Sorry this took soooo long! I had initially intended for it to be quite different but ultimately decided that sounded to much like some kind of porno which [despite what it may look like at time...] is not what I intend this story to be. I promise though that I'm working on new chapters and that some more exciting stuff is coming up!
The Stall
When Milo finally walked into the house the first thing he noticed was complete silence. He wasn't surprised. It had been two in the morning when he had finally been able to leave the hospital. He had known he was going to be home late but after one of his long time patients had been brought into the emergency room he knew that there would be no hope left of having any romantic time alone with Andy.
As he made his way upstairs he made sure to be as quiet as possible not wanting to wake anybody up. He had his fingers crossed that it would just be Andy who was home—even though he had asked Lu to ''participate'' that evening it was late enough that he wanted her to have already left—when he walked into the bedroom he was disappointed though. Not only was Lu still at their house, she was sleeping curled up next to Andy. For a second he hesitated what to do before realizing there was no other option than to sleep next to them. The only other two beds in the house belonged to Jesse and Lizzy and that just wouldn't be right.
Milo could hear Andy groan as his face hit the cold pillow, ''Are you awake?'' He whispered as he tried to make himself comfortable. He could feel her hand on his stomach and it reminded him of just how much he had wanted to be home with her all day. All day, his whole birthday, he had spent away from her.
''No,'' Andy groaned into her pillow as she tried to wake herself up. She couldn't quite recall how long she had spent waiting for him that evening, and she could tell Lu had been waiting too, quickly running out of ideas on how they could spend their night. It wasn't until Lu had found a vibrator and some rope that she had found a way to waste a lot of time, Andy wasn't entirely sure how long she had been left alone like that. All she knew was that she had lost count of the amount of times she came, and that she was now sore in the best possible way.
Under any other circumstances she would've been fine with not having sex for quite a while, but truth be told she would never say no to Milo. She had missed him. She still wanted to make sure he celebrated his birthday in some way, and she had promised him that she would do whatever he wanted and had no intention of now coming back on that.
Andy rolled herself over so that she was cuddled up against him, trying to forget Lu who was asleep behind her. ''How was work?''
Milo's eyes were slowly adjusting to the dark and he could see Andy's dark eyes staring up at him, her bare skin pressed against his. He swallowed hard as he could feel her hand slowly making its way down, but nothing on her face gave it away. ''Fine,'' he said, his mouth dry. ''They brought Mona Jeffers in.''
Andy's face turned to surprise, surprised that she hadn't been paged even despite being off duty. ''My ballerina?'' She asked. Mona had been one of her patients for years, had finally received a human heart transplantation not a month and a half after the initial xenotransplantation they had carried out.
Milo could see on her face that she was thinking about Mona, but could feel her hand push his underwear down and close her hand around him. He was already semi hard. ''She's rejecting the heart,'' he said, trying to suppress his instinct of pushing her down onto her back and fucking her hard until she couldn't remember who Mona Jeffers or anybody else for that matter was. But Lu was there. And yes, he had asked her but now he just wished she was anywhere but in their bed.
Andy peppered his skin with kisses as she made her way down his body. The plan had been all along that she would be with Milo; she wasn't going to keep Lu being there from that. ''I'll go see her in the morning,'' she told Milo as she dragged his underwear down his legs.
Milo inhaled sharply as he could feel her mouth close around him, promptly forgetting what he was going to say. His eyes were slowly adjusting to the dark and he could see Lu asleep not three feet away from him, her long hair covering some of her face. It made it hard to focus on what Andy was doing but he knew it didn't matter, he had been on edge for so long at the thought of what he had planned that he knew he wouldn't last long anyway.
Andy closed her hand around the base of his dick, applying some pressure, and she could hear him hiss. Lu stirred next to her and Andy was simultaneously praying in her head that Lu wouldn't wake up as well as trying not to think about her at all. She could feel Milo's hand on her cheek, keeping the hair away from her face so he could watch her and she picked up the pace a bit. She could taste the pre-cum on her tongue and swallowed around him.
Milo tore his eyes away from Andy just in time to see Lu frown as she tried to wake herself up, clearly unable to even subconsciously ignore what was going on next to her. He could see her eyes widen in surprise when she finally realized what was happening and he couldn't help but stare at her, curious to see how she was going to react. He had known he was going to be home late so he had put into action something he had suggested to Andy before she and Lu had even gotten together officially; she could be with Lu, then tell him about it and he could 'punish' her. It was why he had asked Lu to come over. Sure, her still being there hadn't been part of the plan but he was starting to think that maybe it wasn't the worst thing in the world.
