Teenagers like doing things that parents wouldn't recommend and don't think of the trouble or responsibility that comes with it. An example is one couple sitting out at night in a car, staring out at Magnolia, and was about to do something they shouldn't do.

"Beautiful night." The girl said.

"Just as beautiful as you." The guy said. The two of them were about to kiss when something suddenly smashed against the hood of a car. They saw a knight in black armor with a feather on its head and a mace.

"You who have no morals, no discipline, and no sense shall be punished!" He raced the mace again and smashed it against the car with the couple jumping out. The knight went towards the girl and she was expecting her boyfriend to save her, but he saved his own skin as he ran off.

"Are you seriously running and leaving me here?!" The girl called. The knight looked like he was going to attack her, but someone did save her as he tackled the knight to the ground.

"I don't think so! No knight is going to harm any beautiful girl while Dan Straight is here!" Her savior hurried to her and lifted her in his arms as he carried her away. As for the knight, he just stood up and screamed in anger. For someone who stands for nobility, this knight stands for danger.

...

Magnolia High

It as just another day for the students of Magnolia High. The gang walked in the school and were just minding their own business. While the girls ahead were talking, Gray was trying to encourage Natsu.

"Go on, man. Ask Lucy out." Gray said.

"I'm not sure." Natsu said as he seemed a little nervous to do something. "What if it causes problems in the group?"

"It won't...as long as we don't have to constantly see that." Gray said as he pointed to a couple that was making out in the halls. "Get a room!"

"Hold on." Lucy said as she noticed something strange. "Veronica? Is that you?" She said and got the girl's attention. "Why are you making out with Dan Straight? I thought you were dating Brian."

"Oh please. I dumped that loser after he bailed on me when I was being attacked. This hottie here saved me." Veronica said as she caressed Dan's face.

"I would have done anything for you, Veronnie." Dan said with them a little disturbed by the name.

"Did you say you were attacked? By who?" Erza asked.

"Some weirdo dressed in dark armor up at Moonlight Point. He was like a dark knight." Veronica said.

"A knight?" Gray questioned.

"Well, if he shows up again, I'll take care of him. It was a good thing I was out on my evening jog when I came to save you." Dan said.

"I'll see you later." Veronica said as she gave him one last kiss and walked away.

"Try not to feel jealous, Erza and Lucy." Dan said as he placed his arms around both of them. "There's plenty of Dan to go around. Maybe you two and Veronica can share."

"Eew." Lucy said.

"Don't bet on it." Erza said as she pushed Dan away so the gang could talk about what they just heard. "A knight attacking people? Knights are chivalrous warriors that live by a code of honor. They would never just attack someone."

"Knights aren't even around anymore." Gray said. "Sounds like there's something going on at Moonlight Point."

"I'll say. Isn't Moonlight Point that place where teens go and do things their parents would never approve of?" Natsu said with some humor.

"Being attacked by a knight isn't one of those. Neither is being saved by Dan." Lucy said. "Dan's a playboy and not a charming one either. Someone like Veronica willing want to go out with that nutcase? Something weird must be going on."

"Well, I know where we're heading tonight." Gray said as they have another mystery on their hands.

...

Moonlight Point

The gang went to checkout Moonlight Point at night for this mysterious Dark Knight. The five of them had a look around while also trying not to bother anyone who was at Moonlight Point. They looked around for anything that seemed out of the ordinary.

"Anyone find anything?" Gray asked.

"Nothing that would point to a knight." Erza said.

"I say we should ask the people around to see if they saw anything, but it's probably not a good idea to disturb anyone." Lucy said.

"Maybe this knight isn't even going to show up here." Natsu said.

"Natsu might be right. How do we know this knight is going to attack here again?" Erza said.

"It's really our only lead. Let's just take one more look around before heading home." Gray suggested. All of them agree and had one more look around. Natsu, Lucy, and Happy stuck close to each other as they had a look. While they were looking, Happy tried talking to Natsu as he made kissy noises and pointed to him and Lucy.

