burt said.
"I'm telling you, it's Rachel." Carol said as she called the police and they showed up 10 minutes later.
"Tell me again what happened?" The officer asked.
"This girl Rachel Berry left my son Finn for another girl named Santana Lopez. She came by here yesterday and took my sons Finn and Kurt to lunch to put all the horrible stuff they have done to her behind her. They came home and went straight to sleep. Then my husband and I were walking a movie and then fell asleep. I woke up to find this letter." Carol hands the letter to the officer. The officer reads it.
"I'm so sorry for your loss, but it seems like he committed a murder/suicide. Your son Finn killed his brother, then himself." The officer said putting the letter in his notepad.
"My son isn't that smart to form words and thoughts like what's on this letter. No, Rachel wrote it before she killed my kids." Carol said.
"Does either of your sons have a tracker on their phones? Like find my iPhone or find my friends?" The officer asked.
"Yes, I use it often to make sure they are really at school. I know Finn used to skip, but since I installed find my friends on his phone, he's been at school the whole time every day. I just know that my son wouldn't write that." Carol said.
"Kurt's phone is here." Burt said.
"It's a message on there that's doesn't sound like he was talking to my son Kurt, here listen." Burt said and played it for the officer.
"You think having me beat up, will save you, trust me when I get my hands on you, you're going to regret that you met me. I going to fucking kill you. You hear me bitch!" Recording ended.
"I will need that phone please, one second." The officer went to his car and got a clear evidence bag and walked back to the house and noticed one new message on Kurt's phone and opened it up and read it out loud.
From: Finn
"You keep talking to me the way you are and you will not see tomorrow." The officer finished, then placed the phone in the bag and closed it.
"Ma'am I am very sorry, if your children are deceased then this is looking more and more like a murder/suicide."
"Just look into it please, I know my boy wouldn't do this."
"Okay, I'll see about getting a warrant to bring Rachel in for questioning, but first please track your son.
"That's all I ask." Carol said as she tracked Finn's phone and it said was at Old Forrest RD 2 hour and 10 minutes away.
"Thank you." The officer said and made his way out the door.
"Let's go." Carol said, walking to the door as well.
"No, ma'am you cannot go." The officer to her.
"Finn is my only son, and Kurt is my son through marriage, and I love him just the same, but Finn… I gave birth to him. You cannot tell me I can't come along." Carol said with conviction.
"Okay, let's go." The officer said as Carol, Burt and the officer drove to where the GPS took them to where Finn's phone was.
~ 2 Hours and 10 minutes ~
The officer got out the car and seen mustang convertible parked on the side of the road.
"Ma'am does this car belong to either of your kids?" The officer asked.
"Yes, that's Finn's car. I gave it to as an early graduation present for finishing high school." Burt answered for Carol. The officer wrote down the license of the car down and continued to walk to the location, which was through the woods when he spotted two deceased male teenagers. The officer looked down and shook his head, then turned to Carol and Burt, who were waiting near the car.
"Ma'am are those your kids?" The officer yelled out as Carol and Burt followed to where the officer was, and they could not believe their eyes. Carol screamed so loud as she tried to go over to them, but Burt held her back.
"NOOOOO MY BABY! LET ME GO BURT!" Carol screamed and cried, and he held onto her, crying his eyes out. Burt looked at his lifeless son on ground beaten with stab wounds on him. The officer took their reaction as confirmation of the bodies.
"This is Officer Morrison, I need 2 coroner trucks, I have 2 deceased males, white young around high school age at Old Forest RD on Route 64 North." Officer Morrison said on the radio.
"Sending now." A person responded.
They waited until everyone arrived and got started. Multiple people were there: Detectives, medical examiners, CSI, and corners. Detectives spoke to Burt and Carol. CSI agents took a bunch of pictures. Pictures of the bodies, the weapons, the phone was removed from Finn's pocket handed to Officer Morrison as he asked to see it before it was placed in the bag. Finn's phone also didn't have a passcode. He went to the text messages, and the message was there. The same one on Kurt's phone matching the same date and time exactly. Officer Morrison shook his head again as he knew it was Murder/Suicide but needed more proof. He handed the phone back to the CSI agent that placed it in the bag and finished collecting the other weapons and any other evidence he could find. The coroners removed the bodies as the cops taped off the area as an active crime scene. Finn's car was towed to the police station impound lot.
~ One Week Later ~
Officer Morrison and another officer knocked on Antonio's door and a guard answered.
"What can I help you with?"
"I need to speak with Mr. Lopez." Upon hearing his name as he was headed to the kitchen for a drink, he turned and walked to the door.
"Yes, officer?" Antonio asked.
"I have a warrant for the arrest of Rachel Berry in the connection to the murder/suicide of Finn Hudson and Kurt Hummel. We have some questions for her." Officer Morrison said as Santana and Rachel pulled up to the house. They got out the car. Officer Morrison said.
"Which one of you is Rachel Berry?" Officer Morrison asked.
A/N: Hey everyone thanks for reading this chapter. I hope you all liked it. If many people respond with different ways Kurt and Finn could have been killed, I may consider rewriting the death scene. But in all fairness, I need ask everyone to give me their thoughts on how the boys should die and I did not get many responses back, so if you think it could be better, then please leave a review and let me know. Remember to be constructive. I am always willing to listen to anyone if you are respectful. On to the questions: What to you think will happen to Rachel? How do think this story will end? What do you want to see happen next? Will Rachel see any jail time if so, how much? Do you think anyone will die or should die?