I know introduce you to the newly edited The Challenge That Backfired.
Rated: M
G!P Rachel: If you don't like it, I ask that you don't read it.
Warning: I will not tolerate disrespectful reviews, constructive criticism is allowed. But rude and disrespectful reviews will be deleted immediately. Until Next Time Enjoy!
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee. If I did there would have never been a Bram. (Brittany and Sam) and Faberry would have been a strong possibility.
Pairings: Beginning with Britt-Berry but Pezberry and Quitt is End Game!Puckleberry, and eventually Faberittana friendship.
Chapter 1
Rachel is a self proclaimed bad-ass with a 8" strike zone that all the girls loves the ride. Rachel was indeed a lesbian with a penis. When she was born the doctors thought she was a boy, but it turned out that she was an inter-sex baby. Rachel had a hard time accepting that she was different. She just wanted to be like every other girl. Its wasn't until she was 13 years old when she thought she fell in love with this girl named Bethany Gonzales.
She was the Head Cheerio and a senior and convinced Rachel that she liked her and after they had sex, Bethany never talked to Rachel again and that broke her heart. Since that day Rachel built her walls up higher then the Great Wall of China. Rachel and her best friends Mike, Finn and Puck adapted to the "I don't give a fuck" mentality.
Their popularity grew higher then ever when they joined the football team and pretty much fucked every girl they seen. They were 3 of the baddest motherfuckers in school. They did what they wanted, whenever they want to and didn't give a damn what others had to say about it.
Rachel's P.O.V
February 18th
The last couple of years had been a blast. My boys and I have been ruling the halls of McKinley since freshmen year. We went to the sickest parties and fucked the hottest girls. However, there were 3 girls I wanted and never could get with. The Unholy Trinity. Yes the trio of the most popular and gorgeous girls in the school. The Head Cheerio Quinn Fabray, The Second In Command Santana Lopez and The Choreographer Brittany S Pierce.
The easiest way to achieve my goal is to go after Brittany first. She's not too bright, so it didn't take me time to convince her to go out with me. I couldn't bang and ditch. If I was going to score with the 3 hottest chicks in school, I had to come up with a new game plan. So I worked my magic on Brittany and lets just say her panties dropped quicker then a deck of cards. Brittany's voice pulled me from my thoughts.
"Baby I need you so bad right now." Brittany says as I lay on top of her. We were having hot and heavy make out session and I was hard as rock. We've been having sex for a couple weeks now and I'm loving it. 1 down and 2 to go.
"Is that right." I said sucking on her neck.
"Yeah baby I'm so fucking wet for you." I slid my hand inside her panties and hell yeah, she's dripping for me.
"Lets see what we can do about that." We undressed each other and I'm so damn horny as I line myself up with Brittany's entrance and I thrust into her unprotected. I move at a good pace.
"Ohhh baby yes...Just like that." She starts to moan and quite loudly I might add. I love hearing her moan, it does something to me. So I thrust in faster and little harder.
"Damn baby...your so fucking tight." I grab her left leg and put it over my shoulder and began to thrust deeper into her and boy does this feel so damn good.
"Oh God baby you are so deep...Oh so fucking deep baby...Please don't stop."
"Ohhh fuck you feel so damn good." I said hitting it harder and faster then before.
"Yes, Yes, Yes, I can feel it baby … I'm almost there. Fuck me harder!..." I begin to pound into her and I put her leg back down and she wraps them around my waist as I move my hips from left to right hitting searching for that special spot that makes her go wild. Once I found it, I made sure to hit it every time. Brittany arches her back off the bed, her whole body tightens around me and I know she's close. As she's scratching the fuck out of my back, hoping she doesn't break skin. I can feel myself getting closer as I continue to pound in and out of her.
"Baby I'm so close...Holy shit..."
Brittany moans get louder and I can honestly say I'm happy her parents are out of town. Britt can get loud. She arches her back again and her mouth forms the perfect "O" as her orgasm washes over her like a title wave crashing to the shore.