"No, Happy! I'm not going to do that with Lucy here. At least not yet." Natsu said.

"What was that? Did you mention me?" Lucy asked.

"Nope!" Natsu said as he tried acting normal.

"Hey! Keep it down over there!" A guy called from his car with a date. "We're in the middle of making irresponsible decisions that could affect us for the rest of our lives!"

"Okay, the weird and scary part when people call stuff like that out is that they are aware of that but they do nothing about it." Lucy said. "It's like when someone admits to their negative qualities, but they do nothing to change."

"Lucy, is that you?" The girl asked.

"Charlotte? You're here?" Lucy asked as she knew the girl.

"Yeah. I didn't know you came here. When did you and he started dating?" Charlotte asked, but the two of them denied that they were even dating. Suddenly, that was when the Dark Knight appeared as he smashed his mace against the ground.

"You all sinfully sully this ground with your skirts that are too short and your shirts that do not cover enough?!" The Dark Knight called.

"Hey, where are you watching?!" Lucy said as she pushed down on her skirt.

"You shall all be disciplined for such vulgar decisions!" The Dark Knight called as he went to attack them. He attacked the couple in a car as he smashed the mace against it and scared them both out of there. He went to Charlotte and was going to attack her, but that was Dan showed up out of nowhere. He tackled him out of the way and lifted Charlotte into her arms and carried her out of there.

"Dan?!" Natsu said as they all thought it was weird how he showed up. "What's he doing back here?"

"Worry about him later!" Lucy said as she saw Dark Knight getting back up. He went at the three of them with the three of them running for their lives.

"You shall all be disciplined!" Dark Knight called as he chased after them.

"Disciplined for what?! We did nothing wrong!" Natsu called. The three of them kept running front him until Erza came in. She swung on a tree branch and gave the knight a good kick as she was able to knock the knight right off the cliff. "Nice moves, Erza. You've got to tell me how you do that stuff."

"Are you guys okay?!" Gray said as he came over.

"Yeah, but knight seems pretty strict." Lucy said. "I think he was after me and Charlotte because of what we wore." They all thought it was rather weird.

"He's getting back up!" Erza said. They walked over to where Erza kicked the knight off and saw him get back up. He grunted from that fall, but he was able to walk out of there and disappeared in the woods. "He's a tough one. I'll give him that much."

"What was he doing out here in the first place?" Gray questioned.

"He's trying to "discipline" us for making bad decisions." Natsu said.

"What's this?" Erza said as she spotted something strange in the knight's footprints.

"What is it, Erza?" Lucy asked.

"It's these footprints." Erza said. "I know a lot about fashion. These prints don't look like they were made by metal boots. There's something off about that knight, but I can't quite put my finger on it."

"Come on. Let's get out of here before he decides to come back for round two." Lucy said. The five of them got up and headed back to their van. "Something else weird happened. Dan showed up again and saved another girl. I wonder why he was here again." She wondered about that until the got back to the Myster-V. When they opened it, they were shocked to see Dan and Charlotte kissing in there. "Dan?! What are you doing?!"

"Sorry, guys." Dan said. "We needed a place to lay low from that freaky knight."

"Are you seeing anyone?" Charlotte questioned as she appeared interested in him.

"Two hotties falling for Dan? No way." Lucy said.

"Lucy? Erza? Would you two like to join us back here?" Dan said as he actually was being bold.

"Not in my van! Get out!" Gray shouted. Dan's womanizing aside, there is something strange going on.

...

The Next Day

The gang continued on with their investigation in the Dark Knight. There's something not quite right about it and they all think Dan has something to do with it. They looked and saw another hot girl with him at school. Seeing three hot girls were interested in that annoying playboy just didn't sit right.

"I just know Dan has something to do with that knight." Lucy said. "Why else would he be at Moonlight Point both times the knight attacked."

