Chapter 28
The School Governors

Author's Note: Was considering uploading this tomorrow, but from the response I am already getting concerning Dumbledore in the previous chapter, and reviewers wondering about his part in the future of this story, I decided to post this chapter early. That question will be answered by the end of the chapter (and end-of-chapter Author's Note).

Also, several reviewers commented on why Snape wasn't given Veritaserum after the "revelation" he made. Veritaserum is barred from courtrooms in canon. Fanon seems to love its use, but I'm going with canon in this situation.


Saturday, January 2nd, 1993 – Mid-Afternoon

Minerva McGonagall was currently standing outside of Courtroom One on Level Nine of the Ministry of Magic, where her appointment with the Hogwarts School Governors would be taking place in a matter of minutes. She was waiting to be called into the courtroom. As she waited, she allowed her mind to race with several thoughts.

Only minutes ago, she had been inside Courtroom Ten, as the last of three trials had finished. It had taken less than half-an-hour for the trial to finish, and the Wizengamot to find Severus Snape guilty of all the crimes he had been charged with. It had taken an additional ten minutes for the Wizengamot to decide the appropriate fate for Snape.

Someone had suggested that Snape's history as a prestigious Potions Master could be useful for the Ministry. He could be placed in a high-security holding cell in the Ministry, for a portion of his sentence, and brew Potions for use by the Ministry – Auror Department, and the DMLE, as well as St. Mungo's could all benefit. But the opposition had argued that it was a risk. After all, Snape had a history of brewing illegal Potions and Draughts. The possibility of deliberate sabotage was brought up. Snape could easily create poisons instead of potions. When it was suggested that Snape would simply test any Potion and Draught he made before it was sent off for official use, the opposition said Snape could simply just use the very first Potion he made to kill himself, so he wouldn't have to complete his sentence in Azkaban.

In the end, Snape had been sentenced to fifty years in the maximum security ward of Azkaban Prison. He would be in the same ward as several Death Eaters. Minerva wondered whether or not they'd be happy to see him. Fifty years surrounded by the demons known as Dementors was almost a life sentence. If the prisoners didn't die, they would usually go mad or lose their minds altogether in fifteen years or less. Minerva wasn't sure which fate Severus was doomed to suffer.

Someone else who should have been going to Azkaban for a long time – at least in Minerva's opinion, and probably several others – was Albus Dumbledore. She could not believe he had been cleared of all the charges, especially when it was crystal clear that he was guilty of most if not all the crimes he had been charged with. But Albus Dumbledore was a very popular man, and had many fingers in the pies of certain Wizengamot members – the same people who had obviously helped to clear him of the charges, no matter whether he was guilty or not.

The only silver lining in the cloud was that as soon as word had gotten out that Albus had been arrested, he had been removed from his three prestigious positions of power. This had been done prior to his trial and Minerva was quite sure it didn't matter whether or not Albus was cleared of all charges or found guilty, he wouldn't be able to retain those positions easily. Both the Chief Warlock position and Albus' position in the International Confederation of Warlocks would have other candidates for both positions, and even if Albus could hope to retain those positions, he would have to get enough votes from the Wizengamot and the ICW respectively.

As for the position of Headmaster of Hogwarts – well, Minerva was quite sure that she would be given that title, and when she became Headmistress, she would make sure Albus Dumbledore didn't step foot on Hogwarts Grounds anytime soon for any reason. It didn't matter whether or not the Wizengamot had cleared Albus of all charges, Minerva knew that Albus was guilty of plenty, including crimes toward Harry Potter and Hermione Granger. She would do her best to make sure Albus never got near her Lions ever again.

But she also knew she wouldn't be alone in that endeavor. Harry Potter's godfather, Sirius Black, was now a free man. Minerva had good reason to believe that Sirius would do anything to make sure Harry was protected, and because Hermione Granger was so close to Harry, then Sirius would probably do the same for her, and perhaps those who Harry was betrothed to as well. But first, Sirius would have to be treated at St. Mungo's to make sure he was one-hundred percent healthy.

Although Sirius hadn't spoken to her yet, Minerva knew that he would likely want to meet Harry sooner rather than later, probably even before he started his treatments at St. Mungo's. She would allow it, if Harry wanted it. She would also speak to Remus Lupin about Sirius when she would interview him for her replacement as the Transfiguration post. He would likely be able to help her with that.

Of course, before she could even interview Remus Lupin and Andromeda Tonks – both of whom were planning to meet her at Hogwarts after her meeting with the Board of Governors – she would need to officially be named as the Headmistress. But she figured that was likely going to happen. Who would they assign to that position aside from her? There was nobody more qualified, as far as she knew.

As Minerva pondered, the doors to Courtroom One opened, seemingly on their own. She walked into the room and found a dozen witches and wizards seated where the Wizengamot usually sat for hearings, trials and council sessions. Minerva knew these were the Hogwarts School Governors. She recognized several as parents or guardians of Hogwarts students, including Augusta Longbottom, Braddock Brown and Lucius Malfoy among others. Augusta was sitting in the very center, with Malfoy seated to her right.