"OH MY GOD, OHHHH … RACHAEL!"
She screams my name and I keep thrusting into her to help her ride out her orgasm and that pushes me over the edge.
"OHHH FUCK!" I scream in her neck as I cum so deep inside her. I pull out and lay next to her. I close my eyes trying to catch my breath. Damn that was so fucking good.
"Wow." I say and I look over at her and she was knocked out. I fucked her into unconsciousness...I smirk as I get out of bed and walk over to her bathroom to freshen up. Then I grab my clothes put them back on and I walk out of her house.
~ An Hour Later ~
I was on the basketball court with my boys playing two on two. Puck passes me the ball and asks,
"So, where were you? I called like 40 minutes ago." I smirk.
"Fucking Brittany into unconsciousness."
"For real?"
"Hell yeah. I had her screaming my name and begin' for my shit."
"My Lez-Bro!" Puck exclaimed as he gave me a high five along with Mike and Finn.
"You are my idol!" Finn said.
"You guys are crazy. You guys get as much pussy as I do."
"Not me anymore, I haven't been with any others girls since Tina."
Puck makes a whipping sound and we all laugh even Mike. I was about to say something when my cell phone rings and I look at the name and I smirk cause seeing her name on my caller ID means only one thing...Booty Call!
"Hello?"
"Hey baby."
"What's up?"
"I just off the phone with Brittany and she was telling me how you laid it on her. She gave me the blow by blow and now I so fucking wet and horny. My pussy is throbbing for you baby."
"Oh yeah. Tell me how bad you want it."
"So fucking bad baby. I just put my fingers deep inside me...But mmm baby it can't go as deep as your big ass dick can...I just took it out...Mmmm I taste so good...Baby do you want a taste?" Yep I'm getting hard. I can already tell.
"Oh okay don't trip I'm on my way."
"Hurry up or I'll have to finish the job myself."
"I said I'm on my way...Now chill."
"Okay hurry baby."
"Bye." I said hanging up.
"Booty Call?" Puck asked.
"Yeah, you know how I do."
"Yeah, I feel you!" I get into my car and drive to Quinn's house. This happened about 2 months after I started dating Brittany. Quinn asked me to help her study for the upcoming test that week and let's say she was on her knees sucking me off within 20 minutes of me being there. Then I successfully fucked the shit out of her. Leaving Santana the only one left on my list. Then I would have successfully fucked the Unholy Trinity.
I thought the Quinn thing was a one time thing. But she seems to get off of hearing how good I fuck Brittany. One I finish fucking Brittany, I would get a call for Quinn asking for the same treatment and who and I to deny her of such pleasure?
I know it's wrong to cheat but I just can't help myself. Quinn is just so damn sexy. I pull up to her house, go up to her door and she opens it yanking me inside as I kick the door shut.
"You ready for this baby?"
"You tell me." She grabs my hand and slides it inside her panties and I feel how wet she is. My dick just got even harder.
"Fuck you so wet Q."
"I'm going to suck you up and ride your dick until you're begging me to stop." I smile at her cause she knows damn well I'm not telling her to stop anytime soon.
"Hey you won't get any complaints from me, but you know it's gonna be you that's begging me stop."
"Really you think so?"
"I know so."
"How's that?"
"I have a 8" strike zone that never fails to have you screaming my name."
"We'll see who's screaming who's name." She says she drops my pants and pushes me on the couch.
"Damn you so hard baby." She get on her knees in front of me and take the head of my dick into her mouth and sucks on it. I throw my head back as I close my eyes getting ready enjoy my blow job. My hands fly to her blond hair almost instantly and all I want to do is hold her head and fuck her mouth but I don't.
"Mmm you taste so good baby." Quinn then takes all of me, bobbing her head up and down. Oh fuck she's screw driving my shit...I fucking love her mouth. She take it out and licks the sides of my dick and then deep throat my shit. I cannot take it anymore as I grab head and fucks her mouth.
"Thats right suck my dick." I say thrusting my hips up and move my dick faster in and out of her mouth.
