"Bella" enters South Park.
"Bella": Okay. All I have to do is regain everyone's trust and everything back to normal. Just like what Butters' Grandma told me.
She starts walking all over the town until she spotted the school and headed towards it.
"Bella": Here goes nothing.
She enters the school.
Later at the 4th Grade Classroom...
Mr. Garrison: Alright, class. Today, we have a new student joining us. So please welcome, Bella Jones.
"Bella" entered the classroom.
"Bella": Um...
Damien: Is there something wrong with the new girl?
Scott M: I'm not sure. She's probably shy.
Mr. Garrison: Come on, Bella. Don't be shy.
"Bella": H-h-hi... I'm Bella... And I'm originally from... Denver. I like drawing, p-p-posting pictures of myself on th-th-the internet and... and... That's all.
Mr. Garrison: Okay... go ahead and take your seat.
"Bella" headed towards Butters' old desk.
Pip: Bella, I'm not trying to be mean, but you shouldn't sit in that desk.
"Bella": Why?
Nichole: It's because Butters, who is our recently deceased classmate, used to sit there.
"Bella": What? Deceased?
Tweek: Yeah. He died a little while back.
"Bella": Well, how did he die?
Cartman: Some stupid bitch named Nelly attacked him. That's how he died.
"Bella" was angry when Cartman called her that.
"Bella": (While trying to keep her anger under control): Tell me. How did she attack him?
Wendy: She made a fake account out of him on Twitter and turned everyone against him. After she was busted, she went insane and assaulted him. He tragically died in the hospital an hour later.
"Bella" then felt terrible over what happened during the events of "Nelly's Revenge Gone Wrong".
"Bella": Do you think maybe that Nelly girl didn't mean to do it and wanted to make things right?
Bebe: Make things right?! We told you the story about how she killed our friend and you said she wanted to make things right?! She's in juvie! She's never coming back even if she apologized for killing him!
Annie: Nelly is a Nono!
She was out of the hospital after getting her tongue separated from the pole.
Red: You got that right, Annie! I fucking hate that bitch!
"Bella" was starting to get angry over the 4th graders insulting her.
Nichole: That racist bitch should die in a fire for all I care! Saying the N word at that laser tag facility. Who the fuck does she think she is?!
Pip: I will never forgive that whore for what she did to him and for ruining our weekend together with Dougie!
Cartman: I hated it when she called me a fat fuck! I'm not fat! I'm thicc! Thicc! T-h-i-c-c!
Scott M: She always made fun of my diabetes! And she scared me a lot!
Damien: I wish I could go into that jail cell and execute her myself!
Lola: I hope that bitch rots in jail for the rest of her fucking ass life!
Angela: I WISH THAT BUTTERBEAR KILLER GOT ABORTED!!!
Everyone gave Angela angry glares.
Angela: What? She killed my sweetie!
Jenny: Retard, he dated Charlotte before his death! Plus, that was messed up!
Damien: I wonder how she's feeling.
In Canada, Charlotte was in her bed crying over the death of her boyfriend.
Charlotte's Dad: Charlotte, are you okay in there?
Charlotte: No I'm not! I miss Butters!
She continues crying harder while her face was on her pillow.
Back in the 4th Grade classroom...
Stan: Look, Bella. There's another empty seat next to Daniel. Go sit there.
"Bella" approached the seat. She begins to cry after all the hurtful insults everyone said about her while nobody knew her real identity. Tears started coming out of her eyes and Daniel noticed her.
Daniel: Um, is there something wrong?
"Bella": No! I mean no. I'm fine.
Daniel: I literally saw you about to cry. Are you sure you're okay?
"Bella": Yes. I'm fine! Just leave me alone!
Daniel: Okay. Geez! I was just worried about you. That's all.
"Bella": Don't be. I'll be fine. (Thinking) Those assholes don't even know it's me. All I have to do is earn their trust and I'll finally be back in the girls group. But I can't ditch the look or my plan tomake things right will be ruined! Okay, I just remember what Butters' grandma told me and maybe I'll be accepted by my old friends again.
Mr. Garrison: Bella, are you paying attention?
"Bella": Yes.
Mr. Garrison: Okay.
Later at the cafeteria...
"Bella" approached the girls with her tray of food.
"Bella": Hey. Mind if I sit here?
Wendy: Sure.
"Bella" took her seat.
Red: Bella, you were acting weird in class.
"Bella": What makes you say that?
Samantha (OC): You were acting like you were upset.
"Bella": No. I'm fine.
Annie: Are you her twin cousin?
Nichole: Annie!
"Bella": No! What makes you say that?
Annie: Same voice, same hairstyle, but your hair is blonde, and you have the same face.
"Bella": We are not cousins! I'm new here, so stop making faults claims about me being related to Nelly!
