Back at the Earp homestead, Waverly was upset with Nicole. Nicole had sent several text messages apologizing for what she had done. Waverly was heart broken that Nicole had treated her so poorly. Champ had always put his own needs first and never considered Waverly's wants and needs. The type of sex she had with Champ reminded her of the sex Nicole performed on her last night. This is part of the reason she fell out of love with Champ, she thought Nicole was different, but apparently she had been wrong. Disappointed, she just thought sex with the person you loved would be different then what she experienced in the past with Champ. He was usually rough and never cared if she had enjoyed it. Every time, he would just shoved himself inside her and would thrust so hard into her until he came, this was the type of sex Waverly had had since high school with Champ.
Her and Nicole's first time was nerve-racking. Nicole was gentle and so loving with her their first time. After that first experience with Nicole, Waverly fell more in love with Nicole. Sex with her had been amazing and so different, because there was real love behind the act.
The sex Nicole had with her last night was everything that Waverly hated in having sex with Champ. She thought Nicole was different, but with what happened last night Waverly knew she was no different.
Crying into her pillow, Wynonna walked in and heard her sobbing. Sitting on her bed, "Baby girl, what's going on? Did something happen between you and Nicole? Waves, talk to me." As Waverly continued to sob, Wynonna tried her best to console her little sister. Wynonna suspected that Nicole had done something to hurt her sister but she did not know what. Getting up from the bed, Wynonna went over to the Sheriff's station. Walking in Wynonna spotted Nicole Haught behind her desk. Rage over took Wynonna, as she went at Nicole. "What the hell did you do to my baby sister, you bitch!"
Nicole was stunned. She said, "Wynonna, I love her. I would never hurt her." Wynonna continued, "Then why in hell is she in bed crying. She was with you last night, what happened?" Nicole asked Wynonna to lower her voice as they took their conversation into Nedley's office. Looking at a very angry Wynonna, Nicole did not know how to tell Wynonna what she had done. Nicole said, "Look Wynonna, it is a personal matter between me and Waverly. I will admit, I did make a mistake and it is probably my fault she is crying. I've tried to apologize to her." At that point, Wynonna hit Nicole so hard that Nicole fell to the ground. Bleeding from the mouth, Nicole got up as Wynonna came at her again. Wynonna said, "Tell me, what you did to her." Hitting Nicole over and over again, Wynonna asked her one last time. Nicole mouth was full of blood, her nose was also bleeding, on the verge of passing out Nicole said "I had sex with her."
Confused Wynonna, immediately thought Nicole had forced herself on her little sister and that was why she was crying. Rage engulfed Wynonna in that moment, as Nedley walked in saving Nicole from Wynonna Earp. If he had not have stopped Wynonna she would killed Nicole Haught.
Nedley said, "girls, what the hell is going on in here?" Nedley holding on to Wynonna. Wynonna said, this bitch raped my little sister." Nicole spoke up, "Wynonna, I did not rape your sister!" Embarrassed, Nicole got up off the floor barely able to stand. Looking at Nedley, " I didn't rape Waverly, I would never. Please Nedley, you can go ask her your self." Handcuffing Wynonna to a chair, Nedley dialed Waverly's cell number.
Luckily Waverly Earp answered the call, she immediately thought something had happened to Nicole when she saw it was him. "Sheriff Nedley, is Nicole alright?" He heard the panic in her voice, "Waverly, Nicole is fine. The reason why I'm calling you is that Wynonna and Nicole were in a fight over you. Wynonna seems to think that Sheriff Haught raped you. Waverly, did Nicole hurt you?" In the background she could hear Wynonna saying, "If you raped my sister you bitch, I'm going to kill you!"
Waverly was in shock, "God no, Nicole did not rape me." Waverly had never been so embarrassed. Nedley asked her to come down to the station to collect Wynonna.
A few minutes later Waverly stood in Nedley's office. Nicole's face looked like she had been beaten with a bat. Waverly, went over to Nicole and began crying. "Baby, are you okay? I am so sorry." Looking for Wynonna, Nedley motioned over to the next office. Waverly made her way into see Wynonna, "Wynonna, are you okay? Nicole, didn't rape me." Wynonna looking into her baby sister's eyes, "then, why were you crying?"
Taking a seat next to her sister, Waverly calmly spoke, "Wynonna, It is personal between me and Nicole. It something that I can't talk to you about."
Wynonna shook her head, " I asked her why you were crying, and she said that you guys had had sex. I assumed that she had raped you, I mean why else would you be so upset." Waverly continued, "Nicole didn't rape me, Wynonna. We just need to work somethings out when it comes to our personal life.
Wynonna was set free and went straight to Shorty's. She was lucky Nicole refused to press charges against her. Waverly helped Nicole get home and to get cleaned up. Back at Nicole's apartment, Waverly gently cleaned up Nicole's battered face. Not saying a word to one another, Nicole said,"Waves, I'm sorry that I hurt you last night, I will never do that again. Please talk to me."
Turning away from Nicole, Waverly body began to tremble as she began to cry. Nicole was sitting on the toilet, as she pulled Waverly onto her lap. Kissing her forehead, she said, "Baby, I will never do that to you again, I going to get rid of it, I promise." As Waverly, cleaned her face off. Nicole took some pain medication and lied down on her bed. " Waves, stay with me."
Nicole didn't have to ask twice. Waverly took off her clothes and pulled over one of Nicole's t-shirts. As she laid next to Nicole, Waverly started to place gentle kisses around her face. Kissing downNicole's neck, Waverly started to massage Nicole's breast focusing on touching her hardened nipple. Soft moans escaped Nicole's mouth, as Nicole moved to position herself on top of Waverly. Waverly said, "Nicole, make love to me. I want you inside of me." With that Nicole, pushed open Waverly Earp's legs as she slipped her hand down and into her wet panties. Pushing inside of Waverly, Waverly started to beg Nicole to make her cum. Trying to be gentle, Waverly rode Nicole's fingers until she reached her climax. Gently pulling out of Waverly, Waverly took off her t-shirt and her undies as she straddled Nicole. Nicole looking up at a naked Waverly, Nicole stroked her C cup breasts. Waverly had big breast for her tiny little frame. Her nipples are a dark pinkish-brown color. Nicole took her time touching her breasts, Waverly was going crazy with desire as Nicole noticed a big wet spot appear on her own belly as Waverly's body rode her up and down. Waverly got so wet that her cum was covering all of Nicole's tummy. Nicole inserted her index and middle fingers into Waverly, Nicole immediately began pumping inside of her. As her orgasm was surfacing, Nicole could feel how Waverly's vagina walls were gripping at her fingers, tighter and tighter until Waverly screamed out her name.
Coming down from her orgasm, Waverly stared lovingly into Nicole's very battered face. As tears fell from Waverly's eyes, she explained to Nicole how she felt when she had fucked her with her dildo. It was not an easy conversation for neither to have, but it was something they both needed to talk about. Nicole made it clear to Waverly that she would be more open with her about her own sexual needs and desires and never assume it was okay before she tried something new with her. Waverly was new to lesbian sex, and it would take sometime before she fully was comfortable with doing some of the things Nicole was needing and wanting. That night they both agreed to be more open with each other in this department.
Looking at Nicole, Waverly said "Nicole, I think I want to try it again."