"Greetings, Minerva," Augusta said, then motioned to a single chair and table at the center-left area in front of the Governors. "Please be seated."

Minerva nodded once and strode forward, then sat down in the offered chair. Suddenly, she heard footsteps behind her, and looked over her shoulder, then narrowed her eyes at what she saw. Albus Dumbledore had entered the room.

"Albus," Augusta said, "This is a most unexpected visit."

"When Minister Fudge informed me of a meeting between the Hogwarts Governors and Professor McGonagall," Albus said, smiling lightly at Minerva as he said her name; Minerva did not respond. "I couldn't help but decide to attend."

"Are you here to offer your support for Minerva as Hogwarts Headmistress, Albus?" Augusta asked.

"While I am sure Minerva could be an excellent Headmistress," Albus said, "That is not why I am here. I am actually here to possibly convince you and your fellow Governors to return the title of Hogwarts Headmaster to me."

"You were removed from that position, Dumbledore," Lucius Malfoy said, "That is why we're here, after all. To decide whether Minerva is worthy as your successor."

"I was, indeed, removed," Albus said, "after I was arrested. But as everyone here knows, since you were all present at my trial this morning, I was cleared of all charges. I believe many of you helped with that, so I give you my most sincere gratitude. I am not here to outright demand that you give me the position of Headmaster back, no. I'm simply asking you to consider it. If you decide Minerva will take the position instead, I will hold no grudges. All I ask is for a chance to attempt to reclaim my position."

"Are there any objections?" Augusta asked her fellow Governors.

Minerva frowned when nobody raised their hand or voiced any objections. She hoped that didn't mean that they had already decided Albus should retain the title of Headmaster. Well, if some of them were thinking that way, so be it! Minerva would just have to fight for the position, and she knew just how to do it! Albus would regret ever walking into the courtroom!

"Very well, Albus," Augusta said, "Your name is now in the running for the title of Head of Hogwarts. Please be seated."

Augusta conjured a chair a few feet away from Minerva. Albus thanked her and sat down.

"So begins today's meeting of the Hogwarts School Governors," Augusta said, "It is the second day of January in the year nineteen ninety-three. We are here to decide whether Minerva McGonagall or Albus Dumbledore is worthy of being the Headmaster, or Headmistress, of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Representatives of the Hogwarts School Governors in attendance, please introduce yourselves for the record. I am Augusta Francesca Longbottom, Regent Lady of the Ancient and Most Noble House of Longbottom."

As the rest of the Hogwarts School Governors introduced themselves, Minerva prepared herself mentally. She had thought that she might have some opposition for the title of Head of Hogwarts, that one of the Governors might have had a candidate. She wouldn't have put it past Lucius Malfoy to have named a candidate from his circle of friends, most of which likely had little to no experience in education, and he simply would have named them just so he could obtain some power at Hogwarts. She hadn't been prepared for Albus to be her opposition, however. But that small complication would not hinder her. If Albus wanted his position back, he would have to fight for it!

"Do any of the Governors have any other candidates for the position of Head of Hogwarts?" Augusta asked, after the Governors introduced themselves. "Governor Malfoy, I believe you had talked about a possible candidate?"

Malfoy's lips thinned. "I had chosen Severus Snape as a possible candidate. But, as we know, he is no longer available for candidacy."

Minerva huffed under her breath. Of course Malfoy would have offered Severus up for candidacy for the position. She thanked the heavens that the man was now in Azkaban. There was nobody less qualified for the position of Headmaster than Severus Snape, especially due to his total lack of respect and care for the students of Hogwarts – aside from, perhaps, the Slytherins.

Nobody else made any offers for other possible candidates, so Augusta continued.

"Very well," she said, "Because there are two candidates, we will begin with opening statements, then move onto a series of questions. Albus, as you are hoping to retain your position, you will go first."

Albus moved back to his feet. "Thank you, Governor Longbottom. As you're all likely aware, these past three days have been quite the trial for myself, no pun intended. Madam Amelia Bones, and Auror Alastor Moody made an unfortunate mistake when they arrested me on New Year's Eve, and I forgive them for that mistake. Unfortunately, that mistake cost me greatly. I was removed from, not only the position of Hogwarts Headmaster, but also removed from my position of Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot, and my seat in the International Confederation of Warlocks. All because of an unfortunate mistake. If it wasn't for such a mistake, this meeting wouldn't be taking place because I would still be the Headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry.

"Forgive me if I repeat myself here. As most of you standing before me are members of the Wizengamot, I'm sure you're aware that I was, in fact, cleared of all the charges I was arrested for. Therefore, I cannot see why my removal as Headmaster of Hogwarts should still stand.