Theresa: Look. When some of us said bad stuff about Nelly, you looked like you were about to cry. What's up with that?
"Bella": Nothing. I was just upset that I never got to see Butters. That's all.
The girls began to mourn over Butters.
Sally T: Look. It's okay to feel emotional over certain things, even if someone said something bad about a person.
Isla: Yeah. Just don't let Eric Cartman know that or he'll make fun of you for it. And you know how I take out my anger? I just bully a tiny and ugly piece of shit named Dougie. My friend Theresa bullies him also because her mom is abusive.
Theresa: Yeah. And by the way, you should watch out for that ugly nerd. One wrong move and he'll perv all over you like there's no tomorrow. Trust me, he's done it to all of us.
Nichole: Yeah. He mostly does it to me. That racist little pervert. I fucking hate him!
Wendy: We all hate Dougie. He's just a little creep who doesn't know how to keep his perverted hands to himself!
Red: You know? I feel bad for Kenny because his sister is dating that ugly piece of shit.
Samantha (OC): Watch it! And by the way, Dougie is also my younger stepbrother. My dad married his mom and that's how we became siblings. He even adopted a cat named Cookie.
"Bella": So, I guess you're the only ones who hate Dougie.
Bebe: No. Everybody in this whole school hates him because of his know-it-all personality and his ability to stalk every girl he sees. Eric Cartman had bullied him tons of times, but Theresa and Isla has bullied him more times than Tubby McFatass has ever done.
Wendy: Oh, and speaking of which, you should stay away from Cartman. He's a dangerous kid. He once hosted a chili con carnival and made a kid eat his parents.
"Bella": Wow. (Thinking) Even though I already know about perverted nerd and the fat fuck, I'll just have to pretend that I don't know themso they won't be suspicious.
Bebe: Not only that, but he once killed tons of people with Cthulhu.
Red: He got Kyle's family false imprisoned by the ICE.
Lola: He did a period prank on our old teach Mrs. Nelson.
Jenny: He made me shit my pants and fracture my pelvis!
Sally T: He got my little brother Billy sent to the hospital!
Heidi: He turned into his female counterpart.
Millie: He gave Kyle AIDS.
Nichole: Although he was the main reason why Tolkien and I are a couple, he made tons of sexist and racist comments about everybody!
Allie: He bullied my boyfriend Pip way too many times! He threw a rock at him, he farted on him, he shoved a his birthday invitation up his fatass, and he even attempted to destroy our relationship! He also got every else to torment the poor guy!
Nichole: At least Pip has finally had it with everyone's shit and is starting to hate Eric.
"Bella": Well, where is he?
Allie: Over there with the boys. And trust me, they hate him just as much as we do. Even Pip hates him now.
Bebe: The only time we're okay with him doing something terrible to someone is when he torments Dougie the short and ugly pervert.
"Bella": Okay. Thanks for telling me. I know now to stay away from him.
Wendy: Yeah. He's a huge criminal.
Liza (OC): I'm actually dating Eric.
"Bella": Really? What do you see in him? (The girls started looking at her) Um, I mean how did you guys start dating? (Thinking) That was so close. My cover was about to be blown.
Liza (OC): A month ago. I started coming to school here. I was all shy when I saw him, and then Bebe told me everything about how I need to be brave while talking to him.
"Bella": Okay.
Meanwhile with the boys...
Cartman: Something's going on about the new girl. I feel like we've met her before.
Kyle: What are you talking about, Cartman?
Cartman: She kinda looks and sounds like that bitch who killed Butters. Plus, the hairstyle is similar to hers.
Stan: Really? I haven't noticed that before.
Cartman: Yeah. Do you guys think that Nelly broke out of jail and disguise herself as the new girl just to get back at us for sending her away?
After a short silence, the boys bursted out laughing.
Clyde: That was a good one, dude!
Cartman: I know! As if that bitch is coming back! We're never gonna have to deal with that whore for the rest of our lives!
Kyle: Yeah! Like what the fuck was Francis thinking dating that bitch?!
Francis was behind them.
Francis: Excuse me?!
They all stared at him.
Stan: Sorry. Just pretend you didn't hear that.
Francis walked away.
Later at recess...
Francis was having a snowball fight with Brimmy, Daniel and Nate until "Bella" approached him.
"Bella": Hey.
Francis: Hey. You're new here, right?
"Bella": Yes. I am new here. It's not like I've came here before, right?
Francis: Um, okay?
"Bella": So... do you have a girlfriend?
Francis: I did have one, but I dumped her after she cheated on me with Pip while she was dressed as his ex. And I'm never taking her back after she murdered Butters.
"Bella" begins to cry.
"Bella": Oh... I see. So, do you wanna...
