The dungeon leads Matt and Natalie into a room that is resembling a normal place, with a normal sun like they walked into the outside, Natalie thinks about all the ways it could look like it, multiverse travel, teleportation, illusion, and other ways. As Natalie turns around, she notices she cannot see the entrance they came from anymore, she swallows her worries knowing she has Matt on her side. "We can't go back, let's show this dungeon what you and I got!" Natalie informs Matt who appreciates Natalie's attitude.

The area is a town, not just any town but Matt's and Natalie's rather small and humble hometown. It is a ghost town though. "Maybe we need to find something that connected us in our childhood?" Natalie asks as she and Matt go through the town. "Could be… maybe we should visit your or mine old homes?" Matt asks as he recognizes many places and many old memories come back up. "That sounds like a clever idea! Let's go to my house first!" Natalie responds excited as she runs off towards her house.

Matt and Natalie soon arrive at her old house, but there was a note on the front door that reads: "Hello, I, Natalie, went off to university to study and make use of my magical talent. I am going to be outside of the town for over a year, my friend Matt has a secondary key to my house in case it is needed. Love, Natalie" Upon reading that both Matt and Natalie had tons of memories from that part of their lives. "Hey Matt!" Both Natalie and Matt can hear a voice from the side they have not heard in a long time.

They both turn around to see Cat, a girl with dark red hair and yellow eyes wearing a red shirt and black dress. "Hey Cat, long time no see! What are you doing in this dungeon?" Matt asks Cat not being able to fully believe it. "I don't really know what you are talking about… but… well… I am glad to see you and Natalie are still traveling together… can we maybe adventure again since you are in the area?" Cat then walks closer and asks Matt. "I am sorry, I am here because of some love dungeon and me and Natalie need to do that. But feel free to join us on that!" Matt tries to politely reject and offer an alternative.

"Nah, I am not really interested, I have heard that there is a dragon we could slay as a duo like in the old times when Natalie was studying! You can't believe how annoying it was, I was never able to get a good partner…" Cat says somewhat annoyed but also hopeful. "What about Phyrnna or NoLimbs, aren't they both competent as well?" Matt asks Cat. "Phyrnna went off to the Ice Kingdom to perform songs to the masses and NoLimbs died off old age…" Cat explains to Matt. "Oh… I am sorry that NoLimbs died, we have gotten ourselves a pet cat named NoLegs and since you always were NoLimbs best friend, I am sure that must deeply hurt… Maybe it would be better if I just let you and Matt have this adventure as a duo…" Natalie then says with a somewhat sorry tone as she realizes what she just said.

Natalie then pulls Matt away a bit and tells him something in a rather silent tone to ensure Cat does not hear them: "I think this is some sort of room to deal with the fact that Cat was your replacement me while I was in university…" and Matt has a look like he understands what happens now. "That would make sense…" he says before turning back to cat. "Look, I am sorry you have an identity that revolves around being a forgotten replacement of Natalie… I am not sure what I am supposed to say to help you… or whether I should say something like romantic cliché stuff… like… Natalie is so important to me I replaced her in the time while she was gone…?" Matt then tries to tell Cat, but he is not really sure what to do it.

"You two got it, I am just a replica of cat based on your perception…" Cat then admits. "And what do we need to do to proceed?" Natalie then asks the illusion cat. "I am not allowed to tell that… but you also need to something Natalie… this is not just about Matt…" The illusion cat then tells them. "Oh… do we need to fake some sort of confession to pretend our feelings are romantic?" Matt then asks Cat. "I won't tell you any further hints…" The illusion replies. "I think I know what I need to do… I need to do a confession of my love… a real confession!" Natalie then says as she begins to blush at the thought of that.

Matt is somewhat surprised by the thought. "I mean… we do love each other in a sibling way, don't we? No need to confess that love!" Matt says denying the possibility of a romantic bond. "No, I love you in the romantic way!" Natalie then says with a very certain and determined voice and with a very red face. "Oh!" Matt says surprised as he just thinks about everything they went through. They went through a lot and now that Matt sees it that way… he is not really sure what to say. He decides to kiss Natalie on her lips cheek to show he also feels affection.

