:That One Night:


Summary: It was supposed to be just one night. Girl meets boy, boy meets girl at a club, establish some type of connection before taking things to the next level only to never see each other again. Ever. But for Bonnie and Stefan, sometimes traditions break especially when there's a baby involved.

(Written June 2015)


A/N: This story is similar to "Last Night" but I write the characters a little differently. Enjoy!


Stefan watched her lay horizontally on the bed propping herself up on her forearms looking into his eyes. He raked his eyes down her body then stepped between her legs grabbing her left thigh in his hand and smirking. Stefan leans down connecting their lips running his hands up her dress not surprised at all that she wasn't wearing any underwear.

She gasped in his mouth as he entered a finger then another getting her ready for him. Her legs wrap around his waist forcing him closer and he frees his fingers as she works on his belt. His cellphone buzzes and he thinks about ignoring it but instead, he pulls away reaching in his back pocket.

"I'm hungry." The woman on the other line says before he could even speak.

"Well get something to eat."

"Can you get it for me? It's late and what if something…bad happens."

Stefan let out a ragged breath then looked down at the redhead on the bed. "What do you want?"

She smiled. "I'm really craving some curly fries and- and a burger. With extra cheese and pickles."

"Give me twenty minutes." He ends the call then kisses the girl on the mouth. "I'm sorry, Jessica, but I have somewhere to be."

"Let me guess, you have a girlfriend."

"No, actually I don't, but she's sort of carrying my child so…"

She scoffed. "Men are such pigs."

He was going to comment but decided otherwise and left. Jessica folded her arms under her chest as the door closed then gasped quickly getting up remembering that he drove her to a hotel. She tried calling after him and she knew that he heard her but he had kept going. Jessica grunted then went back only to realize that she couldn't get in because she didn't have a key. She banged on the door in frustration then started walking to the lobby to see if she could get an extra key.


Bonnie opened the door and smiled seeing him with a bag in his hand then quickly reached for it only to frown when he pulled it out of her reach.

"I don't enjoy you calling me this late."

"You said to call whenever I needed anything and I need my food." She reached for it again but he pulled the bag back.

"I think we need to establish some rules."

"Ugh, Stefan just give me my food!"

He chuckled then handed her the bag to which she looked inside of then slammed the door in his face once she saw that he got the right order. Bonnie headed upstairs after pouring herself some orange juice and sat on her bed.

The first bite was heaven and every bite after that seemed to get greater and greater until it was all gone. Bonnie then moved on to her curly fries and ate those five at a time moaning at every bite.

"I remember you moaning that exact way when we were gettin' down and dirty."

His voice initially shocked her and she looked over at her door and saw him standing there. "How did you get in?"

"You left the door unlocked, dummy."

Bonnie rolled her eyes then ate another pinch full. "That doesn't give you permission to come in."

He stood there for a beat before walking up to her leaning in to meet their lips only for him to kiss the air instead.

"What are you doing?" Bonnie asked not even the least bit surprised that he would try something like that.

"I can't kiss you?"

"No, we're not together… you made it very clear that we can't be together."

"How so?"

"Oh, I don't know, maybe when you cheated on me? We tried a relationship, you couldn't keep it in your pants so we're done."

"What if I told you I turned over a new leaf?"

"Ha! You were probably fucking another girl when I called. Let's face it, Stefan, you'll always be the same."

He shrugged then took a seat on the chair beside her bed. He watched her before placing his hand on her stomach and smiled some when her hand covered his.

"I'm getting very mixed signals here."

"We're the baby's parents, it needs to feel the both of us."

"I can tell you the sex if you want to know."

"I don't want to know."

"Why not?"

"Because I don't want to know."

He smirked then leaned in kissing her stomach. "Daddy can't wait to hold you, my little baby—"

"Stefan, I will punch you."

He chuckled then kissed her stomach again. Stefan looks up at her catching her eyes before he moves slowly forward. Bonnie, for one, hates that she's attracted to him and his gorgeous eyes and lips which was why she didn't pull away this time when he kisses her.

Stefan smiles and tosses the food bag on the floor and gently climbed on top of her groaning when she pulled him in closer.

...

Bonnie let out a breath rolling to the side only to be stopped. She opened her eyes and saw her baby daddy laying beside her on his side shirtless facing her and she let out a breath smacking her hand on her forehead once his arm wrapped around her.


Caroline smiled as her friend walked through the door and moments later sat in front of her. She could tell already that something was wrong and she didn't even have to ask.

