Hey guys.
I decided to write up a Toby Peter story involving post No Way Home that is not an MJ romance or gay relationship since seems like those are the only options.
This will be a Peter/Felicia story with let's just pretend Rami's Peter had a different line about being with somebody, and whatever it is I'll leave it up to your imagination.
For whose playing Felicia Hardy? I'm thinking Anne Hathaway like in my other Peter/Felicia fic involving Toby although no connection.
Let's get on with the show
New York during the early morning
Letting out a yell, and a groan of pain given the stab wound Peter is free-falling from where he was sitting up on the Chrysler Building. Turning in midair Spider-Man stretching out his arm manages to fire his web onto a gargoyle and pulls himself up to it. Reaching up Peter feels bare skin where his mask should be, and realizes that one no doubt got left behind on the other earth.
Another earth is well wow Peter knows as the science part of his brain is exclaiming a whole lot of joy. However, the experienced vigilante is just glad for the crisis to be over, although is concerned for the other two Peters. Still, Peter knows deep down his other selves are Spider-Man and they always turn out all right. Maybe not always happy or not having dark times in their life, but they make it through.
Regardless, Peter one losing his Aunt May that early, compared to his May dying peacefully years ago, with revealing she knew he was Spider-Man all along, which was quite a surprise. Plus, that's on top of everybody knowing who Peter One is? He's going to have it rough, but Peter knows his other self will keep going on. After all, that's who they are.
Regardless Peter quickly webs himself a new face mask, and feels sympathy for the two other selves needing to make webbing. Upon quickly webbing his wound close Peter decides is way past time to get home. First, reassure Felicia on being okay, and get caught up on some much-needed sleep. Regarding his job as a college teacher well will worry about that problem when getting there.
Leaping off Peter fires a web onto a nearby building swinging away.
An apartment
Opening the window Peter slips in pulling his mask apart and looking over to see Felicia having stripped down naked revealing Felicia's very attractive body with placing the Black Cat suit, and gear inside a chest kept in the closet.
"Ah, nice to see you back, and what happened to your com device?" Felicia asks.
"It got destroyed," Peter says.
"Yeah, I figured," Felicia says pulling on a robe.
"I think dropped it when falling off the Chrysler Building of the other earth I was on" Peter explains.
"Sounds like your… wait what did you just say?" Felicia asks in shock and confusion.
"Got destroyed when I ended up on a different earth and yeah it turns out the multiverse is real," Peter says in light shock.
"Right… so I guess this day finally came" Felicia replies wearily, and nervously.
Frowning "What day?" Peter inquiries.
"Otto mentioned to me years ago when I fell in love with you that one day that well you would be," Felica says trailing off.
"Gone?" Peter asks hesitantly.
"Something like that" Felicia replies evasively.
"Well, I still love you as I came back expecting things to be normal between us," Peter says reassuringly.
"I'm glad that hasn't changed," Felicia says exhaling in relief "And I love you."
"I'm glad that hasn't changed either, not quite sure what I would have done finding somebody else in your place or this house being owned by someone else" Peter replies then winces.
Shaking her head fondly "And of course no matter the reality you still end up getting injured. Sit and let me fix you up" Felica says walking over to a dresser opening it up.
"Going to play nurse?" Peter asks walking over to the bed.
"Well once we get you stitched and you heal somewhat, I have no problems being your nurse" Felicia replies removing some items while grinning.
Merely chuckling Peter gets his top off with removing the patched webbing while Felicia walks over sitting down. Lightly dabbing the wound with a cloth containing rubbing alcohol causing Peter to hiss until Felicia applies a medical bandage over it. Leaning in Peter kisses Felicia while running a hand through her long white hair as she runs one up his chest. Eventually, after a couple of moments, they break apart, just merely looking at the other.
"I feel tired, think I'll go to sleep now," Peter says.
Letting out a light yawn Peter falls back onto the bed closing his eyes and seemingly falling asleep. Felicia grinning in amusement and fondness reaches down lightly running her fingers through Peter's hair. A man she loves with her whole heart, no longer scaring her like it used to.