Natalie has a very huge and genuine smile. She follows it up by also kissing Matt on the lips and she even tries to make it a longer kiss with tongue and all that, and even though she can clearly tell Matt is super inexperienced at kissing, she still enjoys that she can just kiss him. "I am glad to see you two happy, congrats! You two have solved the puzzle of love!" The cat illusion the happily tells them. "Huh, that was quite easy…" Matt says pleasantly surprised. "It was not as easy for me… but I am glad we have it solved now! That we have proven our love might even be a better reward then the wings I am going to get!" Natalie says before giving Matt another kiss, it's like she is unleashing years of romantic excitement.

"So… can Natalie get the berry that gives her wings now?" Matt asks the illusion. "Of course! To perform the ritual the girl needs to eat the berry, you two need to have intercourse and then the wings grow!" Illusion Cat then explains before taking out a little white berry about the size of an apple and handing it to Natalie. "Can you give us an intimate space then?" Natalie then asks as she takes the berry. "Of course! You are in your old hometown! You guys can do it in your old houses! I will create an illusion NoLimbs and play with him while you two do your thing…" Illusion cat then explains to them.

"So… that is really it? We need to have sex? Is there something after Natalie gets wings, something like a puzzle or really strong enemies we need to defeat?" Matt asks the illusion cat, still in disbelief. "The dungeon decided to do it this way because you two would not be challenged by puzzles or fights. At least not in the way of your relationship, Matt would fully trust Natalie's plans in a puzzle and you two would fight in harmony in a battle as well. This confession type obstacle was the most fitting, at least from the dungeons perspective… but considering how much it knows about you two, I can trust the judgement of the dungeon." The illusion cat then explains.

"Thank you very much, this dungeon has truly been a kind experience! Now I am excited to perform the ritual to get wings! Have fun Cat!" Natalie then tells the illusion goodbye before she heads into her old home. "Thanks as well, due to you I get to have sex with one of the prettiest women I know, so… you are pretty cool illusion cat!" Matt also thanks the illusion before heading into the house behind Natalie. Illusion cat smiles knowing she fulfilled her purpose in life, she only lived for a few minutes and yet, she feels satisfied with her life.

She knows what soon happens, she lies onto a nearby patch of grass and looks into the virtual sun. She can sense that Matt and Natalie have an enjoyable time together, even though she tries to feel it as less as possible to respect their privacy. Illusion Cat knows that once they are done with the ritual… they will exit the dungeon and the illusion will disappear, but Cat isn't afraid of her death, since she is going to reform for the next couple that visits this dungeon, who knows what she will be next, maybe a dragon?

Illusion Cat gets pulled out of her thoughts as after a bit Natalie flies out of the window of her little house with a pair of fresh wings. Natalie enjoying her first test flight with these wings through the town while both Illusion Cat and Matt are looking at her flying around. Even though Natalie has been flying for the first time, it looks like she has an entire lifetime of flying experience, Matt and Natalie are not sure whether it is intuition or talent. But they enjoy it anyhow. After she flew for a few minutes, she lands on the floor in front of the illusion of her old house and Cat goes up and creates an archway that leads back outside.

Matt then quickly comes out of the front door of Natalie's house to be with her. "The illusions will fade away soon, so you two better leave soon!" Cat then explains to both of them. Goodbye you two!" Illusion Cat says as she points at the archway she created. "Thank you a lot! I would love to do something to thank you and the dungeon for it's kindness!" Natalie then says happily as she feels her wings with her hands. "You two don't really need to do anything… just be the heroes the dungeon knows you two can be!" Cat says optimistically.

"Well, goodbye then!" Matt says goodbye to the Illusion as he heads through the archway back outside. "Goodbye!" Natalie adds on as she also heads through the archway, Illusion Cat waving them goodbye as she fades away. They both then go onto the raft they took to get to the dungeon and Natalie tells Matt "Thank you for being yourself" before hugging Matt and making out with him as they both have a very safe travel back to the town, ready to take on whatever adventure awaits them next.