"You might be right, but we got nothing on him." Gray said. "I checked with his parents. Dan does go out for a jog almost every night and Moonlight Point is along that path. Either it's just a coincidence or he's just that stupid."

"Oh yeah. What are you all sweet and spicy people here talking about?" They got a little distracted when a guy dressed like he was ready for the disco walked up to them.

"Uh... Hi. You go by Sugarboy, right?" Lucy asked.

"That's me. I heard you all talking about Danny Boy. He happens to be a buddy of mine and not just my toy." Surgarboy said. "You two spicy and sweet ladies should consider dating him. He might be more of a man than you might think." The thought of either of them dating Dan just sends shivers down the girls spines. "So, what you all talking about here?"

"None of your business. Get lost." Gray said as he just pushed the guy away.

"No need to get frisky." Sugarboy said. That's when he started thinking of something. "That doesn't sound too bad." He said and started singing. "No need to get frisky just because it's getting risky. When the dogs are barking and yapping, I hear the sweet sound of you talking and clapping. Spicy!" He just walked away and they all thought that was rather strange.

"Weirdo." Gray said. "Anyway, I say we head back to Moonlight Point after school and see if we missed anything." All of them agreed so they deal with one less weirdo.

...

Moonlight Point

All of them headed back to Moonlight Point when it was still bright out. They all searched around for anything that could lead to the night or what Dan really does at Moonlight Point.

"Anyone find anything?" Lucy questioned.

"I did find something, but not from the knight. What the heck do people do exactly up here?" Natsu said. "Happy, what about you? Did you find anything?" Happy actually did as he came out of the bushes and carried a book with him. "Hey! Happy might have something!" He called to the others and took the book. "This our school's yearbook from last year!"

"What could that be doing here?" Erza said as they all gathered around. Natsu opened up and saw what was in it.

"Hey! Look at this!" Natsu said as he saw some certain photos were marked. "Hot. Hottie."

"Those are the girls that were attacked by the Dark Knight." Gray said.

"And look here." Natsu said as he found photos of Lucy and Erza and saw they were marked too. "Lucy, Queen Hotties. Erza, Spicy Hot."

"Urgh... I feel disgusted from seeing this." Lucy said as seeing this made them both uncomfortable.

"As do I. What pig does this book belong to?" Erza said.

"Hold on. These are the same girls that were attacked." Natsu said. "This could mean that you two are the Dark Knight's next targets."

"Either this dark knight of virtue has the wrong idea about you two or this knight isn't as virtuous as we thought." Gray said. "Now that we know you two could be his next target, I think I have an idea to trap him."

"And use Erza and Lucy as the bait?" Natsu said. "At least Happy and I are getting a break."

"Sorry, Natsu. I am using Lucy for this, but I'm going to need you too." Gray said. Both of them were getting an unsettling feeling about this.

...

Later

When night came around, Gray put his trap in action. To have it work, Gray gave Natsu and Lucy the van and made it look like they were on a date. The problem was that they were both a little nervous around each other given the scenario.

"So... Nice night, right?" Natsu asked.

"Yeah. Uh... Not too dark or too bright." Lucy said.

"You call that date conversation?" Erza questioned. They were both wearing earpieces while Erza, Gray, and Happy were hiding behind the trees for when the knight showed up. "You're suppose to be on a date, not making small talk with your auntie. Natsu, put your arm around her."

"Okay." Natsu said. He made it looked like he stretched out his arm and put it around her to bring her in closer.

"Gray, are you sure this is going to work?" Erza questioned.

"Nope, but Natsu needs some help if he wants to date Lucy." Gray said. Until the knight showed himself, all the two could do was just sit in the van and make it look like a date.

"So... This seems to be going well, right?" Lucy asked.

"Yeah..." Natsu said. The two of them were terrible at this, but Natsu decided to take the chance since they are in this scenario. "Lucy, there is something I would like to ask you." Lucy listened, but Natsu was a little hesitant. "I was wondering that..." That was when the door opened up.

