Hello, everyone! Welcome to chapter 1 of part 1 of my second MLP story, "The Love of a Killer". Last chapter, we got introduced to Jeff the Killer and saw him kill four teenagers. However, he got hit by a truck and killed. This is going to be the MLP part of the story. Enough said. Let's begin. Disclaimer: I DO NOT own "MLP: FIM" or any Creepypasta characters. All rights go to their respective owners.

Chapter 1: Jeff in Equestria

"Ugh."

Jeff groaned, starting to wake up. At first he saw darkness. He slowly rolls his eyes forward and sees the morning sky.

"It's morning already?" He asked himself.

"What the hell happened? The last thing I remember is killing those teens and getting hit by that truck."

He rubbed his head. When he did he saw something that surprised him. He saw that his hands weren't hands anymore, but hooves.

"What the fuck? Are these... hooves?" He asked himself.

Jeff looks around, checking his surroundings. He turned to see he was near some kind of forest. He remembered the last time he was in a forest. And it wasn't pretty.

"If he's in there, I better get away from here." He said.

He turned and started to walk away from the forest. But when he tried to walk on two legs, he ended up falling over. He landed on his stomach. He looked at his legs to see that they have turned to horse legs as well. He sighed in defeat.

"Guess I can't walk on two legs anymore. Just great."

He got up and glanced at the forest.

"Either way, I better get far away from here." He said.

Jeff turned and walked away from the forest. A while later, he saw that he was entering a town.

"Finally, civilization."

He walked towards the town. Once he entered it, what he saw both surprised and confused him. The town was filled with ponies of all types. Some had horns or wings while others didn't.

"Oh no, you've gotta be kidding me." He thought.

He saw all the ponies walking or flying around going about their business.

"It's like I'm in some little kid's cartoon or something."

After another minute of everyone going about their business, one pony, a pegasus, looks towards Jeff's way. Once he saw him, he got a shocked look on his face.

"What is it?" His friend asked.

He turns to where his friend was looking to see Jeff. He too got a shocked look. Soon enough, everyone slowly started to look at him with the same shocked looks.

"Why are they looking at me like that?" Jeff wondered.

He then realizes why.

"Oh, I know why. It's probably because of my face. Yeah, that's it." He thought.

He started walking through the town.

"If they want weird, they're looking at it right here." He mumbled.

After walking a little bit more, he glanced up again to see the ponies staring at him.

"Do you mind?! You don't see me staring at you do you?" He asked, half irritated.

The townsponies instantly went back to going about their business. Jeff continued walking.

"Fucking asswipes."

Eventually, he saw a fountain and breathed a sigh of relief.

"A fountain. Maybe I can get a drink." He said.

He walked towards the fountain. Once he got close enough, he put his head down to drink. But when he was about to, he saw his reflection in the water. Once he did, he jumped back in surprise.

"What the..."

He walks to the fountain to look again. Once he does, he sees that his reflection wasn't that of a human, but of a pony. It had the same eyelidless eyes and the same cut in smile.

"What the hell? Is that me?" He asked himself.

He stops looking in the water, and steps away from the fountain.

"That's bullshit, that can't be me."

Jeff sat on the ground and tried to rationalize what he saw.

"That truck must've knocked me out pretty bad. There's no way this can be real. Either I'm dreaming or I'm actually a pony." He said.

He suddenly got an idea and looked towards the fountain. He got up and walked to it. He looked at the water again and sighed.

"Okay, Jeff. You're gonna stick your head in the water and you're going to wake up. Then everything will be normal." He told himself.

Just then, he quickly stuck his head in the water. He vigorously shook his head while some of the townsponies looked at him. He pulled his head out of the water and sighed in defeat.

"Yep. I'm a pony."

Author's Note: Looks like Jeff is going to have to try to adjust to his new life. Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. Sorry if it's too short. Be sure to read and review and keep watch for the next chapter. Constructive criticism is welcome. Until next time, see you later, my fellow bronies and pegasisters!