Pmt0622 : I'm going to respond in English so I apologies for any grammatical or spelling errors.

Yes your right, she is a liar. Everybody lies.

For Demming and Josh, she has every right to want to keep her relationship with them to herself. When Rick and Her became an item, they did the same at first. Just like Lanie et Espo.

For her memory, to be perfectly clear, I NEVER said that she was right to lie. What I said before chapter 5 is that I understood the reasons behind this decision. It doesn't mean that it was the right one.

But let's be honest, it's not like Castle tried to call her during that time. So yes Kate had told him that she would call and didn't. Or my part, if I were truly in love with someone, if I had seen the person I love die before my eyes, I would not ha let three months pass without doing anything. Even tough she told me she would called. One again I'm not saying that Rick is the guilty one and Kate all innocence. She made a mistake. A big mistake. She should've called. She wasn't the only one who had to deal with what happened in the cimetery.

I understand that Rick is angry, understand that he feels betrayed. That's normal. What I wanted to show through my story is that while he had every right to be angry that doesn't mean that it was ok for him to act like a total jerk. Seriously, Jacinda ? Slaughter ? He is angry with Kate so he jumped into bed with the first woman. Talk about the case and all. And then follows Slaugher and acts like Espo and Ryan are his subordinates.

So yes, Kate lied. Yes she shouldn't have lied, I totally agree. Yes Rick has a right to be angry. But trying to hurt her deliberately, no.

Rick kept blaming her for never talking, but so do him. He never talk either. That's what it's all about. The two of them never talk and it makes a big mess.

So if you think that my story is about Rick being the only one guilty, you're totally wrong. It was NEVER my intention. They are BOTH guilty. They both lied. And yeah most people think that Kate's lie is bigger than Rick's. For me it's the same. They both lied and both of them were wrong to hide the truth. I totally understand why Rick did it. And I totally understand Kate's reason as well. In the same line, I understand Rick anger and I understand Kate anger too. They should've talk from the beginning, it would have been much easier.