"If you are searching for one specific reason why you should return the position to me, it is this. You are, I am sure, aware of my reputation. Many have said that I am the only one... You-Know-Who has ever feared. Whether or not that is true, is not the issue here. I firmly believe that it is because of that belief why Hogwarts has survived and thrived during my tenure, not only in the harsh Troubles our society has dealt with, but during the many years after the Troubles ended. Because no one would dare threaten or attack Hogwarts while I am in charge. It is this belief that has protected the students – your children, and children of our society – during their time at Hogwarts, for so many years."

Minerva raised an eyebrow. She couldn't believe Albus had dared to say that. Wouldn't the issues with the Philosopher's Stone, Quirinus Quirrel, and the Chamber of Secrets be labeled under that category. Then she realized. Exactly how much did the School Governors know about these issues? Amelia Bones had certainly been surprised when hearing about those issues. What if Albus had made sure the Governors hadn't heard anything about the threats to Hogwarts? What if he had even taken lengths to make sure the children of the Governors didn't inform their parents, or guardians, either?

Well, if that was true, then Minerva could use those threats as a weapon against Albus. But as she thought about this, she realized something. The human culprit of the Chamber of Secrets still hadn't been caught. What if one of the Governor's students was the culprit? What if the Governor was well aware of the threat, because they had something to do with it? Minerva decided then that she would inform the Governors of the Philosopher's Stone ordeal, and the issue with Quirinus Quirrel, but she wouldn't mention the Chamber of Secrets. Just as a caution.

"I have been one of the longest-running Headmasters of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry," Albus continued, "There must be reasons behind that, am I correct? Think about those reasons, as you decide who you will name as the Head of such a fine institution as Hogwarts. Thank you."

"Thank you, Albus," Augusta said, as Albus sat back down in his chair, "Minerva? Please give your opening statement."

Minerva stood up and cleared her throat. "Governors, I thank you for meeting with me on such short notice. Many years ago, I entered Hogwarts as each of you did at one point in time – as a student. A young, eleven year old witch, eager to learn and prove myself. The Sorting Hat placed me in Gryffindor House, and ever since that day I have made sure to honor the beliefs and ideals of Godric Gryffindor himself. I was one of the top students of the year in each and every one of the years I attended as a student. In my third year, I became a Chaser for the House Quidditch Team, and won two championships during my time. In my fifth year, I was made prefect. In my seventh year, I became the Head Girl.

"Years later, after experiencing life and the trials that come with it, including my fair share of triumphs and tragedies, I returned to Hogwarts, where I became the Transfiguration Professor. A few years later, I was named the Head of Gryffindor House, which I consider a very proud achievement in my life. Albus then named me the Deputy Headmistress, which is also a great honor.

"As Transfiguration Professor I taught many of you seated in front of me. I'm sure you all have your opinions of me, and – for those whom I had the privilege to teach – memories of my classes and lessons, whether good or bad. I love teaching. It is one of the greatest loves of my life. So retiring from teaching to become the Headmistress of Hogwarts is, admittedly, a tough move. But that should tell you that it is a decision I wouldn't have made without some long and deep thought about it.

"Now, even though I am happy to say that I am a true Gryffindor Lion, I also feel as if I represent all four Houses of Hogwarts in many ways. Knowing that I toot my own horn, I believe I am as intelligent as your average Ravenclaw, as loyal and hard-working as many Hufflepuffs, and – as much as I loathe to admit – I find myself to be as sly and cunning as a member of Slytherin House. If the best choice for Head of Hogwarts would be someone who perfectly represents all four Houses of Hogwarts, and Hogwarts itself, then I believe I can safely say I qualify.

"Perhaps you're looking for other reasons why I believe I am best suited for the role. If so, then I would answer with this. As Deputy Headmistress, I suppose you could call me the 'substitute Headmistress'. Sometimes, when Albus has been away from Hogwarts for whatever reason, he placed me in charge of the duties of Headmaster. I was essentially the Headmistress when he was away. So I can safely say I've had plenty of practice for the role. Will I be better at the role than Albus? I suppose we'll just have to wait and see."

"Thank you, Minerva," Augusta said, "We will now move onto questions from the Governors. Governors, each of you can ask one question – as well as follow-up questions which form from the answer to your original question. It will be your choice whether one or both candidates has to answer your question. You may also ask one follow-up question for any answers the candidates will give when asking questions from other Governors. Does everyone understand?"

There were nods from every Governor, indicating they understood.

"Very well," Augusta said, "I will begin. This is an answer for both candidates, but I will begin with Minerva. Minerva, if you become Headmistress, then at least two posts for Professors will be empty. Two important positions - Transfiguration and Potions. These two classes are taught to students in every single year at Hogwarts, and are highly important subjects, especially when it comes to OWL and NEWT exams. The next term of classes begin Monday. So my question, Minerva, is this. If you are chosen as Headmistress, do you believe you can hire two new Professors capable of teaching such important classes without causing too much delay in lessons to the point where there will be little to no interference when it comes to student education?"