"Thats right baby fuck my dirty mouth."
"Oh shit I'm coming and you better drink it all!"
I say as I cum down her throat and she swallows all that I have to give her. Once I was done, she runs to the bathroom and brushed her teeth and use some mouth wash. She returned and climbed on top of me. She lowers herself down on me and starts grinding up and down and she then starts bouncing on my dick.
"Oh shit your so fucking tight Q." I say holding her hips, so she wouldn't fall.
"Oh baby you feel so damn good. I can't get enough your dick."
I lift her hips a bit and start thrusting in her faster and faster. I let her hips go and she starts bouncing harder and harder on my dick with her hands on my shoulders.
"Oh shit baby, your dick feels amazing inside me...you fill me up so good...Turn me over and fuck me from behind...Not my ass though."
She gets off me and gets on all fours on the floor. I get behind her and hold her hips as I pound into her smacking her ass along the way.
"Oh Rachel don't stop...Please oh God...I'm so fucking fucking close."
"Yeah, you like me hitting it from the back like this?" I say going harder and faster.
"Yes, Oh God YES!"
"Cum for me Quinn and when you do you better scream my name."
I keep pounding into her and I starts to move my hips in a circular motion, hitting her G-Spot every time.
"OHHHH GOD RACHEL!"
Quinn screams as her orgasm hits her so hard it rendered her speechless. I keep going and until I cum deep inside her.
"FUUCCCKK!" I pull out of her and lay down next to her.
"That was amazing Rach."
"Yeah it was."
"You want to spend the night?"
"Yeah I'm wiped out." We got up and grabbed our clothes from the floor as she grabs my hand and leads me upstairs to her room. Once we entered the room she lays on the bed and lay behind her and cuddle up to her.
"Why aren't you this sweet when we at school?" She asks.
"Babe you know I have to keep up appearances. Plus I am dating your best friend."
"Yeah I feel bad about what we're doing but I can't let you go. I don't want too."
"You don't have too. Listen I love Britt but we aren't as compatible as you and I. If I could be with you without no drama I would."
"Yeah I know baby." She turns in my arms and kisses me and I lay on top of her as she opens her legs and I enter her slowly this time. As I'm kissing her neck she holds on to my back.
"Oh baby yes." She moans breathlessly.
"You're so beautiful Quinn." I say kissing her lips. I speed up a bit and we keep going until we reach our peak together and I release inside her again. This was different. I've never had slow and passionate sex before. Maybe I should have left. I cannot be catching feelings and shit. Quinn is just sex and that's it.
I pull out and lay next to her holding her in my arms as she falls asleep. I stare at her for a while and then I go to sleep.
~ The Next Morning ~
I wake and head to the bathroom and shower and gets dressed. As I leave the bathroom I notice that Quinn's up and staring at the ceiling.
"Hey what's wrong Q?"
"I'm Q now. Yesterday I was babe and baby."
"Q come on you know I care about you but this was just sex remember?"
"Yeah I know that. It's just … You know what it doesn't even matter. Just go back to your girl."
"Quinn I don't want to hurt you and I feel like maybe I am. Do you want to end this?" I ask sitting on her bed.
"I don't know, will it always be just sex?"
"I'm sorry for now yeah."
"Then yeah I think we should end this."
"It's Santana isn't it." I look at her like she's crazy. How could she know I was into Santana.
"What are you talking about?"
"Don't play dumb. I know you wanted to sleep with the 3 of us and you slept with 2/3s already." I let out a sigh of relief. She thinks I just want to complete my list. That's all she needs to know.
"Yeah last one and I'm a legend." I see her roll her eyes.
"When are you are going to be in a relationship you actually care about."
"I don't know, but this feelings shit is killing my vibe so I'm a holla at you later."
"You just can't be real for a minute without leaving."
"Peace." I said walking down the stairs and out the door. I drive home thinking that maybe one day I will be ready and when I am, it's Santana I wanna be with.
