Hello, everyone! Welcome to the next chapter of part 1 of "The Love of a Killer". Last chapter, Jeff woke up in Equestria, not knowing how he got there in the first place. Eventually, he arrived in Ponyville and was surprised to see that the town was full of colorful talking ponies. He eventually finds out he's one himself. Now that Jeff's a pony, how is he going to adjust to his new life? And what characters is he going to meet? Let's find out shall we? Enjoy. Disclaimer: I DO NOT own "MLP: FIM" or any Creepypasta characters. All rights go to their respective owners.

Chapter 2: Rainbow Dash

For a while, Jeff had been walking through the town trying to grasp the situation he was in. First he got hit by a truck, now he was stuck in a world full of multicolored talking ponies. Knowing that was almost too much for him to bear. What was he going to do now?

"What am I going to do now?" He thought, "How did this even happen anyway? One minute, I'm killing some people, the next minute, I get hit by a truck and killed. Then I somehow got transported to this place and ended up turning into... this! If I'm dead... this must be Hell. And if this is Hell, it looks a lot more cheerful and light-hearted than what I ever heard. I thought Hell would be all fire and brimstone."

He stopped in his tracks, shook his head, and sat down. He looked around at all of the other ponies and an idea popped into his head. This causes him to smile evilly.

"It doesn't matter anyway. Now that I'm in a new world, that means there's plenty of new people for me to slaughter. Let's see..."

Jeff spotted a light brown pegasus stallion wearing a blue suit. He also had a mustache and black combed back hair.

"Maybe I can strangle that poor sap with his own necktie."

He then saw a green female earth pony with a short blue mane and tail talking to her friend, a red female pegasus with a long dark purple mane and tail.

"Maybe if I found a knife, I could gut that bitch like a fish."

He then sees an orange male unicorn with a black mane and tail buying some apples at the apple stand.

"Then maybe I can slit that guy's throat."

Then he saw a purple male earth pony walking by him.

"Maybe I could sneak up behind that guy and snap his neck."

He then saw what looked two kids playing with a basketball. One was a pink pegasus, the other was a periwinkle earth pony.

"Or maybe I could-"

Jeff grunts and shakes his head.

"No, Jeff. Think about it. This is a village. Everyone knows everyone." He thought, "With you being a stranger, they might suspect you. And if they suspect you, who knows what will happen. You could try it at night, but what if the pony you're trying to kill not only sees your face but escapes as well. If that happened, he would tell everyone everything. Then they would send an angry mob after you and you would have no way to cover your tracks and nowhere to run."

For the first time ever in his life, Jeff not only felt conflicted about what to do, but scared as well. He wanted to kill, but how was he going to do it without anyone suspecting him? Also, what was he going to do if they sent an angry mob after him? He could kill two or three ponies, but he couldn't possibly take on a whole army of them. He sighed in frustration.

"But if I can't kill, then what can I do?" He asked himself, "Think, Jeff, think!"

Just then, he heard hoofsteps next to him as if someone was walking past him. He glanced and out of the corner of his eye, he saw what looked like a mysterious black pegasus stallion. He turned away for a minute, but then his eyes widened. He turned around and saw that the pony was gone. He was now confused.

"What the fuck?"

Suddenly, he heard the sound of wheels. He looked forward to see a little orange pegasus on her scooter. She was going really fast. Then all of a sudden, one of front wheels came off and it stopped abruptly, throwing her into the air. She screamed as she fell towards the ground. When he saw this, Jeff got up and ran to catch the child. He jumped as high as he could and the kid crashed into him. Jeff was on his back with the little pegasus on his stomach. They both started to get up.

"Are you okay, kid?" Jeff asked.

"Yeah. What about you, mist-"

The kid stopped in mid sentence and got a shocked look as she saw her savior's face. She saw his shaggy black mane, his white fur, his eyelidless eyes, and his grotesque looking smile. For a minute, she was speechless.

"Oh my gosh." She said, finally speaking.

"What?"

"Your... your face."

Jeff instantly knew what she was talking about and sighed.

"Yeah, I know. It's not the best lookin' face in the world. But I guess you have to make do with what you got." He said.

"What happened to it?" The child asked, curiously.

"That is something I really don't wanna talk about."

"Oh. Sorry."

"It's alright. It's not your fault."

The kid looks behind her and sees her scooter. One of the front wheels was lying on the ground next to it. She got up and walked towards it. She picked up her scooter and the wheel. She walked over to Jeff and sat down, looking at her scooter sadly.