"I do, Governor Longbottom," Minerva said, "In fact I already have two possible candidates, one for each position. I have spoken to both, and both are available and eager to take their respective positions. If I become Headmistress, my first task in the role will be to interview both candidates for the job before the end of the day."

"Who, may I ask, are the candidates?" Augusta asked.

"Andromeda Tonks has offered to take the role of Potions Mistress," Minerva said, "I've had several recommendations for her as a possible candidate. She has already promised to resign from her role of Healer at St. Mungo's if she takes on the job. I believe she is highly qualified, and I have high hopes that she will be the new Potions Mistress. As for Transfiguration, I have been in contact with Remus Lupin."

Lucius Malfoy almost immediately rose his hand.

"Governor Malfoy?" Augusta asked, "You have a follow-up question?"

Lucius nodded once and looked at Minerva. "Minerva, I believe most, if not everyone present in this room know that Remus Lupin is a werewolf. I'm sure you're also aware of this. Are you certain that Lupin is a worthy candidate for the position? His... infliction... is certainly a threat against the students of Hogwarts."

"Governor Malfoy," Minerva said, "As you may be aware, Remus Lupin was a student at Hogwarts. He was inflicted with lycanthropy years before he came to Hogwarts, and Albus was generous enough to accept him as a student. The Ministry, and the School Governors, were well aware of this, and they accepted Albus' decision. On Full Moons, Remus was taken to the building known as the Shrieking Shack, where he spent the nights in his wolf form, safely tucked away from the students, even without the aid of Wolfsbane.

"If Remus becomes the Transfiguration Professor, I would make sure that he would be away from students on Full Moons. I will also make sure he has a the required dosage of Wolfsbane Potion every month. On those days where his infliction restricts him from being able to teach, I would be happy to be a substitute. If I am unavailable, I can find a substitute. Andromeda Tonks' daughter, Nymphadora, has also offered to put her name in the candidacy for the Transfiguration Post if I could not find a better candidate. Because she is so young, I am not comfortable with making her the permanent Transfiguration Professor, but I would hire her as a substitute, or in an Apprentice role for the post. I have no doubts that Remus Lupin will be a worthy Professor."

"Does that answer suffice, Governor Malfoy?" Augusta asked.

Lucius' lips thinned, but he gave a short nod.

"Very well, "Augusta said, "Are there any more follow-up questions for Minerva's answer?"

There were none, so Augusta continued. "Thank you, Minerva. Albus, same question."

"If I retain my role as Headmaster," Albus said, "I believe Minerva would be alright with returning to her role of Transfiguration Professor."

He glanced at Minerva, who gave no response. Of course, she would be alright with that, but she hoped it wouldn't happen because she would be Headmistress instead.

"Minerva's suggestion of Andromeda Tonks as Potions Mistress is a fine one," Albus continued, "I'd be happy to hire her. If she is unworthy, then I am quite sure I can persuade Horace Slughorn to return to his former post."

"Are there any more follow-up questions to my question?" Augusta asked; there were none; "Very well. Governor Malfoy, you have the floor for the next question."

"My question is for both candidates," Malfoy said, "Albus, I ask that you answer first. If you were in my position here, and you decided not to vote for Minerva, what would be your reasons for not doing so?"

"Minerva is a fine Transfiguration Professor," Albus said, "She is one of the more popular teachers at Hogwarts. Students enjoy her classes. As Headmistress, she wouldn't be able to teach very often, and I'd feel hard-pressed to take such a fine teacher away from students. She is also the Head of Gryffindor, and an avid supporter of the Gryffindor Quidditch Team. I would have difficulty believing she could put away such bias for Gryffindor to be support the rest of the student body.

"However, even though her teaching is well-liked, I have my doubts. Even though she is the Head of Gryffindor, I had noticed her lack in leadership toward the Gryffindors. The other Heads of House took time out of their days to speak to the students in their House as a whole at least once or twice a week. I cannot say I've noticed this behavior when it came to Minerva. Students will come to her when they do not wish to go to Prefects, the Head Students or other Professors, and I'm not exactly sure she is ready to handle that. Or perhaps it is that students are not ready to come to her when she becomes Headmistress."

"Follow-up questions?" Augusta asked, when Albus indicated he was done.

"Albus makes a good argument, Minerva," Pascal Parkinson – whose daughter, Pansy, was currently in her second year at Hogwarts – said, "Care to defend yourself against it?"

"I admit that I could have done a better job as Head of Gryffindor," Minerva said, "I had three official roles – Transfiguration Professor. Deputy Headmistress, as well as Head of Gryffindor. I was having difficulty finding time to myself when juggling my time around those roles. However, as Headmistress, I would only have that one role, however widespread it would be. I believe I would find plenty of time to lend support to students when they need it.

