"Chuck, don't you dare harm them. I'll kill you," Sam said glaring out at himself.
"Okay Sam, can't you see that you gave me no choice. If you and your brother had just played the parts I scripted for you," Chuck stopped mid-sentence as Sam growled at him.
"We aren't your puppets, and this isn't a story. I'm not going to cooperate with you and kill the two people that mean everything to Dean and I," Sam stated flatly growling again at Chuck, "You lose Chuck, why don't you just go to hell."
"I think you'll find since we're connected I can pretty much make you do whatever I want you to. Besides, you're going to be better off without either of those girls. You'll see, now come on Sam, play nice. I don't want to hurt you any more than you want to hurt me. We're a team right now, connected," Chuck said smiling at the reflection before him.
"NO!" Sam screamed out making both of them grab their heads, "I'll not kill Kaashaa. She may hate me for what you've made me do and so might Eileen but when I'm free of you then I promise I'm coming for you even if I have to hunt through every lore book till I find a way to kill you. Don't think Dean hasn't figured out there's something wrong with me either. He will save me."
Chuck laughed, "I doubt your guilt weighted brother has figured out anything other than he's little brother's gone psychotic yet again from what I've heard. So, how's it going to feel when you're put in a mental hospital by him. Are you going to be so happy to have him as a brother? You know the way to solve that too Sam. Kill them and end this story and you can go to Heaven. Or better yet just have a regular life. Get married, have kids, and work a regular job somewhere till you get too old and die naturally."
"Dean would never do that to me. Him, Dany and especially Kaash will find a way to separate us. Wait you're scared that's exactly what they're going to do. You're scared of Kaashaa and Danylle aren't you. It's because them and Jack are the only beings that's as strong if not stronger than you," Sam stated an almost evil smile on his face.
"I'm not scared of them and they aren't stronger than me," Chuck stated growling himself, "Here take a look at this," he snapped his fingers.
Suddenly Sam found himself and Chuck standing in the bunker. "What the hell Chuck!" Sam snarled glaring at Chuck as he watched himself and Kaashaa came into the library.
Chuck put his finger on his lips, "Shhh, just watch. This is what's going to happen if you choose to stay with Kaashaa and not do what's in your instinct."
Sam watched as both sat down listening in on the conversation, "Sam why don't you go to hell. Like you ever gave a damn about me," Kaashaa hissed her eyes filled with tears.
"I do care about you Kaashaa, but I don't think we need to be having kids right now. Just hear me out. It's dangerous for you and me both. Some hunter's going to find out and kill you and that. While I couldn't care about it you I do love," The other Sam said.
"Fine have it your way. I won't get an abortion, but I'll make sure you don't have to worry about me or this baby. I'm leaving Samuel and you and Dean Winchester can kiss my ass. I just hope you're happy," Kaashaa said, getting up and going out of the room. The place got dark as Sam could see the scene changing before his eyes.
"Now see what happens when you do what you're supposed to do," Chuck said, grinning at Sam.
"Sam, are you okay?" Eileen came in and sat down, garnering Sam's attention and signing to him.
"Yeah, I just can't believe it's finally over. Can you ever forgive me for what happened?" he signed then took her hands in his.
"I forgive you; I do. What about your brother?" Eileen asked glancing around the library.
"Dean will forgive me hell he said he was actually glad to be rid of the constant need to protect either of them, but he needed time. There is something I want to ask you though Eileen," Sam said making sure that Eileen could read his lips. He moved his hands and got up going over to bend on one knee. "Eileen, marry me," Sam asked, holding out an open box with a ring nestled inside.
Eileen's eyes lit up and she actually nodded as Sam happily put the ring on her finger, "I love you Sam," Eileen said, pulling Sam to her and allowing him to kiss her.
The scene changed often as Chuck showed Sam how he got married to Eileen and they had kids leaving the hunting life behind. Chuck even made sure to show how happy Dean was and how he himself ended up with Lisa again before once again bringing them back to their original spots on either side of the mirror.
"Now see what you could have waiting for you. A human who not only understands hunting but also understands you too," Chuck said smiling.
"You can go to hell. I'm not killing Kaashaa and Dany and that's final. Dean would never forgive me, and neither would Eileen. I'd rather take my chances with me and Kaashaa. Besides, you underestimate me. I'd never ask Kaash to get rid of our baby, asshole," Sam growled out the hate evident.
"Have your way Sam. I tried to play nice now you're just going to have to learn a lesson the hard way," Chuck said as Sam's body gave way and hit the floor of the hotel room he was in his body seizing once before his eyes closed and a little blood trickled out of his mouth and nose. In the distance, Sam's phone played his brother's ringtone over and over.