Felicia knows there is a lot to discuss such as all the differences to this reality compared to whatever one Peter actually comes from. How when Spider-Man was fighting Green Goblin all those years ago in that old building the Goblin suddenly stopped after a beat down Peter gave him with merely Norman Osborn being there completely.
Of course, as Peter once told her he was mumbling about other realities, and such as between what Felicia knows is Mr. Osborn's very real multiverse trip, plus the effects of Goblin serum, caused a mental breakdown for a time. Peter quietly took Mr. Osborn back to his house with destroying the Goblin gear. Unfortunately, Harry arrived on the scene and despite helping Spider-Man destroy the equipment began carrying a grudge.
Something that remained even Harry discovered his best friend was Spider-Man during the whole mess with Ock. Before during the final fight, Octavius vanished for a moment only to reappear having his inhibitor chip fixed completely with Peter and him able to push the machine into the river.
Months later Peter and MJ had their final split right around when Harry became the next Green Goblin, despite both his father and Dr. Octavius trying to convince Harry to let go of his hatred. During this time Peter was momentarily under the control of the black suit with getting rid of it allowing Eddie Brock becoming Venom.
Thankfully Dr. Ock alongside Harry, who now let go of his hatred after a conversation with Norman, showed up to help Peter fight Sandman, and Venom. As Sandman mid-way during this entire time turned into normal, which Octavius later said was a product of the multiverse adventure, it allowed all of them to focus on stopping Venom with no casualties.
Well outside of Eddie who tried jumping back into the alien symbiote after Peter threw a pumpkin bomb into the creature. An action which still haunts the man she loves given Peter feels indirectly responsible for killing Brock.
However, this whole mess of events combined with years of past issues further broke Peter and Mary Jane Watson apart for good, despite an attempt to get back together. It's why Peter began allowing himself to develop feelings for her as Black Cat when they first met upon going after Roderick Kingsley who was using his fashion business as a backdoor operation into human trafficking.
Of course, they butted heads initially on her stealing all of the criminal's money leaving them penniless. Well, it's not like she keeps the money entirely for herself Felica notes as has given some to shelters such as FEAST organization and others.
After all, that's how she first met Spider-Man's civilian persona during a gala as one of the photographers. She started having a soft spot for his civilian self as well, and even went on a date while unknowingly they flirted on rooftops as their masked selves.
Naturally, nothing ever was easy in Peter's life for the old Parker Luck when Curt Conners became The Lizard after messing around with lizard DNA, and tried making all of New York like him. Thankfully Peter cured Dr. Conners with allowing him to quietly resume life with his wife and son given no one besides them know.
Upon fighting The Lizard is how Peter and her discovered the other's secret identities. It strengthened the bond and love between them even more. Plus, Felicia notes wickedly grinning has led to some pretty great sex on those rooftops. Not that their sex lacked any issues before knowing who each other was.
Pushing her carnal feelings aside Felicia getting up collects the webbing on dropping the webbing in a wastebasket, with placing the medical supplies back in the bureau. Once that is complete Felicia drops the robe once more while heading back to the bed and lays down beside Peter unbothered for needing covers.
Lightly smiling Peter wraps his arms around Felicia bringing his Black Cat in closer. Felicia enjoying her lover's body heat and presence snuggles in further laying one hand over Peter's neck with moving one of her legs over his knees as well.
Both are glad they are home, which is not the place or earth but rather with each other.
Hope you all enjoyed this and leave a review letting me know what you think.
Okay first on my having Rami's Dr. Conners become The Lizard is if we ended up getting a Spider-Man 4 was a possible role for a villain for having Conners become The Lizard. Which got a name drop in Spider-Man 1 and made appearances in the next two it is rather disappointing that never happened.
Sure, in No Way Home Toby's Peter never said anything, but I can easily see this Peter being a veteran who has faced a wide array of his villains by this point, including no doubt taking on his earth's Sinister Six.
I based Peter and Felicia dating as their normal selves off the old 90's Spider-Man cartoon show which happened for a brief while.
Until next time