He leaned his head back, trying to just focus on how good Andy was making him feel instead of anything else going on around him; his arms fell to the side as he surrendered himself to her, something that rarely happened.
Andy felt a hand in her hair and it took her a second to notice it was Lu's. She hadn't realized it was no longer just Milo who was watching and unlike what usually happened she now felt emboldened by it. The knowledge that she could make feel Milo good enough that instead of taking charge like usual he could merely lie there and take it, it satisfied her more than a dozen orgasms ever could.
She could feel him twitch and then come in her mouth, and suppressed her normal instinct of just immediately swallowing. Over the years she had heard plenty of her girlfriends complain about the taste of it, but for some reason she had never minded it. She moved up his body just the slightest bit, her hand on his chest, and she waited until his eyes were back on her before she kissed Lu deeply. Andy could feel Lu's tongue in her mouth before Lu pulled away after a split second, staring at Andy surprised as Andy chuckled just a little bit before pulling Lu close to her again, kissing her again.
Lu could feel Milo's load slipping down her throat and Milo swallowed hard at the sight of it. He hadn't expected Andy to do that and he certainly hadn't expected Lu to be okay with it.
Andy's hand lingered on Lu's cheek as the latter woman pulled away, sitting back on her heels, ''I'm going to get some water,'' she said as she scooted off the bed, ''Do you want anything?''
After both Andy and Milo had said that they didn't and Lu had left the room, Andy finally turned back to Milo, snuggling up against him. ''Is it okay if she stays?'' She asked, her hand seemingly having a mind of its own as she softly stroked his stomach. His hesitation was evident from his silence and she pulled away so she could actually be face to face with him, somewhat already regretting her words before she had even said them, ''As it's your birthday,'' she could easily recall what Lu had told her just a few hours earlier, ''You get to do whatever you want. To either of us.''
Milo could sense that she wasn't entirely comfortable with the idea and didn't know how to respond. He had never considered doing anything with Lu. He hadn't planned for her to be there at all, let alone have another threesome with—he didn't even know it was possible—less planning than the first time. ''You sure about this?'' He asked, knowing that if Andy changed her mind he would never bring it up again, and the whole point of whether he wanted to would be moot.
Andy stared into his eyes as she made up her mind. She loved both of them; she trusted both of them… She wasn't entirely sure why Lu had decided that she wanted to, but figured she could ask her about it later. ''I want you to have the best birthday,'' she told him. In his eyes she could see he wasn't too sure about this, ''Take it or leave it. Just know that you're not going to get this chance again.''
''I don't know why I agreed to let you do this.'' Andy knew exactly why she had agreed to this.
It had been just over two weeks since Milo's birthday and Andy and Lu had finally been able to go away for the weekend. Though Andy didn't know why Lu had wanted to go to Atlantic City she had found it to be pretty great, knowing that it was mostly because Lu was there.
Now though… it had been Lu's idea to go out to dinner, and it had been Lu who had convinced Andy to put on the underwear Lu had bought for her. Andy could feel the slight buzzing feeling and gripped the table cloth tightly in her hand as she watched a smug look appear on Lu's face. She had been hesitant to agree to the vibrating panties until Lu had reminded her how she had helped Andy out when Andy was lamenting about Milo's birthday being a flop when he hadn't been able to come home yet.
Still, when Lu wasn't looking Andy had fished the remote out of her bag and had hoped that would be the end of it while they were out in public, no such luck though. It vibrated just enough that it was quickly building an ache inside her but not enough to push her over the edge, all Andy could do was lean back in her chair, holding onto the side of the seat as she pushed her legs together, and watch as Lu was sitting across from her pretending nothing was going on.
It was making Andy reconsider if Milo's birthday had been worth this.
Given the fact that just the memory of it got her all hot and bothered told her enough though. Milo hadn't included Lu as much as she had thought he might, and Andy was sure that if it wasn't for Milo being so serious about not straying—even despite Andy's permission to do whatever he wanted to do with Lu—things would have probably gotten quite a bit crazier. Still, it had left all of them satisfied and Andy was glad that Lu had stayed around.