"I… I sort of… slept with Stefan last night?"

"Sort of?"

"Alright, I slept with Stefan last night, shit, what's wrong with me?"

"You're pregnant, hormonal. What was he doing at your place anyway?"

"He bought me some food and I forgot to lock the door so he invited himself in."

"So… how was it?"

"Really, Care?"

"What? I remember you bragging about his…abilities the first time so was it the same?"

Caroline giggled when she frowned. "It was better." She whined. "He was so gentle and sweet and the way he kissed me was steamy and damn, I-"

"Alright, alright, I don't want to get you in the mood again. Think about how much of a douche bag he is."

Bonnie nodded and started listing the things she hated about him and suddenly her arousal lessened and she felt so much better.

Thanks, Caroline.

"Why do you think he slept with you? I mean not that no one wants to sleep with you, but, he was the one to start it up, right?"

"Yeah. I think it was because when I called him he was seducing another woman and I stopped him. I mean if Stefan doesn't get any every day I bet he'd go mad."

Caroline sighed then shook her head. "So how was the morning after? I know it must've been awkward."

"I… we uh, we did it again."

"Bonnie!"

"I know, I'm an idiot, but he's just so sexy but on the other hand he's a douche bag and then on the other-other hand he's the father of my child."

Speaking of, the bell chimed and in walked Stefan with a slight grin on his face. He kept his eyes forward as he walked straight up to the bar sitting beside a brunette.

Immediately, she started staring but Stefan kept it cool and ordered his drink then removed the shades from his face.

Bonnie watched him with narrowed eyes as the two started talking and it wasn't long before his hand was on her thigh.

"I need to get out of here."

Caroline frowned. "I'm sorry, Bon."

She wiped away a tear, "I hate how much he affects me. I hate him but at the same time seeing that makes me a jealous mess."

"Well you guys did date and you were falling in love… You know what, we need to get you a new man."

"No man would want a pregnant woman."

"That's not technically true. I can think of a close friend that would be happy to-"

"No, Care, that wouldn't be right. Matt is too sweet of a person to be used as a rebound."

"It may start off as a rebound, but who knows, it could be something better. You and I both know that he's in love with you."

"But-"

"No more 'buts', Bonnie. If Stefan could move on then why can't you? I'll call him and tell him to come over right now."

Caroline pulled out her phone and started making the call. Bonnie sighed knowing that there was no stopping her now. She looked over at Stefan seeing him even closer to that girl than he was before. Then, she made up her mind. She was going to have an awesome lunch with Matt and Caroline.

...

He was now fully spun around in his chair staring at the group. He had no idea that Bonnie was in here or else he would've gone over there to pick some fun at her. His night and morning were amazing and he could be inside her all day if he wanted to.

Her laugh rang in his ears again and that's when he decided to go over there. The table instantly fell silent once he stepped in front of the table folding his arms under his chest.

"Hey, guys." He looked at Bonnie.

"Stefan," she replied.

He then looked at Matt. He remembers him when Bonnie wanted to try out them dating that Matt would always be around trying to take his place. He will admit that he could see him and Bonnie together but for right now, he wouldn't allow it.

"So. Matt… What are you doing next to my girl?"

Caroline rolled her eyes.

"Stefan, can we talk for a second?" Bonnie didn't give him much time for a response as she pushed him along to the side.

Stefan smiled slightly at her taking control and found himself with his back against the wall.

"What's wrong, baby?"

"Stop calling me that. I'm not your "baby"."

"You didn't mind it last night," he moves a strip of hair behind her ear, "or this morning."

"Yeah, well that was before." She said ignoring the spark she felt.

"Before what?"

"Before you were flirting with some other chick not even a hundred feet in front of me."

He let out a breath. "If I'd known you were here I wouldn't have-"

"It doesn't matter, Stefan, we're not together anymore. I had a temporary moment of weakness but we both know that it will be best if we just stay away from each other romantically."

"I'm not sure if I could do that."

"Why not?"

"Because you're you. You're sexy and you may be pregnant but your body is so damn tempting." He stepped closer to her. "You're the mother of my child and all that I can think about when I see you is ripping your clothes off." He wrapped an arm around her waist pulling her in.

Bonnie kept her attention on his eyes as he looked at her body. Her heartbeat picked up rapidly once their eyes locked. Stefan looked at her slightly parted lips and licked his before leaning in. Bonnie wanted to pull away but found herself licking her lips.

"Bonnie," Caroline said ruining everything, "we should go."