"Sorry about your scooter, kid." Jeff said.

The kid's face brightened.

"It's okay. I fixed it before, I can fix it again." She said.

She looked at Jeff.

"My name's Scootaloo. What's your name?"

He looked away for a second, then turned back to Scootaloo.

"Jeff."

"Jeff? Not to be rude, but that kind of sounds like an unusual name for a pony. Then again, we do know a pony named Trixie." Scootaloo said.

"I don't see why Jeff is an unusual name. Scootaloo isn't really normal either." Jeff mumbled.

Scootaloo cocks her head to the right and gets a curious look.

"Uh, Jeff?"

"Yeah?"

"Why do you have a knife as a cutie mark?" She asked.

Jeff was confused.

"Uh, what kind of mark did you say?"

"A cutie mark. It's right there on your flank."

He turned to his left and looked down at his hindquarters. To his surprise and confusion, there it was. There, on his flank, was a picture of a knife. It looked like it had been tattooed on his hindquarters.

"What the hell? How did this get here?" Jeff thought, "Did someone tattoo me while I was out?"

He heard Scootaloo speak.

"A cutie mark represents somepony who has a talent." She said.

Jeff looked at her again. She showed him her cutie mark.

"My cutie mark represents my talent. Which is helping other ponies find their talents and get their cutie marks. My friends, Applebloom and Sweetie Belle have the same ones too."

"Do all ponies have cutie marks?" Jeff asked.

Scootaloo nodded.

"Yeah. Mostly everypony does."

Jeff puts a hoof on his chin in thought.

"A tattoo-like mark on a pony's ass that represents their talent? Huh, that's pretty weird but cool at the same time." He thought.

"What's your talent?"

"Hm?"

"I thought that since you have a cutie mark, you must have some kind of talent. What is it?" Scootaloo asked.

Jeff didn't know how to answer that question. What was he going to do? He can't tell her he's a killer. If he does, there's no telling how she'll react.

"Judging by your cutie mark, it must have something to do with knives."

"Oh. You think so?" Jeff asked.

Scootaloo nodded again.

"What are you? Are you a knife juggler?" She asked.

"What? No. I'm not even good at juggling." Said Jeff.

"Oh. Then what are you?"

Jeff looked away for a moment, trying to think of how to answer the kid's question.

"Come on, Jeff. Think! There has to be another talent that involves knives." He thought.

He glanced back at Scootaloo who was still looking at him. He looked away again.

"Remember, you can't afford to tell her or anyone else that you're a killer. Then what other talent involves knives?"

He suddenly got an idea.

"I got it."

He turned back to Scootaloo, ready to tell her his talent.

"I'm... well... I'm a knife collector!" He said.

Scootaloo tilts her head in skepticism and confusion.

"Knife collector?"

Jeff nodded.

"Yeah. I used to collect knives for a living. And I mean all kinds of knives. Whether it'd be kitchen knives or hunting knives, I would collect any knife I could find. However, a while back, I lost my old collection in some kind of accident. But that's what I used to do." He said.

Scootaloo thinks about it for a minute. Finally, she speaks.

"I don't know if I could really call knife collecting a talent." She said.

Jeff got a scared look.

"Uh oh."

The filly's smile soon returned.

"But okay."

Jeff let out a big sigh of relief.

"That was close." He thought.

"Hey, kid."

"Yeah?"

"I'd love to stay and chat but I gotta go. I'm new around here, so I have to explore the town some to get used to my surroundings." Jeff said.

"Oh, okay. Welcome to Ponyville by the way."

He walked past Scootaloo and proceeded forward. She watched him walk away with a smile.

"Hey, Jeff. Thanks for saving me. You're a real hero." She said.

This shocked Jeff. Never before had he been called a hero. He turned to the filly and pointed at her.

"Ah! That I am not!" He said, half irritated.

He turned forward and started walking again.

"Stupid kid."

A while later, he was still walking through Ponyville. He stopped and sighed, trying to think of what to do next. He couldn't kill or maim anyone without being suspected. So what was he going to do? Unknown to him, while he was thinking, he was mysteriously being lifted off the ground and into the air. He went up until he was in the middle of the sky. After thinking for one more minute, he sighed in defeat.

"Well, I've got nothing." He said to himself.

When he looked around, he realized he was suddenly in the air. He looked down and his eyes widened. He was up so high, he could see all of Ponyville. He screamed in surprise.

"W-WHAT THE FUCK?!"