"As for Albus' accusation of personal bias toward Gryffindor, I think the only bias I have is for the Gryffindor Quidditch team – Albus was correct to say I am an avid supporter. Would I root for them during their matches? Yes, I would. I believe most who would sit here before you would say the same. There is a common history of students, former or current, whose loyalty for their Hogwarts House reaches far beyond their time as students.

"But I would not focus on the Gryffindors more than the rest of the students for everyday issues. I'd lend my ears to any and all students who need my help or simply a shoulder to cry on. I'd show no bias when it comes to help or punishments. The same could be said for the points system. I would be fair when giving and taking points to and from all students."

"Any more follow-up questions?" Augusta asked; there were none. "Governor Malfoy?"

"Thank you, Albus," Malfoy said, "Minerva, same question."

Minerva smiled privately. She had been waiting for this question. It was time to cause a lot of problems for Albus Dumbledore.

"I would most certainly not support Albus for Headmaster if I was in your position, Governor Malfoy," she said, "And here is why. I happen to know that Albus was not entirely honest during his opening statement."

She smirked softly as Albus looked at her with raised eyebrows.

"In his opening statement," Minerva continued, "Albus stated, and I quote 'no one would dare threaten or attack Hogwarts' while he was in charge. I have evidence that proves that is not true at all."

Albus looked mildly shocked for mere moments before he glared at her.

"When Albus stated this," Minerva continued, "I was surprised. I wondered why he would say such things in front of the School Governors who surely would know better. Unless the School Governors did not know better simply because Albus made sure they didn't. I'm sure most of you remember the attempted theft at Gringotts at the end of July in 1991? The thief had attempted to steal an artifact from a vault, but the vault had been emptied earlier the same day. The artifact was Nicolas Flamel's Philosopher's Stone. It had been retrieved by Rubeus Hagrid on Albus' orders. Hagrid brought the Stone to Hogwarts.

"I did not learn that the Stone was at Hogwarts until June of last year. I did know there was an apparent artifact of some kind at Hogwarts, and that it was targeted by dangerous folk. How? Albus told me, and some of my fellow staff members. He asked us to build obstacles of sorts, protections that would guard the artifact. The artifact would be at Hogwarts in the secure third floor corridor, which students were told was off-limits."

"Wait," Augusta said, "A dangerous artifact – the Philosopher's Stone – was at Hogwarts, when there was intelligence that it was being targeted by dangerous folks? And yet it was kept there when there were hundreds of students there for months on end?"

"Yes, ma'am," Minerva said.

"And you didn't inform this council before now?" Augusta asked.

"I was under the impression that Albus had already informed you of it," Minerva said, "But it appears he did not."

"In my defense," Albus said, "I did not know who exactly was targeting the Stone. I did not want to parade around the information and risk placing it in the wrong hands."

"Be that as it may," Augusta said, "You still placed a dangerous artifact at Hogwarts where students were staying day and night. Our children, Albus."

"If I may continue," Minerva said, "On Halloween in 1991, a troll invaded Hogwarts. Someone had let it in, as an obvious decoy in hopes that the distraction would give them time to attempt to get the artifact. On that evening, a student – Hermione Granger – was in a bathroom. The troll went to the same bathroom, and Miss Granger would have been harmed or even killed had Harry Potter not rescued her. Mr. Potter defeated the troll himself and saved Miss Granger."

"Harry Potter defeated a troll on his own?" Malfoy asked, doubt marring his tone.

"Yes," Minerva said, simply. "As I understand it, he levitated the club the troll was using over its head, and knocked it out with it. The following day, the first Quidditch match of the year took place – Gryffindor versus Slytherin. Harry Potter was the Gryffindor Seeker. During the match, someone attempted to jinx Mr. Potter's broom, in an attempt to knock him off it. Luckily, that crisis was averted. Harry was just fine.

"Then in June of last year, Albus was called to the Ministry of Magic for an urgent meeting. In all actuality, the letter he had received was fake, in a successful attempt to lure him out of the castle. The same person who had brought in the troll on that Halloween, and attempted to jinx Mr. Potter's broom, had found an opportunity to go after the stone.

"Luckily, someone went after him. Three people did. But it wasn't Albus or any of the staff. Mr. Potter, and two other students - all three of whom were first years - attempted to rescue the artifact. They got past the obstacles we had set, and Mr. Potter confronted the bad guy, who turned out to be Quirinus Quirrel, who was the Defense Professor that year."

"So let me get this straight," Augusta said, "The Defense Professor - someone you hired, Albus - was behind these series of attacks, and behind the attempt to steal the Philosopher's Stone? And nobody knew this?"

"He was on my list of suspects, of course," Albus said, "I did realize it was him before it was too late. Halfway into my trip to the Ministry, a message was sent to me and I was able to return. Mr. Potter had confronted Quirrel by the time I got there. Fortunately, I was able to stop Quirrel and saved Mr. Potter."