Francis: What's wrong? Did I say something to hurt your feelings? If so, then I'm sorry.
"Bella": It's nothing. I get really upset every time someone say something bad about me... I mean Nelly. That's all.
Francis: Why are you getting upset over people badmouthing my ex?
"Bella": I don't know. I'm just really emotional. That's all.
Francis: Oh... Okay. You don't need to upset over it. It's not like people are saying that kind of stuff about you. So do you wanna... maybe get some ice cream?
"Bella": YES!!! I mean... Yeah. I'd sure like that.
Daniel: Oooooo... Francis has a crush on the new girl!
Nate: Let's hope she's not a psycho bitch like his ex.
"Bella" was angrywhen she heard Nate say that.
Daniel: I think you pissed her off, man.
"Bella" calmed down.
"Bella": I'm sorry.
Francis: It's okay.
After school...
"Bella" was walking down the neighborhood and noticed her old house.
"Bella": Okay. All I have to do is convince my parents to let me stay with them.But they can't know it's me or I'm fucked. Let's just get this over with.
"Bella" approached her old house and knocked on the door. Matt opened it.
Matt: Hey, little girl. Can I help you with anything?
"Bella": Yeah. Can I stay here? I don't have parents.
Nelly's Mom: Why? What happened to them?
"Bella": They died in a car accident.
She begins to cry.
Matt: Oh. We're so sorry to hear that. Well, you can stay with us.
"Bella": Thank you!
"Bella" entered her room, which was empty.
Matt: Sorry. We forgot to mention that we took everything out of our ex-daughter's room. We'll put everything back in here for you.
"Bella": So this mean I can finally get all my old stuff... I mean, get your ex-daughter's old stuff?
Matt: Sure.
"Bella": YES! I mean, thank you, sir.
Nelly's Mom: Make sure you get settled in.
2 Hours Later...
"Bella" has finally had everything back. Her old room, her personal belongings, everything. After getting settled in, she created new accounts on every social media she's ever been on, but she didn't use her real name. She used her disguised name and got all of her friends and boyfriend back. Her life is finally back to normal. She is now eating ice cream with Francis.
"Bella": Francis, you are so cute.
Francis: Really?
"Bella": Yeah.
Francis: Thanks. You know, I really like your glasses.
"Bella": Thank you!
Francis: You're welcome. And even though you have the same exact hairstyle as my ex, but your hair is yellow, I still love it.
"Bella": Aw! Thank you!
Francis: You're welcome.
"Bella": So do you want to come over to my new house?
Francis: Sure.
They are now at Nelly's house.
Francis: You live here? At my ex girlfriend's house?
"Bella": Yeah. Her parents are nice.
Francis: Wait a second. The hairstyle, the house, the same face... Nelly, is that you?
"Bella": No! I'm not your crazy ex! I'm the new girl.
Cartman walked past them.
Cartman: I knew Bella was Nelly the whole time. I just didn't say anything.
Francis: What? You knew?!
Cartman: Yeah. She cried every time we talked shit about her when she was in the room while dressed as a nerdy slut. Anyways, gotta go work on a Tegridy Hot Dog for Mr. Marsh so he can sell it for his business.
He then left.
Francis: So you were Nelly this whole time?
Nelly: (Sighs and takes off the glasses) Yes. I was Nelly this whole time. It's just that I really missed you and I really wanted you and everyone else back. I'm really sorry for what I did to Butters. I just changed my look and if I didn't, everyone would still be shitting all over me for the mistake I made. I really want Butters back and I want to make things right. So please don't tell anyone about this! I don't want my cover being blown! I just want everything back to the way it was! So please don't tell anybody about my real identity!
Francis: Fine. Your secret's safe with me. But I'm still not getting back together with you.
Nelly: Okay. Thanks!
The next day...
"Bella" entered the school and everybody started booing at her.
Wendy: Why'd you come here, Bella? Or should I say NELLY?!
Nelly: Francis, how could you?!
Francis: I didn't tell them!
Red: Yeah! Cartman recorded a video showing proof that you revealed to Francis that you were actually Nelly! And he shared it with everybody on Facebook!
Bebe: Why'd you come back, Murderer?!
Nelly: Look. I wanted to apologize for everything I did to Butters! I want to make things right and redeem myself for my horrible action!
Lola: Apologize all you want, we still ain't forgiving you.
Dougie: You know, she is really hot in that getup. (Everyone glared at him angrily) But not as hot as Karen. Karen is way more beautiful than her.
Karen: Glad you think that.
Wendy: Nelly, why'd you come back from juvie? Who bailed you out?
Nelly: Butters' grandma bailed me out.
Craig: Wait, so after you killed her grandson, she bailed you out?! Why would she do that?!