~ One Month Later ~
March 20th
It's been one month since I slept Quinn. Things since then has been slightly different as Quinn's been more cold towards me. I just figured she's upset we ended our arrangement. Brittany and I are still together and she's none the wiser.
Some chick is having a massive party tonight and I need to get my party on. It's been too damn long. Plus maybe I could seal the deal with Santana. Naw I can't. Man do I want too. But I did promise Noah. She's his sister and I have to respect.
The party started at 8:45 and I didn't get there until 9:30pm. Everyone knows you never arrive at a party on time. When I walked in I saw Brittany on the dance floor doing her thing. I can't hate though my girl can dance. I walked in the kitchen and made a b-line straight for the alcohol.
"My lez-bro what's up?" Puck said obliviously drunk off his ass.
"Nothing just trying to get my drink on is all."
"I feel you...Well here drink up." He said handing me a drink. Normally I would never accept a drink I didn't make or seen being made, but this is my boy. I've known Noah since the 1st grade. I trust him with my life, and he knows I would end his if he ever tried anything like that.
"Thanks."
"Your girls out there tearing up the dance floor."
"I know my girl got moves." I walk over to her, grab her by the waist and starts dancing with her. She's grinding on me and it's feeling good. Until Santana asks to speak with me.
"Rachel can I have a word with you?"
"Yeah, lets go upstairs and talk."
I walked upstairs with Santana and when we went inside one of the rooms and closed the door I asked,
"So what did you want to talk about?"
"Nothing...I just want you so bad." She said kissing me and I kissed her back as her hands moved down to my belt and she undo it and my zipper. She pushed my pants and boxers down around my ankles.
Then pushed me on the bed as she pulled her panties down and kept her skirt on. There was no need for me to get ready. I was already rock hard. Santana Lopez is by far the hottest girl I have ever seen in my life and that fact I'm about to fuck her is all I need for my dick to be super hard.
That guilty feeling is coming back up. The one thing Puck asked of me when I told him I lost my virginity was to sleep with his sister. He said he didn't give fuck who I bedded down just not Santana. She was better then that.
Then when I went on sleeping every girl I seen, again he asked me not to fuck his sister. He was my best friend and the lease I could do was respect his wishes.
"Hey Santana I...Holy shit you're tight." I began to say, but was cut off when she lowers herself on my dick.
"Santana I..." I tried again and she started moving. Whatever will power I had left inside of me was gone the minute she started moaning my name.
"Oh Rachel you feel better then I could have ever imagined."
"Santana we need to do this fast and quietly okay?"
"Okay...damn...mmm..." She rides my dick faster and faster.
~ 15 Minutes Later ~
"Oh my God Rachel I'm so close... Baby just a little more."
"Me too...Come on San cum for me." I said flipping her over after I kick my shoes and pants completely off, I started pounding in and out of her.
"I'm coming..."
I kissed her as her orgasm rocked so hard...she didn't think she would have the ability to walk straight. Then again that wouldn't be a problem. People would just assume she was drunk. I cum deep inside her moments later. I pull out of her and lay next to her.
"Come on Santana we better get downstairs before people start looking for us." I said as I hurried up and put on my boxers, pants and re-buckled my belt.
"Okay yeah you're right." Once she put her underwear on. I walked into the bathroom that was attached to the room and thank God the room belonged to a girl and I toss Santana body spray and I put on a different one.
"What's this for?" She asked doing her hair.
"The sex smell."
"Oh right yeah...Thanks."
"No problem." Once our hair was under control and we smelt good, we walked back downstairs and was immediately stopped by Brittany.
"Hey S where have you been? And why were you coming downstairs with Rachel?"
"B I had a headace, because I drunk to much and Rachel took me to a room so I could lay down."
"You were waiting for a half an hour to make sure she was okay?" Really you choose now to use your brain.
"Baby, you have nothing to worry about okay. I had to make sure she didn't throw or anything. I was just being a good friend."
"Whats that body spray you have on." Fuck my life!