"I have a question," Braddock Brown said, "How were three first year students able to get past the defenses the staff had set up?"

"Mr. Potter and his friends seemed well-adapted to the obstacles, I admit," Minerva said, "I cannot say how. But as I understand it, the initial door to begin the obstacles had been opened with a simple Unlocking Charm students usually learn in their first year. I am befuddled how that happened, because I distinctly remember myself and the staff creating obstacles much more difficult than any first year could perform. I can only assume they were somehow modified without my knowledge."

"I, too, had questioned how Mr. Potter and his friends were able to get past the obstacles," Albus said, "I may have an answer, however, though I only came up with it as recently as only hours ago. Severus Snape's confession that he had manipulated me seems curious. At the time of the incidents, I had believed that Severus was attempting to thwart Quirrel, and stop him from getting the artifact. Now I have reason to believe he may have been assisting Quirrel. It is possible he had altered the obstacles so Quirrel could pass them by without much difficulty. He did not attempt to steal the Stone, simply because it would send suspicions his way. Instead, he let Quirrel do it. It is interesting to note that the caretaker, Argus Filch, did once inform me that he witnessed Severus and Quirrel speaking with each other as if they were old friends. Perhaps Filch had caught them collaborating to steal the Stone?"

"Be that as it may, Albus," Augusta said, "I have to wonder why we had to hear this from Minerva, and not yourself. As Minerva said, you told us Hogwarts was safe during your tenure. We have undeniable evidence here that tells us the exact opposite."

"My only answer is that it was an old man's mistake," Albus said.

"An old man's mistake," Pascal Parkinson echoed with a sneer. "Can we expect more mistakes from you, old man, if we decide to give you back your position as Headmaster?"

"I would strive to make sure my mistakes are few and far in between, Governor Parkinson," Albus said, "And to make sure that the students of Hogwarts are not affected by them."

Minerva privately smiled. She believed she had done quite well to cast doubt against Albus. Which was, of course, exactly what she had intended to do.

"I think we'll move onto the next question," Augusta said, "Governor Parkinson?"

Over the next half-hour, Minerva and Albus answered several more questions from each of the Governors. After the revelation Minerva had given concerning Albus and the threats involving Quirrel and the Philosopher's Stone, it appeared that a few of the Governors had changed their questions from their original intentions. Several of the Governors were concerned with what else Albus had kept from them, and their questions were basically attacking him causing Albus to verbally defend himself.

Other questions, those targeting Minerva, consisted of asking for her opinions on various teachers, and other goings-on at Hogwarts. She gave good opinions on a few of the Professors, but there were other members of the staff, like Sybil Trelawney, and the ghostly Cuthbert Binns, who either she personally did not exactly approve of, or other students had complained about. Also, while she liked Charity Burbage, she had discussed the dire need of improving the curriculum of Muggle Studies to teach more modern subjects.

One of the questions targeted at Minerva asked how she would improve Quidditch at Hogwarts. This was asked by a Governor with the surname of Wood, and Minerva deduced he was likely Oliver Wood's father. Obviously Oliver had complained to his father about the Slytherin team getting better brooms than the other teams. Minerva promised, among other things, that she would work toward making sure all four teams had equal advantage when it came to broomsticks.

Finally, there was one last question from Braddock Brown.

"Minerva, this last question is just for you," he said, "It appears that Hogwarts is in dire need of some necessary changes. If you were appointed Headmistress, what would you change?"

"That is question that has multiple answers, so I hope you allow me the time to discuss them all," Minerva said, "The first would be the curriculum, I've already discussed certain subjects which I feel needs improvement, and as Headmistress, I would do my best to work on these improvements during the summer holidays, whether it means simply changing curriculum or firing staff members, and hiring new ones altogether. I would also look into adding new classes altogether. Once upon a time, there were nearly twice the number of class options at Hogwarts than there are today. I will take my ideas to both the School Governors and the Hogwarts staff. Also, I might even ask for suggestions from students to see what subjects they might approve of."

Minerva smiled lightly when she noticed the looks of approval from several Governors. Even Albus couldn't hide his mild look of approval, however, she also detected stress from him too. She knew he didn't approve of firing certain Professors. Albus seemed to like Trelawney and Binns for reasons Minerva couldn't fathom. But his opinion wouldn't matter if she was made Headmistress.

Minerva wasn't nearly finished yet. She took a momentary breather, then continued.

"If I am Headmistress, I plan to also improve and enforce various rules which have been almost ignored in the past. For example, bullying – whether it be physical or verbal – will be met with swift and necessary punishment which fits the crime. Insults such as the word 'Mudblood' falls under this category. Also, in the past, there has been history of unfairness when docking or giving House points. All decisions on House points will be reviewed at the end of each day. Detentions will also be reviewed in the same way – if a detention was given to a student who didn't deserve one, it will be discovered with a new system.