He looked up, then he looked down again. He then started looking around to find how he was airborne.

"What the fuck happened?! How the fuck did I get up here?!"

He heard flapping coming from somewhere. One look behind gave him the answer. On his back were two white wings. This also surprised him.

"I have... wings?"

Jeff then flew around in a circle a bit and then stopped. A big smile formed on his face.

"WOOHOO!!!!"

Before he knew it, Jeff was flying through the sky whooping and hollering. He liked the wind in his mane and the freedom he had while flying. He flew a little low and flew over the lake, seeing his reflection. Then he flew up high again.

"I never knew flying could feel this so damn good!" He thought.

Unfortunately he was having so much fun flying, he wasn't paying attention to where he was going. If he was, he would've seen another pony flying in his direction. The pegasus known as Rainbow Dash was flying through the sky checking out the view from above.

"I wonder what I'm gonna do today." She said to herself.

Suddenly, she heard a voice.

"LOOK OUT!" It yelled.

Before she could completely look forward, it was too late. Someone already bumped into her, making them both fall to the ground below. Fortunately, they weren't up too high. They both screamed as they fell. Finally, they hit the ground. Rainbow was on her back while the other pony was on top of her. She groaned as she sat up a bit. She suddenly felt a pain in her right leg.

"Ow! My leg!"

She then looked at the other pony irritably.

"Hey, you hay-brain! Watch where you're fly-"

She stopped in mid sentence and gasped when she saw the pony's face. It had no eyelids and it had a grotesque looking smile cut into his face. She then screamed in terror. Jeff was groaning and rubbing his head when she saw his face. Before he knew it, Rainbow kicked him away, got up, and flew off. However, Jeff wasn't going to let her get away that easy. He wanted answers about where he was and he was determined to get them.

"Hey! Wait!" He called.

He got up and flew after Rainbow Dash. Rainbow was flying really quickly trying to get away from that terrifying looking pegasus. She looked back to be sure he wasn't following her. When she did, her eyes widened in horror. Jeff was following close behind her in hot pursuit. She turned away and started to fly faster. Out of the corner of her eye, she spotted a forest in the distance.

"This may be a dangerous choice, but at least I can lose him in there." She thought.

She flew in the direction of the forest. When she got there, she flew in. Jeff stopped when he saw her go into the forest because he recognized it as the forest he woke up next to. The one he feared a certain someone might be in. Frustrated, he shook his head.

"Aw, fuck it!"

He then flew into the forest. In the forest, Rainbow was still flying, trying to get away from Jeff. After a couple of minutes, she looked back to see Jeff on her tail. She screamed and began to fly even faster. Jeff picked up his speed as well.

"Wait! I just wanna talk!" He shouted.

"Stay away from me!" Yelled Rainbow.

The chase went on for five minutes. Jeff almost caught up to her. However, the cyan pegasus was faster. He was also about to fly into a tree.

"Oh shit."

Jeff crashed into the tree. Rainbow looked back to see that Jeff was no longer behind her.

"Phew, lost him." She said.

However, she wasn't paying attention to where she was going. She turned forward, but it was too late. She hit her head on a tree limb causing her to roll in midair. She fell for a minute until she hit the ground. She was on her back. She kept her eyes open for a few seconds before blacking out. Meanwhile, Jeff was rubbing his head, a bit dazed from the crash.

"Ugh. Fuckin' tree." He said.

He starts getting up and starts flying again. He flew through the forest looking for Rainbow. It took him six minutes until he finally found her lying on the ground. He landed and started walking towards her. At first he thought she was dead, but when he saw her belly slowly rising and falling because of her breathing, that assumption went flying out the window. (no pun intended.)

" Originally, I'd just end her right now." He thought, "But hold on. If I did that, who would tell me what world I'm in?"

Just then, he heard what sounded like a roar. He turned around quickly to see what it was, but didn't see anything. He then turned back to the still unconscious Rainbow Dash.

"Whatever I need to talk to her about, I can't talk about it here. Because I'd hate to be here if whatever roared showed up. So unless I want to be eaten, I better get outta here." He said.

He walked over to the pegasus and lifted her up on to his back. He flew up high until he was out of the forest. He then started to fly away from the forest.

Author's Note: Man, that was a long one! Sorry I didn't get it done sooner. Also, sorry for taking too long on my chapters. I'm trying my hardest. Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. Please be sure to read and review. Constructive criticism is welcome. Also, be sure to keep watch for the next chapter. Until next time, see ya later, my fellow bronies and pegasisters!