"You dare continue with your scandals?!" The Dark Knight said as he showed himself. He grabbed a hold of Lucy and threw her out of the van. He looked ready to discipline her as well.

"You again!" They all looked and saw Dan was there again. "Don't worry, Lucy! I'll save you!"

"Not this time!" Natsu said as he actually jumped on the Dark Knight's back and tried wrestling with him, but he just tossed Natsu away with him hitting a tree. Dan went straight for Lucy, but she just pushed him aside.

"Natsu!" Lucy called as she rushed to him.

"You shall be disciplined, young maiden!" The Dark Knight claimed as he went at them again.

"Now!" Erza called. Gray and Happy pulled on a rope that ran through the field. It caused a springboard that was hidden in the ground to shoot up and it shot the Dark Knight into the air and into the trees. What happened next was night coming down and was suspended in the air with his head and hands in cuffs and his waist held up as well. When they got him trapped, the others came out of hiding. "You're getting good at this trapmaking, Gray. I wasn't too sure this part would work."

"Thanks." Gray said. He took a look at the knight's feet and saw what Erza talked about before. "You were right, Erza. Check it out. His metal boots are just regular shoes with some metal covering them."

"Now let's see who this knight really is." Natsu said as he reached for the helmet and pulled it off.

"Sugarboy?!" They all said with them shocked it was him.

"Uh... Nobody's perfect..." Sugarboy said.

"This is quite baffling!" Dan said as he stood between Erza and Lucy. "You girls must be completely shocked. What do you say I make sure you're comforted."

"Nice try, Dan." Erza said as she took his arm and turned around to hold the back of his arm painfully behind his back. "We know you were a part of this as well." She pushed him near his accomplice and now they were both busted

"What?!" Dan said.

"We knew something had to be off because you always showed up whenever the knight did." Gray said. "We didn't know it until we found this yearbook." He said as he pulled it out and showed who it belonged to. "Maybe next time, don't leave evidence that has your name on it."

"But since we knew you couldn't have been the knight yourself, you had to have had a partner." Natsu said.

"To be fair, Sugarboy here was just being a great wingman." Dan said.

"You know it." Sugarboy said. "This would have went on if these sour meddling mystery solvers didn't get in the way."

"The only part we haven't figure out is why. Why did you do this?" Natsu questioned.

"Girls!" Dan said. "I wanted to be their actual knight in shiny armor. The knights staged crimes and such so they could show off and get girls before the Dark Ages came and black magic was used to eliminate them."

"No they didn't. That has to be the most petty reason I ever heard." Lucy said.

"And you're clearly failing history." Erza said.

"Oh well. I still got a few babes." Dan said as he felt like he still got his way.

"Girls!" Gray called as he had a surprise for him. The girls that Dan did "save" came out of hiding and heard every word. Dan tried giving off an innocent smile, but he got slapped across the face. That was when the girls got a hold of both of them and the gang left those girls to do what they wanted with Dan and Sugarboy.

"Should we really leave them like that?" Natsu questioned as they all went to the Myster-V.

"Natsu, when a girl gets mad, there is no saving anyone." Lucy said.

"I'll keep that in mind when I make you mad." Natsu said.

"I do have to say that it was rather brave of you to jump on that knight like that." Lucy said. "I think that was your bravest point yet." Natsu felt a little flattered from that comment. When the others were in the van, Gray saw a chance as he just drove off.

"Oops! Sorry!" Gray called.

"Hey! Gray! Get back here!" Natsu called.

"Gray, what are you doing?" Erza asked.

"Being a wingman to Natsu." Gray said. With the van driving off, that just leaves Natsu and Lucy.

"What was that about? What are we going to do now?" Lucy questioned.

"Well... I could walk you home." Natsu said. That did sound rather nice. The two of them walked off together into the night. Might not have been an official date, but it was one neither will forget.