Nicole had sex with Waverly Earp for the first time. It wasn't exactly what Nicole expected it to be like but she was happy it was a first step in the right direction. They had talked about it a little before, but Nicole sensed Waverly was very apprehensive and nervous about it. She held back a lot of her sexual desires that day with Waverly as she didn't want it to be to overwhelming for her new young lover. Nicole went easy and slow on Waverly, she knew this was her first time with a woman and sex with a woman was different and very personal than it was with a man. Not to scare her, Nicole focused on making her as comfortable as possible. Waverly orgasmed only into her hand that day, Nicole refrained from going down on her, she didn't need to make Waverly feel so exposed their first time together. After Waverly seemed okay with what they had done and did not seem to out of sorts about having sex with Nicole Haught.
Next couple days, Nicole still found it weird to talk to Waverly about sex. Nicole knew not to push the topic on her as not to seem to pushy. She thought it best to allow Waverly to initiate their next time together. Making dinner for Waverly, Nicole got her some flowers and played her some soft music as they ate dinner together. After dinner, they sat on the couch to look at Nicole's baby photos. After a few glasses of wine, Waverly started kissing Nicole. Their kissing got heated as Waverly positioned herself on top of Nicole. Unbuckling Nicole's belt, Nicole stopped her from going further. Pushing Waverly off of her, Nicole started buckling up her pants.
Waverly was stunned and confused by Nicole. She said, "Nicole, what is a matter? Don't you want to? Embarrassed Nicole, said "Baby, I'm sorry. I just don't want you to think I invited you here tonight so I could jump you."
Waverly smiled. She said, "Nicole, I want to be with you." Nicole moved over to kiss her lips. As their kisses got heated, clothes began to come off. Laying a naked Waverly on her bed, Nicole began kissing her breasts. Kissing down her stomach, Waverly began to squirm under her touch, Waverly's panties were visibly wet. As Nicole pulled them down her legs, she got up and went into her closet leaving Waverly on the bed whimpering for her to come back. Nicole got on her harness with her dildo, and her lube in the other hand. Sitting on the bed, Nicole was careful not to alarm Waverly. Waverly hadn't noticed the dildo. Nicole applied plenty of lube to the dildo as Waverly was still whimpering for her to come touch her. As Waverly laid on the bed, Nicole climbed up over her as she began to spread her legs. Positioning herself over Waverly, Nicole positioned the dildo over Waverly very wet entrance. Pushing into Waverly entrance, Waverly began to dig her nails into Nicole's back. Nicole knew Waverly was no virgin. As Nicole pushed all the way in, looking at Waverly, Nicole could tell that Waverly was not okay. "Baby..Baby are you okay? Does it hurt? In that moment, Nicole began to pull out of her and roll herself off of Waverly. Upset with herself, Nicole began consoling Waverly and apologizing. "Waves, I'm sorry, I should not have done that."
Pulling the sheet over Waverly's naked body, Nicole hugged her tight as she kissed her forehead. "I didn't mean to hurt you. I thought that's what you were use to."
Waverly turned and faced Nicole, "Nicole, take me home." With that their date had ended. Both got their clothes back on as Nicole dropped Waverly off at the Homestead.