The memory of Lu being on top of her, sitting on her face… Milo inside of her, Lu's fingers on her clit… The whole thing just made her mind foggy and if the vibrating panties weren't enough to make her blush, the memory of that night certainly did. Everything that they had done, combined with all the scenarios that had ran through her mind when she had told Milo he could do whatever he wanted…
Okay yeah, it had totally been worth this.
The only thing that had kind of put a damper on the whole evening for Andy was Milo's words from a weeks prior replaying in her head. He had told her to make some kind of commitment to Lu… or actually just told her that that seemed to be what Lu wanted. Andy knew that despite Milo being seemingly more and more supportive he would still always prefer her to just be with him, would prefer them to be monogamous to each other. She knew that at this point it would be useless but she couldn't help but keep that in mind.
She knew that Lu would pay no mind to her being quiet, probably figuring that it was because of the vibrating panties. On the inside though… Milo's words were still replaying in her head and she still couldn't make up her mind about what kind of commitment she wanted to make—or if she even wanted that at all. Andy was staring at Lu who was eating peacefully across the table from her and tried to picture their future like she had done with Milo.
Just a few months into her relationship with Milo she had had no doubt that she wanted to marry him one day, but her relationship with Lu was different. She didn't know if it was because she was already with Milo or if it was because Lu was a woman, she just couldn't picture their future together as easily, couldn't imagine a life without Lu but also couldn't imagine growing old with her. There were such strong feelings between them and Andy felt that sometimes they were stronger even than what she felt for Milo, but that didn't change anything.
''You enjoying yourself over there?'' Lu asked without even looking up from her menu. She could feel Andy's eyes on her and tried to hide how much she was enjoying this but was failing. The punishments that she had come up with weeks earlier had been kept in the back of her mind and though she couldn't say that she didn't enjoy what they had done on Milo's birthday it still felt like a good opportunity to try one of her ideas.
''You really like torturing me, don't you?'' Andy asked as she finally picked up her own menu as well, trying to push her previous train of thought out of her mind.
''That's what you get when you go through my purse and throw the remote out,'' Lu stated matter-of-factly. It had been her plan all along to keep on Andy on edge all evening, Andy trying to get rid of the remote just gave her the justification that she needed if she was going to call this a punishment.
Having the menu in front of her finally gave her something else to focus on, and Andy was glad for the distraction. She loved Lu taking control but it felt nice to sometimes take some of that control back and almost tease Lu with that. Their eyes finally met across the table and Andy picked up her glass of water, making it clear with one simple look that she wasn't bothered. Everything was fine and dandy. As soon as she took her eyes off of Lu she could feel it getting kicked up a notch though and she had to try her hardest to suppress a moan. The table cloth that had been clutched in her hand she accidentally yanked towards herself and she could hear Lu stifle a laugh. ''You think you're so funny don't you?'' Andy asked even though she was smiling as well.
Lu watched Andy take a sip of water as if nothing was going on but she could see on her face that the panties were very much doing their job. ''I just like seeing you like this,'' she said.
After the waiter had taken their order and had left them alone again, Andy silently contemplated telling Lu about her and Milo trying for a baby. On the one hand she felt that Lu had a right to know, but on the other hand… She didn't want to get Lu's hopes up if she did want them to have a baby, and she also didn't want them to break up before any baby had even been conceived if Lu didn't want a baby.
Lu could see by the look on Andy's face that something was going on. One of her eyebrows shot up, ''What's going on?''
Just because Andy wasn't ready to ask her to move in, or ready to tell her they were trying for a baby, it didn't mean she didn't have something to ask. ''I want you to be my maid of honor,'' she said, ''Now, I completely understand if you don't want to because it's too weird or because you and Milo don't always get along… but it would mean the world to me.''
After a second a warm smile spread on Lu's face but it wasn't long before it fell a bit, ''Don't you want the girls to…''
''They can be bridesmaids,'' Andy interrupted her, ''I just feel like despite my best efforts to keep both relationships separate you are a big part of our relationship just like Milo is a big part of ours, I want you to be a part of our special day,'' she hesitated for a second, ''And maybe one day Milo can play a small role in our special day,'' she added softly.