She nodded then moved out of his hold quickly standing by her friend's side. Stefan watched them walk away then let out a breath going back over to the bar.


Caroline looked over at her friend who was seated in the passenger seat looking out the window.

"So," she started. "What was up with that?"

Bonnie shook her head, "I don't know. He seems to care about me but at the same time, he's a jerk. It's like he can hang out with girls but once I hang out with someone, he gets jealous and acts passively."

"Don't let that stop you, Bonnie. You guys tried out a relationship. If he really cared about you, you two would still be together."

"You're right."

"So. Would you agree with going on a date with Matt tonight? Luckily shortly after you pulled Stefan aside, he had to leave so he didn't see anything. I think it'll be good for you, Bonnie. You need to get your mind off of him and on to someone really sweet."

She nodded, "You're right. I'll go."

Caroline smiled.


Matt knocked on her door a bit nervous about tonight, but he's honestly been waiting for this night for a while. He loves her and sure that love revolved strictly around a friendship but that doesn't change how he feels.

The door opened and all he could do was shake his head at her gaining a smile.

"You look beautiful."

She smiled. "Thank you."

"Ready to go?"

"Yeah,"

He reached out to grab her hand walking them over to his car.


Bonnie laughed for about the tenth time that night. She was having one of the best times that she's had in a while and who knew Matty Blue-Blue would be the cause of that.

It was hard to think of them as anything but friends, but the more she pictured it, the less weird it was. He made her happy, he made her laugh, he made her blush. But most of all, he cared about her.

"I'm having a great time, M." She said after calming herself from laughing. "Thank you."

"Don't mention it. I love you see you smile and laugh."

She smiled and melted at his words then started eating. Matt watched her for a few before starting in his meal as well.

Bonnie woke up with a smile on her face. The thought of last night was the first thing she thought about and a part of her couldn't wait to do it again. She ran her hand along her stomach greeting her baby before getting up to shower.


Stefan laid on his back staring at the ceiling fan that spun round and round. He should really be getting ready to be out of here, but his mind was clogged.

He wants to be with the mother of his child but at the same time, he doesn't. He's like both the devil and the angel, he's split in half and it was hard to control. He needed to control it or else things will get out of hand.

He stilled when the woman beside him stirred and he took that as his cue to leave. He counted himself blessed when his phone went off as soon as he escaped.

"Where are you?"

"Where do I need to be?" He asked getting in his car.

"At our appointment- God, Stefan you can never be there when I actually need you."

She hung up on him before he could get another word out and he cursed hitting the wheel before driving over to her place where he waited until she arrived. When she did, he got out of his truck and opened the car door for her once she was parked.

"I'm sorry,"

"Just leave me alone."

She moved passed him and that's when he got a close glimpse of her face and he then knew that she had been crying. He quickly followed after her into the house.

"I forgot to schedule it in my calendar, I'm-"

"Of course you did because you don't care!"

"That is not true. This is the only time-"

"The one time that I actually needed you, Stefan!" She interrupted. "Our baby is breeched…breeched! Feet first, and when I looked over to my side where you were supposed to be so I could hug you and cry on your shoulder, you weren't there! You're never there, you're so selfish!"

He sighed looking down. "Bonnie, I-"

"I don't care about what you have to say anymore, Stefan. Now leave, Matt should be here any minute."

His head quickly snapped up at her. "What the hell is he coming here for?"

"So, unlike you, he could be here for me. He cares about me, Stefan, he cares more than you've ever had so leave. Get out of my house."

He left at that second and not because he wanted to or because he was being a good boy and listen to her orders, but because he needed to. He needed to or else all hell would've broken loose and he didn't want the baby to get harmed over it. If he would've stayed they would be arguing right now and once Matt walked through the door, he would've kicked his ass and he didn't feel like going to jail, so he left.

...

Matt ran his hand along the length of her arm as her head rested on his chest. She told him about everything and all he could do was shake his head. He knew that if he was the father that he would never miss an appointment or if he needed to, he'd make sure that he calls someone so that she wouldn't have to be alone.

He couldn't imagine what it must've been like to hear such news and to have no one to lean on at such a hard and stressful time. He was just glad that he's here now because he's been trying his best ever since he got here to make her feel better.

"What do you say we look up some ways that can help the baby turn over?"

"Can we do that later? I'm very comfortable right here. I'm pretty tired and you're making me feel very homey."

He smiled then kissed her head. "Alright, get some sleep." He rubbed her arm more then her stomach deciding to close his eyes himself.