Nelly: She just really felt bad for me and wanted to help me get you all back as my friends! You were right! Butters wasn't the cause of all of my problems! I did it all by myself! I just wish he was still alive so I can fix the horrible mistake I made!
Red: Well, it's too late! You should've ended this grudge, and now he's dead!
PC Principal appeared.
PC Principal: Nelly?! You're not welcomed back here after what you did!
Nelly: I'm not Nelly, I'm Bella!
PC Principal: Not according to the video Eric Cartman posted on Facebook!
She then noticed Cartman and tackled him.
Nelly: YOU FAT FUCK! YOU EXPOSED MY IDENTITY ON FACEBOOK?!
Cartman: Yeah! You should've stayed in juvie!
Nelly: You've done far worst stuff than me!
Cartman: What I've done is nothing compared to what you did to Butters!
Nelly: Why are you even caring about him?! You always treated him like a pet!
Cartman: Because he was actually a real friend to me! We may have done some terrible shit to each other, but he was still a good friend of mine! And because of you, the only person who is still alive, but I like is Liza!
Pip: Dick!
Cartman: Shut up, Pip. Nobody likes you.
Allie: Nobody likes you either!
Cartman: Always defending that Frenchie. That's so like you, whore.
Pip: I'm gonna fucking kill you if you call Allie a whore one more time!
Nelly: You won't get the chance to kill him because I'm gonna kill him for exposing me on FUCKING FACEBOOK!
PC Principal: Nelly, you won't be killing anyone anymore! Now get out of this school before I have the authorities on your ass!
Nelly got off Cartman and sadly walked out of the school. She then noticed her parents with angry looks.
Matt: Nelly, why'd you come back?
Nelly: I just wanted to fix the mistake I made, so I though that dressing up like this would get me back to everyone's good side. I really missed you guys. I missed Francis. I missed everyone at school. Well, except Dougie.
Nelly's Mom: You shouldn't have come back here after you killed the Stotch boy.
Nelly: I know and I'm sorry! I really am sorry for what I did to Butters!
Matt: Sorry is not gonna bring Butters back! He's dead because of you!
Nelly: Well, I guess it's time I go back to where I came from, which is Grandma Stotch's house!
She ran away crying.
Matt: Are you sure we did the right thing by disowning her? She committed murder and broke everyone's hearts.
Nelly's Mom: When she finally owns up to her mistakes, she'll be back with us and everything will be back to normal.
Later that night at Dougie's house, he was finally finished with his revival ray.
Dougie: Perfect. With this ray gun, I can bring Butters back to life and everyone will be happy!
Ghost Butters appeared.
Butters: So, you've finally finished it?
Dougie: Yeah. I'm ready to bring you back.
Butters: Wait! I said don't bring me back until Nelly finally owns up to her mistakes.
Dougie: But everyone misses you, including your parents.
Butters: I know, but I want Nelly to do something for me before you bring me back.
Samantha entered Dougie's room.
Samantha (OC): Butters?
Butters: Hi, Samantha. Anyway, I gotta go. See you when you bring me back!
He vanished.
Samantha (OC): You finally finished it?
Dougie: Yup.
Samantha (OC): I can't wait to see Butters when he's alive again.
Dougie: Me too. Anyways, Goodnight.
Samantha (OC): Goodnight.
At Grandma Stotch's house...
Grandma Stotch: You got exposed?!
Nelly: Yeah. That fat fuck Cartman ruined everything!
Grandma Stotch: Look. I have another idea that could work.
Nelly: What is it?
Grandma Stotch: Make a public apology to everyone for what you did. I still hate my grandson, but you'll have your reputation backfor what you did to him.
Nelly: Thanks.
She hugs Grandma Stotch and heads to the guest room.
Grandma Stotch: She's such a good kid. I wish my good for nothing grandson who's now dead was like that.
Nelly was about to go to sleep until...
Butters: Nelly.
Ghost Butters appeared right in front of her.
Nelly: Butters? Oh my god! I'm so sorry for what I did to you!
Butters: It's okay. I forgive you.
Nelly: What? But I killed you and everybody hates me!
Butters: I know, but you have to do something for me.
Nelly: What do I need to do?
Butters: Apologize to everybody you have pissed off. That includes the laser tag people, Wendy, Bebe, the entire Marching Band from our school, every single person in South Park you have pissed off. Do all of that and I'll be ready to come back to life.
Nelly: Okay. I'll apologize to everyone.
Butters: Do it on Easter.
Nelly: On Easter?
Butters: Yes. Holidays are times for forgiveness.
Nelly: Okay. I'll do it.
Butters: Great. I've gotta go back to heaven. See you on Easter.
He vanished.
Nelly: Okay. First thing in the morning is to write down a bunch of apology letters. Okay.
She turned off the lights and went to sleep.