"Also, students will be encouraged to talk to me, as Headmistress, about any complaints they may have about staff members, or Prefects. If they believe staff members or Prefects have done something they disapprove of, all complaints will be heard, and the serious ones will be dealt with swiftly."

Minerva indicated she was finished.

"Any follow-up questions?" Augusta asked; she raised her eyebrows when a few of the Governors raised their hands, "Governor Malfoy?"

"Minerva, you said that the students would be able to speak to you about any complaints they may have about staff members," Malfoy said, "What about those students who will have complaints about you?"

"They could take it to the Deputy Headmistress who I choose as my successor," Minerva said, "Or other members of the staff."

"Governor Parkinson?" Augusta asked.

"You said the serious complaints will be dealt with," Parkinson said, "What do you deem as serious?"

"Those complaints I don't find childish or ridiculous," Minerva said, "For example, if a student is fairly docked points, or given a detention they deserve, and they don't happen to like it, I'm sure they will complain about the staff member responsible for it. I would label that as a 'childish complaint' - complaining simply because they don't like getting punished deservedly for something they did."

"Governor Brown?" Augusta asked.

"Could you follow up on your ideas for additional classes, Minerva?" Brown asked.

"I think those can wait until the summer holidays," Minerva said, smiling softly, "None of the successfully implemented ideas would affect this school year. They would begin next school year in September. I would dedicate much of the summer holidays to discussing such topics with the School Governors, of course, and we can work together to decide what would be best for Hogwarts and its students when it comes to curriculum. If I am made Headmistress, of course."

Minerva grinned privately when she noticed impressed looks among the former Slytherins. Obviously they thought her answer was very Slytherin for such an avid Gryffindor. She knew her answer was sly, but she wasn't going to give away things unless she was made Headmistress. That was an extra incentive for voting for her.

After that, none of the other Governors had any more follow-up questions.

"I believe that is the end of the questions," Augusta said, "I do believe we have heard enough to make our vote. We will take a five-minute recess so the Governors can make their final decisions, then there will be a silent vote to decide who will be the Head of Hogwarts."

Minerva relaxed in her chair as she waited. If Albus had any intention to speak to her, he had apparently decided against it. At least for now, until the Governors' decision was made. She had expected Augusta to ask her and Albus to make closing statements, but she figured it was no big deal that Augusta hadn't done so. Most of what she would say in a closing statement would consist of things she had already said, and she didn't want to repeat herself.

Minerva reviewed the speeches she had made over the past hour. While she was confident that she had several votes going to her, she wasn't sure if it was enough. After all, over half of the Governors had all voted to clear Albus of all charges during his trial. Which meant they were either his allies, or supported him. Would they vote for him to retain his position as Headmaster, ignoring all the points she had made about his wrongdoings during his tenure as Headmaster? After all, it appeared they had ignored the obvious crimes Albus had been guilty of, when there was clear evidence of his guilt. Their loyalty to him had overridden their sense of justice. Would their loyalty cause them to vote for him here?

It was a tense five minutes before Augusta cleared her throat loudly.

"We will now cast our votes," she said, "Once again, the votes will be silent. Governors, you have slips of parchment in front of you. Write down your decision for Head of Hogwarts and pass them to me."

It took about a minute for everyone to finish their votes which they passed to Augusta, who had also made her own vote. As soon as everyone had voted, Augusta looked through each vote, obviously counting to herself.

"As decided by the Hogwarts School Governors on this, the second of January, in the year nineteen ninety-three," she said, "by a vote of eight to four, the Head of Hogwarts is... Minerva McGonagall."

Minerva gave a sigh of relief, privately cheering and congratulating herself. Meanwhile, Albus' mouth was twitching and it was hard to note whether he was trying to smile, frown, or do something else.

"Congratulations, Headmistress McGonagall," Augusta said, "If you will remain here for a few minutes, we will discuss some immediate issues, concerns, and address any questions you may have. Albus, you may be excused."

Albus stood up, then turned and proceeded to leave the courtroom without a word to Minerva or the Governors.

Over the next few minutes, Minerva and the School Governors discussed issues that needed immediate attention, such as the various improvements of rules Minerva had discussed. The Governors also discussed other rules that could be added. Some suggestions of rules were voted upon and made official, while other suggestions were disapproved. Minerva promised she would inform the student body the following evening of the new and improved rules.

"Finally," Augusta said, "I have one last issue to address. There is no reason to believe you are in trouble, or that this is anything negative. However, for the first month of your tenure as Headmistress, you should consider yourself on probation."

"Probation, Governor Longbottom?" Minerva asked, mildly shocked at this decision.

"An official term," Augusta said, "Perhaps one that is too serious in definition. Basically for the next month, you will be sent weekly letters with questions you will be required to answer truthfully – you will be asked to write it with an Honor Quill we give you."

Minerva raised her eyebrows. With an Honor Quill, she would have no choice but to answer all questions honestly.