Katherine watched him pace back and forth in front of her. He was rambling on about Bonnie and the baby and some dude named Matt. Personally, she didn't know why he cared so much, she thought that Stefan barely cared for Bonnie in the first place but him doing this proved otherwise.

"I'm not going to let him raise my child." He ended.

Katherine puckered her lips taping his index fingers together. "I think you're overreacting."

Stefan scoffed folding his arms under his chest. "I'm overreacting? Bonnie's playing house with another man and I'm overreacting?"

"I'm sure Bonnie wouldn't raise your child to believe that Matt is the father. You know what, I bet she doesn't even like him, she's just using him to make you jealous."

"Oh, please,"

"Think about it. If I were her, I would do the same thing. You're a screw-up, no offense, and just to show you what you're missing, she's pushing herself on another guy. And it's working. You're jealous."

"I'm not jealous, I'm angry."

"Same thing, Stefan," Katherine said then walked over to him. "And I think you look very. Very sexy when you're jealous." Her arms wrapped around his neck. "Was that why you were extra rough today?" She asked running her finger along his jawline.

He smirked wrapping an arm around her waist. "Maybe I just missed you."

She bit down on her lip when his hand traveled and squeezed her fat in his hand. "Don't I feel lucky."

"Don't let it go to your head."

They were in a staring match before their lips met and suddenly her legs were around his waist as he walked forward moving to the bed.

...

Bonnie breathed out as Matt placed the frozen peas at the top of her belly. If she wasn't laying in a warm bath with her bathing suit on, the cold would've been too much. They looked up methods on how to turn a breeched baby and this was the first one they decided to attempt. Bonnie wasn't so keen about the idea of placing such cold on the top of her baby's head, but it was better than the alternative.

"How does that feel?" Matt asked running his hand down her hair.

"Okay, I guess. I just hope that this works."

"Me too."

The phone went off that next second so he left her side to answer it and returned shortly handing it to her.

"Hello?"

"Oh, I see. You ditched me for Matt." Caroline said on the other line.

"You know that will never happen."

"Then why aren't I there for this fragile time?"

"Because three's a crowd." Bonnie chuckled when she gasped. "I'm kidding. I would invite you over but something tells me you're already on your way.

The doorbell sounding was the answer to that question and seconds later, Caroline was standing by the tub. Matt decided to give them some alone time and headed downstairs to make dinner.

"How do you do it, Bon?" Caroline asked shaking her head.

"Do what?"

"Get the guys you date whipped so quickly. First was Jackson then Kevin then Stefan and now Matt."

She rolled her eyes. "Stefan is not whipped."

"But you admit that the remainder is?"

No comment.

She sighed sitting on the stool. "I have to disagree with you though, Stefan is the worst out of the four."

"So is that why he cheated on me?"

"He may have cheated, but do you remember how he acted afterward? Apologizing over and over begging for you to take him back. Buying gifts, I thought he would never stop."

"But he did. He stopped and went back to his old occupation of a womanizer."

"Only because you held out for so long."

"Are you seriously shamming me for not taking him back?"

"No, I'm just simply trying to prove a point that's all. Now you got Matt playing daddy helping you with the baby and cooking."

All she did was shake her head. "We're not even what you would call dating, we're just hanging out."

"And what does that mean exactly?"

"It means that I'm pregnant about to give birth in a matter of weeks with another mans child making things complicated to the extreme."

"And speaking of giving birth, what are you going to do?"

"What do you mean?"

"You can't expect to raise this child by yourself. I'm sure Stefan'll want to sleep over or maybe even Matt. You have to come to a bit of a decision you know that right?"

Bonnie sighed at the thought. She honestly hasn't thought that far into the future and she has no idea what she's going to do.

"Ugh, why did you push me to give Matt a chance? Now I'm dizzy."

"I'm sorry, but I just don't like how Stefan treats you. I don't like how he is as a person, it took me months to get used to you two dating and then that incident happened and made me hate him even more. I can see that he cares for you, Bonnie, but he is who he is."

"I know, I just… it's going to be hard. I can't deny Stefan from wanting to be with our child, what kind of mother would I be if I do that. But on the other hand, there's Matt and I know he won't be happy about it. I mean who would, if the roles were switched I'd be bitter."

Caroline chewed on the corner of her mouth in thought as her friend did the same. Maybe it wasn't the best idea of setting the two up and she wouldn't have if she'd thought of this sooner.


A/N: In case you didn't realize it, Katherine is Stefan's FWB and vice versa.