Lorelai, Tomas, and Tina had gotten on Bonnie's ship thanks to Kiko, Santiago's small pet frog, using his tongue to latch onto it, and the loyal crew swung onto it using a rope...
Lorelai: Well, Bonnie, it looks like you're still causing trouble on the holidays!
Bonnie: You're certainly not getting this treasure back, ye scallywags! Butterscotch! (The crow flew around the duo, distracting them)
Tomas: (nervously) What are we going to do?
Lorelai: I think I know what to do...
Lorelai then used her mermaid powers to call out to the sea animals for help. Many fish came, and after Lorelai told them what to do, they distracted bonnie by splashing her with water, and continued doing it by leaping out of the sea and back, splashing her all around her ship...
Bonnie: Arrgh! I'm getting all wet!
At the critters of the sea continued to splash the wicked pirate girl, Tomas and Lorelai walked over to the cage to lift it up, and Santiago got out of the cage, with Tina holding to his arm, to check if he was okay.
Santiago: Gracias, (thank you) mateys!
Tomas/Lorelai/Tina: De nada! (You're welcome)
Santiago: Now, let's get back that treasure!
As Bonnie was recovering after being splashed, Santiago and his crew got the treasure, and swung back to El Bravo. When she fully recovered, she saw Santiago and his loyal crew were also holding the big treasure chest, on their ship.
Lorelai: Sorry, Bonnie, but this treasure is going back to the people of Isla Encanto.
Bonnie: (angrily stomps her foot) Arrgh, hornswoggle! You goody-good pirates ruin everything!
As Bonnie and Sir Butterscotch sailed away, Santiago, Tomas, Lorelai, and Tina were celebrating that they got the treasure back...
Tomas: (excited) Whoo! Yeah, we did it!
Lorelai: Now the people of Isla Encanto will have a great Christmas.
However, Santiago was thinking about Bonnie's current situation...
Santiago: (has a sad look) Yeah, but there's one pirate who isn't going to have one. And it's not just because we took the treasure chest back.
Lorelai thought for a bit, before she replied, 'Wait, are you referring to Bonnie?'
Tomas: But she just tried to take the village's treasure for herself!
Santiago: Not exactly. Let me explain to you what I discovered...
Santiago told Tomas, Lorelai, and Tina about what had happened from his encounter with Bonnie, and after he told his story, everyone was crestfallen...
Tomas: Whoa, I had no idea Bonnie could genuinely love other people.
Lorelai: Who knew that bad pirates sometimes do gave a heart of gold?
Tina: I don't believe this. What are we going to do now, Santi?
Santiago: Prima, (cousin) can you find out where Bonnie's family lives?
Tina: (salutes Santiago) Aye, aye, captian! (captain)
Santiago: Tomas, could you and Lorelai sail El Bravo back to Isla Encanto, and bring the treasure back there?
Tomas: We certainly can, but what are you guys going to do?
Santiago: Me and Tina will go to the place where Bonnie's family is, and convince them to reunite with her Christmas, because... (turns around to Tomas, Lorelai, and Tina, who got the message...)
Santiago, Tomas, Lorelai, and Tina: Good pirates always do was right!
After Tina did some research on her submarine, which was right by the ship, she came back on El Bravo to tell the pirate crew some important stuff...
Tina: Good news, everyone. I located where Bonnie's family lives, and it's not too far from here.
Santiago: That's fantastico, (fantastic) prima!
Tomas: (hesitant) Uh, is there an obstacle here?
Tina: (sighs) Si, Tomas. I found out that island is called Bandit Island!
Tomas: So, this means... that whole island is bad news for good pirates!
Lorelai: Santi, are you and Tina willing to go alone? If you want, me and Tomas can come along. (Lorelai had a confident look, while Tomas shivered inside)
Tina: Not to worry, Lorelai. (holds out 2 bandit outfits) I got a few disguises so me and Santi would fit right in.
Santiago: Brillant plan, Tina! (turns to Tomas and Lorelai) You two bring the treasure chest back to Mami, while we talk with Bonnie's family.
Tomas: We're on it!
Lorelai: Let's go!
Tomas, with Lorelai, sailed El Bravo back to Isla Encanto, while Santiago and Tina went into the submarine, to go to the island where the bandits resided. Tomas and Lorelai, after a while of sailing, made it back to Isla Encanto to give the big treasure chest to Josefina. she was happy that Tomas and Lorelai got the chest back, but she also realized something else...
Josefina: Thanks for getting the treasure back from Bonnie, but where's Santiago?
Lorelai smiled, and answered, 'Oh, he and Tina are out on an adventure of their own.' And she was right, as the submarine with Tina and Santiago was just approaching Bandit Island...