Lu could see Andy shifting around a bit and wasn't sure if it was because of what she had just said or because of the panties still buzzing away like nobody's business. She leaned over and gave Andy a quick peck on the lips; ignoring the dirty look she got from the guy sitting at the table next to them, hoping Andy didn't see him. ''I can't wait,'' she said, deliberately not making it clear whether she meant Andy and Milo's wedding or her and Andy's.
''Well, you'll have to wait a little while longer because I have to go to the ladies' room,'' Andy said as she got up, she could see Lu eyeing her suspiciously. ''Don't worry,'' she said, lowering her voice, ''I'm not going to take them off.''
It was in the ladies room that Andy finally felt like she could breathe. In the mirror she saw how red she had gotten and she was glad that she could for just a second stop hiding how incredibly turned on she was. She splashed some cool water in her face—grateful that she was alone—before closing the stall door. The familiar clicking of Lu's heels and the subsequent closing of the door echoed off the tiles as Andy turned the lock and she could hear Lu call out her name. Andy had barely opened the stall door before Lu pushed her way inside. ''Did you miss me already?'' Andy asked, ignoring the fact that Lu was already kissing her neck.
''Always.''
Andy narrowed her eyes though Lu didn't see it. ''Are you checking up on me?'' She asked. Yes, it had crossed her mind to just throw the panties in her bag and go without, sure that Lu would be just as turned on knowing that Andy wasn't wearing underwear, but she had already decided against doing that.
''Just wanted to make sure,'' Lu said as she captured Andy's lips in an increasingly deepening kiss. Eventually she pulled away, ''Plus I couldn't wait until we got back to the hotel room.'' She slipped the fabric on Andy's shoulder to the side and kissed the newly exposed skin.
Andy leaned her head back against the cold tile behind her, ''If we weren't in a public bathroom I'd jump you,'' she whispered despite nobody else being within earshot, ''But we are,'' she added after a second, trying and failing to ignore how good Lu's lips felt on her skin. That, combined with the panties that had left her on the edge for a while now, it felt like a lethal combination. She could hear Lu murmur something about not caring about that and felt her try to turn Andy around, pushing them into the same position they so often used.
Lu didn't expect Andy to fight back against what she was doing and she pulled away for a second, ''What's wrong?'' She asked as she gathered some of the fabric of Andy's dress in her hand and started to pull it up. Despite how well Andy had tried it Lu had still been able to see how she was being slowly being pushed closer and closer to coming and without any stimulation and without even wanting to she had followed suit.
Andy inched up Lu's dress as well inch by inch, knowing that despite what she was doing Lu was still in charge, always. ''Let me have some fun,'' she said as she slipped Lu's panties to the side, feeling that she was already wet.
''Me making you come isn't enough fun?'' Lu asked as she pushed the vibrating panties against Andy's clit, making her moan quietly into Lu's hair. She shut up rather quickly though when Andy's fingers finally made contact with her own clit, taking a deep shaky breath.
''I prefer to not be the only one having a good time,'' Andy said as she pushed Lu into the wall behind her, their bodies pressed together with their hands in the other's underwear, it wasn't exactly as she had imagined their vacation to go but she wasn't complaining. She was softly nibbling on Lu's ear before moving down and kissing her neck, feeling Lu's head resting against her shoulder. It so often felt like the focus got put solely on her in situations like these and Andy would be lying if she said it wasn't also the guilt over not being more willing to make commitments that now pushed her to make things more two-sided.
Lu sped up her movements as she could feel herself start to get closer to the edge as well and could feel Andy's body arching into her own, Andy's teeth nearly breaking the skin on Lu's throat as she tried to stifle a moan, one of Andy's hands grasping at the wall behind Lu as she looked for something to hold onto. Lu could hear a soft cry and then felt Andy contracting around her as she finally slipped two fingers inside her. ''Now don't tell me you're not having a good time,'' Lu said as she slipped the vibrating panties back into place, rubbing them against Andy for a few seconds just for good measure.
Andy could feel her legs shaking a bit beneath her and decided to not ignore that for once. She slowly sank to her knees and pushed Lu's dress up, glad that she wasn't wearing a very tight one. Andy couldn't resist rubbing her thighs together as she tried to make herself comfortable on the cold tile floor, pushing Lu's dress over her hips and her panties far to the side, slipping a few fingers in as her tongue at last made contact with Lu's clit, feeling that despite her trouble with committing to Lu she would gladly spend her lifetime between the apex of her legs.