"These questions will have to do with your performance," Augusta continued, "A review, or sorts. If we Governors believe you are not performing as expected, your probation will extend for another month, and one of us will be at Hogwarts to witness your day-to-day performances as Headmistress. We would also get the opinions from staff and students about your performance, if it is necessary. As long as you perform well, you shouldn't worry too much. Frankly, this is just cautionary. If your answers to the questions were any indication, I believe you'll be a wonderful Headmistress."

"I very much hope so," Minerva said.

"If you have no questions, I believe we can call this meeting to a close," Augusta said.

"I have no questions," Minerva said, "I would just like to thank you all for this privilege."

"You're very welcome," Augusta said, "You may be excused."

Minerva nodded, said farewell, and another thanks, then headed out of the Courtroom. Unsurprisingly, Albus was waiting for her.

"Headmistress," Albus said, with a small smile, "Congratulations on a well-fought victory in there."

"Thank you, Albus," Minerva said, "I believe it is necessary that I apologize for some of the things I said in there. Informing the Governors of the issues with Quirrel and the Philosopher's Stone may have been an unfair move on my part."

"No apology necessary," Albus said, "It was a fine strategy. I was just curious, and admittedly relieved, that you didn't discuss the Chamber of Secrets fiasco in there."

"I did it for a reason," Minerva said, "I, as well as Madam Bones, and Auror Moody, have reason to believe there is a human threat still at large – it could be a student, or an outside source. I didn't want to risk the possibility that one of the Governors is the culprit."

"Discussing the topic would have alerted the culprit if there was one," Albus said, nodding, "A wise idea to leave that out. I must admit there is a reason I am here to speak with you. I have realized I have several possessions of mine at Hogwarts that need to be removed since I no longer have a position there. I was hoping I could accompany you as you return to the castle."

"That will not be necessary," Minerva said, "I can have one or more of the House-Elves pack up your belongings. I will send them to Aberforth at the Hog's Head. You can pick up your belongings there in a few hours."

Albus frowned. "You would not let an old man visit Hogwarts for one last time to say goodbye to the old castle? It was like a home to me, you know."

Minerva did her best not to roll her eyes. She knew Albus had ulterior motives for going to Hogwarts, which he wasn't keen on discussing with her. She wasn't going to risk Albus getting anywhere near Harry Potter or Hermione Granger.

"I am sorry, Albus," Minerva said, "I am going to be very busy between now and tomorrow evening, and I have no time to arrange a visit to an outsider. Perhaps another time."

Albus' lips turned into a frown at the term 'outsider'. Then he nodded. "Very well, Minerva. I will leave you to continue your busy day. Congratulations again."

"Thank you, Albus," Minerva said.

Albus bowed slightly to her then walked off in the direction of the lifts. Minerva remained where she was for a couple minutes, so she wouldn't have to join Albus in the lifts. Then she made her way to the lifts. She needed to meet with Amelia Bones, so she could arrange for the DMLE, Aurors and Unspeakables to visit on Sunday, in hopes to put an end to the Chamber of Secrets fiasco once and for all. Then she would head back to Hogwarts to begin her tenure as Headmistress.


Chapter finished! How did you like that chapter? How did you like the answers Minerva gave to the questions? What did you think about the Governors? Was the Governors' decision too predictable? What did you think about the last discussion between Minerva and Albus?

I'm sure there are some readers who are rather disappointed I kept some parts of the chapter to summaries, perhaps even the section where the Governors were questioning Albus, and he had to defend himself. I might publish some deleted scenes for the stories, and will add that in later (even though I have not written that yet... so it is more like a 'bonus scene' instead of 'deleted').

This chapter provided a lot of hints to what is going to happen in this story when it comes to the future of Hogwarts. A lot of exciting things will happen when it comes to that!

Aside from Lucius Malfoy, there is no official information on who is part of the Board of Governors. I know it might seem odd that someone like Augusta Longbottom, a formidable witch in her own right, is a part of the Board of Governors given that, as mentioned in canon, Lucius Malfoy threatened all the members to decide to suspend Dumbledore. But she seemed like a good possible member of the Board. Also, if she was a part of the Board, I think she'd be a leadership position in it. So that is why she was in charge instead of Malfoy.

Originally the meeting with the School Governors was only supposed to take like... half of this chapter. I didn't expect it to be so long. Of course, originally, Albus had little, or nothing to do with the Governors meeting Minerva. But I really liked what I did here. When Albus got thrown into the mix, it made the focus on the meeting much more important.

For those wondering what is going to happen to Dumbledore now. Well... it is entirely possible he'll take a leave of absence from the story for a while. After all, he has been ceremoniously removed from Hogwarts with no official reason to be there anymore. The story will be focusing on Hogwarts, Harry, Hermione, and other things for a while. But Dumbledore will return... and with a vengeance!

Next chapter: Amelia Bones meets with Sirius, as well as Minerva.

Wow that was a long author's note. Sorry! Hope you liked the chapter!