"Brittany I can't believe you forgot you brought me this body spray...Forbidden Romance. Lord Tubbington told you I would like it, so you brought and I did like it remember baby?" Please buy this.
"Oh yeah I remember then we made love, because it was the anniversary of our first date." Thanks God!
"Right." Wait what? The night we had sex was our anniversary? That slipped my mind. Puck looked at me then back at Santana, then back at me again. He walked over to me and grabbed my arm.
"Tell me didn't fuck my sister?"
"I didn't fuck your sister, she honestly wasn't feeling good and I wanted to make sure she was okay."
"You're telling me the truth right?"
"I promise. I wouldn't do that to you man." I said feeling bad, cause yes I did fuck her and even though it was fast it was the best sex I ever had. The list is complete. I officially fucked the Unholy Trinity.
"Okay then lets get our drink on. There some fine ass bitches here tonight and I need my lez-bro to run an interference for me."
"Hey now what kind of a lez-bro would I be, if I didn't help my fellow bro get laid?"
"Not a good one."
"You're right lets get you laid." We did our normal thing...Where I would talk to a girl and he would come and take her from me and I would walk away, so he could seem all bad-ass. It worked every time, it really never fails.
After I get Puck some girls number, he walks upstairs with one and turns to me and shot me the slam dunk sign...basically saying he's about to score. I shake my and do the same pointing at Brittany." He nods his head and turn back around disappears around the corner. I walk up to Brittany and say,
"Baby, I'm going home are you coming?"
"No, I'm spending the night with Quinn and Santana. I'll see you tomorrow."
"Keep an eye on her Q and S." I say to Santana and Quinn, who was sitting next to her.
"We got her." 5 minutes or so later, after saying goodbye to my boys, I was heading out the door when I saw some boy pushing up on Brittany and Santana and Quinn were no where to be seen. I walked back over to her.
"Hey baby I forgot, didn't you promise me...We could have tonight just for us?" I said and catches my drift quickly.
"Oh yeah...I'm sorry my girlfriend and I are leaving." Brittany tells the boy, he gets pissed and grabs her arm. That pissed pissed me. You don't put your fucking hands on my girlfriend.
"You're not going anywhere until I SA..." I punched the guy in the face as hard as I could before he could even finish his sentence and I laid him out with just one punch...Yep put that motherfucker to sleep.
I grabbed Brittany and we left. I text Puck to find Santana and Quinn, because there were some drunk asshole all over Brittany and I couldn't find them.
"I was just talking to them 5 minutes ago, where the hell could they have gone that fast?" I said as we headed to my car.
"I don't know they said they would be right back." Brittany said getting in the car. No need to worry about me, that shit got me super sober. I got in and drove us to my house. Once inside the house, we walked to my room. My mom was sleeping which I am grateful for. We entered my room and Brittany changed into her pajamas, she had left a while ago. I only sleep in my boxers and my wife beater, so I just took my clothes off. We got into bed about to go to sleep, when I got a text from Puck,
From Puck: I got Q and San, don't worry they're fine and I'm taking Quinn home with me and San.
To Puck: Okay thanks man.
From Puck: No problem...See you tomorrow.
To Puck: Okay, hey did you get laid?
From Puck: No, I was in the middle of a BJ when I got your text.
To Puck: Shit my bad bro.
From Puck: Its cool man...My sister and Quinn's safety was more important then getting my dick sucked.
To Puck: Aww Puck has a soft side.
From Puck: Oh blow me! You would have done the same shit and don't even lie. By the way I'm still a bad-ass."
To Puck: I believe you.
From Puck: Whatever dude, see you tomorrow.
To Puck: Alight man.
With that said I placed my phone on my side table and went to sleep holding Brittany in my arms wishing it was Santana. Don't get me wrong, Brittany's a great girl and so is Quinn but there's just something about Santana.
A/N: I hope you guys like it. Let me know what how think. How you would like the to go. Leave a review and I may use your suggestion. let me know what you think will happen next. Please read and review. Until Next Time See You Later!